Comparing the Moral of Shane and A Christmas Carol

Comparing the Moral of Shane and A Christmas Carol

Length: 799 words (2.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Comparing the Moral of Jack Schaefer's Shane and A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens         

 

In Jack Schaefer's novel Shane, Jack Schaefer states his opinion on peoples ability to change.  Shane says to Bob, "A man is what he is, Bob, and there's no breaking the mold."  Jack Scaefer supports this quote by making Shane return to his old method of dealing with problems.  When Shane first arrived he was dessed in all black.  Shane later tells the Starrett family thatr he was a gunfighter in his past.  Later in the novel you can tell that Shane is to avoid his past, Shane begins to dress in colors besides black and he also tries to handle problems verbally rather than physically.  Shane tries very hard to prevent having to return to his violent past.  Shane keeps to himself a lot too, Shane does not like disscusing his past with anybody, as if he were ashamed.  When confrtont Shane  Stark Wilson, Shane tries to give Stark Wilson a chance out, Shane gives Stark wilson a chance to walk away, but Stark Wilson refuses.  Since Stark Wilson insited on fighting Joe Starrett Shane is forced to go back to his violent past.  Shane dresses back up in his all black clothes, just as he wore when he first arrived.  Shane grabed his gun and met Stark Wilson for the final showdown.  By having Shane return to solving problems with a gun, Jack Schefer implies that a man can not changed, there is no breaking the mold.

            In A Christmas Carol, Charles Dickens expresses his belief on changing ones personality.  The moral of A Christmas Carol is "People can make changes in their lives whenever they really want to, even right up to the end."  Charles Dickens shows the moral by haveing Scrooge change his personality.  In the begining of A Christmas Carol Scrooge is a cold and almost heartless man, Scrooge doesn't like Christmas or anything to do with it.  Scrooge keeps to himself a lot, he does not like having people around him, not even his own family.  Scrooge had a partner named Marley, Marley was just as bad as Scrooge is.  Because of Marley's foul behavior he is condemed to an eternity of carrying heavy chains.  One night Marley appears before Scrooge and warns him that if he continues being the kind of person that he is, he will face a destiny much worse than what Marley is facing.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Comparing the Moral of Shane and A Christmas Carol." 123HelpMe.com. 18 Oct 2019
    <https://www.123helpme.com/view.asp?id=3200>.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Dickens' A Christmas Carol and the Industrial Revolution Essay

- Dickens' A Christmas Carol and the Industrial Revolution Besides being the secular story of Christmas time in an urban setting, A Christmas Carol, tells the sacred story of Christmas as well. With A Christmas Carol, Dickens initiated an ongoing creative process in the Anglo-American imagination. As a result of the Industrial Revolution and the growth and development of cities people's lives changed drastically as they moved from the life and traditions of the country into those of the city....   [tags: Dickens A Christmas Carol Essays]

Research Papers
897 words (2.6 pages)

Scrooge's Transformation in Dickens' A Christmas Carol Essay

- In this essay I am going to distinguish the personality of Scrooge also show you how he was at the beginning of the novella in the 1st Stave to how he changes at the end in the 5th Stave. The title to the novella 'A Christmas Carol' this suggests that the story will be a joyful Christian message. 'Christmas' is a time for celebration and togetherness. It is the time for forgiveness, kindness and charity. 'Carol' is a chant which a group of people sing Christmas and Christian songs, so this is meant to be a time where people have fun and are united with family and friends....   [tags: a christmas carol]

Research Papers
2180 words (6.2 pages)

Essay on Scrooge's Transformation in Dickens' A Christmas Carol

- Ebenezer Scrooge is the major character in the story, A Christmas Carol written by Charles Dickens. A Christmas Carol is about how a “cold-hearted, tight fisted, selfish” money grabbing man is offered an opportunity of a life time, to change his behaviour, attitude... to have a second chance in life. The theme of this novel is to look at the good you do in life and how it carries over after your death. The moral of the book is; "People can make changes in their lives whenever they really want to, even right up to the end." In this essay I am going to distinguish the personality of Scrooge also show you how he was at the beginning of the novella in the 1st Stave to how he changes at the end...   [tags: A Christmas Carol]

Research Papers
1323 words (3.8 pages)

A Christmas Carol By Charles Dickens Essay example

- A Christmas Carol was initially written and published on 19th December 1843, as a novella by Charles Dickens. The story has later been adapted into a play by Romulus Linney with the new adapted version of the play of A Christmas Carol being performed from November 18th to 21th at the Joan C. Edwards Playhouse, by the Marshal Theatre Alliance. The current adapted production is directed by Associate Professor Nicole Perrone, with the leading role of Ebenezer Scrooge played by Professor Jack Cirillo both of whom belong to the Marshall Theatre program....   [tags: Charles Dickens, A Christmas Carol]

Research Papers
948 words (2.7 pages)

A Christmas Carol By Charles Dickens Essay

- Bella Brandon Lynn Hovde English 101 28 October 2014 A Christmas Carol A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens is a holiday novella published in 1843. Dickens wrote this book after he finds himself struggling with his writing meaning he wasn 't getting much attention from his readers; immediately after he released a Christmas carol, it became popular all around the word and it gave live to his writing once again. It 's been said that A Christmas carol is Dickens best work and has been adapted many times to film and other media; the popularity of the book remained, and has not been out of print even today....   [tags: A Christmas Carol, Charles Dickens, Jacob Marley]

Research Papers
1070 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on A Christmas Carol By Charles Dickson

- The play “A Christmas Carol – A ghost story of Christmas” by Charles Dickson, directed by James Black in Houston, TX was performed in a similar way in “A Christmas Carol” by Charles Dickson, directed by Michael Wilson in Washington, D.C. The both plays had similarities and differences throughout the play in which demonstrated different creativity from the different directors. The rating that was given by the reviewer of the play in Washington gave a 5 out of 5 star rating. For the play that I went to watch the rating I would give it would be a 5 star rating....   [tags: Christmas, Charles Dickens, Christmas carol]

Research Papers
856 words (2.4 pages)

Charles Dickens ' A Christmas Carol Essay

- A key to a good society is one in which each person has equal opportunity. The U.S.A has a good society because no matter, your situation, reputation you still have the chance to make something of your future. However, not everyone has that opportunity. In other countries you can 't overcome your situation or poverty you were born in. However, if a person in a position realizes this then they can make a change for the better. In “A Christmas Carol”, Charles Dickens uses the protagonist, Scrooge, to illustrate that a society can be effected by the heart of one person....   [tags: Charles Dickens, Christmas, A Christmas Carol]

Research Papers
1127 words (3.2 pages)

A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens Essay

- A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens Introduction Charles Dickens was born in Landport, Hampshire, in 1812 and died in 1870. His father was a clerk in the navy pay office and family life was occasionally hard, especially when his father had to go to the debtor's prison. The young twelve year old Charles became the main money-maker in the family at this time and worked in a blocking factory. Charles' father was released a year later and Charles was able to go to school. After school he became a clerk for solicitors, later becoming a journalist, a reporter at Doctors' Commons and at 22 joined a London newspaper....   [tags: Christmas Carol Charles Dickens Essays]

Research Papers
3546 words (10.1 pages)

Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol Essay example

- Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol The editor of one edition of ‘A Christmas Carol’ wrote “A story so admirably told, the details of place, of time, of person so dexterously made real for us” How does Dickens achieve this. How does he ‘A Christmas Carol’ a story which “No one could help but enjoy” In this essay I am going to be writing about the different techniques in which Dickens uses, and by using these bring people, place and time to life. Dickens cleaver use of techniques throughout this book really makes us feel as if we are actually there are selves....   [tags: Charles Dickens Christmas Carol Essays]

Free Essays
1421 words (4.1 pages)

Essay about Analysis of Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol

- Analysis of Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol Charles Dickens, one of the greatest novelists in the English language, was born in 1812 into a middle-class family of precarious economic status. His father was a clerk in the Navy Pay Office at the time of Dickens's birth; by the time Charles was ten, however, his father was in debtor's prison, a victim of bad luck, mismanagement, and irresponsibility. In order to help support the family during this time of crisis, young Dickens went to work in the packing department of a factory that manufactured blacking--a compound of charcoal, soot, sugar, oil, and fat used to polish boots....   [tags: Charles Dickens A Christmas Carol Essays]

Research Papers
3865 words (11 pages)

Related Searches

  Marley tells Scrooge that he shall be visited by three ghosts.  The three ghosts show Scrooge different things, the final ghost shows Scrooge the horrible consecuences that await Scrooge if he continues being the kind of person he is.  Since Scrooge realized his mistakes, and was afraid of the future, he changed into a completely different person.  Scrooge began to love Christmas and all the wonderful thnings that came with it.  By making Scrooge completely change, Charles Dickens shows that a person can change at any age, Charles Dickens shoed that it is never too late to change.

            Both of the morals are true in one way or another, but it is my own personal belief that a person can change at any time, if he or she desires to change.  Although the moral in Shane makes some sense, I agree more with the moral from A Christmas Carol.  I believe that if a person really wants to change it is possible, no matter what the habbit is the person is trying to break.  Although it is easier to chane a person when he or she is young, it is not impossible when a person is older.  Millions of people smoke, and a lot of them wish to change that habbit, sometimes they are succesfull, and sometimes they are not.  The ones who are not sucessfull were probably not modivated enough to break the habbit.  Sometimes it takes extreme measures to break a habbit.  But if a person truely wants to change, they can do it.  Modivation and support is a great way to help a persaon change.  If a person wishes to stop being greedy for example, the best way to do so is by having somebody by your side to teach you how to share and be generous.  Change is not easy, but if the right things are done, then it is not so bad.  For example, in A Christmas Carol Scrooge is shown the future if he doesn't change, seeing that gives Scrooge a "reality check" and enables him to change with great ease.  If a smoker wishes to change, doctors often let the person see people who have been affected greatly by the dangers of smoking.  Being able to change is everybodys right, not being able to change at a certain age would be like taking their freedom away.
Return to 123HelpMe.com