Misrepresented Cultures

Misrepresented Cultures

Length: 940 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Misrepresented Cultures

Horace Mitchell Miner spent much of his life educating himself on anthropology before writing his confusing but brilliant article on American culture. He was born in Minnesota and then moved to Kentucky, where he became a museum curator before becoming an associate professor of anthropology and sociology at the University of Michigan at one point in his career. Although he was a member of the Executive Committee of the Sociology Department he was not very active due to the fact that his work was mostly field based. For this reason many of his peers did not utilize his expertise. (website) It is also evident that he was an expert in his field by his history in the anthropology field. It is quite possible Miner was offended at the fact no one cared to consult him on issues or discuss things with him, and he wanted to show them that his opinions were worth hearing.

This is probably the reason he proceeded to write the article “Body Rituals Among the Nacirema.” He was quite brilliant in his writing of this article. In it, Miner writes about the people who take human behavior to an extreme, The Nacirema, who present many unusual aspects but yet they are poorly understood. Though their origin is unknown they are a North American group who is devoted to economic pursuits whose days are spent mostly in ritual activity.

According to Miner, these activities are towards the human body. “They believe it is ugly and its natural tendency is to debility and disease.”(Miner) Each home contains at least one or more shrine. The shrines are accompanied in particular rites. The focus of the shrine is a charm box in the wall which contains all the medical potions. Each day every member in the family at different times must bow and perform a rite to this shrine.

Since, they believe the mouth has a supernatural influence and a daily mouth-rite must be performed. Once or twice a year the people seek out the holy-mouth-man. When people get sick the visit a medicine man at their temples called latispos. Many temples will not accept people if they do not give a rich enough gift. Most will not even allow a person to leave if they do not give another gift. The ceremonies involve much discomfort and torture. Another type of person in the culture is called a “listener,” who exorcises devils from children.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Misrepresented Cultures." 123HelpMe.com. 07 Apr 2020

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Cultural Appropriation Of Minority Cultures Essay example

- A common theme seen in the Grand Narratives of many westernized cultures is the cultural appropriation of minority cultures. This begs the question of why do these dominant cultures with such ethnocentric self-identities build themselves based off of the many traits of other cultures that they oppress; as well as what effect this might have on intercultural communication. By looking at the following articles I found they show a strong understanding of a Grand Narrative and its effects, how and who dominate cultures have oppressed over years of building their own cultures as well as what they have borrowed from these cultures and incorporated within their own....   [tags: Culture, Cross-cultural communication, The Culture]

Research Papers
1126 words (3.2 pages)

Differences Between Cultures And Cultures Essay

- In the world we live in there are several different cultures that surround us in everyday life. What we may think people do is weird others think the same about us because of the culture style they live in. Everyone fits into there own culture and some fit into many as well. There are high context cultures, collectivist cultures, conflict as opportunity cultures, and many more to follow. The main ones I will be talking about are individualist cultures and monochronic cultures. Monochronic cultures are cultures that see time and punctuality important....   [tags: Culture, The Culture, Time, Chronemics]

Research Papers
1040 words (3 pages)

National Cultures and Organizational Cultures Essay

- Introduction: (Hofested, 1980) Culture consists of values, attitude , assumptions ,understandings & goals that are learned from one generation, imposed by the current generation, & passed on to succeeding generations. Culture consists in showy way of thinking, feelings & reacting, ideas & values. It is a community’s set of shared hypothesis about how the world works & what ideals are worth determined for. The essential core of culture consist of traditional values. Values form the blocks of the culture....   [tags: Indian Culture]

Research Papers
1784 words (5.1 pages)

Death and its Personofication in Greek Mythology and Other Cultures Essay

- Death “The fear of death is deeply embedded in us” (Cave 1). Death is something that everyone fears. As humans we like to believe that we are inhuman and that death will never affect us. It’s the ugly side of life that no one likes to think about. It doesn’t matter what race, culture, or region we are, we’ll all die. Many believe that when we die we go to heaven or hell, but what happens to our body after we are dead. Do we float on to parallel universe, or does our body just appear wherever we are destined to be....   [tags: Cultures, Religion]

Research Papers
1559 words (4.5 pages)

Ho to Establish Relationship with Other Cultures Essay

- Relationship is a fundamental and powerful tool that helps to connect people together. People, who have healthy relationships in their lives, usually achieve great goals and live better than those who don’t. Therefore building relationships with other people is something that everyone should do in order to have a healthier and richer lives. Establishing relationships with people from the same backgrounds and cultures who live in the same community with you can be fairly simple. The reason for that is because people from the same community often use the same language and share similar traditions....   [tags: lives, goals, cultures, learn]

Research Papers
857 words (2.4 pages)

Stem Cell Media Cultures Essay

- All cell culture procedures were performed under sterile conditions in laminar class II biohazard safety cabinet (ESCO). The cell cultures were incubated at 37oC in 5% CO2 humidified incubators (RSBiotech). MSC were cultured in MSC complete medium made up of Dulbecco’s Modified Eagle’s medium with nutrient mixture F-12 (HAM)[1:1] (DMEM/F12) with GLUTAMAX -I (Gibco, Invitrogen, USA), supplemented with 10% pre-selected foetal bovine serum (Stem Cell Technology Inc.), 1% of Penicillin /Streptomycin (Gibco, Invitrogen), 0.5% Fungizone (Gibco, Invitrogen), 0.1% Gentamicin (Gibco, Invitrogen), with or without 40ng/ml basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) (Peprotech, USA) ....   [tags: Stem Cells Media, science, cultures,]

Research Papers
886 words (2.5 pages)

Cultures Affecting Our Daily Lives Essay

- Cultural differences effect many aspects of our daily lives. With the many different cultures embedded in the United States, it is important that everyone has an understanding and respect for the melting pot that is encountered daily in our communities, workplaces and schools. "Culture is not an exotic notion studied by a select group of anthropologists in the South Seas. It is a mold in which we are all cast, and it controls our daily lives in many unsuspected ways... Culture hides much more than it reveals, and strangely enough what it hides, it hides most effectively from its own participants." (Hall) The United States populated from the beginning with people from different cultu...   [tags: Cultures, Cultural Identity Essays ]

Research Papers
1098 words (3.1 pages)

Differences in Cultures Essay

- Differences in Cultures Cultures are a complicated characteristic to understand. Living in the United States all of my life I never truly understood other cultures. When I would see people from other cultures come into my work or see them at school I thought they were bizarre. Last summer I went overseas to England, Ireland, and Wales. There I observed that the customs overseas are very different. One facet I noticed was their alcohol consumption. In the United States the law says you have to be twenty one or older to consume alcohol....   [tags: World Cultures]

Research Papers
458 words (1.3 pages)

Essay about Classification Of Cultures

- Culture is a hot topic. Scholars (Fukoyama, Huntington, to mention but two) disagree about whether this is the end of history or the beginning of a particularly nasty chapter of it. What makes cultures tick and why some of them tick discernibly better than others – is the main bone of contention. We can view cultures through the prism of their attitude towards their constituents : the individuals they are comprised of. More so, we can classify them in accordance with their approach towards "humanness", the experience of being human....   [tags: Sociology Culture Cultures Essays]

Research Papers
1623 words (4.6 pages)

War as a Form of a Dialog between Cultures Essay

- If we are talking about dialogue, the first thing that comes into our mind is verbal, oral dialogue. And a good example of this in contemporary cultural context is translation. However, this is fairly new form of communication and the three much earlier and older ones are: war, love and trade. At first sight they seem to be rather different, but in fact they have a lot of common features and in real life are closely linked together. A good illustration for this is marriage, which clearly belongs to the love-discourse....   [tags: World Cultures]

Research Papers
761 words (2.2 pages)

Related Searches

The child simply tells the listener all his troubles that he can remember.

The people have many unusual rituals. Such as, the man lacerating the surface of his face and the women baking their heads in small ovens, but some practices depend on the pervasion aversion to the natural body and its functions. Excretory and reproductive functions are ritualized. Intercourse is taboo and scheduled as an act. Pregnancy, when happened, is hid by the woman who would where a large dress. The Nacirema are shown to be very magic-ridden people by many of their rituals and beliefs.

The Nacirema are actually Americans. If not noticed by now, Nacirema spelled backwards is American. Yes, Miner was writing about his own culture, but from a non American viewpoint. To the reader it seems as though he is writing about a culture with very unusual and abstract views. But who are these behaviors unusual to? The American culture is very infrequently looked at from anyone else’s point of view besides our own. It is very ethnocentric and therefore we believe what we do is the way things should be done. Miner had noticed this and must have wanted to change the way Anthropologists thought since the way they were doing it was dreadfully incorrectly. He knew it was more important that cultures be looked at more in depth than just the behavioral aspects. He then proceeded to write the article about the Nacirema to show that almost anything can be seen as unusual, it just depends who is looking at it.

Miner apparently knew what he was doing when writing this article because this article has provoked others to write about other aspects of their own culture from other perspectives. There are other articles written such as “The sacred Rac” by an anonymous source. The fact that other articles have been written looking at ones own culture from a less ethnocentric point of view shows that Miner’s article was well written and well thought out. At one point, his peers were probably stunned reading about this culture with behaviors that seemed so out-there, but when analyzed they were actually reading about their own culture but from some else’s eyes who wasn’t familiar with the American culture.

His brilliance is also noticeable in the fact that he thought enough to make up a fictional culture to show his peers that any culture can be presented in almost any way, it just depends on who is writing it and what they believe and think is right. Miner used many usual ways to prove his point, which he did prove because his article is still being used in classrooms for teaching purposes. If his article did not have some sort of brilliance then professors and teachers would probably use one of the many other well written articles. Instead, they chose his. Since his was chosen and is still being used today it must have opened up the minds of his peers and made them think of Miner in a different light and use his knowledge.

Works Cited

Hooglans, Josh. “Horace Mitchell Miner.” 39 Oct. 2003.

Miner, Horace. “Body Rituals Among the Nacirema.” American Anthropologist
58:3, June 1956 Rpt. <http://www.msu.edu/~jdowell/miner.html>
Return to 123HelpMe.com