Comparing the Duke and Angelo in Measure for Measure

Comparing the Duke and Angelo in Measure for Measure

Length: 576 words (1.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Comparing the Duke and Angelo in Measure for Measure

Angelo and the Duke are similar in the following respects: they both initially claim immunity to love and later come to be affected by it; to achieve ends they desire, both manipulate others into situations those others would not willingly choose to be in; both have sought to maintain a particular reputation; they both spend much of the play seeming other than what they appear; both think themselves to be other than what they are in the beginning; and both claim to value a life removed.

The Duke says: “Believe not that the dribbling dart of love / Can pierce a complete bosom” (1.3.2-3). Angelo said, “Ever till now, / When men were fond, I smiled and wondered how” (2.2.185-186). The Duke asks Isabella to marry him by the end—which isn’t necessarily proof of love, however.

The play begins with the Duke manipulating Angelo to “weed” the vice of the people (3.2.258), and to see “what our seemers be” (1.3.58). The Duke has reason to believe that Angelo will strictly enforce laws that the Duke had neglected to enforce (1.3.50-53). We have already seen how Angelo manipulates Isabella. The Duke’s manipulation, he believes, will bring order to his people without him personally having to be perceived a tyrant, “And yet my nature never in the fight / To do it slander” (1.3.42-43). Angelo, too, has taken pride in maintaining a particular reputation. The Duke’s great concern about being slandered suggests he has a less than complete bosom, showing a lack of self-knowledge—another feature shared by Angelo.

The Duke manipulates others in part by using a disguise. Angelo, too, comes to use a disguise (2.4.12-15; 2.4.153-156). In addition, the Duke has “ever loved the life removed” (1.3.8), which sounds similar to Angelo’s reputation for austerity.

The differences between the Duke and Angelo are far greater, however, depending on the reading the play is given (All the perspectives I mention below come from Lever’s ‘Introduction’). It is possible to interpret the Duke as being more a stage device than a full-fledged character. His primary role may be to represent the middle way that good rulers should adopt, and to orchestrate the trials and learning experiences that move the other characters from their extreme positions into more moderate ways of being. The Duke does this by implementing the historic ruse of going in disguise among his people to find out how things are really going, and to set them right if need be.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Comparing the Duke and Angelo in Measure for Measure." 20 Oct 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Matrimony and Recompense in Measure for Measure

- Matrimony and Recompense in Measure for Measure (A version of this essay appeared in Shakespeare Quarterly 46 (Winter, 1995), 454-464.) Since 1970, when the Isabella of John Barton's RSC production of Measure for Measure first shocked audiences by silently refusing to acquiesce to the Duke's offer of marriage at the end of the play, Isabella's response (or lack thereof) to the Duke's proposal has become one of the most prevalent subjects for Shakespearean performance criticism.See, for example, Jane Williamson, "The Duke and Isabella on the Modern Stage," The Triple Bond: Plays, Mainly Shakespearean, in Performance, ed....   [tags: Shakespeare Measure Essays]

Free Essays
7072 words (20.2 pages)

Comparing The Prince and Measure for Measure Essay

- Parallels Between The Prince and Measure for Measure        The parallels between Machiavelli's Prince and Shakespeare's Measure for Measure are significant.  The great majority of characters in Measure for Measure - the Duke, Angelo, Claudio, Pompey and even Isabella - display Machiavellian qualities. A comparison of key passages, both of The Prince and Measure for Measure, will establish this clearly.   A study of kingship, arguably the entire premise for Measure for Measure, is immediately introduced in the first scene, with the Duke's declaration "Of government the properties to unfold/ Would seem in me t'affect speech and discourse." It is not until the third scene of act one, howe...   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Research Papers
1755 words (5 pages)

Essay on William Shakespeare 's Measure For Measure

- While justice is the standard of morality, which establishes what is right and what is wrong, the Law is the organization of rules that govern society, to help uphold that standard of morality. In order to create laws, society as a whole must determine what is just and appoint persons to create laws in addition to having someone to interpret the law when people break it so as to serve them punishment to fit the crime. In William Shakespeare’s Measure for Measure, not only do the citizens of Vienna break the law constantly, but also, those who are supposed to carry out the law, Duke Vincentio and Angelo, are incapable of interpreting the law fairly and abuse their power for selfish gains....   [tags: Law, Justice, Plato, Punishment]

Research Papers
1277 words (3.6 pages)

Comparing Heroes and Villains in Measure for Measure, Othello, and Hamlet

- Comparing Heroes and Villains in Measure for Measure, Othello, and Hamlet According to John Steinbeck, "Heroes are innocent; villains are cunning." This statement likely regards the internal aspects of characters, such as intellect, reasoning/motivation, and morality/responsibility, as indicated by consistency in action and/or articulation, as in direct speech or soliloquy. An examination of the heroes and villains in Measure for Measure, Othello, and Hamlet can determine whether Steinbeck's generalization is applicable....   [tags: Comparison Compare Contrast Essays]

Research Papers
2331 words (6.7 pages)

Comparing Measure for Measure and The Merchant of Venice, As You Like It, and Twelfth Night

- Parallels between Measure for Measure and The Merchant of Venice, As You Like It, and Twelfth Night What is comedy?  Funk and Wagnalls New Encyclopedia says: "A comedy depicts the follies and absurdities of human beings."  Webster's Dictionary defines comedy as: "A drama or narrative with a happy ending."  Shakespeare's play, Measure for Measure, fits both of these descriptions.  Follies and absurdities are present in the play: Lucio slanders the Duke, not realizing that his crude remarks are being spoken to the Duke himself; Angelo abuses his power thinking that the Duke is not present to know; and Ragozine happens to die in prison the day a head is needed to substitute for Claudio's.  Th...   [tags: Comparison Compare Contrast Essays]

Research Papers
1984 words (5.7 pages)

Comparing Wealth, Power, and Virtue in Measure for Measure and Mrs. Warren's Profession

- Wealth, Power, and Virtue in Measure for Measure and Mrs. Warren’s Profession     As seen in the dramas Measure for Measure and Mrs. Warren’s Profession, the Elizabethan and Victorian periods have different views of wealth, power and virtue. To compare these views, one should start by defining the different views of virtue. The people of the Elizabethan times see virtue in obtaining a balance of their three souls and as promoting order within their society and city. Also in this period of time, wealth and power were rarely gained, but when they were, it was due to virtue....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Free Essays
1420 words (4.1 pages)

Measure for Measure Essay: Angelo

- Angelo in Measure for Measure       Within Measure for Measure, the character of Angelo can be seen as a case study of will over moral nature. Angelo, a deputy, is given the Dukes authority to act in his behalf while the Duke is away. The story unfolds as Angelo uses the agency he's been given in ways that many men in authoritative positions have done. It is interesting to follow his line of thought and to realize that this is a man who is not unlike many others. The main conflict between Isabella and Angelo is a contemporary problem....   [tags: Measure for Measure]

Research Papers
1019 words (2.9 pages)

The Good and Evil Angelo of Measure for Measure Essay

- The Good and Evil Angelo of Measure for Measure                  In Shakespeare's Measure for Measure, Angelo emerges as a double-sided character.  Scholars have argued for centuries whether or not Angelo is a moral character or an evil character.  Those scholars who support the notion of Angelo as moral often cite the following facts: the Duke obviously trusts Angelo, Angelo is disheartened enough by the end of the play to offer a sincere apology, and Angelo tries to resist the temptation that Isabella presents.  On the other hand, others have argued that Shakespeare depicts Angelo as a purely evil man.  These critics emphasize Angelo's treatment of Marian, the Duke's possible suspicion...   [tags: Measure for Measure]

Research Papers
1975 words (5.6 pages)

Measure for Measure Essay: Lord Angelo's Hypocrisy

- Lord Angelo's Hypocrisy in Measure for Measure      Within ‘Measure for Measure’ Shakespeare presents the notion that mankind's corruption is not necessarily born by power, but rather already innate in humanity. Shakespeare argues that power is not a producer of corruption by presenting the Duke, who holds the most power, as a moral hero, and conversely revealing the corruption of the powerless class (through characters like, Pompey, Mistress Overdone, and Barnadine).  Shakespeare uses Lord Angelo in Measure for Measure to show that corruption is innate within mankind whilst Angelo is a symbolism for pharisaical fanaticism in the play....   [tags: Measure for Measure]

Research Papers
1516 words (4.3 pages)

Measure for Measure Essay: The Growth of Angelo and Pompey

- The Growth of Angelo and Pompey in Measure for Measure      It is very difficult for a state to impose morality on its' citizens since morals have a tendency to be relative.  Adding to the complexity is the fact that everyone has sinned - the enforcer is as much at fault as the accused. This problem comes to a boil in Shakespeare's play, "Measure for Measure", where Angelo enforces the death sentence for fornication against Claudio. Angelo then uses Claudio's problem as leverage to get his sister to commit the same crime with him....   [tags: Measure for Measure]

Research Papers
1098 words (3.1 pages)

Related Searches

While the play is set in Vienna, from an Anglican perspective the ruler’s masquerading about as a monk might not be sacrilegious but part of his role as head of the church. And one of the Duke’s main speeches (3.2.249-270) can be seen as a chorus where he is speaking in part as ‘everyman’—in which case “my vice” (3.2.258) means the vices of the people. In addition, the speeches where the Duke complains of slander (3.2.176-180; 4.1.59-64) may have originally been one speech, but lines were taking from one part to fill in at the later part. All this is to say that the Duke could be interpreted as a much less rich, complete, and carefully portrayed dramatic character than Angelo. That sounds lazy however.

Works Cited

Lever, J. W.. Introduction. The Arden Shakespeare. Measure for Measure. J. W. Lever, ed. London: Methuen & Co., 1965. xi-xci.

The Pelican Shakespeare. Measure for Measure. Jonathan Crewe, ed. New York: Penguin Books, 2000.
Return to