Exploring the Validity of Natural Theology

Exploring the Validity of Natural Theology

Length: 1129 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Exploring the Validity of Natural Theology

The thought processes that underlie Creationism and Evolution are undoubtedly very different. The fundamentalists of the former school of thought adhere to the Biblical tenet that divine creation in six days is responsible for environmental diversity, whereas evolutionists have repeatedly stated that the universe was created billions of years ago and is in a constant state of fluctuation. At first glance, these accounts of life on Earth seem incompatible—the creationists base their beliefs purely on faith and explain their surroundings based on that conclusion, while scientists work in the opposite direction by asking questions first and make systematic observations that have resulted from their propositions (Moore 5-6). Ernst Mayr claims that "the beliefs of creationism are in conflict with the findings of science," but the founders of Natural Theology have managed to unite the principles of Genesis with those of evolution (qtd. in Mayr 4). There are strict purists who claim that it is not viable to combine the two ideologies, but it is possible to incorporate the concept of G-d into scientific fact.

Although there are several variations on the concept of Natural Theology, its advocates generally accept evolution. Whereas strict creationists reject the notion that the Earth was formed billions of years ago, natural theists accept the scientific evidence for the age of the Earth with one large discrepancy: organisms could have only originated with the aid of divine intervention. However, it is acknowledged that there is no concrete evidence to substantiate the belief that the Earth was created a mere few thousand years ago, just as there isn't any geological confirmation that a global flood engulfed the entire planet (Science and Creationism). This liberal interpretation of Genesis and cautious acceptance of evolution allows for some flexibility with previously undisputed Biblical notions, such as the idea that the creation of the world was completed within six twenty-four hour periods. Those six days have been construed to signify as a literary device by the author of the Bible, six days separated by long time periods, or as six days from the perspective of an ageless G-d (Commission on Creation). Thus, the essence of Natural Theory is that an omnipotent creator fashioned the physical processes that set evolution in motion and these processes resulted in the creation of life.

This theory appears to be logical, except for the notion that some aspects of life are so complex that they completely transcend human understanding and are thereby the work of an Intelligent Designer.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Exploring the Validity of Natural Theology." 123HelpMe.com. 18 Aug 2018

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Theology Behind The Suffering of Job Essay

- The book of Job provides a vivid illustration of the theology of suffering. In the beginning of the book, Job’s blessings are apparent. He possesses a large family, good health, many servants, flocks of multiple species of livestock, and is considered the greatest of all men in the East (Job 1.13). Job is not only cover story material for “Progressive Farmer” and “Fortune” magazines, he is more importantly a godly man, “blameless, upright, fearing God and turning from evil” (Job 1.1). In rapid succession, however, Job experiences numerous calamities....   [tags: Theology]

Research Papers
1337 words (3.8 pages)

Computer Science: Data Mining Essay

- Data mining is an analytic process of exploring huge amount of data, extract useful information, finding consistent patterns and trends between variables, and build predictive computer models from the relationship discovered using a combination of classical statistics, machine learning and artificial intelligence. The findings are then applied to new subsets of data to test its validity. It performs two essential tasks, descripting and predicting. Descriptive mining tasks characterize the general properties of the data in database....   [tags: exploring data, prediction, validity]

Research Papers
1518 words (4.3 pages)

The Elimination of Natural Theology Essay

- The Elimination of Natural Theology ABSTRACT: The dispute between fideists and rationalists seems intractable since those who argue for faith alone claim that they are offended by the use of reason in religion. The advocates of reason claim that they are equally offended by the appeal to faith. This dispute may be resolved by showing that those who rely on faith may be seen as engaging in an experiment of living, so they can become part of a rational experiment without having to alter their practice; in contrast, those who use reason to justify religion can be seen as addressing a spiritual need....   [tags: Religion Religious Theological Papers]

Research Papers
3299 words (9.4 pages)

Dynamics of History as Argument for Biblical Theology Essay

- In this point we explore how Edwards related the dynamics of history, location and time, as arguments for Biblical Theology or for his Work of Redemption. Edwards believed that redemption is inextricable from history and vice versa. However it would take him many years to develop this connection into a coherent philosophy and theology of salvation history. Edwards faced the acute problem how to demonstrate God’s sovereignty and redemptive activity in an evolving age. In this respect it was difficult to reconstruct the series temporum (stages of time) from God’s redemptive plan....   [tags: theology]

Research Papers
1830 words (5.2 pages)

Validity: Critical Thinking About A Research Project Essay

- Validity A research is valid to the world when a number of key concepts are used in the research design. The document must be organized and planned according to the criteria used in the field. Some important concepts to know include: validity, variable, operationalization, sample, measurement, measurement error, causation, plausible rival explanations, hypothesis, reliability, and unit of analysis. The researcher must learn how to apply each key concept in an effort to make the research study valuable....   [tags: validity, variable, operationalization]

Research Papers
1596 words (4.6 pages)

Liberation Theology Essay

- Arising out recent class discussion topics touching on the ideas of James Cone’s ideas on Liberation Theology and the relationship between the Cross and the Lynching Tree, our group decided to focus the topic of our presentation around Liberation Theology. However, in order to create a counter argument to stimulate further discourse, we introduced the Theology of Prosperity, as an opposing theological concept, to our presentation. Hence, we came up with the topic of Liberation Theology vs. Theology of Prosperity....   [tags: Theology]

Research Papers
1064 words (3 pages)

Reformed Theology Essay

- There were various theologies of the sacrament of Holy Communion that were being debated during the Reformation. Among reformers there were conflicting views on transubstantiation, consubstantiation, infant baptism and Christ’s importance of being in communion overall. Some reformers and reformation events that appealed believers more than others were Martin Luther, Ulrich Zwingli, John Calvin and the Council of Trent. Martin Luther was a German priest who rebelled against authorities of the Roman Catholic Church and initiated the start of the reformation....   [tags: Theology ]

Research Papers
1361 words (3.9 pages)

Exploring the Validity of Hamlet's Madness in Hamlet by William Shakespeare

- Exploring the Validity of Hamlet's Madness in Hamlet by William Shakespeare The issue of madness is one of major importance in this play. Is Hamlet truly mad, meaning insane. Or is he merely angry. Does he feign madness and use it as a guise. Or does he place himself so dangerously close to the line between sanity and insanity that he crosses it without even realizing it. Or is he so intelligent, cunning and in control that this is merely the playing out of his completely conceived and well-executed plan of attack....   [tags: Papers]

Research Papers
1968 words (5.6 pages)

Essay on Liberation Theology

- Liberation theology is religious phenomenon which bursts on the scene in the 1960’s. A consciousness for injustice was always prevalent in the Church, but the “theologies of liberation, particularly the classical Latin American variety, evolved in protest against the inability in Western church and missionary circles, both Catholic and Protestant, to grapple with the problems of systemic injustice.” (Boch 443) To truly understand the critiques of missiology which have been articulated by Latin American liberation theologies and Asian theologies, one must first understand liberation....   [tags: Theology, Church]

Research Papers
1002 words (2.9 pages)

Validity Essay

- Validity The use of music seems to be a good way of operationalising the IV as many people do learn to the sound of music so therefore the difference between the music and no music condition should be marked. Also, getting the participants to write down the words is a good way of measuring the DV as it means it is easy to collect and analyse the data. The study itself was quite simple and it seemed to measure what effects music has on learning....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
949 words (2.7 pages)

Related Searches

This idea would have been more logical in previous centuries where the scope of science was very limited or nonexistent altogether, but we have since gained the knowledge of the cell—the basic unit of life—and have thus learned of the complexities of the even the smallest micro-organisms. It would appear that in modern times, there is very little that is (or will ever be) completely unknowable to the formidable scope of science, but at the end of the nineteenth century, such a conclusion would have been unreasonable. For example, the discovery of radioactivity provided scientists with an accurate geological clock that enabled them to determine a close approximation of the Earth's age, which led many creationists to re-evaluate their belief that world was merely thousands of years old (Moore 180). Essentially, what we do not know today we may discover tomorrow; the only genuinely improvable concept being the existence and nature of G-d.

Science and Creationism do not completely make sense on their own accords, so the concept of a higher being can be incorporated into evolutionary thought. Faith is not necessarily only for the closed-minded—it is the few vocal fundamentalists who give religion a negative reputation in the eyes of logical thinkers. The question of the Creationists is certainly valid: how can inanimate matter suddenly become life and how did that matter even come to be created? A
strict interpretation of the Bible states that G-d created the universe in all of its entirety in a mere six days, but this explanation of our existence does not correlate with proven facts regarding the age of the Earth. Science cannot prove the existence of a G-d or other supernatural occurrences because science is involved with the natural world and there are no such tools that have been developed to prove in the reality of an omnipotent force. Conversely, Genesis contains no scientific evidence nor provides an explanation of the diversity of life and the universality of cellular biochemistry in living organisms (Moore 52). The Natural Theology solution: G-d created evolution.

Like Creationism and evolution, Natural Theology has its flaws. In particular, the issue of whether Adam and Eve were the first humans or whether Man evolved from a common ancestor. The Natural Theologians adhere to the belief that humans were created by G-d, who used a body plan that was reminiscent of the apes (Commission on Creation). Those who adopt this belief argue that evolution is a progression to a more complex form of organism and it is the ultimate goal of perfection that incites development. Although there no such internal genetic drive has been discovered, the word 'perfection' is certainly open to debate. That word is used quite frequently in the diction of Natural Theology, for eighteenth century theologians believed that the world was created as a perfect realm, and that even when it was subsequently discovered that some aspects of it were not quite ideal, it was believed that G-d's laws would ultimately lead to perfection (Mayr 213-15). However, this idea proves to be very problematic for two reasons; the first being that this view is conflicted by the Bible. If it is believed that the Messiah will come to Earth to repair and bring peace to the world, then it could not have been perfect at the onset. The second is that the physical world is far from perfect; it is a brutal and disorganized place in which many resources are wasted (Mayr 148). Therefore, the word 'perfection' is much too finalistic to
be credible.

Although there is no tangible scientific proof that an omnipotent deity exists, the story of evolution does leave many questions unanswered; chiefly, how does inanimate matter suddenly become life and how did that matter come to originate? Although modern technology has disproved many literal interpretations of the Bible, religion and science aren't necessarily incompatible. With flexible analyses of both, it is quite feasible to believe that a god created the world, complete with evolution.

Works Cited

Commission on Creation. Aug. 2000. American Scientific Affiliation. 17 Feb. 2004.

Mayr, Ernst. What Evolution Is. New York: Basic Books, 2001.

Moore, John A. From Genesis to Genetics. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 2002.

Science and Creationism. Aug. 1999. National Academy of Sciences. 17 Feb. 2004.

Return to 123HelpMe.com