Inaccurate Portrayal of the Dinosaur Face

Inaccurate Portrayal of the Dinosaur Face

Length: 1214 words (3.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Inaccurate Portrayal of the Dinosaur Face

As time goes on, Paleontologists discover more and more fossil remains, and with that more and more information about dinosaurs. Yet even with the great deal of fossils that have been discovered in the past century, scientists are still forced to make educated guesses about certain dinosaur behaviors, traits, and appearance. Dr. Lawrence Witmer’s recent research addresses this issue. Dr. Witmer argues that the fleshy nostril of dinosaurs lies in a different place than has been assumed and portrayed for over the last one hundred years.

Dr. Witmer’s discovery was published in the August issue of Science magazine in 2001 and may change how we envision dinosaurs forever. Movies like “Jurassic Park” and the BBC’s “Walking with Dinosaurs” portray dinosaurs with fleshy nostrils which lie very high on their head. Not only in popular media is this true but in sculptures, kids’ books and scholarly journals.

How could so many scientists have been wrong for so long? Very easily. When a dinosaur fossil is discovered it has an extremely large nasal cavity in its skull, sometimes several feet in length. Since flesh does not preserve all too well over the course of millions of years, paleontologists have been forced to make an educated guess as to where the fleshy nostril lies within the larger nasal cavity.

Since the 1880’s scientists assumed that the nostril existed near the top of the head. The reason for this is that when sauropods (long necked dinosaurs) were discovered, it was thought that they must live under water in order to avoid crushing themselves under their own weight. This would explain their long necks. It would also follow that the fleshy nostril would be near the top of the head so the creatures could breathe easily while their bodies were under water.

Even after it was realized these dinosaurs did not live under the water, the idea that the fleshy nostril existed near the top of the head persisted. The idea was also spread to most other dinosaurs that were discovered thereafter. Perhaps you have noticed this in a drawing or movie, that Tyrannosaurus Rex’s large nostrils do not lie in the front of his face but instead halfway up his head.

Witmer believes his years of research with his “DinoNose” project prove that dinosaurs’ fleshy nostrils actually exist on the front end of the nasal cavity instead of the back end as was once believed.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Inaccurate Portrayal of the Dinosaur Face." 16 Aug 2018

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Face-to-Face Communication in Special Situations Essay

- In addressing the families and co-workers about the 30 workers that are trapped in the Chilean Copper Mine. I feel that it is best to understand that they people are scared and the best form of communication would be face to face. In face-to-face communication you are able to show empathy and comfort in a scary time. When the message, about the workers that are trapped 300 meters underground, is delivered to the family members a worker from the company needs to do these one by one. Bringing these 30 miners families to the site may cause an up roar so it is best to get to these families individual to create less mayhem....   [tags: copper mine, chilean miners, face to face]

Research Papers
884 words (2.5 pages)

Essay about Analysis of Face Descry System

- The user interface for the computer systems is evolvinginto an intelligent multi-modal interface. It is now movingaway from keyboard-given instructions to more naturalmodes of interaction, using visual, audio and sensorialmeans. This is the first step in achieving a human-likecommunication between man and machine. Human communication has two main aspects: verbal(auditory) and non-verbal (visual). Phenomenalike facial expressions, body movements and physiologicalreactions are the atomic units of the non-verbal communication.Although it is quite clear that non-verbal gestures arenot necessary for successful human interaction, considerable research in social psychology has shownthat non-verbal...   [tags: software, interface, face detection]

Research Papers
985 words (2.8 pages)

Disney's Inaccurate Portrayal of Mulan and Pocahontas Essay

- Many times, things are not what they seem. Deception is often used to publicize things in a different light and it distorts actual historical content and facts. One example of this is when Disney inaccurately portrays the actual life of historical characters such as Mulan and Pocahontas. In the movie Mulan, based on the “Ballad of Mulan,” Disney inaccurately portrays her life causing many incongruities. In the movie, Mulan is portrayed as being weak and unskilled with weapons and horsemanship....   [tags: Mulan, Pocahontas]

Research Papers
913 words (2.6 pages)

Improve ATM Security by Face Recognition Essay

- ... If details of SIM card matches, the device asks the face recognition. The recognition is done by MATLAB. When the image matches from the data base it asks for selecting the bank when the user select the bank it ask the pin number of bank account and next processing starts like user can make transactions, check balance etc, otherwise the process is cancelled. The system used Spartan-3 FPGA kit for controlling the system, one buzzer is connected to the system on the FPGA board which guide the process for transaction....   [tags: databases of face, biometic techniques]

Research Papers
1369 words (3.9 pages)

Use of Plot and Sensory Description in Julio Cortazar's Face Up Essay examples

- How do you know that a dream is really a dream or if reality is real. The ‘Night Face Up’ is a short story written by Julio Cortazar depicting a nameless protagonist who flips between dream and reality. The main character is switching between a hospital setting between the 1950’s and 1980’s, and an ancient Aztec area. The man experiences a world where he was recently involved in a motorcycle accident and ends up in the hospital with a broken arm. In the Aztec area he is running for his life as he is being hunted down to be a human sacrifice....   [tags: face up]

Research Papers
1252 words (3.6 pages)

Is the Portrayal of the Dinosaurs in the Movie and Book Accurate in Real Life

- Deinos, Greek for fearfully great; awe-inspiring and sauros meaning a lizard. From these words “Dinosaur” is created. When imagining a dinosaur, do thoughts of a large Tyrannosaurus Rex, a swift Velociraptor, or a gliding Pterodactyl appear. Or are those thoughts composed of an image of a small Compsognathus. Do visions of the dinosaurs that we often saw in our childhood come to mind. The amiable brightly colored friends in cartoons or the fearsome bloodthirsty experiments in movies. Were those dinosaurs portrayed accurately....   [tags: jurassic park, dilophosaurus, archeologists]

Research Papers
900 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Lucy Grealy's Autobiography of a Face

- Lucy Grealy's Autobiography of a Face "Language supplies us with ways to express ever subtle levels of meaning, but does that imply language gives meaning, or robs us of it when we are at a loss to name things?"(Grealy 44). Throughout her childhood and young adulthood, Lucy Grealy attempts to create a self-image based on her looks, through the reactions of others, and her own hopefulness, but these fail and she learns to forget her image completely. It is at this time of forgetting her image that Grealy demonstrates that she is able to recognize a difference between an image that is reflected in a mirror and an image that one can create through language....   [tags: Lucy Grealy Autobiography of a Face]

Research Papers
1429 words (4.1 pages)

Portrayal of Gays in the Media Essay

- The media has had a significant shift from the past in their portrayal of gay people including in gay marriage and gay rights. In the 1980’s and 90’s the subject was much more taboo and the idea of gay marriage was popularly opposed. However today, the majority of Americans support legalizing gay marriage. What could be the reason for such a change. Could it be the media portrayal. Beginning in 1975, the first gay couple was shown on television. After that a variety of other programs included the ideas of homosexuality until 1991 when the first kiss between a same-sex couple was shown....   [tags: Media portrayal of LGBT]

Free Essays
636 words (1.8 pages)

The Cause of the Dinosaur Extinction Essay

- The Cause of the Dinosaur Extinction The biggest mystery surrounding the dinosaur is how did they die. For over 130 million years dinosaurs ruled the earth. Then 65 million years ago, at the end of the Cretaceous period, they died out. Nobody can really say what actually eliminated the species, although everyone has their very own idea. Asteroid impact, atmospheric changes (hot to cold), catastrophic eruptions and astronomical events (supernovas etc.). Some have ventured that early mammal inhabitation slowly “pushed” the dinosaurs to extinction....   [tags: Papers]

Research Papers
835 words (2.4 pages)

Dinosaur Essay

- Dinosaur Dinosaurs: Extinct or Natural Causes As geologic time goes, all the dinosaurs living on earth suddenly disappeared. How did these dominated and gigantic creatures really die. Was it a slow extinction through natural causes, or did it happen suddenly. These questions give rise to many different beliefs on how the dinosaurs disappeared over sixty-five million years ago. Something happened sixty-five million years ago, at the end of the Cretaceous period that was so devastating that it altered the course of life on earth....   [tags: essays papers]

Research Papers
721 words (2.1 pages)

Related Searches

Witmer had many reasons for doubting the previous views of nostril position and for starting his research. Dr. Witmer believed that from an evolutionary standpoint and practicality standpoint the former view of fleshy nostril placement just did not make sense.

Nostrils have many very important purposes in the lives of dinosaurs and other animals. If nostrils lie near the back of the nasal cavity, much of their use cannot be utilized. If the fleshy nostril lies in the front of the nasal cavity like Dr. Witmer believes it would provide the dinosaurs with a better sense of smell. Certainly almost all dinosaurs relied upon this sense in their daily life. Predators needed an acute sense of smell to find their prey, while the prey needed the sense in order to avoid predators.1[1] The sense of smell is also thought to be important in the process of dinosaur mating as.

If the fleshy nostril was located at the front of the nasal cavity it would also provide the dinosaur with a better sense of taste as well. More importantly it would help keep the dinosaur better adapted for survival. With the nostrils located more to the front of the head dinosaurs would be able to breath much easier than if the nostrils were located on top of their head. This would allow dinosaurs to perform daily tasks like hunting much easier with far less effort. The more natural airflow would also help to keep the head and most importantly the brain cool. This trait could help keep the dinosaur alive in the most humid weather or in the most stressful of conditions.

Though Dr. Witmer’s ideas seem practical they still needed to be tested in some manner. Without dinosaurs to test his hypothesis on however, Witmer chose the next best thing. Today scientists feel that some members of the bird and reptile families are the closest relatives to the ancient dinosaurs. Witmer therefore used these animals as evidence for his theory. Witmer took X-Rays of over 60 types of lizards, birds, crocodilians and turtles in order to see their fleshy nostril placement in relation to the larger nasal cavity.2[2] In almost all of the X-Rays it could be seen that the fleshy nostril was located near or at the front of the nasal cavity as he had hypothesized.

While studying the fleshy nostrils of these animals, Witmer also noticed that small blood vessels feed the tissue of the nostrils. Besides supplying the nostril will fresh blood and oxygen, these blood vessels also leave small imprints on the bones of the nasal cavity. From these observations, Witmer felt it could be assumed that wherever these blood vessel marks were found on the fossils of dinosaurs was where the fleshy nostril must have been located as well. As he predicted, Witmer found these markings near the front of the dinosaurs’ nasal cavity and not in the back.

Dr. Witmer believed that since the dinosaurs’ closest relatives from the present exhibited these traits, it is reasonable to assume that dinosaurs themselves would share these same characteristics. As Witmer himself stated, the research “basically says that dinosaurs are like almost all other animals today”.3[3]

Many have hailed Witmer’s efforts. Though to many the research seems insignificant, it is an example of the efforts to go beyond just the fossils and learn more about dinosaurs without merely guessing. As Witmer’s colleague Dr. Christopher Brochu stated, “He’s looking at something a lot of us took for granted and applying some common sense to it”.4[4]

Witmer’s discoveries bring to light the fact that even with all of the recent discoveries in the field of paleontology; scientists are left to their own assumptions in many instances about the traits and characteristics of ancient creatures. When watching “Jurassic Park” the viewer must realize that not only could the placement of the T-Rex’s nostril be incorrect but the way and speed at which the T-Rex moves, or the way he hunts his prey or interacts with other dinosaurs.

But as research like Dr. Witmer’s continues to be conducted it can be assumed that the amount and accuracy of our knowledge about dinosaurs will only increase with time. The impact of Witmer’s research still has yet to be seen. Perhaps illustrations of dinosaurs in schoolbooks and scientific journals will include his findings from now on. Or perhaps Steven Spielberg will correct his representations of dinosaurs in a special edition of “Jurassic Park” some years down the road. In any case it is exciting to wonder and hypothesize how different dinosaurs will look and behave in future media representations as our knowledge of these creatures continues increase.


1[1] Science, Vol 293, Issue 5531. pg. 853
2[2] Science, Vol 293, Issue 5531. pg. 851
3[3] Science, Vol 293, Issue 5531. pg. 779
4[4] Science, Vol 293, Issue 5531. pg. 779
Return to