Comparing The Great Santini and Death of a Salesman

Comparing The Great Santini and Death of a Salesman

Length: 1249 words (3.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓

Comparing The Great Santini and Death of a Salesman




Elementary school taught everyone that to compare and contrast two things, the best way to go about doing that is with a Venn diagram. Truthfully, this is an effective method, but it is quite rudimentary under the circumstances. "The Great Santini" by Pat Conroy and "Death of a Salesman" by Arthur Miller are two books that can become victims of the dreaded Venn diagram. The two stories are accounts of the lives of two families, each living out its version of the American Dream. The focus of both stories is on the father and how he interacts with everyone and everything around him. Bull Meechum of "The Great Santini" is a marine, raising his children as "hogs" and expecting only the best, if not better, from his brood. Willy Loman of "Death of a Salesman" also expects great things from his children, to the point that he refuses to believe that either of his sons is a failure, even when it is clear that they are. Although the two men themselves have many similarities, there are also other similarities between the two stories. One similarity is the role of the first son in the two anecdotes. Also, there is the role of the second child. Finally, both stories involve characters that are realizing what it means to be a man and what responsibilities come with the title.


Bull Meechum is the father of four kids: two boys and two girls. His oldest son is Ben, a senior in high school who is well on his way to a career in basketball. As the son of a marine, Ben has been raised to take orders, no matter what the possible consequences may be. At the beginning of the story, Ben is talking to his father about his future. When Ben vehemently expresses his interest in pursuing basketball, Bull protests and reminds his son that he will serve in the marines for his four years, and then he can do whatever he wants. Unfortunately, Ben's basketball calling is cut short because of his father's hot headed insistence that Ben must take out a player on the other team, resulting in a broken arm and Ben's expulsion from the team.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Comparing The Great Santini and Death of a Salesman." 23 Feb 2020

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Comparing the Plays, A Raisin in the Sun and Death of a Salesman

- In history there have been an uncountable amount of plays made, but there have only been two that fully captured the American dream like A Raisin in the sun and Death of a Salesman. In both plays the protagonist is trying to achieve the American dream, but it is near impossible when neither of them has the respect of their superiors or the people around them. It is amazing that two different plays can so closely parallel each other when they have a time gap of over 10 years. Both Miller and Lorraine created a theme of achieving goals, Willy Loman just wanted to earn the respect of the people around him while Walter Younger wanted to get rich quick and support his family....   [tags: A Raisin in the Sun, Death of a Salesman]

Research Papers
911 words (2.6 pages)

Death of a Salesman Essay

- It is known that in literature, a tragedy is one of the most popular genres. It always combines some story which discusses human sufferings with a certain sense of audience fulfillment. The roots of the tragedy are related to ancient Greece. A Greek tragedy is a sad story, which represents a character with a tragic flaw leading to his downfall. In addition, in traditional tragedy, the main character falls from high authority and often it is predetermined by fate, while the audience experiences catharsis (Bloom 2)....   [tags: Death of a Salesman]

Free Essays
1644 words (4.7 pages)

Death Of A Salesman By Arthur Miller Essay

- Family relationships, because of their closeness and emotional involvement can significantly influence one’s life, either positively or negatively. This is the case in Death of a Salesman by Arthur Miller, where Willy’s, family has a massively negative impact on his life. Their abandonment of him, their enabling of his mistaken ideas and his conflict with Biff contribute to his failure as a father, salesman and human being. During his life, Willy is abandoned by many family members. The first of these is his father who leaves for Alaska when Willy is a baby....   [tags: Family, Death of a Salesman, Failure]

Research Papers
1060 words (3 pages)

The Death Of A Salesman Essay

- In the Death of a Salesman which main character seems most likely to be the classic enabler that tends to lead the family in its dysfunctional family dynamics. It has to be Linda Loman the wife of Willy Loman the highly respected “New England’s salesman” and mother to two sons Biffy, And Happy Loman. In the book there is an enabler for the family’s problems that seems to cause the conflicts between the family members that enabler is Linda Loman. Linda Loman is the enabler of the family because she just simply overlooks everything that her family does to avoid living in their reality....   [tags: Death of a Salesman, Family, High school]

Research Papers
1739 words (5 pages)

Essay on Father and Son in Death of a Salesman, and Fences

- The role of a father could be a difficult task when raising a son. The ideal relationship between father and son perhaps may be; the father sets the rules and the son obeys them respectfully. However it is quite difficult to balance a healthy relationship between father and son, because of what a father expects from his son. For instance in the narratives, “Death of a Salesman,” and “Fences” both Willy and Troy are fathers who have a difficult time in earning respect from their sons, and being a role model for them....   [tags: Death of a Salesman, Fences]

Research Papers
962 words (2.7 pages)

The Death Of A Salesman Essay

- The Death of a Salesman Have you ever worked long and hard on a project, only to realize that it was effort wasted and the project was totally meaningless in the end. That is just what occurred in the play The Death of a Salesman by Arthur Miller. Willy Loman, the protagonist, spent decades in mind numbing work, only to discover that he had “built his life on shifting sand” (Nicholas). Through the course of his journey, Willy kept on the straight and narrow highway, which he thought would bring success and happiness....   [tags: Death of a Salesman, Arthur Miller, Lee J. Cobb]

Research Papers
1138 words (3.3 pages)

Essay On Biff And Happy In Death Of A Salesman

- The Time of Realizing Things Introduction In Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman, Biff is the eldest son of Willy Loman who always tries to impress his father. But unlike him, Biff is able to see his own flaws and is self-aware of his values, especially the value of truth. I can relate to this because I always try to please my parents, specifically my father, by doing everything they ask me to. Even though I do as they say, I know my self-worth and my limits. As seen in the book and my life, as one grows, the realization of a life’s purpose becomes ever clearer....   [tags: Death of a Salesman]

Research Papers
1017 words (2.9 pages)

Essay about The American Dream in Death of a Salesman

- "The American Dream" is based on the 'Declaration of Independence´: 'We believe that all men are born with these inalienable rights - life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.´ (Thomas Jefferson, 1776). This 'dream´ consists of a genuine and determined belief that in America, all things are possible to all men, regardless of birth or wealth; you work hard enough you will achieve anything. However, Miller says people have been 'ultimately misguided´. The origins of the American Dream seem to have been rooted in the pioneering mentality of the 18th and 19th century immigrants, most of whom came to America because of a promise of a new and better life....   [tags: Death of a Salesman]

Research Papers
1563 words (4.5 pages)

The American Dream Conspiracy in Death of a Salesman Essays

- Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman tells the story of the failure of a salesman, Willy Loman. Although not all Americans are salesmen, most of us share Willy’s dream of success. We are all partners in the American Dream and parties to the conspiracy of silence surrounding the fact that failures must outnumber successes.(Samantaray, 2014) Miller amalgamates the archetypal tragic hero with the mundane American citizen. The result is the anti-hero, Willy Loman. He is a simple salesman who constantly aspires to become 'great'....   [tags: Death of a Salesman]

Research Papers
1739 words (5 pages)

Essay about Death of a Salesman - A Modern Day Tragedy

- Death of a Salesman - A Modern Day Tragedy The question which arises within Death of a Salesman is, 'Is this a modern Tragedy?' A tragic play can be commonly observed when a protagonist falls from a great height. His decline is not about immediate death, although in most cases death becomes apparent at the end of the play, e.g. Macbeth. A tragedy shows the suffering of a character and utter compulsion of him if he does not succeed to reach his dream. These plays show the blissful release from intolerable suffering this character feels....   [tags: Death of a Salesman]

Research Papers
1182 words (3.4 pages)

Related Searches

Like Ben, Biff Loman, the son of Willy Loman and the older of two boys, is a rising sports star. Biff is a football player for his school but his commitment to the sport results in a failing math grade. When Biff finds out his grade, he is willing to go to summer school immediately, but his father persuades him otherwise, telling him that he will be fine without summer school, though Willy does not remember that this is how the account takes place. It is not until later when Willy visits Bernard that he realizes that it is his own fault that his son never succeeded in making something out of his life. Although both sons have issues with standing up to his over powering father, they do finally fight back. Through Ben's experience with Toomer's death and Biff's comprehension that his father's idea of what the future holds is horribly skewed, the two boys realize that it is better to fight back and disobey the orders that they have always followed. Still, no matter what Ben and Biff do, whether it is good or bad, they still receive the majority of the attention of their fathers.


Mary Anne Meechum and Happy Loman are the second children of their individual families. Both Mary Anne and Happy play the role of the "less important" child, receiving less respect and attention from their entire family. For Mary Anne, the lack of attention that she is given is even harder for her to accept because she is a drama queen, craving the spot-light at all times. At one point, in attempts to catch her father's interest, Mary Anne tells Bull that she is pregnant and that the father of the baby is everything that her father could ever hate about someone: a black pacifist. Even when she tells him all of this, he continues to ignore her, getting mad that she is interrupting him while he reads the paper. The same kind of thing happens to Happy. In an endeavor to get his parents' attention, he announces that he is getting married, to which they nonchalantly respond with little more than a "go to bed." All that these two victims of second-child syndrome want is a little respect and an occasional word of approval.


In the process of becoming an adult, respect, among other things, is something that is taken for granted as a privilege that comes with age. Willy does have his family's respect, but he has a horrible fear of losing that admiration. For that reason, when he does not have enough money to pay the bills, Willy borrows money from Charley so his family will not notice the difference. In Bull's case, he has his children's respect because he is not actually their father, but essentially their drill sergeant, and they are not really his children, but in fact his "hogs." Willy and Bull seem to feel that as the heads of their respective homes, it is their job to be the "manly man." In some cases, the man of the house is known to have some sort of immoral streak. In Bull's case his appalling facet is that when he gets very angry, he takes it out on Lillian, his devoted and loving wife. For Willy, his vice is the affair that he is having. Learning what it means to be a man is not only important for Willy and Bull, but also for Biff and Ben. The two boys go through the process of becoming men in much different ways. To start with, Biff has to finally accept responsibility at a much older age than most boys would. He is already thirty-four when he realizes that if he ever wants to turn his life around he is going to have to do it one step at a time. Ben on the other hand is only a senior in high school when he takes charge of not only his life, but also the lives of the rest of his family. One of Ben's lessons in becoming a man is the experience that he has with Toomer's death. He also finds out that defending his mother when his father is hitting her is also one of his new responsibilities as a man. It is finally evident that Ben has accepted the role as the man of the house after his father's death. When the family is moving back to Atlanta and Ben follows the old custom of his father of getting his family up at three in the morning to avoid traffic, its clear that he has truly become a man.


Becoming a man; the first child; the second child; all of these are topics that "The Great Santini" by Pat Conroy and "Death of a Salesman" by Arthur Miller have in common. Through the relationships between father and child, the two books can be compared and contrasted. Not only can the stories be compared by their relationships concerning the father and child, but also just the fathers themselves can be compared and contrasted in so many ways that one could probably write a thorough essay just comparing Bull Meechum and Willy Loman.


Return to