Male Dominance Over Women Traced Back to Roman Times

Male Dominance Over Women Traced Back to Roman Times

Length: 1501 words (4.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Male Dominance Traced Back to Roman Times

Women are enigmatic. Their complexity is evident in their very anatomy; at least it was according to Plato. Therefore, as what is alien is often feared and what is feared is often subject to aggression, perhaps the men of Rome attempted to dominate women in every facet of life because they feared the possibility of women usurping power. Gender, as suggested by Women's Life in Greece and Rome and "Elite Male Identity in the Roman Empire," is not anatomy but power. Yet how can one be more powerful than an unknown entity? Men can only hope to dominate a species they do not even understand through carefully crafted treatises on anatomy, laws, education, and the unbreakable chains of culture and tradition.

Plato boldly states that women are simply underdeveloped men. He does this through the argument that blood creates heat in the body and heat sustains and strengthens the body; so, because women lose blood through regular menstruation, women are cold and therefore weak. Moreover, women are created through a "deficiency of heat" in conception (qtd. in Lefkowitz et al. 228). Plato asserts that because "all concoction works by means of heat" and "some of the body's parts are 'principles'" (qtd. in Lefkowitz et al. 229), a lack of heat will affect concoction which will, in turn, affect a principle body part. This is crucial to the development of the body as "once a principle has been 'moved' (i.e. changed), many of the parts which cohere with it must of necessity change as well" (qtd. in Lefkowitz et al. 229). Therefore, no heat in concoction, or conception, creates a woman, and a woman, subsequently, has no heat in her body. Plato reinforces his theory of heat's effect on the body with observations of other body parts. For example, humans go bald on the front part of their head only because, "the brain is there" (qtd. in Lefkowitz et al. 229), and the brain's fluid absorbs the very little heat necessary for hair to exist. Women cannot go bald, on the other hand, because they are incapable of creating the most heated substance that the body can produce: "seminal secretions" (qtd. in Lefkowitz et al. 229). This argument makes logical sense within its own confines, and Plato is able to successfully defend his assertion that "a woman is as it were an infertile male" (qtd.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Male Dominance Over Women Traced Back to Roman Times." 25 Aug 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Roman Empire Essay

- Have you ever taken the time to think about the Roman Empire. You are probably saying to yourself; No, Why would I be thinking about the Roman Empire. Surprisingly, you probably do not think of them but chances are you are using something every day that the Roman Empire, and their culture, contributed to our modern times. The Roman Empire brought us so many influences from their culture, for instance we can thank them for thermal baths, central heating and floor heating. They also brought us architectural styles, an efficient highway system, mass entertainment in the way of stadiums & amphitheaters and also aqueducts and viaducts....   [tags: Ancient Rome, Roman Empire, Roman Republic]

Research Papers
986 words (2.8 pages)

The Roman Era Essay

- Over this course, I had the chance to immerse myself in the many cultures of the world. It astonishes me how many empires have risen to great heights and then suddenly fall by the mistakes of its people. I then realized that throughout history, many of the different cultures shown similar characteristics, as well as some very different ideas. An idea I see that is very common with almost every culture in the world, is that they have a ruling class, or one single ruler. There are many names the ruling classes can be called such as the Literati in China, the Patricians in Ancient Rome, or the Knightly Class in Medieval Europe....   [tags: Roman Empire, Ancient Rome, Middle Ages, Pope]

Research Papers
1726 words (4.9 pages)

Pax Romana And The Roman Empire Essay

- The Pax Romana lasted two hundred years during the empire that was founded by Emperor Octavian who used the title of Augustus. Augustus ruled in the place of the Republican government. Using his political power power he was able to have reformed the army, fight against corruption in the local provinces, keep the peace, build roads and other public services. By providing these policies, Pax Romana was widely accepted due to a majority of it helping the common Roman citizen. Building roads improves the daily to and fro of the Roman citizens....   [tags: Ancient Rome, Roman Empire, United States]

Research Papers
926 words (2.6 pages)

Factors Affecting The Greek And Roman Empires Essay

- Empires began as different states although some grew as monarchies. A powerful leader called an emperor who controlled everything including trade ruled them. A combination of different factors influenced the growth of these empires with the most powerful empire conquering weaker ones through military conquest. Geographical factors are among the factors. This essay will focus on how various geographical factors impacted the Greek and Roman empires. It will also outline their culture, leaders and how things changed from time to time....   [tags: Roman Empire, Ancient Rome, Ancient Greece]

Research Papers
1087 words (3.1 pages)

Fall of the Roman Empire Essay

- The rise and fall of the Roman Empire has bewitched many historians, scholars, and archaeologists alike. This period in history would give way to brilliant leaders, a rising religion, technological advances, a stirring economy and robust army. However as the years would past, the once glorious empire would plummet from political turmoil, a deteriorating economy, religious unrest, and vicious attacks from foreign invaders. (Rosenwein 1-56). The history of the Roman Empire stretches over a thousand years with its foundation traced back to a mythical legend, where two twins named Romulus and Remus were left to die in a river....   [tags: Rome, territory, military prowess, invasion]

Research Papers
1205 words (3.4 pages)

Roman Women Essay

- Roman Women, by Eve D’Ambria, is a short, well–written work that is a part of the Cambridge Introduction to Roman Civilization collection. The work covers the topic of the women of Rome, across nearly all social classes and across the entire history of Rome until the rise of Christianity. The description of the book states that “by using a variety of sources… D’Ambria shows how these sources serve as objects of social analysis, rather than simply as documents that re–create how life was lived.” Unlike some other topics and works read during this semester, the topic of Roman women has the benefit of drawing upon a large repository of primary and secondary sources, and thus does not have to e...   [tags: Eve D´Ambria, Rome, chronology, images]

Research Papers
1245 words (3.6 pages)

Cleopatra: A Sign of the Times Essay

- Cleopatra: A Sign of the Times "For Rome, who had never condescended to fear any nation or people, did in her time fear two human beings; one was Hannibal, and the other was a woman" (Lefkowitz 126). Abstract Cleopatra VII, the last reigning queen of Egypt, has intrigued us for centuries. Her story is one that has been told many times, and the many different and vastly varied representations of her and her story are solely based on the ways in which men and society have perceived women and their role in society throughout history....   [tags: Egypt History Papers]

Research Papers
3705 words (10.6 pages)

Nerva: The First Good Emperor of Rome Essay

- On the 8 of November, [A.D. 35], I was born into this glorious world (Henderson 169). My noble family raised me in fairest Narnia in Umbria (Birley 30). Although I was born into a Senatorial family, I pursued neither a military career nor a public speaking one (Wend). From as far back as my ancestors can be traced, somehow they have always been involved in the political realm (Birley 30). My dearest great-grandfather, M. Cocceius Nerva, was consul [36 B.C.]; his grandfather, a man with the same name, was a fine jurist who accompanied Tiberius to Capri in [26 A.D.] (Wend)....   [tags: Roman History]

Research Papers
1474 words (4.2 pages)

A Government Older Than It's Country Essay

- Although almost everything in American architecture, language, military concepts, and ideals can be traced back to both Roman and Greek cultures, the single most influential concept that has been retained from Rome and Greece is government set-up. Either the direct democracy of Greece or the elective democracy of Rome can be seen in modern America. Although seen more and more rarely in the United States, direct democracy still exists today. Direct democracy means that each person votes on decisions individually, as opposed to representative democracy in which an elected individual makes, or helps make decisions....   [tags: Greek and Roman democracy applied ]

Research Papers
939 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on The Roman Economy During Ancient Times

- Merriam-Websters dictionary defines economy as “the process or system by which goods and services are produced, sold, and bought in a country or region”. In both Rome and Greece, the economy was bustling, because the people would sell good to other civilization in order to continuously grow enough food to feed themselves. Many systems that were in place in antiquity are still around in our modern times. The Roman economy during antiquity time was made up of many different aspects but the Roman economy relied heavily on the use of slave labor and agriculture....   [tags: Ancient Rome, Roman Empire, Roman Republic]

Research Papers
974 words (2.8 pages)

Related Searches

in Lefkowitz et al. 227).

If women, then, are not more but rather less physically complex than men, should they not be given less responsibility in society? The extensive writings of the Roman jurists, the emperor's legal experts, suggest yes. For one, women "do not have power even over their real children" (qtd. in Lefkowitz et al. 100). This comment on women's lack of responsibility in Roman society is compounded by their inequality under the law. Another such example of inequality under the law is that "wives have no right to bring criminal accusations for adultery.for while the law grants this privilege to men it does not concede it to women" (qtd. in Lefkowitz et al. 105). Moreover, it is not only allowable for a husband to kill the person who slept with his wife, but, if he kills his wife, he "should be punished more leniently, for the reason that he committed the act through impatience caused by just suffering" (qtd. in Lefkowitz et al. 104). These laws clearly place men in power over women. Indeed they even seem to place men in possession of women; however, the jurist Gaius makes an argument against a custom that blatantly reveals the idea of male possession. Roman children were assigned a guardian who would protect and guide them until they reached the age of puberty. Yet, women were forced to be under guardianship for their entire lives as they were thought of as "being scatterbrained" (qtd. in Lefkowitz et al. 99). Gaius argues, however, that "women of full age deal with their own affairs for themselves" (qtd. in Lefkowitz et al. 99). Moreover, their guardians continue to make decisions for their wards more because they are compelled to do so by a praetor than because they must help the woman survive. This argument shows that the laws with regard to women in Rome were in place because women were considered to be incapable of surviving in the complex Roman society. Another proof of this assertion is the law that "adultery cannot be committed with women who have charge of any business or shop" (qtd. in Lefkowitz et al. 104). This suggests that property denotes ability which denotes responsibility. The business woman, then, is no woman at all. Her responsibility defines her gender.

So, if gender to the Romans was about responsibility under the law, it was, therefore, also about power. Indeed, the Romans called the business woman " Androgyne . because she exhibited a male spirit in the outward form of a woman" (Gleason 67). This gender-power relationship is not only inferable from the law itself but from the evident hyper-sensitivity that men had towards their appearances. Seneca wrote that "a man who is sexually revealed by his walk, by a single gesture, by the way he answers a simple question or touches his head with his finger" (qtd. in Gleason 75). To avoid this sexual dissolution, aristocratic male children were taught to behave and speak in manly, and therefore powerful, manners. The importance placed on possible effeminacy was such that "a lot of anxious 'normal' males. cultivated various degrees of refinement while eyeing one another warily for signs of weakness" (Gleason 78). This preoccupation with masculinity, or the lack of it, reveals not only gender's direct relation to power but to status as well. For instance, for a man to "have [his] will with [his] slaves" (Gleason 76) said nothing of his dominance and masculinity, yet for "two men of equal status. [to] be rumored to enjoy a sexual relationship" (Gleason 76) would show one of the men's submission and womanliness. The education on masculinity to powerful men in Rome created an even stricter adherence to the principle of male dominance because it extended the definition of man himself: some men can dominate other men because not all men are masculine.

As more Roman men were taught the propriety of masculine domination, and as more men subscribed to this belief, a culture was developed that served men. This culture, moreover, fed on itself. Its male-oriented laws, customs, and standards created new generations that centered their beliefs on male-superiority. Though most cultural standards remain unsaid, the proper roles of women are evident in the epitaphs that men left there wives and daughters. The epitome of wives, for example, is characterized in the epitaph of Amymone, wife of Marcus, who was honored as "best and most beautiful, worker in wool, pious, chaste, thrifty, faithful, a stayer-at-home" (qtd. in Lefkowitz et al. 17). One son compares his mother's greatness not to all humans but only to other women: "nor did she take second place to any woman in virtue, work and wisdom in times of danger" (qtd. in Lefkowitz et al. 18). Women, evidently, had clearly defined roles and possible achievements. Yet these achievements do not contend with the male achievements, which seem to be glory-based: "a man's name and fame in the eyes and on the tongues of his fellowmen" (Gleason 83).

Plato justifies male-dominance on the basis of physical and natural male complexity and, therefore, superiority to women. Roman laws reflect this belief in the lack of power and responsibility they allot to women. However, this belief also allows for the idea that gender not only dictates but is dictated by power and responsibility. Though this can be illustrated partially by women who are considered man-like in nature because of their power in society, it is most evident in Roman men's preoccupation with their own masculine appearance. If one lacks power, one is a woman, but if one is an effeminate man, one lacks power. This definition of gender was taught to powerful aristocrat's children who made it even more central to their own culture. Gender and role's centrality in the ancient Roman culture is clearly evident in the epitaphs that honor the best women of the day. So, if the culture of male-superiority is self-perpetual, where did it begin? Though the reasons for male-domination are evident as one with power tries to retain power, and though men's methods to retain power are definable, from whence did men first gain the want and subsequent ability to dominate women? Perhaps Plato in his naiveté was correct in his theory that men dominate because they were meant to by nature. Or, perhaps, it is true that one instance in history, such as Rome, could be powerful enough to shape the cultures to follow forever. Are we, then, still affected by the male-centrality that Roman aristocrats learned and developed more than two-thousand years ago? Does our culture not stress the importance of the fertile man?
Return to