Race and the American Criminal Justice System: The O.J. Simpson Case

Race and the American Criminal Justice System: The O.J. Simpson Case

Length: 867 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Race and the American Criminal Justice System: The O.J. Simpson Case


Historically racism has pervaded the administration of justice in America and Canada. Racial biases against blacks are still apparent today through the many different arenas of the criminal justice system. Black Americans argue that they are treated unequally and more brutally than whites at all levels in the criminal justice system. As a result of this unequal treatment blacks are more likely to be arrested, charged, convicted and receive longer sentences then whites for the same crimes. Black Americans make up about 12% of the US population and they account for more then 30% of all arrests, 44% of all prisoners and 40% of prisoners on death row (Hunt, 1999:74).

The racial problem exists in many forms within the criminal justice system and most of this racial disparity can be attributed to the practices of the prosecution and more particularly the police. The unequal treatment of blacks within the justice system becomes evident through various forms of police misconduct such as excessive use of force against blacks, harassment, planting and falsifying evidence and police perjury. Most of these issues were brought to question in the criminal court case against O. J. Simpson, who was arrested and charged with the murders of his ex-wife Nicole Brown Simpson and Ronald L. Goldman.

The question of race was addressed in the high profile court case of O.J. Simpson when Simpson's lawyer, Johnnie Cochran took a Critical Race Theory position in defence of his client (Aylward, 1999:68). Cochran believed that racism was a central issue to the case and it was revealed primarily by detective Mark Fuhrman of the LAPD in a white supremacist form. Fuhrman was the detective who uncovered most of the evidence that connected Simpson to the murders. The defence's argument was that detective Fuhrman, motivated by his hatred of blacks, had planted the blood on O.J.'s bronco and the bloody glove at the Simpson's residence in order to incriminate him for the crime.

In order to prove Fuhrman's racial hatred and willingness to fabricate evidence, Cochran wanted to introduce evidence of thirty incidents where detective Fuhrman used racial epithets ("nigger") and eighteen examples of his misconduct contained in audio tapes that Fuhrman had made (Aylward, 1999:69). The court did not allow this evidence to be admitted but did allow for the defence to put three witnesses on the stand to testify to the racist attitudes they had experienced from detective Fuhrman.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Race and the American Criminal Justice System: The O.J. Simpson Case." 123HelpMe.com. 19 Aug 2019
    <https://www.123helpme.com/view.asp?id=26709>.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Criminal Justice: Racial Disparity and Discrimination and O.J. Simpson Essay

- Criminal law is based on the principle of actus non facit reum nisi mens sit rea. The principle is to the extent that a man is not guilty of his acts, actus in the absence of a guilty conscience, mens rea (Gardner, 2009). To this end, criminal law justice provides that the person alleging the commission of a crime must proof beyond reasonable doubt that the accused person(s) possessed mens rea, if the court is to hold a criminal liability against the accused. In the case of People of the State of California v....   [tags: criminal law, O.J. Simpson Trial, justice system]

Research Papers
763 words (2.2 pages)

The Criminal Justice System Essay

- The criminal justice system is composed of three parts – Police, Courts and Corrections – and all three work together to protect an individual’s rights and the rights of society to live without fear of being a victim of crime. According to merriam-webster.com, crime is defined as “an act that is forbidden or omission of a duty that is commanded by public law and that makes the offender liable to punishment by that law.” When all the three parts work together, it makes the criminal justice system function like a well tuned machine....   [tags: Criminal Justice]

Research Papers
1478 words (4.2 pages)

Reasonable Doubts: The Criminal Justice System and the O.J. Simpson Case

- Book Summary The New York Times bestseller book titled Reasonable Doubts: The Criminal Justice System and the O.J. Simpson Case examines the O.J. Simpson criminal trial of the mid-1990s. The author, Alan M. Dershowitz, relates the Simpson case to the broad functions and perspectives of the American criminal justice system as a whole. A Harvard law school teacher at the time and one of the most renowned legal minds in the country, Dershowitz served as one of O.J. Simpson’s twelve defense lawyers during the trial....   [tags: book summary, Alan M. Dershowitz]

Research Papers
2404 words (6.9 pages)

Simpson Was Acquitted For Murder Essay

- October 3, 1995 the day O.J. Simpson was acquitted for murder was a day of either utter discuss, or of triumph against a system that has not been known to be on the side of minorities. At the time just being 13 years old, I was already seeing the difference between how Caucasians and minorities where treated differently by the law. Living an area where it was heavily Caucasian I would be harassed by the police on my way home to school, or to meet with friends at whatever location we had decided to hang out at....   [tags: Crime, Police, Bill Clinton, Criminal justice]

Research Papers
1364 words (3.9 pages)

Essay on Race and its Implications in the Criminal Justice System

- Race has continually been an important issue within the United States and most predominantly the criminal justice system. Racial tension in America is often thought of as being white versus black, even though that is not in fact the case. African-Americans view the system as favoring whites while trying to keep them at the bottom. While whites claim that the criminal justice system is colorblind, blacks clearly do not feel this way; whites underestimate the racial divide in the criminal justice system (Bikel, 2005)....   [tags: United States, African Americans]

Research Papers
994 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on Problems with the OJ Simpson Trial

- ... Poor collection methods of evidence can result in the contamination of evidence. Evidence contamination is defined as the addition or removal from the originally collected specimen (Schiro, n.d.). This issue is perhaps the most important in crime scene investigation. In an effort to fully preserve a scene of a crime, a large area is cordoned off to the public and a crime scene log is created. The crime scene log contains five components. The components are as follows: the name of the individual entering the crime scene, date, time entered, time out, and reason for entry (Schiro, n.d.)....   [tags: notorious, televised murder trials]

Research Papers
1705 words (4.9 pages)

Racial Disparities in the Criminal Justice System The purpose for creation of legal systems in the world is to pursue justice. Pursuance of justice re

- The purpose for creation of legal systems in the world is to pursue justice. Pursuance of justice requires fair application of the law. Therefore, the events unfolding in the United States undermine this principle. The Justice Integrity Bill is meant to increase public confidence in the justice system and address any unwarranted racial and ethnic disparities in the criminal process that has raised eyebrows over the years. This bill purports to enforce fair application of the law in order to realize justice for all; both black and white....   [tags: social issues, negro, race]

Research Papers
1120 words (3.2 pages)

Race Relations in the U.S. Essay

- Race Relations in the U.S. I've discovered the real roots of America these past few days and decided that writing about it was better than killing an innocent victim to soothe the hostility I feel towards my heritage. I picked up a pen because it was safer than a gun. This was a valuable lesson I've learned from my forefathers, who did both. Others in my country react on instinct and choose not to deliberate the issue as I have. If they are black, they are imprisoned or dead. As The People vs....   [tags: Papers]

Research Papers
2135 words (6.1 pages)

Minorities and Justice Essays

- Minorities and Justice Television shows such as Dateline, 60 Minutes and 20/20 have often aired segments on discrimination within the justice system through hidden cameras recording police behavior towards minorities, interviews with minorities falsely accused or mistreated, and by referring to capital punishment statistics seemingly biased especially towards blacks. The Justice Files has produced several biographies on minorities who were subjected to some atrocity by the American justice system....   [tags: Papers]

Research Papers
1787 words (5.1 pages)

Ideological Bias Reflected in American Crime Statistics Essay

- As Nils Christie argued, crime is a property of the state (2004). As such, it can be defined by the same systems of ideals which influence the state. Crime statistics, which refer to a category of human acts that society view as deviant, can consequently be argued to be without objectivity (Dorling and Simpson, 1999). The statistics they provide are thus arguably not exact. To a certain extent one could infer they are reflections of society, of those who present the data and most importantly of those who accumulate it....   [tags: Race and the Criminal Justice System]

Research Papers
1787 words (5.1 pages)

Related Searches

There was more evidence of Fuhrman's hatred of blacks contained in legal documents in which he admitted to extreme hatred for blacks and incidents of his misconduct. The judge also excluded most of this evidence, because he thought the jury might draw negative inferences if they heard all the racial and misconduct comments (Aylward, 1999:70).

The jury in the criminal trail of O. J. Simpson consisted of nine black female jurors, two white jurors and one Latino juror, who unanimously acquitted Simpson of all charges of murder. Many whites believed the verdict was a racist one because the jury was primarily black and believed the jury participated in jury nullification. Pertaining to race based jury nullification, it is believed that black jurors ignore the facts and acquit a defendant whom they believe to be guilty to prevent the unfair and discriminatory imprisonment of more Blacks by a racist criminal justice system (Aylward, 1999:72). However, the jury claimed they acquitted O.J. Simpson based on the evidence presented about a racist policeman and the possibility of evidence tampering, therefore the jury believed the prosecution did not prove innocence beyond a reasonable doubt.

Cochran placed Blacks at the core of his defence, he believed the jury, consisting mostly of Blacks, would easily accept and understand evidence of police misconduct against Blacks. Due to the history of the unequal treatment of Blacks within the criminal justice system, Black jurors are more likely to entertain the thought that there are racist police officers and that police officers sometimes do lie. The defence implemented a Critical Race Litigation strategy and forced the court to consider the race question in hope to change the condition of "colour-blind" justice in America (Aylward, 1999:74). The Race Litigation strategy requires a contextualized approach to a court case that puts the experiences of blacks at the center of analysis.

Since the beginning of slavery Blacks have continuously sought equal rights and equal protection under the law in America. Despite their attempts to obtain equality, race still remains a serious problem in American society as is illustrated in recent court cases. Issues of race and racism can no longer be ignored, the new Critical Race Litigation strategy has emerged in order to face the ongoing problem of racism within the criminal justice system.

References

Aylward, Carl.
1999 Canadian Critical Race Theory. Halifax: Fernwood.

Hunt, Darnell M.
1999 O.J. Simpson Facts and Fictions. Cambridge, UK; New York: Cambridge University Press.

1.
1 Carol Aylward, Canadian Critical Race Litigation (Halifax: Fernwood, 1999) 83.
2.
2 Aylward 95.
3.
3 Aylward 84.
4.
4 Aylward 95.
5.
5 Aylward 97-98.
6.
6 Aylward 102.
7.
7 Aylward 84.
8.
8 Aylward 97.
9.
9 Aylward 84.
10.
10 Aylward 97.

Return to 123HelpMe.com