Free Essays - The Phony Holden of Catcher in the Rye

Free Essays - The Phony Holden of Catcher in the Rye

Length: 1438 words (4.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓

The Phony Holden of Catcher in the Rye



J.D. Salinger writes about a young man who is very distraught after World War II. In Salinger's only published novel The Catcher in the Rye he talks about a young man who does not understand society and the surroundings he lives in. He keeps referring back to how everyone and everything around him is a phony. He makes himself seem unreliable by telling the reader that he lies openly.


In the novel Holden is what you would call an unreliable narrator. The definition of unreliable is - a person or thing that cannot be counted on or trusted. You cannot trust Holden if you know that he lies all the time. Since the reader knows that he is a habitual liar you may never know the difference from when he is telling the truth or when he is telling another one of his stories. Holden goes in and out of mental lapses throughout the novel that affected his mind and psychological state greatly.


Holden is an unreliable narrator for many reasons. Holden tells the reader that he lies all the time and sometimes does not even notice that he is lying. Holden does not see things beneath the surface. Finally he is not mentally stable and feels very insecure about many things.


Susan K. Mitchell's comments talk about how Holden is confused about the world and the people who are around him. He is an immature man who is still recovering from the effects the war had on him. He has also just failed out of school and so that has sent him into further depression. Holden sometimes contradicts his statements that he said earlier on and he doesn't realize it. "Holden is a man who does not practice what he teaches."(Mitchell 1) "You cannot believe what Holden says about his family after he has told you that he lies."(2) "Holden tells falsifications so often that he doesn't even realize whether he is lying or telling the truth."(2) Holden tells Sally he loves her, "It was a lie of course, but the thing is, I meant it when I said it."(2) "Since the book is told through the eyes of the narrator our observations are biased.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Free Essays - The Phony Holden of Catcher in the Rye." 16 Sep 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Catcher In the Rye: Genuine or Phony?

- J.D. Salinger published Catcher in The Rye in 1951. The main protagonist in the novel, Holden Caulfield experiences many conflicts and predicaments. It is common for Holden to hold opinions on characters throughout the book. His opinionated nature shows that human interactions mean a lot to him. Holden generally likes genuine people opposed to phony people. The comparison of genuine and phony is shown throughout the novel, especially when Holden meets new people. His true personality is shown to the reader when we see whom he respects and despises....   [tags: J.D. Salinger]

Research Papers
866 words (2.5 pages)

Holden Caulfield in The Catcher in the Rye, by J.D. Salinger Essay

- The novel “The Catcher in the Rye,” revolves around the protagonist Holden Caulfield as the story is told from his perspective. J.D. Salinger constructed Holden Caulfield as a cynical person who cannot accept to grow up. Throughout “The Catcher in the Rye,” J.D. Salinger uses symbolism to reveal and reinforce critical aspects of the protagonist Holden Caulfield. Three important aspects Holden acquired through Salinger’s use of symbolism are: his stubborn, uncompromising mentality; his softer, more caring respectful side; Holden’s cowardly way of acting and thinking....   [tags: The Catcher in the Rye]

Research Papers
1156 words (3.3 pages)

Essay about Holden Caulfield as Protagonist in The Catcher in the Rye

- Holden Caulfield is the protagonist in the novel "The Catcher in the Rye" by J.D. Salinger. Holden has a bleak outlook on life, but respects the basic human qualities. He views the world as having been taken over by materialistic objects such as money and that people do not realize the importance of basic human qualities such as love and kindness. He believes that these basic human qualities can take people further than any material object can. Holden is very cynical of everything around him. He sees the worst in everything and everyone....   [tags: The Catcher in the Rye, J.D. Salinger, protagonist]

Research Papers
677 words (1.9 pages)

Holden Caulfield : The Catcher Of Mystery Filled With Speculation And Rumors

- In The Catcher in the Rye by Jerome David Salinger, Holden Caulfield is a troubled teenager who is swinging dangerously between becoming an adult and protecting the innocence of his childhood. Holden’s repressed feelings, extreme depression and cynicism emerge from Salinger’s own reclusive life. There are several similarities between J. D. Salinger and his protagonist Holden. Salinger lead a life of mystery filled with speculation and rumors. Holden is Salinger’s way of expressing his hidden feelings and dealing with his inner demons without publicly announcing them to the world....   [tags: The Catcher in the Rye, J. D. Salinger]

Research Papers
1199 words (3.4 pages)

Free Essays - The Metamorphosis of Holden in Sallinger's Catcher in the Rye

- The Metamorphosis of Holden in Sallinger's Catcher in the Rye In J.D. Sallinger's Catcher in the Rye, is based on the sullen life of Holden Caulfield, a 16-year-old teen-ager is trying to find his sense of direction. Holden, a growing adult, cannot accept the responsibilities of an adult. Eventually realizing that there is no way to avoid the adult life, he can only but accept this alternative lifestyle. What Holden describes the adult world as a sinful, corrupted life, he avoids it for three important reasons: His hatred towards phonies and liars, unable to accept adult responsibilities, and thirdly to enshrine his childhood youth....   [tags: Catcher Rye Essays]

Free Essays
823 words (2.4 pages)

Catcher in the Rye Essay: Holden - The Misfit Hero

- The Misfit Hero of The Catcher In The Rye       The Catcher In The Rye by J.D. Salinger was published in 1951. "A recurring theme in J.D. Salinger's stories concerns people who don't fit in with the traditional American Culture. Salinger's 'misfit heroes', unlike the rest of society, are caught in the struggle between a superficial world and a conscious morality" (1 Wildermuth). In his attempt to create a new and realistic portrayal of the times, Salinger first, effectively creates Holden Caulfield, the main character....   [tags: Catcher Rye Essays]

Research Papers
2104 words (6 pages)

Free Essay on The Catcher in the Rye

- Free Essay on The Catcher in the Rye The catcher in the rye is a work of fiction and a tragic-comedy. I came to choose it because I heard it is about a boy who is around my age. In this book, the main character, Holden Caulfield, tells us a story about what happened during his Christmas vacation. Holden is a sixteen-year-old boy who has flunked out of a private prep school. Because he is afraid that his parents would find out this fact, he goes to a hotel in New York City instead of going home after he leaves school for Christmas vacation....   [tags: Catcher Rye Essays]

Free Essays
895 words (2.6 pages)

Free Catcher in the Rye Essays - Holden Runs, be He Cannot Hide

- Catcher in the Rye - Holden Runs, be He Cannot Hide While reading Catcher in the Rye, one can easily see that Holden has a certain romantic view about his world. Holden thinks in a particular romantic way about almost everyone and everything. This unusual view upon the world actually hinders Holden rather then helps him throughout the story. By his own actions Holden is harming himself, not necessarily physically. Holden has an idealized view of the world, is introspective, and he celebrates the freedom of his spirit....   [tags: Catcher Rye Essays]

Free Essays
1005 words (2.9 pages)

Free Catcher in the Rye Essays: Keeping It Real

- Keeping It Real in The Catcher in the Rye The Catcher in the Rye is a story about a kid named Holden Caulfield who experiences some interesting things and people. From having breakfast with a couple of nuns, to being with a prostitute, to getting kicked out of school, Holden handles each situation the best way he can. Some of the people Holden meets, he likes, but the type of people Holden cannot stand are the ‘phonies.’ Holden had met a lot of phonies in his lifetime. Holden lived in a dorm that was named after a phony, he heard a phony playing a piano, and he met his date’s phony friend....   [tags: Catcher Rye Essays]

Free Essays
655 words (1.9 pages)

Existentialism in Catcher in the Rye Essays

- Existentialism in Catcher in the Rye The Catcher in the Rye creates an existentialist out of Holden Caulfield by giving him a strong personal opinion, a different sense of view, and isolation. Holden's individuality and his different way of thinking creates within him an Existentialist that refuses to accept weakness but holds sympathy for the weak and vulnerable. The basis for these beliefs lies within the most commonly identifiable theme of existentialism, which states that the philosophy stresses the concrete individual existence along with the individual freedom and choice....   [tags: Catcher Rye Essays]

Research Papers
615 words (1.8 pages)

Related Searches

"(2) Holden is an unreliable narrator for many reasons but two key ones are, "he is a self- proclaimed liar but also because he perceives reality in a simplistic way."(2) "Holden's readerly perception creates blinkers for the reader, Holden then makes statements that seem to make sense, but which upon closer inspection, do not bear up to a writerly view."(3) "Holden knows that he is a liar, but he refuses to acknowledge that this means he is a phony too."(5) Holden has been so drained out after all that he has gone through.


In the beginning of the story Holden is in a sanitarium in California recovering from a mental breakdown. Peter J. Seng's comments just go into more detail about how Holden got himself into a sanitarium and how he is doing now back in the real world. "Holden keeps thinking that he is a young man who thinks he will never die."(Seng 1) "Holden is a man to pass severe judgments on others he is not so quick to see the faults in himself."(1) Holden once again is too focused on something rather than himself. He does not see his life slipping away slowly like we do. "Holden's failure might be that he was never able to connect with himself."(1) "Holden hates lies, phoniness, pretense, yet these are often his own sins."(1) Holden says, "He hates people who do not measure up to his standards of taste and urban sophistication."(Seng 2) Holden contradicts everything that he has just talked about.


Salinger goes onto say that Holden is really down about things and needs someone to save him but no one is there to save him and so Holden falls through the cracks. Holden, "The funny part is I felt like marrying her the minute I saw her I'm crazy."(Salinger pg124) Holden, "I'm the most terrific liar you ever saw in your life."(Pg16) Holden, "I swear to God I'm crazy I admit it."(Pg124) These are takes of the two critics and the one author. This is how they interpreted the story through the eyes of Holden.


Peter Shaw's comments help to understand Holden himself going through the tough times and how it affected his mental state. "Holden's self punishments have something to do with the guilt over Ali's death."(Shaw 2) The reason Holden is going through so many ups and downs is because of a very strange and rare disease. "Holden is suffering from the prime danger of this age an exclusively prolonged moratorium on growing up."(3) Holden is a very smart character but he is extra attentive when children are present more so than when an adult is around. "Holden is insightful it seems where children are concerned, but less so with adults especially parents except when their children are present."(7 "Holden feels sympathy for the outcasts in life and literature but not for anyone who does not display psychological disturbance."(8) "Holden has been known to deliver negative judgments on the world."(Shaw 8)


My examples of Holden proving that he is a liar are in the quotes that I'm presenting. He keeps repeatedly saying that he lies all the time and so that should be enough in itself to prove it. Holden's mind is not always where it should be. Sometimes he wanders off onto things that are so far off topic. Holden is an unreliable narrator you never know when to believe him or not. All of these help to prove that he is a liar and if not a liar one who is going to tell lies more often than who is not going to.


In this novel there are countless examples to show that Holden is grief stricken. Mitchell says of Holden, "Holden wants to protest all children."(Mitchell 5) Holden wants to look out for all the children because he does not want to see any of them get injured or hurt. He cares more about the average child than a regular person would. "By thinking this he believes that he can save everyone but the one person that he cannot save is himself."(5) "When Holden does become aware of his own writerliness be goes over the brink into insanity."(Mitchell 5)


Seng's comments are slightly altered from that of Mitchell's. "Holden is disturbed because he now sees that the world belongs to adults."(Seng 3) Holden does not like this idea because he thinks that all adults are phonies. Holden says, "he wants a world with little boys and girls who need help with tying their shoes."(2) "Holden's mental breakdown is a direct result of his inability to come to terms with adult reality."(2) This next quote sums it all up for Holden. "Holden is not a mere victim or modern society, but is in some sense a tragic figure."(Seng 5)


Salinger has some great quotes that come directly from the book. Holden says, "All I wanted to do first was say good bye to old Phoebe so all of a sudden I ran like a madman across the street I damn near got killed doing it."(Salinger) This quote shows a lot about how close Holden was to Phoebe and how he had to be taken from this world so quickly. "This is what old Phoebe had on it Phoebe Weatherfield Caulfield. That killed me. Middle name is Josephine for God's sake not Weatherfield."(Pg 160) "I thought what I'd do was I'd pretend I was one of those deaf mutes. That way it would not have to have any God damn stupid useless conversations with anybody."(Salinger PG 198) All of these quotes show how upset Holden was about life and everything going on around him. So many things have made him think that life is crap and pointless and not worth living. But if Holden had just gotten help sooner rather than later then maybe he would have been completely different.


Is Holden going to be the person who is always telling lies to society, acting corrupt, and being a phony? Or is Holden going to change to a new someone a Holden that maybe we have not seen before. Well you will never know because this book does not go on, but you can be left to ponder that question. Will Holden change or be the same old person who was corrupt and always telling lies?


Return to