Barbara Huttmann's A Crime Of Compassion

Barbara Huttmann's A Crime Of Compassion

Length: 644 words (1.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Who has the right to take one's life from them? The Supreme Court says
that no man shall take the life of another man without punishment. The Bible
says, "Thou shalt not kill" (Exodus 20:13), yet humans are still the only
species that kills their own kind. Murder is wrong. Murder is unlawful.
But when does taking the pain and suffering away from a dying victim become
murder? Barbara Huttmann believes that there is a time when living has just
gone too far. Her essay "A Crime of Compassion" addresses these points and
this very controversial question: When is it lawful and moral to take the
life of another person?

Murder is still a crime, and there is a fine line between murder and a
"Do Not Resuscitate" (DNR) order from a Doctor. The state of Montana tried
and convicted Dr. Kavorkian of murder just because he helped sad, tired and
suffering patients end all of their pain, by killing them. Is this murder?
Maybe, Kavorkian killed suffering victims. He had their permission, but
nonetheless, he ended their life. DNR is different. While I have never had
cancer, like "Mac" in the essay, or any other terminal illness for the
matter, I can sympathize for the patient and his family. Why should he have
to stay alive or suffer? There comes a time when medical technology is just
impending in the grand scheme of life. What's wrong with death? What are we
so afraid of? Why can't we treat death with a certain amount of humanity,
dignity, and decency? Whether the patient believes in an after life or not,
death is a part of life. While Barbara was required by hospital guidelines
to report all "Code Blues", it is not morally wrong. But, in most states,
unless the patient prior to the accident has signed a DNR, you must do
whatever it takes to keep them alive. That is not moral, that is legal. But
where do you draw the line? Barbara said hat she resuscitated Mac "52 times
in just on month" (3). Should there be a number that once reached, an
understood DNR is in place? Or do we continue to treat only the symptoms of
terminal illnesses and send patients back home to suffer?

The point is that it is not fair to make someone to offer through pain
day in and day out, just waiting to die.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Barbara Huttmann's A Crime Of Compassion." 123HelpMe.com. 18 Nov 2019
    <https://www.123helpme.com/view.asp?id=49518>.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Critique of Barbara Huttman’s A Crime of Compassion Essay

- Critique of Barbara Huttman’s “A Crime of Compassion” Barbara Huttman’s “A Crime of Compassion” has many warrants yet the thesis is not qualified. This is a story that explains the struggles of being a nurse and having to make split-second decisions, whether they are right or wrong. Barbara was a nurse who was taking care of a cancer patient named Mac. Mac had wasted away to a 60-pound skeleton (95). When he walked into the hospital, he was a macho police officer who believed he could single-handedly protect the whole city (95)....   [tags: Euthansasia Mercy Killing Essays]

Research Papers
1007 words (2.9 pages)

Barbara Ascher's On Compassion and David Wallace's This Is Water Essay

- The two essays “On Compassion” and “This is Water” by Barbara Ascher and David Wallace argue their different viewpoints on both compassion and empathy. While Ascher simply argues that compassion is not a simple character trait but more so a skill acquired overtime; Wallace tries to convince his audience that humans are preprogramed to be motivated by their own selfish desires and must reprogram themselves to think out of sympathy and concern for others. Barbara Ascher’s, essay, “On Compassion,” compels the audience to interpret the compassion and empathy with their underlying definitions....   [tags: compassion, empathy]

Research Papers
785 words (2.2 pages)

Analysis Of The Novel ' A Crime Of Compassion ' Essay

- Right to Die Barbra Huttmann’s purpose in writing her story in A Crime of Compassion is to convince people that no matter their beliefs, it is sometimes more humane to let someone die if they are suffering. This was the case with a cancer patient of hers named Mac. She communicates this directly by saying, “Until there is legislation making it a criminal act to code a patient has requested the right to die, we will all of us risk of the same face as Mac” (Huttmann 422). Huttmann wants to convince people that the right to die is necessary....   [tags: Religion, Morality, Law, Ethics]

Research Papers
1074 words (3.1 pages)

Religion and Morality in Major Barbara Essay example

- “It is not my business to flatter the Salvation Army”. “It (the Salvation Army) is even more dependent than the church (church of England) on rich people who would cut off supplies at once if it began to preach dispensable revolt against poverty which also must be a revolt against riches”. Shaw makes the above comments in the preface to Major Barbara. He presents this view of religious organizations role playing as tools of social engineering for the rich among other controversial views on morality and religion, particularly directed on Christian beliefs of the Salvation Army, one of the foremost organizations of Christianity of his time....   [tags: Major Barbara Essays]

Research Papers
1008 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Compassion in the Workplace in Nickel and Dimed by Barbara Ehrenreich

- Why might people in the workplace share a good common goodwill, generosity, and solidarity amongst each other. They most likely will share these things because they are all in the same boat. For example, as hard and difficult as work may be, it may be an escape for most of the workers. The feeling of care and support may come from other workers because at that moment, they are all together, and they are away from the hardships they might face. They all know how their co-workers feel, and to share a smile, it may help someones day....   [tags: goodwill, generosity, solidarity]

Research Papers
554 words (1.6 pages)

I Feel Compassion For The Friend Essay

- 1) My first 3 thoughts are shock, anger, and compassion. I am shock because a supposed friend of 10 years could do something so horrible like that with no hesitation. His friend shot him multiple times, beat him with the end of the shot gun, stole his belongings, and left him for dead. I just can’t wrap my mind around the idea you could do that to someone who trusted you and probably shared most of your life with during the good and bad times. I also feel anger because of the way how as a country we don’t do enough to prevent these things from happening....   [tags: Crime, Gang, Criminology, Illegal drug trade]

Research Papers
1095 words (3.1 pages)

Nickel And Dimed By Barbara Ehrenreich Essay

- Nickel and Dimed book Response Nickel and Dimed, by Barbara Ehrenreich was a very thought provoking book to read. The author spent a year of her life working several low paying jobs, and staying in low quality facilities. She hoped to share year long journey with the world in order to show how these types of workers live and how they are viewed by the upper class. After reading this book, I learned many things from the author and made connections to my own life. This book also helped me look at businesses in a different way....   [tags: Nickel and Dimed, Barbara Ehrenreich]

Research Papers
720 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Idealism and Realism in Bernard Shaw’s Major Barbara

- Idealism and Realism in Bernard Shaw’s Major Barbara Submerged in their own ideas about idealism and realism, Barbara and her father Undershaft are at odds with one another in Major Barbara. In this Bernard Shaw play, minor characters are important in exemplifying these conflicting values. The moral perplexities of capitalism and charity are explored through the words and actions of Undershaft’s family, his future sons-in-law, and the common folks at the Shelter. Thriving in the British upper class, Undershaft’s wife and son are well aware of Undershaft’s grip on Europe’s economy and government....   [tags: Bernard Shaw Major Barbara Essays]

Research Papers
1283 words (3.7 pages)

Hypocritical Christianity Exposed in Bernard Shaw's Major Barbara Essay

- Hypocritical Christianity Exposed in Bernard Shaw's Major Barbara Bernard Shaw reveals in his plays a type of religious standard that is not unlike Christianity but with what most people see as a stereotypical view of hypocritical Christianity. Shaw's concept of Crosstianity , as he calls it, shows a religion in which the church preaches what the rich and powerful tell it, scoundrels are treated as equals, and punishment is concerned with prosecution rather than salvation. "Poetic justice" rules judicial retribution rather than redemption....   [tags: Bernard Shaw Major Barbara Essays]

Research Papers
618 words (1.8 pages)

Barbara Anderson's First Fieldwork Essay example

- Barbara Anderson's First Fieldwork Précis: “First Fieldwork” 1. Where did Barbara Anderson’s fieldwork take place and what was the goal of her research. Barbara Anderson’s fieldwork took place in the fishing village of Taarnby, Denmark on the island of Amager in the Oresund in the 50’s. The goal of her research was to publish the unseen side of fieldwork. She wanted to share the personal and professional sides of fieldwork with the reader. She went to the island to help her husband study culture change....   [tags: Barbara Anderson Anthropology Essays]

Research Papers
663 words (1.9 pages)

Related Searches

The Constitution has a law against
cruel and unusual punishments: Does terminal illness count? Can they not
just be allowed to die peacefully? Barbara uses emotional tactics to sell
her ideas and convey her point. By attacking the reader's heat, it is much
easier to win the "right or wrong" battle, because everyone can relate to
death. By using extreme adjectives and figurative metaphors, the reader has
no choice but to want to reach out not only to Mac and his family, but also
to Barbara, for she loved "him, his wife, Maura, and their three kids as if
they were [her] own"(5). She had suffered right along with him through all
of this. Death is sad, and it might not be fair, but dealing with death is
far easier then dealing with pain and suffering of a loved one.

Barbara Huttmann may have broken hospital policy that day, but the truth
is, she did her friend Mac a favor. He wanted it, the family wanted it, and
she wanted it. Medical technology, while unbelievably spectacular, is
sometimes a nuisance. Mac deserved to be left along. He was tired of pain,
tired of suffering, and tired of delaying the inevitable. Murder and
assisting death are one thing, but this is just allowing life to run its
course. Sometimes it is just time. Time to let go, and time to move on.
Barbara Huttmann is not guilty of murder. Her only crime is compassion.
Return to 123HelpMe.com