Essay PreviewMore ↓
- All laws are a species of command, a command being an expression of a wish or desire that some other person do something. Commands can only be issued by one who has the power and intention to inflict a sanction in the event of disobedience.
- A legal duty is a liability to a sanction for refusal to comply with a command. Hence, commands and duties are correlative; there can’t be one without the other. Commands are said to bind or oblige the person to whom they are directed. Sanctions are always intended to be evils, never goods. Rewards (bribes) cannot be sanctions.
- Conclusion regarding the basic definition of law: a command that obliges a person to observe a general course of conduct, issued by a superior (in power) to an inferior.
- Special problems:
Customary laws and rules of common morality which may appear to oblige independently of any superior power are not really laws until recognized by a court.
Common laws (judge-made law) likewise may appear not to stem from a superior power. Austin argues such laws are tacitly commanded by the state.
Legal rights are creatures of law, but they are not exercised by following orders; the option to exercise a right is up to the owner of the right. Austin: no law creates a right without also creating a correlative duty, hence the link with commands.
- Positive Law is a set of commands issued by a sovereign to his subjects. The sovereign is a determinate person or group (a) who receives habitual obedience from the bulk of society (he is the superior power within his society) and (b) is not in a habit of obedience to a like superior group (independent of any other
How to Cite this Page
"austins theory of law." 123HelpMe.com. 30 Mar 2020
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- The contemporary theory evolved from a collaboration of Hart’s work in 1961 The Concept of Law and Austin’s command theory, creating a “…more precise and informative explanation of law… and providing a closer analysis of rules” (Tebbit, 2005, p. 49). With that said, the importance of contemporary theory is to solve hard cases and to close a case with a fair verdict. But how is it possible for a Judge to make a decision based on the law in “hard cases” when the law has “furry edges” when applied to certain situations.... [tags: Law, Common law]
1325 words (3.8 pages)
- Can Legal Theory Assist in Our Understanding of Law. By convention, ‘the law’ generally refers to a system of rules that are usually enforced through a set of institutions for social control. Nonetheless, a more precise definition of the law has largely eluded legal theorists, who have attempted to advance their own individual fixed concepts of law. However, law is a dynamic and diverse system that encompasses too many socio-political phenomena for one universal definition. Even if a theory is able to achieve a uniform conceptualization of law, its conceptual clarity satisfies itself and little else – it still fails as an optimal, comprehensive understanding of what law actually is and how... [tags: law, politics, command theory]
2275 words (6.5 pages)
- Kelsen’s Pure Law theory attempts to describe law as a hierarchy composed of basic norms called “Grundnorms”. These grundnorms rest upon higher norms in each level of the hierarchy. The lowest level represents a completely general description and the norms become more individual as you climb the hierarchy. For example, Kelsen maintains that a higher grundnorm can determine if another norm is created, such as a bye law gets its validity from another norm being a statute, which will also get its validity from another norm being a constitution, which thereby gives the legislator/congress power to create statutes.... [tags: Law, Administrative law, Sociology, Hans Kelsen]
956 words (2.7 pages)
- The focus of this essay is to examine the extent to which Dworkin provides a convincing alternative to positivism. The central claim of legal positivism states that "in any legal system, whether a given norm is legally valid, and hence whether it forms part of the law of that system, depends on its sources, not its merits". Dworkin completely rejects the positivist approach because he believes that "no combination of source-based rules, no matter how broadly construed or how carefully crafted can ground a theory of law".... [tags: Law, Legal positivism, Common law, Social sciences]
1539 words (4.4 pages)
- Natural law theory is a legal theory that recognizes law and morality as deeply connected, if not one and the same. Natural law theorists believe that human laws are defined by morality, and not by an authority figure. Humans are guided by human nature and the term natural law is derived from the belief that human morality comes from nature. From a natural law perspective, legal systems have a function which is to secure justice. Moreover, according to the natural law theory, a law that does not provide justice is not considered a law at all.... [tags: Law, Legal positivism, Morality, Natural law]
811 words (2.3 pages)
- As I have stated in my proposal, I want to analyze selected legal fiction novels written by John Grisham through a feminist theory lens to demonstrate the underlying stereotypical, subtle/passive assumptions regarding the treatment of women, along with the consequences outside of the legal fiction realm. To do this, I had to compile research on John Grisham’s novels and strategies, female legal fiction writers, feminist legal theory and law and literature movements, effects in real life from Grisham’s rhetoric, and narrow down his list of books that will be useful in narrowly yet holistically showing his treatment of women in general in his legal fiction novels.... [tags: Gender, Gender role, Law, Female]
1055 words (3 pages)
- Morally-driven issues are often the centerpiece of political discussion and dinnertime conversation alike, and while each individual may hold their own moral beliefs, resolutions are found much more easily when a unifying theory is utilized in order to define and extract a universally agreed upon solution. For this example, I will consider a case where the debate arises over the exploitation of the family of a suspected terrorist, by means of non-lethal torture, in order to extract information from the terrorist that may go otherwise unknown.... [tags: Immanuel Kant, Morality, Ethics, Natural law]
1294 words (3.7 pages)
- Law is Law In order to determine whether something is legitimately law or not, one must first determine what exactly law is; something that theorists such as Hart, Aquinas, Austin and Fuller have been arguing about for generations. While it is easy enough to argue who can make law, how it can be made, and so on, it is a little bit more difficult when it comes to deciding whether a bad law, such as the The Law for the Prevention of Offspring with Hereditary Diseases put into effect in 1933, among many other laws which were put into effect during this time by Hitler as Germany’s sovereign, is indeed actually law.... [tags: Law, Appeal, LAW, Political philosophy]
2037 words (5.8 pages)
- Jurisprudence Essay Patrick Cooke 44802447 Question: “If a law is unjust, do we no longer have a legal obligation to obey it. Discuss with reference to the course readings as well as your own research.” A law’s legitimacy is completely dependent on the adherence it attracts from the society it helps to govern. A prominent cause for dissidence is the injustice implied by a law – in intention or effect. This raises the question therefore, if a law is unjust by nature, does a legal obligation apply to its subjects.... [tags: Law, Morality, Justice, Natural law, Jurisprudence]
1300 words (3.7 pages)
- The consensus theory of criminal law contents that society finds its own way and it is product of social needs and values, it also serves the interest of society at large. Rules are for the community to control themselves and to put order. If a crime is committed it is punished by what the society considers appropriate. The significance of that crime has to be evaluated by the same society as well as the punishment itself. The notion of acceptable behavior needs to be set and established by society itself.... [tags: Criminal Law Essays]
587 words (1.7 pages)
- Natural laws or the laws of God are genuine laws, but positive laws need not be in compliance with the laws of God to qualify as genuine laws.