Love, Sonnets and Songs

Love, Sonnets and Songs

Length: 1338 words (3.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Love, Sonnets and Songs.

 Mary Wroth's prose romance, The Countess of Mountgomeries Urania, closely compares with her uncle, Sir Philip Sidney, 1593 edition The Countess of Pembroke's Arcadia.  Wroth was undoubtedly following her uncle's lead by trying to emulate Astrophil and Stella.  Astrophil and Stella and Pamphilia to Amphilantus are both about being in love and they both have over one hundred sonnets and songs.

After rereading both pieces, I was struck not by their similarities but by their differences.  For example, Stella is assertive and Pamphilia is passive.  Stella is truly bound by her love for Astrophil while Pamphilia cannot break herself free from the love she feels forAmphilantus.  Sidney creates a female beauty that retains her voice and speaks, whereas Wroth allows her woman to remain inactive and vulnerable.  However, Wroth no longer allows the female to be the object.  She gives the female a voice and she is now the speaking subject.  Pamphilia remains inactive and unfulfilled but very patient.

A good question for the reader to ask oneself is why would Wroth not establish a strong female speaking subject like the one she was trying to imitate?  Wroth was the first woman writer in England to publish a romance and a sonnet sequence.  She was by no means conservative or cared about what people thought of her, which has been proved by the antics of her personal life.  So why not establish that same woman character/speaking voice in her prose?  I would like now to look at the similarities and differences of Stella and Pamphilia.

First, Philip Sidney and his female character Stella.  Stella has a voice and does speak, however, she speaks in the songs and not the sonnets themselves.  We see in the first two lines in each stanza of the Eleventh Song, Stella speaking and Astrophil answering her.

Who is it that this dark night
Underneath my window plaineth?
It is one who from they sight
Being (ah) exiled, disdaineth
Every other vulgar light.

Because she is not granted a sonnet, the standpoint that women are not allowed a voice has some truth to it.  Another standpoint is the way the women are viewed.  Women are viewed by their physical aspects.  For example, in sonnet 7, the speaker states:

When Nature make her chief work, Stella's eyes
In color black why wrapped she beams so bright?

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Love, Sonnets and Songs." 16 Feb 2020

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Shakespeare’s Sonnet 18 and Dolly Parton’s Love is Like a Butterfly Essay

- “Sonnet 18”, decidedly the most celebrated of Shakespeare’s 154, was written in the early 17th century. It consists of 14 lines in iambic pentameter, each comprising of ten syllables, and utilizes the rhyming scheme abab, cdcd, efef, gg. It is typical of the sonnets written during that time period, both in its format and content. “Sonnet 18” deals with love’s relation to beauty, as well as immortalization of love and beauty through poetry. In the first two lines, Shakespeare compares the beauty of a young person, to a summer’s day....   [tags: love essay]

Research Papers
1032 words (2.9 pages)

Lasting Love in Shakespeare Essay

- “So it's not gonna be easy. It's gonna be really hard. We're gonna have to work at this every day, but I want to do that because I want you. I want all of you, forever, you and me, every day” (Sparks). Being in a relationship is tough now days, and apparently couples in the older times still went through the same types of situations couples today go through. Everyone has their disagreements, and couples never know what life will throw their way. After being with someone for so long, one is bound to have a few fights, but true love perseveres....   [tags: Love, Sonnets, Literary Analysis, Shakespeare]

Research Papers
1129 words (3.2 pages)

Shakespeare?s Sonnets: The Theme Of Love Essay

- Shakespeare’s poems are the monument of a remarkable genius but they are also the monuments of a remarkable age. The greatness of Shakespeare’s achievement was largely made possible by the work of his immediate predecessors, Sidney and Spenser. Shakespeare’s sonnets are intensely personal and are records of his hopes and fears, love and friendships, infatuations and disillusions that in turn acquire a universal quality through their intensity. The vogue of the sonnet in the Elizabethan age was brief but was very intense....   [tags: essays research papers]

Research Papers
1232 words (3.5 pages)

The Beauty of Shakespeare's Sonnets Essay

- In today's society, not many books or songs describe the true value of human relationships. Most popular songs and books are all about partying and doing things that make us forget about morals. However, if you were to read some of Shakespeare's sonnets, you would find that human relationship's are very much valued. By showing that friendship can mend a persons sorrows, that love could and should be immortalized, and that marriage between two individuals can be strong and true, Shakespeare's sonnets 55, 30, and 116 truly explain the real value of human relationships....   [tags: Shakespeare, Human Relationships, Analysis]

Research Papers
1335 words (3.8 pages)

Essay Comparison: Petrarchan and Shakespearean Sonnets

- Through the form of sonnet, Shakespeare and Petrarch both address the subject of love, yet there are key contrasts in their style, structure, and in the manner, each approaches their subjects. Moreover, in "Sonnet 130," Shakespeare, in fact, parodies Petrarch's style and thoughts as his storyteller describes his mistress, whose "eyes are in no way as the sun" (Shakespeare 1918). Through his English poem, Shakespeare seems to mock the exaggerated descriptions expanded throughout Petrarch’s work by portraying the speaker’s love in terms that are characteristic of a flawed woman not a goddess....   [tags: Style, Structure, Subject Approach]

Research Papers
1199 words (3.4 pages)

Essay about Love Is Not The Matter Of Insufficiency Of Language

- Introduction: Although, people might say out of emotions that their feelings are so intense that they cannot be expressed in words. Because of the same emotion, people may say that love cannot be described by words. It is evident that the language has proved to be sufficient enough to not only analyze, dissect or explain the feelings of love from so many angles, but also the chemical reactions happening in the body when somebody is in love. Subversions of conventions of love is not the matter of insufficiency of language but a matter of how a poet experiences love or how a poet chooses to express those experiences....   [tags: Poetry, Sonnet, Great Depression, Love]

Research Papers
1060 words (3 pages)

The Great Gatsby and E. Browning Sonnets Essay examples

- ‘The Great Gatsby’ was written by F. Scott Fitzgerald in, and set, in America during the 1920’s. Like all literature, this novel reflects the time period in which it was written; that is, the American Dream and its decline, social classes and the difference between them, along with World War I. The Elizabeth Browning Sonnets were written during the Romantic era. This was a period of great change and emancipation, which is unmistakably evident in E. Browning’s sonnets. Both Fitzgerald and E. Browning use a multitude of techniques throughout their texts....   [tags: Literary Analysis ]

Research Papers
1597 words (4.6 pages)

The Flea by John Donne Essay

- The Flea by John Donne “The Flea”, a witty poem of seduction and conceit, taken from John Donne’s “Songs and Sonets” is the poem that I have chosen to compare to “Song”, another poem of John Donne’s where he is passionately pleading with his wife not to be disheartened about his departure abroad. Both poems which belong to “ Songs and Sonets”, written around the time of the 16th century, show that their title suggests they are both short poems, following the traditional form of a sonnet, consisting of fourteen lines....   [tags: The Flea John Donne Songs and Sonnets Essays]

Research Papers
2360 words (6.7 pages)

Love's Legality in Shakespeare´s Sonnets Essay

- In most of the sonnets from around Shakespeare's era, love is a common theme. Written is a standard Shakespearean form, the rhyme scheme nor the meter deviate from the typical sonnet structure; although the form does not differ much, the central meaning and approach to love does. While the majority of sonnets speak of love for someone else, in sonnet 116 Shakespeare describes the truth of love between a couple. In 'Let me not to the Marriage of True Minds' Shakespeare utilizes legal terms to support their right to marriage and backs up his argument by employing solid metaphors regarding their love....   [tags: sonnets, marriage, fake]

Research Papers
673 words (1.9 pages)

Essay on Critical Appreciation of Shakespeare's To His Love Sonnet 106

- Critical Appreciation of Shakespeare's To His Love Sonnet 106 Shakespeare, William, 1564-1616, English dramatist and poet, b. Stratford-on-Avon. He is considered the greatest playwright who ever lived. He is also a sonneteer. His father was John Shakespeare. In 1582 Shakespeare married Anne Hathaway, eight years his senior and pregnant at the time of the marriage. They had three children: Susanna, born in 1583, and twins, Hamnet and Judith, born in 1585. In 1594 Shakespeare became an actor and playwright for the Lord Chamberlain's Men, the company that later became the King's Men under James I....   [tags: Papers]

Research Papers
1931 words (5.5 pages)

Related Searches

Would she in beamy black, like painter wise,
Frame daintiest luster, mixed of shades and light?

Black is also noted in lines10 and 11, "That whereas black seems beauty's contrary, / She beauty even in black doth make all beauties flow?"  The beauty of Stella's eyes, black is beauty's contrary, and even if she is in a black, she is still beautiful.  These are all physical aspects of Stella.  However, Stella is more than just an object of affection and becomes a well-founded human being who can put forth her own human rights.  She gains respect because Asrophil does not fall in love with her immediately, but, as suggested in the second sonnet, "But known worth did in mine of time proceed, / Till by degrees it had full conquest got."  In the start of the sequence, Stella's "worth" has become the most important factor, not her physical beauty. 

Stella is neither serious nor a symbol, but rather an individual. We see her individuality develop in sonnet 41.  For example, Astrophil is at some sort of horse tournament and he wins the prize.  We see Astrophil giving her credit for his prize because he is in love with her and she is there watching him and his "horsemanship".  The beams are love and he did not win because of nature or skill, but, because she loves him.  The concept of behind every good man is a great woman falls into place here. Astrophil states in lines 10 through 14,

The true cause is,
Stella looked on, and from her heavenly face
Sent forth the beams which made so fair my race.

Astrophil individualizes Stella and she is humanized. 

She also returns Astrophil's love by giving him a kiss which in turn justifies human feelings.

The impression of Pamphilia is that she is a victim.  She has to tolerate the inconsistency of Amphlanthus and finds her only peace by withdrawing from the outside world.  In the first sonnet, we see emotional pain.  For example, in lines 9 through 14,

But one heart flaming more than all the rest
The goddess held, and put it my breast.
Dear son, now shut," said she: "thus must we win."
He obeyed, and martyred my poor heart.
I, waking, hoped as dreams it would depart:
Yet since, O me, a lover I have been.

The gloom that this sonnet starts out with sets the tone of the sonnet sequence.  Pamphilia sees sleep as "death's image" and the arrow that the son shot through her heart as wounding her emotionally.

    However, Pamphilia is not as truly wounded as we think.  She does display some inner strength by tolerating the acts of betrayed love.  To me though, this is a very passive act unlike the individualized and very assertive Stella.   Pamphilia as taking the initiative to control her own life and because she withdrawals from the world, she is freeing herself from love and male domination.  In sonnet 77 lines 9 through 14:

Then let me take the right-or left-hand way;
Go forward, or stand still, or back retire;
I must these doubts endure without allay
Or help, but travail find for my best hire.
Yet that which most my troubled sense doth move
Is to leave all, and take the thread of love.

Pamphilia is making choices about whether to still love Amphilanthus or get on with her life.  This is the point, I think, where she makes it clear that she is moving forward with her life.  She is moving forward but she is taking love with her. 

Pamphilia withdrawing from love and the world to free herself from male domination has truth to it.  For example in sonnet 16 lines 10 through 14,

Must we be servile, doing what he list?
No, seek some host to harbor thee:  I fly
They babish tricks, and freedom do profess.
But O my hurt makes my lost heart confess
I love, and must:  So farewell liberty.

Pamphilia brings some assertiveness to this.  In line 10 she asks the question why women have to obey "he"?  He represents love.  Instead of obeying a love she retreats from the world and into her own space that is free from love and possibly male domination.  She does still love Amphilanthus, so she is willing to give up her freedom.

    So, I am now back to the question as to why Wroth did not portray her speaker as a strong, assertive female, like herself, and like the speaker her uncle portrayed?  Because back in these times, Wroth was not concerned with making her character/speaker a strong, assertive female like we as twentieth century readers believe it should be.
    Although a strong, assertive female and gender itself is not an issue, it does put forth consequences on the reader.  We sympathize with the female speaker (Pamphilia) in Wroth a lot of the time because she is the most pathetic and the male lover has rejected her.

    The male speaker (Astrophil) in Sidney makes the woman weak and puts in our mind that she is the one that suffers, which then in turn portrays the speaker of any sonnet as a victim. Stella, at times, becomes a victim when Astrophil berates her.  All sonnet speakers are victims of love.  They are either in love, are loved, or have been betrayed by love. 

Wroth, through Pamphilia, takes us through the emotional pain of being in love and not having it returned.  She loves to be in love but cannot stand to be so pregnable.  We can definitely see Wroth's personal life in this sonnet sequence.  She knew what it was like to have to suffer from the infidelities of a lover. 
Return to