Patricia MacLachlan’s Sarah Plain and Tall - Comparing Book and Movie

Patricia MacLachlan’s Sarah Plain and Tall - Comparing Book and Movie

Length: 574 words (1.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Patricia MacLachlan’s Sarah Plain and Tall - Comparing Book and Movie

The beginning of the movie begins with the exact same scene between Anna and Caleb that appears in the book. However, the movie, Sarah Plain and Tall has a variety of differences from Patricia MacLachlan’s children’s novel Sarah Plain and Tall. Essentially the movie had to go to a deeper level in order to attract adults to the story. Every event that is in the book happens in the movie. However, the movie adds scenes and complicates the relationships between the characters.

The complication between characters is especially shown in Anna and Sarah’s relationship. In the movie Anna is mad about Sarah coming to stay for a month. However, in the book she says “I wished everything was as perfect as the stone. I wished that Papa and Caleb and I were perfect for Sarah” (21). In the book Anna has no trouble liking Sarah, but in the movie Anna has a hard time letting go of her real mother and will not let Sarah get close to her. It is not until Sarah comforts Anna after a bad dream and tells her “when I was ten my mamma died” (which was not told in the book) that Sarah and Anna have a close relationship. After Sarah and Anna reach an understanding, Sarah tries to help Anna remember her mother by putting her mother’s candlesticks, quilt, a painting, and her picture back into the house. They also put flowers on her grave together. However, Anna and Sarah’s relationship is not the only one that takes a while to develop.

With the exception of some small problems with Sarah’s strong will, MacLachlan makes the relationship between Sarah and Jacob seem easy. However in the movie, Jacob also has a hard time letting Sarah get close to him because of his love for his dead wife, Katherine. For example, in the movie when they fight about putting Katherine’s possessions in the house and going to visit the grave Sarah says “I cannot make a difference until you make peace with Katherine’s death”. Jacob does not make that peace until Sarah goes to help Maggie deliver her baby. The delivery brings back memories of Katherine’s death since she died giving birth to Caleb. It is here that Jacob realizes “I never stopped long enough to tell her that I missed her”. Once Jacob realizes this he has room to love Sarah.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Patricia MacLachlan’s Sarah Plain and Tall - Comparing Book and Movie." 20 Jun 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Patricia MacLachlan's Sarah, Plain and Tall

- Patricia MacLachlan's Sarah, Plain and Tall By telling you the story, Sarah, Plain and Tall, Patricia MacLachlan portrays the importance of family and allows you to see that by through a little bit of hope and wishing your happiness can be fulfilled. She shows you how personal sacrifices occur when forming a successful family. Overall, this book provides insight on how powerful and meaningful family life can be. In Sarah, Plain and Tall the concept of family is the base on which the book is written....   [tags: Patricia MacLachlan Sarah Plain and Tall]

Free Essays
601 words (1.7 pages)

Essay on Realism in Patricia MacLachlan’s Sarah, Plain and Tall

- Realism in Patricia MacLachlan’s Sarah, Plain and Tall A book that has a clear understanding of what is “real” is often thought to be a quality book. Although what is thought to be “real” is different for everyone, for me it is how easily I am able to relate to the characters in the book. If I can sympathize and understand what they are going through on an emotional level and can put myself in their shoes, I am more apt to enjoy the story. Narrative style and structure play a very important role here; because it is through these that we get a sense of what type of realism is being portrayed....   [tags: Sarah Plain Tall]

Free Essays
849 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on Patricia MacLachlan's Life Reflected in Sarah, Plain, and Tall

- Patricia MacLachlan's Life Reflected in Sarah, Plain, and Tall Beyond MacLachlan's basic interest in creating a good children's novel in Sarah, Plain, and Tall, she also has a very personal investment in connecting her story and its characters with the many facets of her personal experiences: family, her beliefs, and her biography. It seems odd that an only child, from an intact family, would have the insight to write so detailed about the feelings of loss and a blended family. When asked “Do you think a family means a mother, and a father, and a child....   [tags: Biography Biographies Essays]

Free Essays
643 words (1.8 pages)

Comparsion of Book and Movie of Hound of the Baskervilles by Arthur Doyle

- Between the book and the movie I prefer the movie. My reasoning for this is that the movie seemed much more interesting to me. It made much more sense. I also love who they chose to play the characters in the movie. Seemed much more interesting than the ones that were in the book. I must admit that the book was pretty good, though some of it I found rather boring. One thing I did not like about the movie is that they changed or added some details into the movie that the book did not have. The ending of the movie was much better then the ending in the book....   [tags: setting, book, movie, character]

Research Papers
564 words (1.6 pages)

Essay on Into the Wild: Comparing the Book and Movie

- Into the Wild, a novel written by Jon Krakauer, as well as a film directed by Sean Penn, talks about Chris McCandless, a young individual who set out on a journey throughout the Western United States, isolating himself from society, and more importantly, his family. During his travels, he meets a lot of different people, that in a way, change his ways about how he sees the world. There are many characteristics to describe McCandless, such as “naïve”, “adventurous”, and “independent”. In the book, Krakauer described McCandless as “intelligent”, using parts in his book that show McCandless being “intelligent”....   [tags: Book vs Movie]

Research Papers
755 words (2.2 pages)

Review of Jodi Picoult's Plain Truth Essay

- Throughout the novel, Plain Truth, by Jodi Picoult, we as the reader are presented an inside look into the many boundaries that are placed on the main character, Katie Fisher. While one could argue that the majority of the boundaries were placed on her because of her religion there are also boundaries present that were placed on her because of her parents. Katie Fisher's life pressures are much similar to those of a young student named Neil in the movie Dead Poets Society, where he endures daily pressures that turn into a problem he cannot overcome....   [tags: Book Review]

Research Papers
1382 words (3.9 pages)

The Big Sleep - The Movie and The Book Essay

- The Big Sleep - The Movie and The Book One would think that it would be quite easy to adapt a novel to a screenplay; after all, what is there to do but turn the dialogue into lines and description into set design. However, common sense, aided by the horrifying number of absolutely awful adaptations, dictates that it simply is not that easy. When moviegoers have problems with a film adaptation of a book, their complaints tend to lie in the tendency of the creators of the film to change elements of the story: plot, character, and the like....   [tags: Movie Film comparison compare contrast]

Free Essays
1320 words (3.8 pages)

Out of Africa Movie and Book Essay

- Out of Africa Movie and Book Winner of seven Academy Awards, including 1985's Best Picture, Out Of Africa is the story of Karen Blixen and her travels in Africa. Based on her writings after returning to Denmark, Out of Africa is a love story of both Karen Blixen and her true love, Denys Hatton, and a love for Africa's land and people. The movie is based on the books "Out of Africa: Shadows on the Grass", written by Karen Blixen under the pseudonym Isak Dinesen, and "Silence Will Speak", the story of Denys Hatton, written by Errol Trzebinski....   [tags: Movie Film comparison compare contrast]

Research Papers
1026 words (2.9 pages)

Essay about The Scarlet Letter: The Book vs. the Movie

- The Scarlet Letter:  The Book vs. the Movie    Demi Moore's portrayal of Hester in the movie The Scarlet Letter proved her worth as a feminist actress, which led her to other, more modern female empowerment roles ranging from Striptease to GI Jane.  But in the moviemakers 'attempt to give the story what they might think is a little modern flavor, they barbarously misconstrued the theme, and thus the importance, of a timeless story.  In the novel, there can be little doubt that Hester is a strong person, but the movie made her out to be a martyr for women's rights.  The female empowerment theme of the movie also inevitably led to the characterization of Christians and their ethics as tyra...   [tags: Movie Film comparison compare contrast]

Research Papers
1433 words (4.1 pages)

Little Women - Movie vs. Book Essays

- Little Women - Movie vs. Book According to the Internet Movie Database's exhaustive records, Louisa May Alcott's novel "Little Women" has seen itself recreated in four TV series, four made for TV movies and five feature length movies since 1918. The most recent version appeared in 1994 and features Winona Ryder, Claire Danes, Kirsten Dunst, Samantha Mathis, Eric Stoltz, Susan Sarandon, and Gabriel Byrne. As a long time fan of the novel, who has happily carted her large leather bound gold-gilded unabridged edition whenever she has moved, I find that I was disappointed in this newest movie version....   [tags: Movie Film comparison compare contrast]

Free Essays
805 words (2.3 pages)

Related Searches

But he gets scared of her leaving him when she goes to town, so Jacob goes to town, kisses her, and brings her back home. In contrast, MacLachlan’s novel tells us, “Sarah kissed us all, even my father, who looked surprised,” and Jacob is not worried about her coming back from town (53).

Due to the drama, I enjoyed the movie a little more. I think Hallmark accomplished their goal in making the movie more appealing to an adult audience. The fundamentals between the movie and the book were the same, but the added tension gave the movie a deeper connection between the characters and overall created realism. Let’s face it, in most families there would have been some tension between the new mother, Sarah, and the memories of the beloved mother, Katherine.

Works Cited

MacLachlan, Patricia. Sarah Plain and Tall. HarperCollins: New York, 1985.

Sarah Plain and Tall. Dir. Glenn Jordan. Perf. Glenn Close and Christopher Walken. Hallmark Hall of Fame and Republic Pictures, 1991.
Return to