The Children in Sons and Lovers and What Maisie Knew

The Children in Sons and Lovers and What Maisie Knew

Length: 933 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
The Children in Sons and Lovers and What Maisie Knew

    The characters in Sons and Lovers by D. H. Lawrence and the

characters in What Maisie Knew each have a special meaning.  They all seem

to be interwoven with one another portraying a new cycle in another

characters life.  For instance, in What Maisie Knew Mrs. Wix was introduced,

in my opinion, at a time when Maisie needed a mother figure. Also, Sir

Claude is introduced when she seems to need a father figure.  On the other

hand, in Sons and Lovers there are not very many new characters introduced.

However, the ones that are introduced seem to want to try and break the

bond that Paul and his mother have.   Thus, James and Lawrence seem to be

using similar themes with different surroundings and events.  Although the

circumstances are different, Henry James and D. H. Lawrence characterize

the children as being Impoverished.


      Henry James in his novel What Maisie Knew, portrays the main

character, Maisie, as being impoverished emotionally.  The emotional

poverty that Maisie experiences in her life exist because of her parents

extremely vicious hatred for each other.  They use Maisie as a "vessel for

bitterness" (13). To Beale and Ida, Maisie was just a tool that they used

to hurt the other person.  Eventually, Maisie figured out that they were

using her to be the bearer of brutily hateful messages.  Consequently, she

learned not to deliver such messages.  This made her parents very angry and

they decided that she had "grown incredably dull".  Thus, Maisie realized "

They had wanted her not for any good they could do her, but for harm they

could, with her unconscious aid, do each other." Unfortunately, Maisie's

emotions were of no concern to either parent.  As a result, Maisie seldom

experienced any meaningful affection from either of her parents.

Furthermore, on the rare occasions when Maisie's mother embraced her it was

performed without any affection, or it is so convulsive that it makes her

feel as though "she had suddenly been thrust, with a smash of glass, into a

jeweller's shop-front..." (112 Lawrence).    Likewise, Maisie's father

subjects her to emotional neglect by reminding her that everything had "

changed on her account, everything ordered to enable him to give himself up

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"The Children in Sons and Lovers and What Maisie Knew." 23 Feb 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Challenging the Identity of the Family in What Maisie Knew by Henry James

- Challenging the Identity of the Family in What Maisie Knew     Although Henry James did not confine himself exclusively to the scope of literary themes facing America, in his novel What Maisie Knew, he did challenge the changing identity of the modern family.  At the turn of the century, the dynamics of the family institution became an important theme in American literature due to such issues as the increased social mobility of the industrial age, the new emerging independence of women, and a modern view that lent itself to challenging tradition.  For many of James' contemporaries, Edith Wharton, for example, a colleague and friend of James, this theme became the focus of works...   [tags: What Maisie Knew]

Research Papers
2032 words (5.8 pages)

Essay about What Maisie Knew Is A Movie About A Young Girl Named Maisie

- ... On her 13th birthday her best friend Matty,who likes her, arrives early to her party to give her his handmade present, which is a dollhouse with wishing powder on it. As the party continues people, including the popular girls suggest that Jenna plays seven minutes in heaven and Jenna is eventually put in the closet with Matty, much to her horror. She then wishes that she was 30 and the next day she wakes up and realizes her wish came true. She then see’s what her life is like now and realizes that all she wants to do is find Matty....   [tags: Mother, Parent, Father]

Research Papers
802 words (2.3 pages)

Conflict in All My Sons Essays

- Conflict in All My Sons The conflict in the play “All My Sons” in embodied by two different sets of values. The older generation represented by Joe and Kate strongly believed in family values and Pursue of the American dream at any cost. In contradiction, Joe and Anne express the younger generation’s ethics and ideals clearly shown in the thoughts of idealism that money is not the most important thing in life. Even though the younger generation’s ideals are sometimes thought of as being irrational and in conflict with reality, all throughout the play their validity is greater....   [tags: All My Sons Parent Child Relationships Essays]

Research Papers
1097 words (3.1 pages)

Prose and Style in Sons and Lovers Essay

- [1]And after such an evening they both were very still, having known the immensity of passion. [2]They felt small, half afraid, childish, and wondering, like Adam and Eve when they lost their innocence and realized the magnificence of the power which drove them out of Paradise and across the great night and the great day of humanity. [3]It was for each of them an initiation and a satisfaction. [4]To know their own nothingness, to know the tremendous living flood which carried them always, gave them rest within themselves....   [tags: Lawrence Sons and Lovers Essays]

Free Essays
1195 words (3.4 pages)

Relationships in Lawrence's Sons and Lovers Essay

- Relationships in Lawrence's Sons and Lovers      There can be no argument that D. H. Lawrence's Son's and Lover's is a study of  human relationships. Gertrude Morel, because of her turbulent and odd relationship with her husband, ends up developing deep emotional relations with her two eldest son's. The second eldest in particular, Paul, is the receiver of most of this deep emotion. Because of these feelings and the deeper-than-usual emotional bond between the two, Paul has difficulty being comfortable in his own relationships.  Paul's relationship with Miriam is plagued by his mother's disapproval, jealousy, and Miriam 's own spirituality....   [tags: Lawrence Sons and Lovers Essays]

Research Papers
849 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on Sons and Lovers by D.H. Lawrence

- Sons and Lovers by D.H. Lawrence THE PLOT In the rolling hills and coal-pitted fields of central England, known as the British Midlands, live the Morels, a poor mining family. The family has just moved down in the world from the nearby village of Bestwood to the Bottoms, a complex of working-class row houses. Gertrude Morel is a small, stern woman, pregnant with her third child, Paul, the protagonist of this novel. The Morels' other children are William and Annie. But unlike his siblings, Paul is not wanted by his mother....   [tags: Sons Lovers Lawrence Essays]

Research Papers
6138 words (17.5 pages)

Sons and Lovers as Bildungsroman Essay

- Sons and Lovers as Bildungsroman      As a twentieth century novelist, essayist, and poet, David Herbert Lawrence brought the subjects of sex, psychology, and religion to the forefront of literature. One of the most widely read novels of the twentieth century, Sons and Lovers, which Lawrence wrote in 1913, produces a sense of Bildungsroman1, where the novelist re-creates his own personal experiences through the protagonist in (Niven 115). Lawrence uses Paul Morel, the protagonist in Sons and Lovers, for this form of fiction....   [tags: Lawrence Sons and Lovers Essays]

Research Papers
930 words (2.7 pages)

D.H. Lawrence's Sons and Lovers Essay

- D. H. Lawrence is considered one of the Twentieth Century's greatest and most visionary English novelists. He was born in 1885 in Eastwood, a mining community in Nottinghamshire, England (DeMott iii). His father was an uneducated miner and his mother had been a schoolteacher before she married. According to England's rigid class system, his mother's marriage to his father was considered a step down, since she came from a well-educated middle-class family. Thus the vast differences between his parents was cause for "the fabric of his parents' marriage [to be] ripped by bitterness, violence and hate" (DeMott vii)....   [tags: Lawrence Sons and Lovers Essays]

Research Papers
1384 words (4 pages)

Paul's Relationship with Clara in Sons and Lovers Essay

- Paul's Relationship with Clara in Sons and Lovers     Paul's relationship with Clara is based on passion. Her womanliness impresses him from the first time that they meet and throughout their relationship. Since Paul has never had any sexual experiences Clara amazes him thoroughly because she is so sensual, unlike Miriam who is afraid of any physical contact and his mother who is not in a position to offer him such things. During their relationship, Paul matures from a boy into a man not only physically but also mentally....   [tags: Lawrence Sons and Lovers Essays]

Free Essays
2003 words (5.7 pages)

All My Sons Essay

- Life is full of many hard decisions that people have to take, often on the spur of the moment. Some we get right others turn horribly wrong. Joe Keller, the tragic hero of Arthur Miller's play All My Sons, was no different. His whole life was dedicated to his family and their well being but all his plans were undone by one fatally flawed decision. The audience can relate to Joe and feel sympathy for him because he was a good man who did many great things for his family and in the end paid the ultimate price....   [tags: All My Sons by Arthur Miller]

Research Papers
1226 words (3.5 pages)

Related Searches

to her." (17).  This, in my opinion, was Beales way of telling Maisie that

she was a bother to him, thus, she is unconsciously informed that she is

not wanted.  The emotional poverty that Maisie lives with makes her feel

that her parents made "it hurt more than usual" (17). Consequently,

Maisie's fate is sealed.  Unconsciously she knows what is about to happen

and she will have to live with the pain of knowing that her parents did not

want her, thus, allowing others to raise the child.  Similarly,  D. H.

Lawrence, in his novel Sons and Lovers, portrays the main character, Paul,

as being emotionally poor. Emotionally, Paul is impoverished because of

his feelings for his mother.  The passion they feel for each other is, in

my opinion, an emotional incest.  They act more as lovers than they do

mother and son.  For instance, when they were out together his mother felt

like "she was gay, like a sweetheart", and, Paul felt his "heart contract

with pain of love for her" (Lawrence  ). Because of this passion Paul does

not allow himself to leave his mother. Eventually, when Mrs. Morel tells

Paul that she "never really had a husband...", Paul starts assuming the

mental role of the husband.   Consequently, this mental action of being a

husband to his mother, destroys any emotional relationships Paul tries to

have with other women.  For example, He is in love with Miriam, but, in my

opinion , he feels that she cannot fufill him like his mother does.Also, he

trys to have a relationship with Mrs. Dawes, however it seems to be more

sexual and he helps her get back together with her husband.  As a result,

He feels that no woman can match up to his mother.  Therefore, he has

decided that he is unable to meet the right woman as long as she is alive.

As a result, Paul promises never to leave his mother. Therefore, like

Maisie, Paul's fate is sealed.  He will be destin to live a life of

emotional poverty until his mother dies.  When she dies Paul will then be

able to take on a normal relationship with a female.


      In conclusion, The characters are in an emotional poverty caused by

their parents inability to recognize that what they are doing is hurting

their children emotionally. Lawrence and James choose to write this way so

that it reflects the moral sense as well as the fate of the moral sense in

a corrupt and sinister world.  The moral sense is the conscious which is

reflected through Maisie and Paul. The characters that represent the

consciousness seem to be full of unconditional love.  For instance, when

Maisie's parents abandon her, she seems to get angry, however, she also

seems to be happy.  Also Paul seems to get angry at his mother for having

such control over him, and, at the same time he feels a deep passionate

love for her.  James and Lawrence, in my opinion, are trying to get the

readers drawn into the book and their own conscious mind.  Thus, making

them more aware of their thoughts and surroundings.


Work Cited

DeMott, Benjamin. Introduction. Sons and Lovers. By D.H. Lawrence. New York: Penguin Books, 1985.

James, Henry. What Maisie Knew. London: Penguin, 1985.

Lawrence, D.H. Sons and Lovers. New York: Penguin Books, 1985.

Return to