Comparing Romantic Opposition in Billy Budd, Bartleby the Scrivener and Artist of the Beautiful

Comparing Romantic Opposition in Billy Budd, Bartleby the Scrivener and Artist of the Beautiful

Length: 1220 words (3.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓

    Herman Melville wrote some of the most widely read works in the history of literature during the late nineteenth century.  He has become a writer with whom the romantic era is associated and a man whose works have become a standard by which modern literature is judged.  One of his most well-known and widely studied short pieces of fiction is a story entitled, simply, Billy Budd.  In this short story, Melville tells the tale of Billy Budd, a somewhat out-of-place stuttering sailor who is too innocent for his own good.  This enchanting tale, while inevitably entertaining, holds beneath it many layers of interpretive depth and among these layers of interpretation, an idea that has been entertained in the literature of many other romantic writers.  Melville uses a literary technique of developing two characters that are complete opposites in all aspects and contrasting them throughout the narrative, thus allowing their own personalities to adversely compliment each other. Melville also uses this tactic in another well-known short story, Bartleby the Scrivener.  Much like Melville's two stories, another romantic writer, Nathaniel Hawthorne, uses this tactic in his short story, The Artist of the Beautiful when he creates two completely different characters who vie for the same woman's love.  Both writers use the contrary characters to represent the different facets of the human personality.   Using this idea and many others, these romantic writers, Melville and Hawthorne, created works with depth of meaning that were both interesting to read and even more intriguing to interpret.


 In his short story, Billy Budd, Melville uses this romantically based idea of characteristic opposites in two of his main characters, Billy Budd and Claggart.  To give the comparison even more strength, Melville also puts these two characters in virtually opposing roles in the story.  Billy represents the good that is present in humans and Claggart represents the bad.  Similarly, Claggart takes on an intelligent persona while Billy appears to be a bit innocent and uneducated in the ways of the ship.  These two men are essentially at odds and appear to represent the dueling facets of the human conscience, the sort of angel and devil on the shoulder.  Claggart wishes to rid the ship of Billy and eventually, the captain of the ship is forced to hang Billy because of Claggart's malice.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Comparing Romantic Opposition in Billy Budd, Bartleby the Scrivener and Artist of the Beautiful." 24 Feb 2020

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Comparing Billy Budd and Christ Essay

- Comparing Billy and Christ in Billy Budd Herman Melville's Billy Budd provides us with a summation and conclusive commentary on the ambiguities of moral righteousness and social necessity. The conflict that arises pitting natural justice in opposition to military justice essentially deliberates over whether the sacrifice of the individual is required for the continuum and conservation of social order. The deep allegorical theme of the passion of Christ that resides in Billy Budd illustrates Melville's adjudication on this issue....   [tags: Billy Budd Essays]

Research Papers
3108 words (8.9 pages)

Billy Budd Essay: Comparing Christ to Billy

- Comparing Christ to Billy of Billy Budd         "I stand for the heart. To the dogs with the head!" wrote Herman Melville in his June 1851 letter to Nathaniel Hawthorne (Davis and Gilman 3). Yet, by the time he began writing Billy Budd, Sailor in 1888, Melville must have tempered this view, for Billy Budd depicts the inevitable destruction of a man who is all heart but who utterly lacks insight. Melville no doubt intends for his reader to connect this tale with the gospel of Jesus Christ. Billy Budd endures a persecution similar to Christ's; he is executed for like reasons, and he eventually ascends, taking "the full rose of the dawn" (BB 376)....   [tags: Billy Budd Essays]

Research Papers
3199 words (9.1 pages)

Politics: The Concept of Domesticated Opposition Essay

- Conceptualization of “domesticated opposition” The concept of “domesticated opposition” is used by scholars to describe opposition parties that are loyal rather than competitors and that have complied with the government’s game of restricted pluralism. Also dubbed as “toothless”, domesticated opposition hardly challenge the regime’s semi-authoritarianism and are not part of the decision making process. They have come to depend on the regime’s consent to secure their minimal political gains and to protect the narrow political space in which they are operating (Shehata, 2009)....   [tags: pluralism, democracy, opposition parties]

Research Papers
2370 words (6.8 pages)

Perspective on the Opposition of Interfaith Marriage Essay

- Interfaith Nation Marriage is considered one of the most important parts in a person’s life. Choosing to enter a marriage can change a person’s life forever. It can bring great happiness and beauty or intense stress and sacrifice into an individual’s life. But, most importantly, it can show people a love that is unconditional. Marriage has existed for hundreds of years and beyond that, the establishment of marriage is seemingly timeless. Interfaith marriage on the other hand, has a little known history or record of occurring....   [tags: Religion, Family opposition,divorce]

Research Papers
1049 words (3 pages)

Michael Ondaatje's The Collected Works of Billy the Kid Essay

- The Perception of Violence in Michael Ondaatje's The Collected Works of Billy the Kid A question that arises in almost any medium of art, be it music, film or literature, is whether or not the depiction of violence is merely gratuitous or whether it is a legitimate artistic expression. There can be no doubt that Michael Ondaatje's long poem The Collected Works of Billy the Kid is a violent work, but certain factors should be kept in mind before passing it off as an attempt to shock and titillate; certainly, the poem does both of these, but they are not the primary purpose of the work....   [tags: Collected Works Billy Kid]

Research Papers
2721 words (7.8 pages)

Comparing Jane Eyre and Billy Casper Essay

- Comparing Jane Eyre and Billy Casper Jane Eyre and Billy Casper are similar, yet very different children. I am going to compare their similarities and differences. The issues that I will concentrate on are their home lives and their treatment by people. Jane, 10 year old lives in a mansion with her aunt Mrs Reed and her children. The family are extremely wealthy. "A small breakfast room adjoined the drawing room". As we are told that the family has a breakfast room, we assume that Jane has her own room, which demonstrates that Jane is entitled to privacy....   [tags: Papers]

Research Papers
2039 words (5.8 pages)

Free Billy Budd Essays: Billy Budd as Christ

- Billy Budd as Christ In this novel, Billy Budd, Melville acts as a "Creator", in that he gives Billy Budd certain superhuman qualities, which allows him to posses the traits of a servant of God. Billy Budd appears Christ-like, because of his peace-making abilities. Although, he is a peacemaker whom will fight for what he believes in and to keep peace. In the beginning of the novel, when Red Whiskers gives Billy Budd problems, he strikes him with a powerful blow and does not have any more problems with him or the crew again....   [tags: Billy Budd Essays]

Free Essays
952 words (2.7 pages)

Captian Vere's reactions to Billy Budd in Billy Budd Essay

- Captian Vere's reactions to Billy Budd in Billy Budd When Captain Vere says “Struck dead by an angel of God. Yet the angel must hang!” his attitude towards Billy Budd changes from one of paternal concern and personal respect to one in which he has set aside his personal thoughts and feelings for the sake of his nation. Each sentence represents this dichotomy by indicating his sentiment towards Billy. In the first, Billy is “an angel of God” who has “struck” Claggart dead, in a righteous manner....   [tags: Vere Billy Budd Essays]

Free Essays
414 words (1.2 pages)

Essay on Biblical Allegories in Billy Budd

- Biblical Allegories in Billy Budd Herman Melville's Billy Budd is a novel with many biblical allegories ranging from subtle references to quite obvious similarities between characters and Biblical figures. One of the most prevalent and accepted similarities is that of "Billy as Adam" (Berthoff, Certain 33) around the time of the Fall, "The ground common to most discussion of Billy Budd is the assumption that the story is allegorical ... a reenactment of the Fall" (Berthoff, Certain 32)....   [tags: Billy Budd Essays]

Research Papers
598 words (1.7 pages)

Irony in Billy Budd Essays

- Billy Budd is a story filled with irony. This literary aspect can be seen through the plot and characters of the work. As defined in The American Heritage Dictionary, irony is the use of words to convey the opposite of their literal meaning. After a casual reading of the story' the many ironic aspects may have been igonred, but after analyzing the story it becomes obvious that they are of great importance. "...The fate of each character is the direct reverse of what one is led to expect from his nature" (Johnson, 185)....   [tags: Billy Budd Essays]

Research Papers
609 words (1.7 pages)

Related Searches

  This final altercation brings into play all of the differences that are present in the characters of Billy and Claggart.  Billy is a moral person and Claggart is not.  Billy is also subservient and unassuming while Claggart is self-sufficient and always seems to be planning something.  Claggart is older and Billy is younger.  Melville even makes the characters look different, creating Billy as a big, dark-skinned, healthy man while describing Claggart's complexion as "pale" and "seeming to hint of something defective and abnormal in the constitution and blood" (Melville 448).  Not only are these characters' personalities and appearances different, but they are also pitted against each other in the story.  "But Claggart's conscience being but the lawyer to his will, made ogres of trifles, probably arguing that the motive imputed to Billy in spilling the soup just when he did . . .made a strong case against him (Melville 461)".  These two characters are so different that they are often compared to Adam and the serpent in the Biblical garden of Eden, once again bringing to light their differences and their natural tendency to oppose one another.  In the development of these characters through the storyline, Melville is able to capture the good and the bad sides of human nature.


 In Bartleby the Scrivener, Melville also creates two characters that are both the antithesis and the nemesis each other.  The situation in this story is not as consciously cruel as in Billy Budd, but nevertheless the two main characters stand on opposing sides of one important issue.  The title character, Bartleby, is a newly hired scrivener for the narrator of the story and all goes well until Bartleby refuses to read over the copies he has made.  He says, simply, "I would prefer not to", a phrase that eventually angers the narrator to drastic measures (Melville 51).  These two men play a mostly mental tug-of-war game throughout the story, heightening the tension to extreme proportions.  Perhaps this tension is heightened also because of the great differences between the two men.  As far as appearances go, the narrator seems to be a hearty, healthy man while Bartleby is described as gaunt, pale, and sunken.  The narrator also has the brisk manner that his occupation often requires at the same time as Bartleby's character possesses nothing of the sort.  Likewise, on a more interpretive level, Bartleby is well acquainted with human mortality, specifically his own, in his slow progression toward emaciation.  He forces the narrator to deal with his own mortality, a subject that he has not yet dealt with at his advanced age.  In Bartleby the Scrivener, Melville creates the characters of Bartleby and the narrator to further demonstrate the many differing aspects of human personality and appearance.


 Another romantic writer, Nathaniel Hawthorne, also includes opposing characters in his stories.  In his short story, The Artist of the Beautiful, Melville creates two completely different characters who vie for the love of one woman.  Owen Warland and Robert Danforth are both in love with Annie Hovenden.  They both, at the beginning of the story, would love her hand in marriage, but they have completely different personalities.  Robert is a big, burly working man who spends hours of his day mindlessly clunking at his blacksmith's anvil.  Warland, on the other hand, is a watchmaker who is small and fragile in appearance with a sharp mind and a passion for the intricately beautiful.  Warland has a visionary mind while Danforth possesses a simple mind and a down-to-earth personality.  Hawthorne best illustrates these great physical and intellectual differences in the comparison of the men's hands.  "He [Danforth] laid his vast hand beside the delicate one of Owen (Hawthorne 269)".  Despite these two men's differences, they are both enamored with the beautiful Annie Hovenden, a woman who seems to appreciate the men for their individual qualities (or at least sympathizes with Owen's predicaments).  Of course, only one man may have the honor of her hand (in marriage).  Thus, Hawthorne creates the tension between these two very different men.  These men represent the different qualities that may be present in people and the good and bad things that they produce.  With Annie, Danforth creates a sturdy little child and with his own intelligence and foresight, Owen creates, for a moment, pure beauty.


 These two romantic writers use different characters to represent the different facets of human personality and appearance.  They create the personalities of the characters throughout the plot and then compare them while telling an entertaining story.  A reader may read just the surface story or may enjoy the depth that each tale presents.  Through these three short stories, Billy Budd, Bartleby the Scrivener, and The Artist of the Beautiful, these writers create a standard for romantic literature that will be upheld for years to come.


Works Cited

1.  Arvin, Newton.  Hawthorne's Short Stories.  Vintage:  New York, 1946.

2.  Bethoff, Warner.  Great Short Works of Herman Melville.  Harper:  New York, 1969.
Return to