Carnieros Theory

Carnieros Theory

Length: 447 words (1.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓

The land of Mesoamerica changes through time and conflict. Carneiro’s theory defines a state as “an autonomous political unit, encompassing many communities within its territory and having a centralized government with the power to collect taxes, draft men
for work or war, and decree and enforce laws.'; Carneiro’s model of Mesoamerica shows the growth of two states, Uruk and Susa.
     In Caneiro’s theory, the two states follow his philosophy by the book. A slow rise in population also increases the growth of control. Thus more people in one area, the greater power they posses over others. However, superiority arouses the problems of
war. When a state is on top, someone is always out there looking to surpass them. Conflict rises due to this discrepancy of a high and mighty population. A slight decrease from 4 to 3 in control leaves many possible reasons open. One possibility could be a rebellious or fleeing group, causing the state to become smaller. Fortunately, a successful state possesses resilience and is able to bounce back. Many social factors are necessary to cause state origins.
     Environmental Circumscription is a major factor in the creation and existence of states. Environmental Circumscription is obtaining the good, scarce land from the surrounding dry land and being able to maintain and keep it from surrounding states.
Social Circumscription can also be a deciding factor on the length of existence of each state. It is the relative closeness of a group of people, that results in everyday confrontations and increases chances of fighting. The last factor is Resource Concentration. This is one of the most prominent reasons behind war. When a certain
area or state has certain resources that others do not, conflict arises. Trading may occur for a period of time, but when then the other states lack trading materials, war can break out. The increase in population and high political control can be factors in archaeologically identifying a state. It takes time to reach a maximum level of control, and
certain estimates of age can be made. When an area reaches the 4-5 range of political control, it is considered a state.
     Carneiro’s model can be seen in this example as true.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Carnieros Theory." 04 Apr 2020

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay Theory : Theory X And Theory Y

- In review of several significant elements of theory as it concerns theory X theory Z and theory Y. In addition, we identified the various components that help build the landscape and understanding of theory. In addition to a diverse set of views associated with theory and its relationships that guide managers as well as researchers in the development of theory and practical applications within a given area of study. However, research has unveiled a view of Theory X that workplace produces a negative effect on employee morale as well as performance (Head, 2011)....   [tags: Management, Theory X and theory Y]

Research Papers
834 words (2.4 pages)

The Theory Of The Multiple Intelligence Theory Essay examples

- The multiple intelligence theory is based on eight different intelligences which reflect a person 's intellectual ability. This model of intelligence challenges other theories such as the General Intelligence Theory created by Charles Spearman. Spearman’s theory focuses on a person 's ability to perform efficiently while being tested as well as their general cognitive capability. The MI theory differs due to the fact that it explores how test scores are not necessarily accurate representations of the amount of knowledge a person possesses because it has been demonstrated through this theory and experimental research that human beings are not necessarily less intellectually capable if they do...   [tags: Theory of multiple intelligences, Intelligence]

Research Papers
836 words (2.4 pages)

Behavioral Theory Of Leadership Theory Essay

- Behavioural Leadership theory Behavioural theory of leadership mainly concentrates on the study of behaviour of leaders. As per the behavioural theory ,the behaviour of a leaders is the best indicator for influencing the leadership and it would be the best factor for the leadership achievements. Behavioural theory defines that “ leadership is the behaviour of an individual directing the activities of a group towards a shared goal”(Hemphill, 1957,p.7).Behavioural leadership theory is mainly concentrates in real behaviour of leaders....   [tags: Leadership, Situational leadership theory]

Research Papers
899 words (2.6 pages)

Criminological Theory and Legal Theory Essay

- Criminological Theory Rational Choice Rational choice is based on the presumption that crime is a personal choice and that people can freely choose to participate in such criminal activity based on the outcomes, whether it be negative or positive. A person may choose to engage in a crime because it may seem rewarding and pleasurable. On the other hand, a person may decide to avoid participating in criminal activity from their fear of being punished. If the risk of getting caught is too high, one may decide not to commit the crime....   [tags: choice, crime, benefits, theory]

Research Papers
1701 words (4.9 pages)

Nursing Theory Vs. Theory Essay

- Nursing Theory Analysis Paper Nursing theory and research are integral aspects to improving and promoting nursing practice. These theories exist as grand theories and middle-range theories. While grand theories tend to involve broader or abstract thinking, middle-range theories are developed from grand theories but are seen as less abstract and narrow making them more applicable to clinical practice (Butts, 2015). An example of a middle-range theory that demonstrates clinical pertinence is Nola Pender’s Health Promotion model....   [tags: Nursing, Nursing theory, Nursing practice, Theory]

Research Papers
1246 words (3.6 pages)

The Theory And Theory Of A Person And A Crime Essay

- There are many theories that can be applied to different cases that have occurs in Americas history. The two theories that are choses for this paper are the trait theory and under the trait theory is psychological which is “abnormal personality and psychological traits are the key to determinant of anti-social behavior. There is a link between mental illness, personality disorders and crime (Siegel, 2014). The second theory is the Choice theory which “criminals weigh the cost and benefits and make a conscious, rational choice to commit crime” (Siegel, 2014)....   [tags: Personality psychology, Psychology, Trait theory]

Research Papers
1099 words (3.1 pages)

Essay about The Theory And Decision Making Theory

- A theory is a tentative way of explaining something. “It consists of a set of assumptions, concepts, relationships, and logic that are combined to explain a phenomenon of interest (Johnson & Kruse, 2009).” “Theories come from science and research. The purpose of theory/theorizing is to understand and control the world in which we live by describing and explaining it. Education is saturated with theory (Johnson, 2015). Theory can be both normative and descriptive. The normative explains the “ought” while the descriptive explains the “is”....   [tags: Decision theory, Decision making, Cognition]

Research Papers
1122 words (3.2 pages)

Critical Theory- A Social Theory Essay

- “Critical Theory is a theory seeking emancipation and change in a dominant social order” (Baran & Davis, 2012). Critical theory is a social theory that deals with different aspects of society. It tends to critique cultures that include: media, advertising and consumer culture. Moreover, Critical theory is also used to study how education is dealt with using information technology and it also concentrates on social relationships that are social, political and economic. The critical theory is known to be one of the theories that have been defined in different ways by different theorists depending on how they understood the theory....   [tags: Emancipation, Dominant Social Order, Theory]

Research Papers
1323 words (3.8 pages)

Leadership Theory And Contingency Theory Essay

- Are leaders born or created. Do they manifest in certain situations and not others. Does it depend on the dynamic or even demographics of the followers. In every society there are leaders, people who stand out from the crowd. Such a peculiar role and instrument of human interaction has been the subject of research for centuries. Leader’s use wisdom to guide other or manipulate social situations to gain followers. Over the years, new research promotes new ideas of leadership. Beginning with the trait theorists and Great Man concept through behavioral and situational ideologies, leadership theory is constantly evolving....   [tags: Leadership, Trait theory, Personality traits]

Research Papers
1408 words (4 pages)

The Theory Of Attachment Theory Essay

- Attachment theory: The first theory that will be explored and further critiqued is Attachment theory a basic explanation of this theory is “Attachment is a deep and enduring emotional bond that connects one person to another across time and space”(McLeod, 2009) The attachment between one person to another does not have to be reciprocal, this is because it is characterized by the specific behaviours in children alone, for example crying when they are hungry or upset when feeling threatened. The theory of attachment originated from the work of John Bowlby a psychoanalyst who “believed that mental health and behavioral problems could be attributed to early childhood (McLeod, 2007) he suggeste...   [tags: Psychology, Attachment theory, Family, Behavior]

Research Papers
960 words (2.7 pages)

Related Searches

With the material and data given, his theory seems to be proven. I highly agree with Carneiro&#8217;s theory because of its sensible logic and reason. The presence of many people promotes conflict and can be
paralleled and proven with our cities today. On occasion, the model showed that high population showed little conflict. It can be inferred that little political control overrides the presence of population and conflict. In its simplest terms and one convenient definition, Carniero&#8217;s theory can be seen as logical.
Return to