Categorizing of People in Shakespeare’s Tempest and Dante’s Inferno

Categorizing of People in Shakespeare’s Tempest and Dante’s Inferno

Length: 1201 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Categorizing of People in Shakespeare’s The Tempest and Dante’s Inferno

Shakespeare’s The Tempest and Dante’s Inferno both exhibit Foucault’s idea of categorization and subjectification using “dividing practices.” (Rabinow 8) Foucault argued that people can rise to power using discourse, “Discourse has the ability to turn human beings into subjects by placing them into certain categories.” (Rabinow 8) These categories are then defined “according to their level of deviance from the acceptable norm.” (Rabinow 8) Some examples of such categories are the homosexual, the insane, the criminal and the uncivilized. (Rabinow 8). By the above method, called “dividing practices,” people can be manipulated by socially categorizing them and then comparing them to norms. In this way human beings are given both a social and a personal identity (Rabinow 8) and this is how superiority among human beings can be established.

In the play, The Tempest by William Shakespeare, Prospero took control of Caliban and made him his servant. Prospero was able to do this because he viewed Caliban as an uncivilized being; Caliban was portrayed as a beast. Thus, Prospero was able to assume power over Caliban. It can be seen from Prospero’s speech that he thinks that Caliban is inferior to him when Prosper says, “I have used thee, Filth as thou art, with human care […]” (1.2.348-349). Prospero tries to justify enslaving Caliban, but all he really does is place Caliban into a category of bestial and uncivilized and as a result enslaves him.

Even Miranda, Prospero’s daughter, speaks in a way that categorizes Caliban as an uneducated and uncivilized savage. “I pitied thee, Took pains to make thee speak, taught thee each hour […] When thou didst not, savage, know thine own meaning […]” (1.2.356-359) Miranda doesn’t stop there; she continues labeling Caliban, “But thy vile race, though thou didst learn, had that in’t which good natures could not abide to be with; therefore wast though deservedly confined into this rock […]” (1.2.361-364). Exactly this kind of discourse turns Caliban into a subject. If Caliban had not been alone on the island, then Prospero and Miranda would have categorized a whole group of human beings rather than just one.

In addition to the above, Prospero also accused Caliban of trying to rape Miranda. The fact that in the play Caliban doesn’t contest this challenge shows that his character is being categorized as a “black rapist” (Loomba 324). The “black rapist” theme is the thought that black men have a lust for white women and that they are much more likely to rape a white woman.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Categorizing of People in Shakespeare’s Tempest and Dante’s Inferno." 24 Jan 2020

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

William Shakespeare 's The Tempest Essay

- “Discoveries can challenge or renew our perceptions of ourselves, others and the world” The challenging nature of a sudden or unexpected discovery can alter an individual’s perspective in various ways, resulting in the re-evaluation of a human beings belief, values and behaviour. The journey of discovery in which an individual accomplishes new insights and perspectives, allows them to procure understanding into their own individuality, as well as being able to envision their strengths and weakness....   [tags: The Tempest, William Shakespeare, Psychology]

Research Papers
1011 words (2.9 pages)

Shakespeare's The Tempest as a Microcosm of Society Essay

- The Tempest as Microcosm of Society       The Tempest is one of Shakespeare's most universal plays and, not coincidentally, is very much concerned with human behavior and emotion. As John Wilders observes in The Lost Garden, “Prospero’s island is what the sociologists call a ‘model’ of human society. Its cast of characters allows Shakespeare to portray in microcosm nearly all the basic, fundamental social relationships: those of a ruler to his territory, a governor to his subjects, a father to his child, masters to servants, male to female, and the rational to the irrational within the human microcosm itself" ([London: Macmillan Press Ltd., 1978], 127)....   [tags: Shakespeare The Tempest]

Research Papers
1254 words (3.6 pages)

Shakespeare's Tempest - A Tired and Dated Work? Essay

- The Tempest: Immortal Classic or Tired and Dated Work. Why do educators hold the works of Shakespeare in such high regard. Should The Tempest be considered an "immortal classic". Indeed Shakespeare's works had great significance in the evolution of English literature, but these works, including The Tempest are mostly devoid of significance and literary value in the present day. One can expect to gain little appreciation for fine literature from the reading of Shakespeare's works for reasons enumerate....   [tags: Shakespeare Tempest]

Free Essays
1045 words (3 pages)

Analysis of Shakespeare's The Tempest - A Jungian Interpretation Essay

- A Jungian Interpretation of the Tempest   Shakespeare’s Tempest lends itself to many different levels of meaning and interpretation. The play can be seen on a realistic plane as a tale of political power and social responsibility. It can be seen as allegory examining the growth of the human spirit. The Tempest investigates marriage, love, culture. It is symbolic of man’s rational higher instincts verses his animal natural tendencies. This is a play of repentance, power, revenge and fate that can also be seen as fantasy, dream, imagination, metaphor or magic....   [tags: Shakespeare The Tempest]

Free Essays
2401 words (6.9 pages)

Shakespeare's The Tempest - Is Prospero Good or Evil? Essay

- Tempest:  Is Prospero Good or Evil?     To be able to answer this question we must first understand why Prospero can be seen as good or evil. It is fair to say that Prospero is a main protagonist to the plot of Shakespeare’s Tempest. It is due to Prospero's role as a key figure in the play that has put him under so much scrutiny. Many different Shakespearean critics have their own view of Prospero and those that read or see the play also have their own opinion of the way in which Prospero may be seen....   [tags: Shakespeare Tempest]

Free Essays
1001 words (2.9 pages)

Essay about Analysis of Shakespeare's The Tempest - Caliban and Trinculo

- Psychoanalytic Analysis of Caliban and Trinculo of The Tempest    From a psychoanalytic perspective, both Caliban and Trinculo of Shakespeare’s The Tempest are interesting characters. Caliban is very sexual and bitter, while Trinculo is at odds with everything: his situation of being washed ashore and wrongly accused of saying things when he did not utter a word, as well as Caliban’s worship of an unkingly man, his drunken friend Stephano. Caliban has obviously not had all of his desires trained to stay within him, despite Prospero’s punishments and Miranda’s schooling....   [tags: Shakespeare The Tempest]

Free Essays
511 words (1.5 pages)

Analysis of Shakespeare's The Tempest - The True Villain Essay

- The True Villain of The Tempest On June 2, 1609, five hundred colonists set out in nine ships from Plymouth in association with the imperial Virginia Company. It was the aim of this expedition to fortify John Smith's colony in Virginia. While eight of the party's vessels securely arrived at Jamestown, the flagship, called the “Sea Adventure” , was conspicuously absent. This ship --which carried the fleet's most valuable cargo, the admiral Sir John Somers and the future governor of Virginia Sir George Somers --was separated from the other eight during a fierce storm off the coast of Bermuda, the legendary Isle of Devils, dreaded by superstitious sixteenth-century sailors....   [tags: Shakespeare The Tempest]

Free Essays
993 words (2.8 pages)

Prospero in William Shakespeare's "The Tempest" Essay

- Prospero in William Shakespeare's "The Tempest" Prospero has long been read as one of Shakespeare’s most cherished and provocative protagonists. His timeless role in “The Tempest” has provided readers and critics with insights into many attributes of Shakespeare as a man, his works, and the political views that are personified in his play. The historical context of “The Tempest” is one that convincingly conveys the political views of the English people of his time, relating to the colonization of the New World, the expansion of British powers, and the domination of the indigenous peoples that was necessary for the British to thrive in the Americas....   [tags: Shakespeare Tempest Prospero Essays]

Research Papers
1260 words (3.6 pages)

European Colonization in Shakespeare's The Tempest Essays

- No Critique of European Colonization in The Tempest    Since the 1960s, several critics have found a critique of colonialism in their respective readings of Shakespeare's The Tempest. The most radical of these analyses takes Prospero to be a European invader of the magical but primitive land that he comes to rule, using his superior knowledge to enslave its original inhabitants, most notably Caliban, and forcing them to do his bidding. While the textual clues concerning the geographic location of Prospero's island are ambiguous and vague, there is a prominent references to the "Bermoothes." We know that shortly before he wrote his final play, Shakespeare read a contemporary travel accoun...   [tags: Tempest Shakespeare Colonialism]

Research Papers
1295 words (3.7 pages)

Shakespeare's The Tempest Essay

- The Tempest raises many questions regarding the formation of authority and power. Is hierarchy understood as natural or as constructed. Also, what are the consequences when authority is usurped. This paper will attempt to answer these questions in a succinct manner using textual references to solidify its arguments. As the play progresses, Prospero constructs the hierarchy in such a way as to return things to their "natural" state. Any type of usurpation, whether attempted or successful, will always end up with power back in its rightful place, and most of the time with a lesson learned....   [tags: Tempest Shakespeare]

Research Papers
1719 words (4.9 pages)

Related Searches

Furthermore, it demonstrates that sexual violence is just a part of Caliban’s inferior nature (Loomba 324), as seen from the point of view of Prospero.

Just like The Tempest, The Inferno by Dante Alighieri also demonstrates Foucault’s theme. The Inferno itself is structured based on categorization of people. Those who are placed closer to the center of Hell have sinned worse than those who are in the outer circles. One part of Hell specifically deals with the “Sins of the Lion.” These are the sins of the violent and the bestial. Caliban would have probably ended up in Circle 7, Round 3, where the Violent against God, Nature, and Art reside.

The chief sinner of this place is Capaneus, who is stretched out on the burning sand. Capaneus is a blasphemer. While he was alive he was against God and now, even in Hell, Capaneus still curses God. Capaneus is separated from the rest of the society and placed into Hell only because he is against God. There is an even further categorization that happens here. Capaneus is placed in the part of the Hell represented by The Sins of the Lion. Thus, he is labeled as a beast. Even Virgil spoke of Capaneus with great intensity, “At this my guide spoke with such vehemence as I had not heard from him in all of Hell […]” (p. 130 line 58 -59). It is clear that Dante, both the author and the character, has much contempt for blasphemers. Obviously hatred towards God represents a great level of deviance from the accepted social norm. In this scene, we also see Virgil, who represents human reason. Why does Virgil have more authority than any of the creatures of Hell? It is because Virgil is in a different category, a category that is superior to any of the guardians of Hell.

If The Tempest and The Inferno are compared based on “dividing practices,” (Rabinow 8) then we can see that Caliban and Capaneus are similar in their fate. Both have been categorized as beasts. Caliban was portrayed by Prospero and Miranda as a dirty and crude animal. Capaneus was classified as a beast by being placed into the part of the Hell that deals with the violent and the bestial. Both are also are made subjects against their will and both are punished. The two “beasts” are forced into the situations that they find themselves in. Caliban is kept subjectified with the power of Prospero’s magic whereas Capaneus’s soul is restrained in Hell forever. In Capaneus’ case, he is always being punished for his deviation from the accepted norm, the so-called blaspheming of God, while Caliban is only punished in the instances when he does not obey his master, Prospero.

Caliban and Capaneus are also similar in the fact that they are being described with harsh words. Virgil uses phrases such as “by your insolence” and “only your rage could be fit torment for your sullen pride” (p. 130 lines 60, 62-63) to describe Capaneus. Miranda and Prospero use much more words to categorize Caliban. They use expressions such as “thou most lying slave,” (1.2.347) “abhorred slave,” (1.2.354) “savage,” (1.2.358) and “thy vile race.” (1.2.361)

Before Prospero came to his island, he probably has seen somewhere and/or has heard about people like Caliban. Therefore he is already biased against Caliban, and in his mind, Caliban already belongs to a certain category, even though Caliban himself has no idea about it. Consequently, Prospero is already thinking that he is superior to Caliban when they are first coming into the Prospero-Caliban relationship. Similarly, it was socially acceptable in Dante’s time that it is wrong to be against God, just as it is wrong to be a “beast” like Caliban. Dante has the categorization of people who are against God in his head even before he comes in contact with Capaneus.

As you can see, both Caliban and Capaneus are being categorized and made inferior. With the use of right discourse, the two characters are being labeled as violent and bestial creatures; Caliban because he is uncivilized and because he tried to rape Miranda, and Capaneus because he is against God and because he is placed into the part of Hell that deals with the sins of the lion. Their level of deviance from the norm might vary, but it is clear that Capaneus and Caliban are being categorized and “given a social identity” (Rabinow 8).

Works Cited

Alighieri, Dante. The Inferno. Trans. John Ciardi. New York: Signet Classic, 2001.

Rabinow, Paul, ed. The Foucault Reader. New York: Pantheon Books, 1984.

Shakespeare, William. The Tempest. Ed. Gerald Graff and James Phelan. New York:

Bedford/St.Martin’s, 2000.
Return to