The Controversial Relationship between Early Humans and their Environment

The Controversial Relationship between Early Humans and their Environment

Length: 909 words (2.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
The Controversial Relationship between Early Humans and their Environment

In the very beginning of human history, there was no clear separation between man and nature. Early humans’ way of living was in unison with their environment and it is likely that it was pleasurable as well. Humans supported themselves by hunting and gathering and due to their small population size and density, they were able to sustain themselves without too much effort. Thomas Hobbes claims that the life of early humans was “nasty, brutish and short”, but modern theories reject such viewpoint (Ponting, p.19).

Unfortunately, there is little direct evidence that shows what daily human life was like hundreds of years ago. Therefore, anthropologists and historians use studies on African tribes and Aborigines to build theories about the customs of early humans. Of course, such an extrapolation is not very reliable, but it is as close as one can get to the truth.

It would not be too flattering for early humans to claim that they had a very modest and conscientious way of life. The tropical climate was very benign toward all forms of life, so humans did not have to preoccupy themselves with storage or conservation of food. Fresh plants were available and plentiful all year round, so obtaining food was not the main human concern. Judging from the diet of the bushmen in Africa, early humans probably had more nutritious and balanced meals than modern humans. As Ponting points out in his book, Green History of the World, the African bushmen consume the nuts of the mongongo tree, which adequately meet their nutritious and energy needs. Since the mongongo nuts are abundant and easy to gather, the bushmen have a steady source of food which they can rely on for subsistence.

It can be concluded that early humans followed a similar pattern of behavior. They used gathering of plant material as main food source, because hunting was much more difficult and less efficient. According to Ponting, one out of ten attempts to kill an animal was successful, therefore hunting was used solely to complement the fresh provisions. Since early humans were completely dependent on their environment for survival, they carefully used the available resources without overstressing them. They took from nature as much as they needed, not only to protect it, but also to save time. Bushmen value food and leisure time equally, that’s why it is fair to suppose that early humans harvested only as much as they could consume, so that they can enjoy the rest of their time.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"The Controversial Relationship between Early Humans and their Environment." 19 Sep 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Relationship Between Humans And Nature Essay

- The relationship between humanity and nature has undergone a power shift since the time of cave paintings in Lascaux. The Tragedy of the Commons describes a balance between pre-industrial humans and nature, a relationship of morbid regulation. Human kind was prosperous, however limited in growth by various methods of population culling, which prevented humans from dominating the resources presented by nature. The issue occurs when humans reach a point of social cohesiveness that they are able to resist nature’s methods of population regulation and grow uninhibited....   [tags: Human, Natural environment, Developed country]

Research Papers
974 words (2.8 pages)

Essay Analysis Of Pippa Goldschmidt 's ' An Anecdotal

- In an anecdotal piece, Pippa Goldschmidt depicts the struggle of balancing a promising career with a lackluster life as she succumbs to routine and boredom rather than experiencing the wonders of life. She describes her irritation with day-to-day activities through the gloomy, polluted skies of Britain and the striking phenomena of Magellanic Clouds of Chile, rendering two distinct places marvelous, but flawed . Fascinated by astronomy and the understanding of distant skies, the tone of the narrative shifts from one of astonishment to nostalgia as she recalls the endless days stuck in an office or the lonely nights glaring at the sky ....   [tags: Human, Humans, Morality, Nature]

Research Papers
735 words (2.1 pages)

The Benefits of a Vegetative Cover Essay

- In the fields, the pollution can be finding in the crops and in the way of planting. Uses of chemicals products, such as pesticides and fertilizers, can be dangerous for the human and the nature. For humans, because of the contamination that some products, such as pesticides and herbicids (for weed control), can cause when it is apply, by the exposure to it. This products, because their are dangerous for the human health, has to follow rules of application and in restriction quantity (1). And when applied by a person, this has to own special clothes and accessories (like gloves and glasses) to their security, to not be exposure at the toxicity of the substance....   [tags: pollution and toxicity to humans]

Research Papers
1159 words (3.3 pages)

The Relationship between the Environment and Humans as Shown by the Native Americans and the English Settlers

- The relationship held between the environment and humans is sacred and ever-changing. Both the Native Americans and the English settlers used the land to their advantage, but they had different goals in mind. The English Settlers were more interested in creating civilizations and killing animals so they could make a profit. Native Americans were more interested in using the land and the animals that they killed in an efficient manner. Native Americans were natural born warriors, they were not schooled and they suffered from a lack of farming abilities, but their capability to adapt to their surroundings was unmatched and gave them a greater appreciation for the land they lived on....   [tags: Environment, Humans, Environmentalism, Native Amer]

Research Papers
752 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on The Relationship Between Economic Growth and Social Development

- Economic growth and social development are complementary and close relationship constraints. However, with economic growth, it is clear that there are many environmental concerns in today’s society. Air, water, and land pollution have been worsening; the environment of wild animals and plants have been seriously damaged, many species are threatened with extinction, deforestation and over-exploitation of mineral resources give human survival and development a real and more serious potential threat....   [tags: Economics ]

Research Papers
1458 words (4.2 pages)

Essay about The Relationship Between Humans and the Environment

- The Relationship Between Humans and the Environment Nearly everything that a human does is in response to the environment. Our lives are defined by what is around us and what we find in front of us, whether this means accepting, dealing with or changing it. This has been the pattern since primates first stood up and became Homo erectus, and has continued until we considered ourselves doubly wise. The shape of the land affected where humans moved. Weather was something with which to contend. Fire affected humans until they conquered it – and herein lies the core of the relationship....   [tags: Environment Environmental Pollution Preservation]

Research Papers
1367 words (3.9 pages)

Essay about The Relationship Between Early Humans and Their Environment

- The Relationship Between Early Humans and Their Environment In television shows and textbooks, early humans are often presented as being an isolated force within their environments - that is, that they evolved with relatively little influence from their environment. This view often stresses the advances of human beings and their exploitation of the environment as a function of their anatomical development, particularly brain capacity. However, it fails to address the fact that human beings were not as we know ourselves to be today; that we were simply another large carnivore interacting with many different types of animals and environmental conditions, who happened to evolve into a social...   [tags: Environment Environmental Pollution Preservation]

Free Essays
983 words (2.8 pages)

A Controversial Issue On The Environment Essay

- Knowing how exactly to take care of our environment has always been a controversial issue. Some environmentalists believe that humans are ruining the earth with air pollution, rapid industrialization, excess trash, deforestation, and water pollution. Some believe that not only are humans taking up precious space, but they are polluting the surrounding area as well. In fact it is believed that the pollution seeps into the soil and waterways, affecting land far beyond the original settlements. Waste that is dumped into small rivers travels through channels and ends up polluting the ocean....   [tags: Natural environment, Environmentalism]

Research Papers
1283 words (3.7 pages)

Essay about The Relation of Early Humans to Their Environment

- The Relation of Early Humans to Their Environment The relationship early humans had to the environment that surrounded them is one that is shrouded in debate. As Thomas Hobbes said, and as every subsequent anthropological writer has quoted, life for early man was supposedly "nasty, brutish and short". Were hunter/gatherers lives before the development of agriculture ruled by the Darwinian whims of the environment that surrounded them, or were they able to raise above the toil of everyday survival to better control their own fates....   [tags: Environment Environmental Pollution Preservation]

Research Papers
1698 words (4.9 pages)

Essay about Early Humans and the Environment

- Early Humans and the Environment Early humans were quite different from modern humans. Modern humans have many technologies and advances that we take for granted. In my lifetime (1982 - present) I have seen the five and a half inch floppy yield to the dvd, cloning of sheep and other advances in the fields of math, science, and engineering. Humans and Pre-Humans have always been developing, either intentionally or unintentionally, technologies that were either necessary for the continuation of life, or for the improved quality of life, thus changing the environment....   [tags: Environment Environmental Pollution Preservation]

Research Papers
915 words (2.6 pages)

Related Searches

Early humans did not lead a sedentary way of life judging from the fact “the Gidjingali Aborigenes of Northern Australia have a clear seasonal round of varying exploitation” (Ponting, p.22). They moved several times a year within short distance, adjusting to the location of the plants that were ripe or in season. Such a behavior suggests that early humans had a deep and detailed knowledge of their natural surroundings. It was through careful observation that they were able to adapt to the environment. Adjusting their needs to what is available helped them survive without too much effort or inconvenience. Ponting concludes that “these groups lived in close harmony with the environment and did minimal damage to natural ecosystems” (p.32).

Another theory about early humans, which contradicts the above statement by Ponting, is put forward by geologist Gilford Miller from the University of Colorado. He believes that the activities of early humans resulted in an irreversible climactic and ecological change in Australia. While studying 50,000 years old sediments in Wolf Creek Crater in Western Australia, Miller encountered fossils from extinct megafauna. His data shows that large marsupials and lizards inhabited Australia before humans conquered the continent. The geologist claims that it was humans that drove these large animals to extinction. He believes that early humans set fires which destroyed most of the vegetation in Australia and doomed the existing fauna to starvation. Reduction of vegetation affected rainfall patterns as well. Miller concludes that early humans’ activity caused a negative cascade effect on the environment which was responsible for the extinction of large mammals.

Miller’s theory is not very well substantiated. The fact that two events happen at the same time does not necessarily mean that one is a result of the other. There is no direct evidence to prove that the appearance of humans caused the disappearance of the megafauna, besides the fact that they take place in approximately the same time. Miller is “speculating” that early humans set fires deliberately, thus altering the vegetation and depriving the large mammals of food. There is no clear evidence why and how humans set fires. Besides that, it is unlikely that a small number of settlers would set so many fires as to affect the vegetation of such big piece of land as Australia.

Given the above hypotheses, the relationship between early humans and their environment is controversial. On one hand, early humans did not exploit more resources than they could use, so they were preserving nature. On the other hand, it is inevitable that their actions had some kind of impact on the environment, but not to the extent to which Miller believes. The truth, as always, is somewhere in the middle, but it is hard to find the middle in piles of dust.


Ponting, Clive. 1992. A Green History of the World: The Environment and the Collapse of Great Civilizations. St. Martin's Press: New York.
Return to