Use of Experiments in Natural Sciences and in Sociology

  • Length: 862 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)
  • Rating: Excellent
Open Document

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Text Preview

More ↓

Continue reading...

Open Document

Use of Experiments in Natural Sciences and in Sociology

Experiments are particularly important in natural sciences as they are
the device used to either prove or disprove a hypothesis. Sciences
such as chemistry or physiology operate in what is known as closed
systems, where all the variables can be controlled. This means
therefore that such experiments can be carried out, and effectively.

Whereas it may be difficult in physical sciences to control the
variables, and in sociology to recreate everyday life, natural
sciences do not face the same overriding problems. What they are
investigating is predictable and all that makes up the experiment can
be controlled and changed in order to assess how true their hypothesis
is. They do not have to worry about the results not being reliable as
the situations do not change, nor do the subjects under study; they
are going to react to different situations in the same way every time.
Therefore they are particularly useful and well respected as they give
true, unquestionable results that ultimately prove or disprove a
hypothesis, with no room for any substantial opposing argument.

By using experiments it enables scientists to test precise
predictions. Laboratories are environments that the scientist can
control and indeed manipulate the various independent variables
however they wish. They can calculate the effects of a single
independent variable while removing the possibility that any other
factors are affecting the dependent variable they are studying.

b) Assess the reason why experiments are rarely used in sociology. (12

Even though experiments appear to be extremely useful in proving
something to be true, or to simply find a lot more about a certain
subject, in sociology they are not as useful and reliable. They
frequently incur many ethical or practical problems and are therefore
not used as often as the results they show are very questionable.

A first reason why they are rarely used in sociology is due to the
known and accepted fact that it is extremely difficult to recreate
normal life in the artificial setting of an experiment.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Use of Experiments in Natural Sciences and in Sociology." 19 Jun 2018
Title Length Color Rating  
Natural Sciences with Ethical Considerations Essay - Interpreted literally, ethical judgements do seem to limit methods available in the production of knowledge in both the arts and the natural sciences; it’s not difficult to imagine the chaos of a world void of any kind of ethical considerations. However, can knowledge in the natural sciences even be compared to knowledge in the arts. Knowledge in the natural sciences includes knowledge that helps improve methods used in hospitals to treat previously untreatable illnesses. Art at first glance does not hold enough weight to be compared because it reaches a smaller number of people giving it less importance than knowledge gained in natural sciences....   [tags: Experiments, Studies, Natural Sciences]
:: 15 Works Cited
1329 words
(3.8 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Ethical Judgements in Art and Natural Sciences Essay - Ethical judgements limit the methods available in the production of knowledge in both the arts and the natural sciences. Discuss. We make decisions all the time. Similarly, there are decisions in various areas of knowledge whether it would be the arts or the natural sciences. Natural sciences is the area that is seeking for patterns. Meanwhile the arts is the area that is more broad and subjective. However, both areas of knowledge are affected by the decisions people make. These decisions are associated with the ethical judgments in society....   [tags: knowledge, decisions, arts, sciences]
:: 10 Works Cited
1452 words
(4.1 pages)
Term Papers [preview]
Social and Natural Sciences Essay example - ... By taking both natural and social sciences into consideration. By taking personal experiences and relevant knowledge issues into account, this essay will discuss several aspects regarding the knowledge question. In natural sciences, one usually requires action in the form of experiments to justify knowledge. Experiments generally include a purpose procedure and quantitative results. Moreover they always have maximum control and show a cause and effect relationship. By achieving maximum control, the results are solely based on the independent ant variable....   [tags: knowledge, experiments, creation] 849 words
(2.4 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Difference between the Social Sciences and the Natural Sciences Essay - Explain the argument for each side of this issue, then describe your own view. Social sciences are the analysis methodically of the social area of the world. They are mixed area of study of human behavior and society which include disciplines of anthropology, economics, political science, psychology and sociology. Social sciences study methodically the manner in which people behave and how they influence the world around us. It aims to comprehend any given social phenomena by using a methodology borrowed from the physical sciences....   [tags: research approach] 966 words
(2.8 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Ethical Judgments in the Arts and the Natural Sciences Essay - Ethical judgments limit the methods available in the production of knowledge in both the arts and the natural sciences. Discuss. When talking about ethics we have to take in account that it is based on the socially standardized concept of some things being good and some things being bad. Therefore what might be seen as socially unethical arts for some people, in another society or in another time, it probably won’t be so. The same is true for the natural sciences. And even if we take our western society as a base, there are some aspects of ethics and some specific topics of which people do not have a standardized opinion....   [tags: Ethics Essays]
:: 1 Works Cited
1298 words
(3.7 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Critical Thinking in Mathematics and Natural Sciences Essay - Knowledge is generated through the interaction of critical and creative thinking. As an IB student in high school we are faced with problems that involve us using our minds for critical thinking. It is hard for students to engage their creative thinking in times when it is critical. We are rarely encouraged to use our creative minds during problems. In this world there are logical answers that is probed using critical thinking. But what is the right situation to use critical thinking. Can critical and creative thinking be used and interact with each other in certain problems or maybe all problems....   [tags: Critical Thinking Essays]
:: 3 Works Cited
1488 words
(4.3 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
What is it about theories in the human sciences and natural sciences that makes them convincing? - Theories are unproven hypotheses that serve as explanations for observations and events, so they must have a way of convincing people that they are true. A theory’s objectives are to explain and predict a phenomenon. Most ideas are not convincing without solid evidence or proof. The human sciences and natural sciences have different ways of showing the validity of a hypothesis. The natural sciences, which include subject areas such as physics, chemistry, and biology, depend on physical proof through experiments with several trials....   [tags: Science]
:: 2 Works Cited
1468 words
(4.2 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
What is it about theories in human sciences and natural sciences that make them convincing? - When looking at the human sciences and natural sciences, one may question the validity of a claim or choose to support it without any evidentiary support. For many years, science has been accepted by many as the dominant cognitive paradigm, or model of knowledge. In fact, there are also people who believe that science is the only pathway for gaining knowledge, and if something isn’t provable through science, then it should not be accepted. A person might ask, what is it about the human sciences and natural sciences that makes them convincing....   [tags: Human Intellect, Science]
:: 2 Works Cited
1199 words
(3.4 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Methods of Experimentation and Research in the Natural Sciences that are Limited due to Ethical Considerations - The production of knowledge, the theoretical or practical understanding of a subject (New Oxford), has constantly been accomplished throughout the history of man as a result of the characteristics of creativity and curiosity. These attributes, besides ethics, have set humans apart from the other species allowing for constant and rapid development. According to (Rest), an ethical judgment is the process by which an individual determines that one alternative is morally right and another alternative is morally wrong....   [tags: eugenics, animal testing, ethical judgement]
:: 8 Works Cited
1459 words
(4.2 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Essay The Theory of Knowledge - "That which is accepted as knowledge today is sometimes discarded tomorrow." Until 1900, human knowledge doubled approximately every century. Post-WWII, it doubled every 25 years. It now appears to grow exponentially. This has resulted in the revision of the information previously thought of as knowledge. This raises these knowledge issues: if knowledge that is accepted today is sometimes discarded tomorrow, and the aim of the natural sciences is to provide the complete objective truth, can science ever achieve this aim....   [tags: Natural Sciences]
:: 11 Works Cited
1450 words
(4.1 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]

It is one
thing to observe people and the goings on in society, but actually
trying to reconstruct a perfect, replica situation in a laboratory, in
a non-realistic setting is a whole different matter. For a start it
cannot be proven to be completely valid as what they are experimenting
may be totally different from how it would be in normal society.

Furthermore, there are often ethical problems in performing
experiments on people. Just the fact that they are being experimented
on, and in their eyes singled out for some reason, people may feel
they are being discriminated against and be offended by the research
that is being carried out directly on them. Not only might if offend
them, but with the underlying knowledge that they are being watched
could easily put added pressure and stress on their ordinary, calm

But experiments not only could affect the subject under study, but it
could consequently affect the results and their reliability. The
results may be influenced by the experimenter effect, where people
respond to what they perceive to be the expectations of the
researchers, rather than acting as if they would normally. Linked in
with this is the possibility of the ‘Hawthorne Effect’ where the
subject act differently as they know they are being experimented on
and respond differently as a result.

Ultimately though laboratories are unnatural situations. Members of
society do not, in the normal course of events, spend their time under
observation in laboratories. The knowledge that they are being
studied, and the artificiality of the situation, might well affect the
behaviour of those involved and distort the results so as to make them
of little use. Because the results obtained in a laboratory may have
little relationship to how people might behave outside the laboratory,
the results of experiments lack external validity.

It is impractical to carry out experiments in laboratories on many of
the subjects of interest to sociologists. It is not possible to fit a
community, let alone a whole society, into a laboratory. Nor is it
possible to carry out a laboratory experiment over a sufficiently long
time span to study social change.

Field experiments are therefore used which are outside the laboratory.
But although field experiments overcome the problem of experiments
taking place in an unnatural setting, these experiments do have other
problems associated with them. It is not possible to control variables
as closely as it is in the laboratory. Also, in some field
experiments, the fact that an experiment is taking place can affect
the results, as explained before with the ‘Hawthorne Effect’. To
possibly avoid this, it is necessary that the subjects of experimental
research are unaware that the experiment is taking place. This,
however, raises a further problem: the morality of conducting
experiments on people without their consent. Some sociologists
strongly object to do this.

Although field experiments open up greater possibilities than
laboratory experiments, they are still likely to be confined to
small-scale studies over short periods of time. Experimentation on
society as a whole, or on large groups of society, is only likely to
be possible with the consent of governments. Few governments are
willing to surrender their authority to social researchers who are
keen to test the theories and hypotheses they have developed. In these
circumstances sociologists normally rely upon studying society as it
is, rather than trying to manipulate it so that their theories can be
tested directly.

However, whilst there may be the obvious underlying problems
associated with experiments in sociology, they do have their clear
uses. Some of the techniques of experiments are used in sociology and
psychology, but in sociology there is the problem of being unable to
completely control the variables, something that is possible with
scientists. At least with the new form of experiment in the field
experiment, researchers are able to disrupt normal activity in an
attempt to uncover the phenomena they are investigating.

Nevertheless, experiments in sociology will always face the problem of
wanting to study people in society itself rather than in the false
situation of a laboratory, whereas what they see here is not a true
reflection of society, and consequently only gives them false results.

Return to