Moulin Rouge and the Disneyfication of the Avant Garde

Moulin Rouge and the Disneyfication of the Avant Garde

Length: 1332 words (3.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Moulin Rouge and the Disneyfication of the Avant Garde

At best Moulin Rouge is a lot of fun. At worst it represents the erasure of history. Moulin Rouge is set in the Paris of 1900--at least ostensibly it is. The actual Paris of 1900 is the Paris of Satie, the Paris of Ravel, of Debussy. The actual Paris of 1900 is the Paris of Matisse, and at least for part of the year, the Paris of Picasso.

This is very fertile ground for a love story, a musical, anything, really. Puccini found it good enough for La boheme, after all. What we get in Moulin Rouge, though, is a Paris of 1900 filtered through the myopia of late 20th Century pop culture, especially pop music. We get an anachronistic melange of Madonna and Elton John, of Nirvana and Olivia Newton John.

In other words, it isn’t the Paris of 1900. It isn’t even close.

Granted, Henri Toulouse-Lautrec shows up as a supporting character and there is, in the film, a nightclub called Moulin Rouge from which the film cribs its title. But other than that, and the ubiquitous absinthe, there’s not much Parisy about Moulin Rouge the movie, much less Paris, 1900. The character of Toulouse-Lautrec speaks vaguely of the “Bohemian Revolution” but only long enough for the film to make fun of it, and never in enough detail for either a credible manifesto or a credible satire. And, of course, it has to be advocated by Toulouse-Lautrec because Hollywood still thinks dwarves are funny, especially dwarves with lisps.

So why does so little of the real Paris of 1900 appear in this film? I have my suspicions that to use, say the music of Erik Satie, would have been too “challenging” for contemporary audiences. It may have been deemed out of the target demographic of the film, probably “indie” movie buffs in the 19-30 range whose introduction to the avant-garde was Trainspotting. A movie about a writer in Paris that actually dealt with other writers who were really there, other artists who didn’t have the luck to be born lisping dwarves, would never have been made. I mean, who would go to see it? Old people?

The problem, of course, with always making things people can “relate” to, is that in constantly recycling what we know, we fail to ever learn or be challenged by anything new, even if that thing, new to our experience, is past history.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Moulin Rouge and the Disneyfication of the Avant Garde." 15 Oct 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Analysis of a Scene in The Moulin Rouge Essay

- Cinematography is the art or technique of motion-picture photography. The Moulin Rouge is a visually striking film, which incorporates brilliant elements of cinematography. One scene in particular that captures the brilliance of the cinematographer is the scene within which the “Unconscious Argentinean” takes it upon himself to explain the situation with an incredible, tango, adaptation of The Police’s song “Roxanne.” The lighting and other elements of this are gorgeous, as they eloquently convey the dark emotions of the situation: “Jealousy, anger, betrayal.” The different elements of cinematography, specifically, color, lighting, and the use of camera angles, bring to life the emotions, a...   [tags: Cinematography, Moulin Rouge]

Research Papers
767 words (2.2 pages)

The Power of Love in Moulin Rouge and To Dance With the White Dog Essays

- The Power of Love in Moulin Rouge and To Dance With the White Dog       The power of love is exposed in the films Moulin Rouge and To Dance With the White Dog. In each movie, each individual must overcome obstacles within themselves in order to overcome the obstacles in their relationships. Although the love shared by each couple is different, both cases of love are real and run deeply. Satine and Sam Peek each handle their romantic relationships differently according to their situations....   [tags: Moulin Rouge Essays]

Research Papers
1229 words (3.5 pages)

The Garde Of The Avant Garde Essay

- The avant-garde is a movement that pushes the boundaries of what is considered normal. Artist during this time disregarded the rules of art put in place by the artist before them. This art was made to go past what would be commercial; it is more about making art for arts sake, purist avant-garde, and art as life, radical avant-garde Charles Jencks claims “almost all serious critics think that the avant-garde is dead.” There are many reasons why avant-garde could be considered dead but the most important and evident are; the on set of capitalism, there is no more progression and the fact that the world is now in a massive tech age....   [tags: Art, Arts, Visual arts, Aesthetics]

Research Papers
1478 words (4.2 pages)

The Avant Garde Paris Essay

- Paris today is known as a center of arts and rich culture both acclaimed and original. Famous moments pop up through the history of France’s art, such as the impressionistic artworks by Monet, the École des Beaux-Arts teachings of classicism, and the iconic Eiffel Tower by Stephen Sauvestre. Paris augments itself with numerous museums to catalog countless masterpieces and sculptures throughout France’s enduring, yet sometimes gritty, history. As a whole, Paris comprises of a mixture between historic architectural themes like rusticated brick clad, mansard roofs, striated columns, and a modern day architectural themes like engineered metalwork, and external program support machinery....   [tags: Center of Art, Culture, Paris, France]

Research Papers
1812 words (5.2 pages)

Essay The Avant-Garde Die First

- The Avant-Garde Die First In the 19th century, under the suffocating weight of a centuries long tradition in academic art, artists began to break free. Tired of meaningless imitation and decoration, the avant-garde artists pushed for drastic revolutions in aesthetic and social taste. This experimentation rapidly grew less and less controlled, and new technique and new style, which shocked and enraged the critics and public, stopped being experimental and started desiring the side effects of shock and disgust....   [tags: Artists Art History Papers]

Research Papers
2304 words (6.6 pages)

Analysis of Movie Moulin Rouge Essay

- Analysis of Movie Moulin Rouge In this essay I will be analyzing in depth four scenes from Baz Luhrmann's critically acclaimed Moulin Rouge that was released in 2000. I will be analyzing the opening sequence, the sequence in the Moulin Rouge itself, the two dancing sequences 'Like a Virgin' and 'Tango Roxanne' and the final scenes of the film. Throughout this essay I will be commenting on the filming techniques that Luhrmann uses and what affects these have on the audience, also I will be analyzing how the film is similar and different to typical Hollywood Musicals....   [tags: Film Cinema Baz Luhrmann Papers]

Research Papers
1933 words (5.5 pages)

Russian Avant-Garde Essay

- Russian Avant-Garde was born at the start of the 20th century out of intellectual and cultural turmoil. Through the analysis of artworks by Aleksandr Rodchenko and El Lissitzky this essay attempts to explore the freedom experienced by artists after the Russian Revolution in 1917. This avant-garde movement was among the boldest and most advanced in Europe. It signified for many artists an end to the past academic conventions as they began to experiment with the notions of space, following the basic elements of colour, shape and line....   [tags: Russian History, Artists, Russian Revolution]

Research Papers
1660 words (4.7 pages)

The Avant-garde Architecture O Essay

- The Chinese-American architect Ieoh Ming Pei (I.M) is known as one of the greatest architects of the Twentieth Century. His long, brilliant career was highlighted by several internationally famous structures. While many of Pei’s buildings were generally accepted by the public, some of them precipitated fair amounts of controversy. The most notable of these controversial structures is his Glass Pyramid at the entrance of the Louvre in Paris. For these reasons, I.M. Pei seems to be an architect who exhibits interest in the avant-garde through both the creative design and aestheticism of his architecture....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1290 words (3.7 pages)

Baz Luhrman's Moulin Rouge Essay

- Baz Luhrman's Moulin Rouge Moulin Rouge was Baz Luhrman’s next great success after his polarizing fusion of Shakespearean dialogue and MTV stylisations that was William Shakespeare's Romeo + Juliet. Released in 2001 Moulin Rouge caused considerable controversy amongst its audiences, with critics claiming “you either love it or hate it”....   [tags: Papers]

Research Papers
502 words (1.4 pages)

Analyzing Moulin Rouge Essay

- Moulin Rouge is celebrated for its art direction, music, and performances. One of its biggest endeavors is the set design. With a combination of real sets and computer generated images, Moulin Rouge manages to showcases a 19th century Paris, France as a world of moral decadence but undeniable beauty. The set design further pushes the message of France, at this time, being a place of plague, poverty and sin; but also a place of art, music and beauty. In the introduction of the film, we see an elaborate design of 19th century Paris, France....   [tags: essays research papers]

Research Papers
1191 words (3.4 pages)

Related Searches

We are never able to deal with anything but that which is most immediately known or knowable to us. So Debussy is substituted with the Doors. And there is nothing new in Moulin Rouge: the plot is the standard “hooker with a heart of gold,” the soundtrack, as has been noted, is almost completely pop songs from the past 40 years, and many of the scenes themselves are recycled, most obviously from Singin’ in the Rain and Nirvana’s “Smells Like Teen Spirit” video.

I suppose we could chalk this up to po-mo video sampling. We could call this the filmic version of hip-hop. But it follows a trend that began for many viewers of Moulin Rouge with the Disney films of the ‘80s and ‘90s: it takes perfectly legitimate literature and history and washes it with contemporary good feelings to gain a new audience. Disney has been cleaning up some really Grimm fairy tales since Snow White. But it went beyond itself with The Little Mermaid, The Hunchback of Notre Dame, and the myth of Hercules, turning heart-wrenching tales of star-crossed loves, tales, some clearly aimed at children, all clearly challenging to Romantic notions about love, into cute little animations embracing just such values. This same trend is reflected in advertising where Janis Joplin’s song decrying the materialism of Mercedes Benz ownership is used to sell that very marque.

Let me be clear: this isn’t “irony,” and it gives cynicism a bad name. For this sort of thing to be ironic it must be understood so by its audience, and if it is, it’s self-defeating: to make fun of materialism while you try to sell Mercedeses with a song that makes fun of materialism, tells your audience not to buy your car. The most likely explanation is that the ad makes fun of the song, saying, in essence, “Remember back when we were idealistic and thought materialism was bad? How foolish we were!” In other words, this is advertising critiquing art, advertising embracing, and indeed celebrating, superficiality and dumbness. It is, in other words, meant to make the viewer more comfortable in having sold out (No values? Well, at least you’ve still got a bigass luxury car all your friends will be envious of!). The ad says it’s ok to be a capitalist pig since the Mercedes Benz company gave you permission to do so. It makes palatable a difficult problem in social ethics at the personal level.

In the same way, then, Moulin Rouge glosses over the more difficult aspects of Paris in 1900, the deep changes in culture, the clash (who says it doesn’t speak to today?) of high and low art that sent spasms through painting, sculpture, music, writing, and replaces it with, well, with just low art. If Ubu Roi made low culture avant garde, Moulin Rouge makes the avant garde Disney. In the same way that the millions who grew up with Disney’s version of Grimm, of Hans Christian Anderson, of Greek mythology will never know the real things with all their depth and terror, so the millions who know Janis Joplin’s song only from the ad will never know the real anger and disappointment at the heart of the satire. They may never even understand that it is satire, and that’s as great a loss as anything.

In like style, the WB Network has recently begun airing a set of promo spots in which The Who’s “My Generation” is redone hip-hop style to promote shows aimed at the so-called “Y” generation--those born post 1976. Of course, this generation will never know the original, don’t remember The Who, and will never understand the song not merely as an anthem of a particular set of people, but as a meaningful part of history. It will only be a jingle to them, the WB’s song to sling its own shows, made “relevant” with a sampled beat and an inner-city rap-type delivery. They will never understand a generation disillusioned with the powers that were, angry at their war, at their values, at their lifestyle. They will understand that it’s just another ad in an endless wash of ads in which they’re virtually dissolved.

What’s lost here is history. History tells us what is here, what it means, how it got here, and hints as to what should be done with it. With every cycling of culture, a little meaning is lost, the sense of the song falls away, the context of the book is forgotten, the footnotes removed. With each transvaluation of culture, which is what Daimler Chrysler has done in its ad, what Disney has done, what Moulin Rouge does, history is erased, meaning turns in on itself is repolarized and destroyed. It is worse than the old Soviet practice of writing the unfavored out of the history books since the persona non grata were obvious in their absence, since the practice is blatant and bold. What Moulin Rouge does, however, is much more insidious: it resells you Paris, 1900, gutting it of what was there and replacing it with what wasn’t, paternalistically, to “reach” you, to “relate.” It gives you just enough to make you think it’s somehow fantasy, but fantasy lives on its own terms, uncompromisingly. It does not need to relate to you. This is why Dada and Surrealism continue to challenge: they make no attempt to accommodate your experience and are all their own. Fantasy creates history; Moulin Rouge replaces it. And with this we get back to the real Paris of 1900, fantastic, challenging, new.
Return to