Essay PreviewMore ↓
In "Sex and Violence, or Nature and Art," Camille Paglia claims nature is inherently stronger than society. "Society is an artificial construction, a defense against nature's power.a system of inherited forms reducing our humiliating passivity to nature." (Writing in the Disciplines 572) I agree with the majority of Paglia's opinions, however, I believe that there are points that could have been elaborated on more substantially.
In this essay, Paglia states that man is born evil and it is society's job to condition him to be a good, moral person. Paglia would disagree with someone who said the reason a person murdered was because he grew up in a bad section of town, or his home life left something to be desired. On the contrary, Paglia claims it is the inner evil, the "nature," of the person to kill, and it is society's lack of conditioning that releases this savage response. "Society is not the criminal but the force which keeps crime in check." (Writing in the Disciplines 574) She claims no matter how much a person sinks into religion, or their society, nature will always have the upper hand.
Paglia believes if man is left to his natural instincts, with no threat of society's punishment, he will be evil and commit evil deeds. In society, sexual urges can often influence a person's morality, making him second-guess his values for the sake of sexual pleasure. She also goes on to say, "getting back to nature. would be to give free rein to violence and lust." (Writing in the Disciplines 573-574) I agree that this scenario is a possible outcome, but Paglia fails to mention that with out society we would have no idea, which deeds were evil and which were not. It is society that has set the limits and told us what is evil. Before men were grouped together in societies, they roamed free with no idea of right and wrong. It wasn't until man made up his religion with its rules, regulations and laws that he had a conscious idea of evil.
But I do agree with Paglia that nature is the stronger force, and no matter how much we try to fool ourselves into believing that society or religion can save us from the torment of nature, we will always be reminded of mother nature's force. "Civilized man conceals from himself the extent of his subordination to nature.
How to Cite this Page
"Sex and Man's Struggle Against Nature." 123HelpMe.com. 20 Jul 2018
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- The act of rape is arguably one of the worse crimes that can be committed against another person. In the last few years there has been much debate about whether sex offenders should be castrated either voluntarily or as a forced treatment. There are a number of arguments for and against chemical or surgical castration being implemented against known sex offenders. First it is important to explain the difference between surgical and chemical castration. Surgical castration is the removal of a man’s testicles, for the purpose of removing his reproductive abilities and to control the levels of testosterone being produced.... [tags: Sex Crimes]
1117 words (3.2 pages)
- Throughout the novel “The House of the Spirits” by Isabel Allende the reader sees many instances that exemplify the antagonistic nature of man verses woman. Through Esteban Trueba’s raping of many of the women at Tres Marias, his marriage with Clara, his relationship with his daughter Blanca and her with her lover Pedro Tercero Garcia and with Alba Trueba’s relationship with her lover Miguel and her Grandfather Esteban, much of what Allende wants the reader to know about the nature of man verses woman is exposed.... [tags: Literary Analysis ]
1627 words (4.6 pages)
- ... By this he means that society condemns sexuality that does not aid in assisting what natural law theorists find most important, reproduction. However, he disputes that non-reproductive homosexual relationships are immoral and unnatural, because the Catholic Church allows sex with sterile, pregnant and menopausal people. Each of these factors are not condemned as immoral by society even if they are indeed misusing the natural function of the organs. Corvino connects this argument about inconsistency’s to describe how homosexuality does not harm the self or others.... [tags: gay sex, morality, natural]
849 words (2.4 pages)
- The authority of the masculine ideal of the current decade is subject to crisis, the decline of a traditional male developing out of a 1950s post-war traditional patriarchal society; born into a decline in heavy industry and the redefinition of the nuclear family. Contemporary dominant models of masculinity, still fundamentally operate of a series of traditional characteristic; the strength, the independence, the fertility and the bravery of a man (Reeser, 2011, pp. 1-8). Yet, developments in society contextualise the modern man at a crisis, with the birth of a "lad" culture, rise of metrosexuality and decreasing gender specific roles through the social progression towards egalitarianism be... [tags: male authority, masculinity, modern man]
2257 words (6.4 pages)
- The Power of Discourse in a Political Sex Scandal On August 12th, 2004 New Jersey Governor James McGreevey became this nation's first openly gay state governor. Several moments after he stated, "I am a gay American", he succumbed to intense political and public pressure by announcing his resignation from New Jersey's most powerful position. This announcement and resignation came after a week of intense allegations that McGreevey sexually harassed a male colleague whom he had appointed. While American politics are not foreign to sexual scandal, the political destruction and individual defeat which McGreevey currently faces is poignantly unique.... [tags: Politics Political Sex Gender Essays]
1570 words (4.5 pages)
- Equal Rights for All What is marriage. Recently, people argue with respect to the definition of marriage. The definition of the word marriage is a topic that often comes up when discussing same-sex marriages. To get married is a very important event for almost everyone. Many people believe that getting married to the one whom he or she loves is natural. However, what do you think if you cannot get married to him or her because it is socially unacceptable. There are numerous opinions and standing views on same-sex marriage.... [tags: gay rights]
1903 words (5.4 pages)
- A sex offence is the commission of acts of a sexual nature against a person without that persons consent (Hale, et al, 2005). There are several different types of sex offenders such as those offending against children, against adults and sexual murderers. The sex offending itself takes many forms, “from the man who indecently exposes himself, the man who possesses illegal pornography, to the man who offends against his children” (Thomas, 2005). In the United Kingdom, Sex offences are defined under the 2003 Sexual Offences Act which lists over seventy different types of sexual offence (Home Office, 2003).... [tags: Social Issues, Child Sexual Abuse]
2115 words (6 pages)
- Same-sex marriage has continuously been contradicted throughout our nation and so the arguments never seem to cease. Some argue the legality of same-sex marriage while others suggest that it compromises the sacredness of marriage. Various religious groups and their supporters in the U.S. tend to either support same-sex marriage or greatly oppose it, depending on their viewpoints and beliefs. Thus, the constant, bitter arguments between these parties. These two groups constantly argue over the validity of same-sex marriage and never seem to come to an agreement.... [tags: Civil Right, Legal Relationship]
1651 words (4.7 pages)
- Legalizing Same-Sex Marriage All couples in a committed loving relationship should be legally allowed to marry. United States marriage concepts have been changing in conjunction with society’s evolving culture. Traditional concepts assigning marital duties based on gender no longer apply, strengthening the effectiveness of the marriage in today’s world. Society is actively moving towards becoming a culture of contributing individuals who have equal rights regardless of ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, or religion.... [tags: legalization, sexual orientation, discrimination]
1092 words (3.1 pages)
- Same-Sex Marriage The United States is known world wide for its civil rights and freedoms. Many Americans are appalled by the idea of same-sex marriages. What?s wrong with the idea of two people who care greatly for one another wanting to spend their lives together. The gay community is misunderstood because many straights are not willing to listen. These individuals would rather just be closed-minded in this situation and reticent to really think about what this means to the gay community and the country.... [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Essays Gay Civil Rights]
1121 words (3.2 pages)
Paglia states that "Society is an artificial construction, a defense against nature's power." (Writing in the Disciplines 572) I agree, because without first religion and then society the human species would have become extinct a long time ago. But in her essay, Paglia does not address the fact that religion and society are inevitable structures. There can never be a true "anarchy" because even if all of the world's governmental societies collapsed, then you would find that smaller "societies" would emerge. People who lived near each other would band together to deal with the conflicts that nature would throw at them, and in those bands of people you would find rules and regulations designed to make everyday life more bearable.
We have proven that the rules of society and the teachings of religion can help pacify nature's urges. Society has provided us with the concept of right and wrong. Religion has helped to give man confidence to confront nature's raw power. Sometimes nature wins but society and religion have given us the ability to deal with that too.
Paglia, Camille "Sex and Violence, or Nature and Art." Writing in the Disciplines. Ed. Alison Reeves. New Jersey: Upper Saddle River, 1996.