The Negative Side of Affirmative Action

The Negative Side of Affirmative Action

Length: 765 words (2.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
The Negative Side of Affirmative Action

Affirmative Action…Is it positive or negative? “Remembering the Negative Side of Affirmative Action,” a reflection of the graduate college life and experience of Lisa Chavez, a Mexican American, is a strong article of the negative aspects of affirmative action. Published in the Chronicle of Higher Education in 2002, the article provides a somewhat modern approach or view to the controversial issue. Chavez’s article addresses her own personal experience of teaching a class filled with affirmative actions students, brought in from previous- offender’s programs. She provides details of the situations that she was placed in, and their effect of her teaching at that time and in the future. This article is a valuable example of a negative view on affirmative action.

This article is very persuasive thanks in part to all of the direct evidence she provides. Chavez discusses her job offer to teach a college level English class to some immigrant and previous offenders that came from the local jail.

I thought that affirmative action would extend a helping hand to those who might otherwise learn about available opportunities…I learned however, that affirmative
action could be a double-edged sword, even though its intended beneficiaries.(1)

This example gives the framework for the argument she is trying to present. The majority of these students were unwilling to learn and resulted in using negative gestures toward Chavez in order to “strict up a rise” with the other students.

They took every chance to embarrass me, and I soon found out that open-ended writing assignments usually turned into fantasies of what they would like to do to me if they could get me alone sometime. (1)

Chavez also explains the repercussions that the university was willing to hand down. The university was unwilling to discipline the students; they merely told Chavez to handle the problem herself. This left Chavez with no place to turn and limited ideas. Later Chavez tried to incorporate the student’s ethnic background with the lesson being taught. This leads to Chavez receiving threatening phone calls, and damages to her personal property. This evidence provides a more believable thought for the author’s argument.

By using Pathos, or emotions, she appeals to her audience. By looking for sympathy, caused by all the bad events that had taken place, Chavez is able to grab the heartstrings of her audience.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"The Negative Side of Affirmative Action." 25 Sep 2018

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Affirmative Action: Giving Preferential Admissions to Minority Students

- Should universities eliminate affirmative action polices that give preferential treatment in admissions to minority status. “Anyone interested in higher education should want to contemplate, on behalf of colleges and universities, students and faculty, alumni and paying parents, the fate of affirmative action(Chace, M William 20). The Oxford Dictionary states Affirmative Action is “an action or policy favoring those who tend to suffer from discrimination, especially in relation to employment or education; positive discrimination.” In 1961, John F....   [tags: Affirmative Action in Higher Education ]

Research Papers
1316 words (3.8 pages)

Affirmative Action Essay

- Affirmative action is meant to be an attempt at equality throughout society. It supposedly proposes that each person receives equal opportunities in the classroom as well as the work force. Not only would this apply to minorities but to women as well. Every sector in America would be equal and unprejudiced - or so proponents say. On the other hand, adopting affirmative action would force many employers to replace hard-working employees with those of less qualification simply due to their gender or ethnic background....   [tags: Affirmative Action Essays]

Research Papers
1673 words (4.8 pages)

Essay on Affirmative Action on Social Inequality

- Social inequality, an issue that has been debated many times throughout the years, has discrimination, racism and sexism. Since people have to deal with this every day, social inequality seems like it will never disappear. However, society believes that their answer to solving this problem has been created, which is Affirmative Action. The purpose of affirmative action is to acquire more diversity and to control the basis of racism in America. This idea is to represent equality for women and minorities who work and are attending universities....   [tags: discrimination, sexism, racism]

Research Papers
1665 words (4.8 pages)

Affirmative Action Essay

- The roots of Affirmative Action can be traced back to the passage of the Civil Rights Act where legislation redefined public and private behavior. The act states that to discriminate in private is legal, but anything regarding business or public discrimination is illegal. There are two instances when opposing affirmative action might seem the wrong thing to do. The nobility of the cause that help others. Affirmative Action was a great starter for equality in the work place. The most promanite variable in deciding Affirmative Action as right or wrong, is whether or not society is going to treat people as groups or individuals....   [tags: essays research papers]

Research Papers
1079 words (3.1 pages)

Affirmative Action is Discrimination in a New Form Essay

- Affirmative Action - Discrimination in a New Form   The roots of affirmative action can be traced back to the passage of the 1964 Civil Rights Act where legislation redefined public and private behavior. The act states that to discriminate in private is legal, but anything regarding business or public discrimination is illegal ("Affirmative" 13). There are two instances when opposing affirmative action might seem the wrong thing to do. Even these two cases don't justify the use of affirmative action....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics]

Research Papers
1764 words (5 pages)

Analyzing Affirmative Action Essay example

- Nowadays, education is an important factor in our society. When society started educating themselves, knowledge was passed generation through generation. In past centuries, education was only available for certain groups of people like upper-classmen and clergymen. As time went by, education became more accessible to others, but discrimination existed and many minorities weren’t able to receive the education they deserved. Although there’s still some discrimination present in our society, education is now available to most people....   [tags: minority quotas in higher education]

Research Papers
966 words (2.8 pages)

Essay about Using DNA Testing as an Admission Requirement into American Colleges

- On March 7th of 2008 a moot court was held addressing racial preferences in higher education. The case, set in 2013, involves the University of Kentucky using mandatory DNA testing as a major factor in determining aid from affirmative action. The plaintiff, an African American, does not receive preference because through the test he discovers he is a quarter European. On the opposing side, the defendant is a Caucasian female who discovers she is part African American and is eligible for the preference pool....   [tags: affirmative action]

Research Papers
715 words (2 pages)

Benefits of Affirmative Action Programs Essay

- Benefits of Affirmative Action Programs The purpose behind affirmative action programs during the admissions process of universities is to promote equal opportunity, and to further desegregate our educational system. Those who do not promote affirmative action feel that these programs instill reverse discrimination, as well as segregation in the universities. They believe that these special programs lower the test scores of prestigious universities while also setting up minorities to fail in the real world....   [tags: Papers]

Research Papers
1173 words (3.4 pages)

Essay about Affirmative Action

- Introduction Affirmative Action began in 1965 when President Johnson signed the Executive Order 11246 in to law. The Executive Order prevents federal contractors from discriminating against any employee or applicant for employment because of race, color, religion, sex, or national origin. The phrase “affirmative action” was first coined, when federal contractors were required to take affirmative action to ensure that applicants were not discriminated against in anyway. When affirmative action was created, it only included minorities....   [tags: essays research papers]

Research Papers
939 words (2.7 pages)

Affirmative Action v. Reverse Discrimination Essay

- Affirmative action in the U.S. started to come about in the early nineteen sixties. It was enacted along with many other anti-segregation laws, as part of the "Civil Rights act of 1964 and an executive order in 1965 (Affirmative, Encyclopedia Britannica par. 2)." Today affirmative action is still going strong. It has many positive aspects, but it also has several negative affects, one of which is "reverse discrimination. Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary defines affirmative action as "an active effort to improve the employment or education opportunities of members of minority groups and women." Some of the other areas of emphasis are age, religion, and ethnic origin....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Free Essays
987 words (2.8 pages)

Related Searches

“I had no idea who was harassing me. It was hard to imagine what I had done to engender such hatred, but I was fairly certain it was one of the students I had flunked the previous spring” (4) . Her examples of things happening to her and her final discussion to leave the city to teach someplace else is a huge step that definitely is a powerful strain on emotions. This is a very relevant part of her argument.

In a very similar circumstance, her use of Logic or Logos, also allows her to appeal to the emotions of her audience. “I accepted the offer but soon discovered that I had struck no bargain. Nothing I had encountered in my teaching assignments to that point had prepared me for the problems I would face in the classroom that spring.” (2) Her examination of what logically to do with her students left her in a confused state. By using information that could be thought as more understandable to her incompliant students, her students the harassment grew even more directly shot her down. This feeling is easily understandable by an audience. This too is a persuasive argument in her favor.

Finally her use of credibility or Ethos, allows her to tie everything together, and provide valid examples from her own experience. Speaking from her own experiences allows the reader to see how things actually were. This allows the reader to also see how things were handle, which in turn leads to a decision on their part of the article effectiveness. This article is made more believable thanks to Chavez’s use of mostly Pathos and Logos, with a small amount of Ethos to tie things together.

In conclusion, the article written by Chavez is a good example of an article which is persuasive through the use of examples and emotional attachment to the store she is telling. This article can be viewed as persuasive because it hits on many emotions, logical thoughts, and evidence to support all her claims. The evidence that Chavez provided allowed all of her readers to firmly grasp the concept that affirmative action, in cases like Chavez’s.

Works Citied

Chavez, Lisa. "Remembering the Negative Sides of Affirmative Action". Chronicle of Higher Education. 2002
Return to