No Utopia Found in Wendell Berry’s What Are People For?

No Utopia Found in Wendell Berry’s What Are People For?

Length: 1015 words (2.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
No Utopia Found in Wendell Berry’s What Are People For?

The preface to Wendell Berry’s What Are People For? is in the form of a two-part poem, titled “Damage” and “Healing.” By carefully digging through its cryptic obscurities (“It is despair that sees the work failing in one’s own failure”), we find the main message: The more diminutive, local, and settled a culture, the healthier it is and the less “damage” it inflicts upon its people and the land. Berry can be called a utopian but not in the traditional sense. He pines not for the future but for the past. Basing his lifestyle upon his boyhood memories of fifty years ago as well as America’s pioneer days, Berry is confident he has found the answer to the perfect existence.

In this case, book and individual are difficult to separate. What Are People For? is Wendell Berry, so to criticize one is to criticize the other. His book is a compilation of contemplative essays on subjects ranging from literature to technology from the perspective of a Kentucky farmer. Having been in the same profession and location most of his young life, Berry in 1958 (at age twenty-four) accepted a Stanford University Stegner Fellowship. Intrigued, he decided to read Stegner’s books and take this professor’s writing seminar. Berry is reverent and testifies that Stegner filled the Jones Room of the Stanford Library with an aura of literary authority. It is here that Berry learns “responsible writing.” This is writing that contains the values one has “proven” by living exclusively in one country place and by perfecting one’s knowledge of the place so as to bring sustainable benefit to it. Responsible writing actively promotes “good agriculture and forestry” unlike writing “by self-styled smart people in the offices and laboratories of a centralized economy and then sold at the highest possible profit to the supposedly dumb country people.” What Berry says about his seminar experience is that it started him on his development toward working at home, and away from his assumption “that I was going to follow a literary career that would lead me far from [Henry County] to teach at a university in a large city.”

In important ways Berry has some very good ideas. Concerned that radio and television have done too much to homogenize society, he uses “Nate Shaw” (a pseudonym) to provide an illustration of a man who lived without euphemistic clichés.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"No Utopia Found in Wendell Berry’s What Are People For?." 25 Apr 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Peace Of Wild Things By Wendell Berry Essay

- “I rest in the grace of the world, and am free.” This quote, found in Wendell Berry’s poem, “The Peace of Wild Things,” absolutely jumped out at me as my eyes trailed across the text. I have read many, many poems throughout high-school and my first years of college but, none of which have stood out to me such as this poem did. As I read it, I fell in love with the musicality of the short, simple poem. I adored the directness of it; it was straight to the point, no beating around the bush. As I read this work of art, my mind was transported to my favorite place in the outdoors....   [tags: Mind, Thought, Idea, Cognition]

Research Papers
723 words (2.1 pages)

The Pleasure Of Eating : Wendell Berry Essay

- The Pleasure of Eating Wendell Berry, an environmental activist, cultural critic and a farmer tells consumers to eat “responsibly”. That consumers should realize that eating is an agricultural act. An act that gives us freedom. Meaning that every time we make choices about what we eat and who we purchase from, we are deciding what direction our food system moves. Berry states that to make a change we need to make individual choices to live free. “We cannot be free if our food its sources are controlled by someone else” (2)....   [tags: Food, Food industry, Food processing, Want]

Research Papers
1368 words (3.9 pages)

Language And Literacy By Wendell Berry Essay examples

- In today’s society many technological advances have contributed to advanced communication. While these are advantageous and can improve communication across the globe, they have become a hindrance to critical thinking. With the advancement of technology throughout the world human beings are able to think less while still “functioning.” Literacy is thrown to the wayside and texting “lingo” runs rampant. Why read a book when you can watch the movie. Students are becoming less interested in language, reading, and writing and more involved with surfing the web for answers....   [tags: Critical thinking, Thought, Mind]

Research Papers
1585 words (4.5 pages)

Literacy And Intellectualism By Wendell Berry Essay

- Literacy and Intellectualism “In Defense of Literacy,” written by Wendell Berry was the topic of this discussion in his own essay of whether or not people are really and truly educated or literate. He acknowledges this in his essay by first acknowledging that while many people do go to school and continue their education in this country, people who are supposed to be well-educated have writing skills which are really not that good. Some points which are noteworthy are such as even some people who teach English are not even that good at the subject either in regards to reading or writing....   [tags: Writing, Education, Learning, School]

Research Papers
715 words (2 pages)

Another Turn of the Crank by Wendell Berry Essay

- Another Turn of the Crank by Wendell Berry Wendell Berry’s Another Turn of the Crank is about sustainability of the environment. He believes that you must first start at a local level then sustainability can be accomplished at a global level. This is the same idea that was expressed at the start of this course, “think globally, act locally,” which means the consequences of our actions effect the world. As I address the some of the chapters in the book I will associate how Berry’s ideas link into the material discussed in this class....   [tags: Papers]

Research Papers
691 words (2 pages)

Wendell Berry's Another Turn of the Crank Essay

- Wendell Berry's book, Another Turn of the Crank, takes us well beyond the sustainability of agriculture as such. This is a book about community and, necessarily then, it is a book about economics. John Dewey wrote, "Natural associations are the conditions for the existence of a community, but a community adds the function of communication in which emotions and ideas are shared as well as joint undertakings engaged in. Economic forces have immensely widened the scope of associational activities....   [tags: Economics and Community]

Research Papers
2306 words (6.6 pages)

Rhetorical Analysis Of ' The Pleasures Of Eating ' By Wendell Berry Essays

- Rhetorical Analysis of “The Pleasures of Eating” by Wendell Berry In the article by Wendell Berry titled “The Pleasures of Eating” he tries to persuade the readers of the necessity and importance of critical thinking and approach to choosing meals and owning responsibility for the quality of the food cooked. He states that people who are not conscious enough while consuming products, and those who do not connect the concept of food with agricultural products, as people whose denial or avoidance prevents them from eating healthy and natural food....   [tags: Food, Agriculture, Eating, Critical thinking]

Research Papers
895 words (2.6 pages)

The Agricultural Crisis by Wendell Berry Essay

- The Agricultural Crisis by Wendell Berry In this novel by Wendell Berry, Berry’s describes in his thesis that modern culture is destroying the agricultural culture. He feels that technology is seen as the easy way to produce food faster and more efficiently. With this modern way of farming comes the idea that hard work is not needed to make a living. The goal is comfort and leisure. Berry feels that this is the reason for the deterioration of the agricultural culture. He believes that hard work and pride in workmanship is more important than material goods and money....   [tags: Papers]

Research Papers
887 words (2.5 pages)

The Waste Of Our Food By Wendell Berry And Michael Pollan Essay

- The second our spoons come near our mouths, we instantly start to think about indulging in the deliciousness that is our food; however, we don’t tend to think beyond the taste of our food as we should. Nearly all of us do not take a moment out of our dinner to think in depth about all the details of what went into producing our food. Wendell Berry and Michael Pollan would agree that when people look at their food, they do not stop to think about the life it had, the ingredients that went into it, the effects it may have on our health and the environment, or the shady business behind it all....   [tags: Food, Nutrition, Eating, Food and drink]

Research Papers
887 words (2.5 pages)

A True Legacy: Home of the Free by Wendell Berry Essay

- When I hear the word “legacy,” I often feel intimidated because I instinctively compare myself with those who have accomplished something significant. In fact, I get the impression that I am disadvantaged, or strictly speaking, useless, compared to those who are leaders. I feel that my fate prevents me from meeting new opportunities, which ultimately impedes me from making great accomplishments. However, after reading “Home of the Free” by Wendell Berry, I am forced to riffle through my life span and smile at the great accomplishments that I, as a “disadvantaged” kid, have taken pride in....   [tags: achieving satisfaction, philosphical analysis]

Research Papers
912 words (2.6 pages)

Related Searches

Shaw does prove to be interesting, as Berry points out:

[Mr. Shaw] does not say ÔFreedom now’ or ÔPower to the People.’ He says ÔMy color, the colored race of people on earth, goin’ to shed theirselves of these slavery ways, but it takes many a trip to the river to get clean.’

The trouble with Berry is that he, too, wants to homogenize society. The great majority of his essays promote the concept that everyone should live in a small, tight-knit rural enclave. Here is where Berry’s self-righteousness creeps in. While there may be numerous personal and environmental advantages to his way of life, anyone not living in this fashion is seen by Berry as an enemy. Farmers are the only good people in the world. Everyone else (computer-hacking environmentalists, “outside experts,” city-dwellers, etc.) has an inherent problem. This level of hatred is not deserved. While attacking critics for calling Edward Abbey a xenophobe (“A Few Words in Favor of Edward Abbey”), Berry neglects to see that he himself is one.

Berry does have some reason to resent big corporations, power companies, mining industries, and agribusiness. He has seen poor farm families driven off their land. He has seen land decimated and miners poisoned. But for him to harp on modern schooling (“A powerful superstition of modern life is that people and conditions are improved inevitably by education”) is unreasonable. Berry should remember that without education he would be unable to write his essays.

Berry too often stands on a soap-box. True, when we feel passionate it may be permissible to stand on one, but Berry never proves many of his statements, and this can frustrate his readers. Merely to say Abbey is a “cultivated man, a splendid writer” is unfair to Berry’s audience. Where is the evidence? Berry’s righteous indignation unfortunately tends to cloud his arguments. People who criticize him for implying that every writer’s wife must serve as her husband’s editor are “audacious and irresponsible gossips” (“Why I Am Not Going To Buy a Computer”). In this rush to always have the last word, Berry ends up appearing foolish, with terrible arguments:

[W]hen somebody has used a computer to write work that is demonstrably better than Dante’s . . . then I will speak of computers in a more respectful tone of voice, though I still will not buy one.

It therefore becomes easier to identify with critic Toby Koosman, who reminds us that “the value of a computer to a writer is that it is a tool not for generating ideas but for typing and editing words.”

In trying to attain any utopia, problems arise. The pre-industrial rural model of community life has its advantages, but no one can inspire everyone in America to follow his lead in adopting a model of community. Indeed, we may not be able to follow the lead. Even with everyone’s consent, it would be difficult to regroup the population into separated rural enclaves. The logistics of relocation, the confusion for our system of distribution and supply of goods and services, and the havoc visited upon our property values, are huge and prohibitive problems. Small is not always possible. Big hospitals are necessary to provide care and services unavailable from small hospitals. Big schools and universities are necessary to educate the populace and help us understand each other better. And “outside experts” in their laboratories are necessary to discover new ways of feeding everyone. The population problem is not going to go away. While certainly Berry is right in saying we should strive to cause less environmental damage, to do so we must remain down to earth. Ironically, Berry the Farmer hasn’t realized this yet.
Return to