Comparing Love in To Dance with the White dog and Moulin Rouge

Comparing Love in To Dance with the White dog and Moulin Rouge

Length: 1027 words (2.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Comparing Love in To Dance with the White dog and Moulin Rouge


    In the novel, To Dance with the White dog, Terry Kay crafts a love story about Sam Peek and his wife Cora, that seems to extend beyond the grave in the form of a white dog.  At the same time, the film Moulin Rouge is a fast paced, tensely dramatic, love triangle between Christian, the poor writer, Satine, the courtesan that everyone fancies, and the Duke, who has the money to transform the Moulin Rouge into a theatre with real merit. Both movies center on the main theme of love but take two different stands on that love. While Satine is unable to concentrate solely on a single relationship, Sam Peek is able to focus solely on the love of his life, Cora.

 

      In To Dance with the White Dog, there are several instances that show Sam's devotion and unchanging love for Cora.  When Sam writes in his journal, at the beginning of the novel, "Today my wife died.  We were married 57 good years" (Kay 9).  Sam was completely devoted to his wife for over half a century and even after her death with his devotion to White Dog, who he perceived to be his deceased wife watching over him.  Even though Satine was unable to pursue her love for Christian due to her death, her ambiguity towards her two suitors makes the viewer wonder if she could be as devoted to one love as Sam is devoted to his wife.

 

      A prime example of Sam's enduring fidelity is when he goes to his wife's grave, "[...] He took the hoe and cut away at the weeds, balancing on his walker, until the plot was clean" (Kay 42).  No matter what his circumstance, Sam is going to do what he can for his wife, even if it is simply taking care of his wife's grave.  Christian does something similar to this by writing Satine's and his story, so that the world would know about their love.   The love is there, but the audience is unable to see if Satine and Christian's love would last as long as Sam and Cora's due to Satine's untimely death at the end of the film.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Comparing Love in To Dance with the White dog and Moulin Rouge." 123HelpMe.com. 18 Aug 2019
    <https://www.123helpme.com/view.asp?id=14099>.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Power of Love in Moulin Rouge and To Dance With the White Dog Essays

- The Power of Love in Moulin Rouge and To Dance With the White Dog       The power of love is exposed in the films Moulin Rouge and To Dance With the White Dog. In each movie, each individual must overcome obstacles within themselves in order to overcome the obstacles in their relationships. Although the love shared by each couple is different, both cases of love are real and run deeply. Satine and Sam Peek each handle their romantic relationships differently according to their situations....   [tags: Moulin Rouge Essays]

Research Papers
1229 words (3.5 pages)

Comparing Dignity in A Lesson Before Dying, Jane Pittman, and Of Love and Dust

- Dignity in Southern Society in A Lesson Before Dying, Autobiography of Jane Pittman, and Of Love and Dust       The ante-bellum Southern social system put blacks in a low economic and social class and limited their pursuit of happiness.  The aristocracy firmly held blacks in emotional and spiritual slavery. Cajuns, Creoles and poor whites maintained a low status in society, which frustrated them because they felt they should be superior to blacks and equal to whites. Racism was a base of southern society and a hope to improve life and gain respect....   [tags: compare and contrast essay examples]

Research Papers
2663 words (7.6 pages)

Essay on The Regime Of The Khmer Rouge Movement

- When looking at history, dictators and dictatorship have played a large role in controlling the desires of those they dominate, in such areas as religion and freedom of speech. An obvious example would be Adolph Hitler, who committed mass genocide on over 11 million “undesirables” such as Jews, the handicapped, and the gay, regardless of age or gender. Further, there were 50-70 million other lives taken in World War II, which Hitler started. Another brutal dictator was Saloth Sar, or as he was known, Pol Pot....   [tags: Khmer Rouge, Pol Pot, Khieu Samphan, Death]

Research Papers
868 words (2.5 pages)

Essay on The Khmer Rouge And Cambodia

- Once American troops left Cambodia, the time known as the Khmer Rouge era started for Cambodia. This era contained four years of Pol Pot having control over the terrifying army. As he has control over this army, he leads them into Phnom Penh and starts the mass killing known as The Killing Fields. This area of land which was once a torturing ground and killing fields, is now the biggest tourist attraction in Cambodia. The goal of the Khmer Rouge was not to eliminate the Cambodian race but instead was to teach them to become loyal communists....   [tags: Khmer Rouge, Pol Pot, Phnom Penh, Cambodia]

Research Papers
893 words (2.6 pages)

Love in The Lady with the Dog and Hills like White Elephants Essay

- Anton Chekhov and Ernest Hemingway both convey their ideas of love in their respective stories The Lady with the Pet Dog and Hills like White Elephants in different ways. However, their ideas are quite varying, and may be interpreted differently by each individual reader. In their own, unique way, both Chekhov and Hemingway evince what is; and what is not love. Upon proper contemplation, one may observe that Hemingway, although not stating explicitly what love is; the genius found in his story is that he gives a very robust example of what may be mistaken as love, although not being true love....   [tags: Compare Contrast, Comparing]

Research Papers
898 words (2.6 pages)

Analysis of a Scene in The Moulin Rouge Essay

- Cinematography is the art or technique of motion-picture photography. The Moulin Rouge is a visually striking film, which incorporates brilliant elements of cinematography. One scene in particular that captures the brilliance of the cinematographer is the scene within which the “Unconscious Argentinean” takes it upon himself to explain the situation with an incredible, tango, adaptation of The Police’s song “Roxanne.” The lighting and other elements of this are gorgeous, as they eloquently convey the dark emotions of the situation: “Jealousy, anger, betrayal.” The different elements of cinematography, specifically, color, lighting, and the use of camera angles, bring to life the emotions, a...   [tags: Cinematography, Moulin Rouge]

Research Papers
767 words (2.2 pages)

Essay about The Khmer Rouge And The Vietnam War

- In 1975, amidst the chaos that resided in the region following the American abandonment of Vietnam, the Khmer Rouge, led by Pol Pot, staged a revolutionary communist uprising in Cambodia. They retained power for four years until 1979 when relations with Vietnam collapsed; Cambodia was invaded and Phnom Penh, the capitol, was captured. The Khmer used many varying methods to conserve their power in Cambodia and repress opposition, mainly from urban Cambodians who preferred a capitalist rule. This essay sets out to explore the extent of the impact the Khmer’s use of terror had on the conservation of their rule in comparison with other methods such as social and educational destruction and recon...   [tags: Khmer Rouge, Cambodia, Phnom Penh, Pol Pot]

Research Papers
3397 words (9.7 pages)

Comparing Two Love Poems, Our Love Now and To His Coy Mistress Essay

- Comparing Two Love Poems, 'Our Love Now' and 'To His Coy Mistress' Poetry has been around now for many decades, it is a form of writing that can be expressed in many different forms of style, context and language. The majority of poetry is love or war poetry, this is because love and war have many different view points form every individual person therefore no love or war poem can be the same due to this emotion involved. I.e., in a love poem you are writing your own personal feelings about or for a loved one, no other person can have these exact feelings, it is a way of opening out your heart....   [tags: Compare and Contrast Comparing]

Research Papers
1001 words (2.9 pages)

Unconditional Love in E.B. White's Charlotte's Web Essay

- Unconditional Love in E.B. White's Charlotte's Web In fantasy like Charlotte's Web, the animals are true to their natures, yet similar to people. They think and worry and love and hurt and laugh and needle one another as people do. In Charlotte's Web, human truths of friendship and love are revealed. I strongly agree with the statement that Charlotte is truly the ideal role model of unconditional love and will support my stand by highlighting Charlotte's selfless acts, contrasting her with Templeton, showing why he is the complete opposite of her, comparing her with other models of love such as Fern, Mrs....   [tags: English Literature White Charlotte's Web Essays]

Research Papers
2251 words (6.4 pages)

Love in D.H. Lawrence's The White Stocking Essay examples

- Lust Plus Rage = Love "I love you," is used on a daily basis. Though nobody agrees what that means, all agree the feeling is powerful. In fact, nothing can control a person like love can, and worse, nobody has control over what love is going to do to them next. Love causes lust, love causes happiness, and love causes anger. In D.H. Lawrence's short story "The White Stocking" the main character Ted Whiston loves his wife Elsie. As the story progresses the reader finds out this love has psychological control over Whiston's actions....   [tags: Lawrence D H Love]

Free Essays
1636 words (4.7 pages)

Related Searches



 

      One of the most obvious moments of Satine's inability to focus on a single love comes just after she meets Christian and he sings her his song, written and originally sung by Elton John. When the Duke comes to see her, while trying to allow Christian to escape, she sings to the Duke Christian's song. This does not seem to be the same declaration of love but in a sense, Satine is still courting the Duke, the same way Christian is courting her.  In turn, Satine may have deeper feelings for Christian but that is unable to stop her desire to become a real actress and never have to work at the Moulin Rouge again. The audience within the movie may have problems understanding this considering the fact that Satine is a courtesan and thus her love is for the highest bidder, as well as the fact that the Duke can make her dreams come true and thus could influence her to sacrifice her love for her dreams.

 

      Also, in the scene where Satine gives into the Duke's wooing and goes on a picnic with him, Christian accompanies them under the guise of much work to do on the play.  The scene shows the Duke oblivious to Satine and Christian's loving looks towards one another. Soon thereafter, the Duke turns to Satine and she pulls away from Christian and becomes enthralled with the Duke.  Satine is unable to separate her ambition and her possible career as an actress from her love.  The majority of the movie depicts Satine juggling the two men who each hold a possible future.  Where Sam only juggles the thoughts of his wife and how much he loves and misses her now that she is gone.

 

       Satine has deeper motives for her behavior than love.  Satine is essentially a prostitute and in her line of work, love is not allowed. Therefore she is able to be an astounding actress and fool Christian into believing she does not love him when his life is in danger.  It was the ulterior motive of becoming and actress and knowing that she would die soon, not her love, that prompts Satine to play the part so well. Satine still goes to the Duke and persuades him to continue funding the play and to keep the lovers ending.  Even thought Satine pushes Christian away, she is still able to do her job and entice the Duke. The act she puts on, is her, fueled by her fear for Christian's life and because she is torn, she is fueled to go to the Duke to save the Moulin Rouge.  She is ultimately unable to focus on or pursue a single love in her life.

 

            Essentially Satine is pulled between two loves, her ambition and her love for Christian.  Sam Peek is able to focus solely on his wife and the love filled life they shared for fifty-seven years and after her death, the love he has for White Dog who is supposedly Cora on Earth again to watch over Sam.  While Satine may love Christian, she is unable to devote herself solely to him, because not only is she promised to the Duke already, but also the fate of the Moulin Rouge and her life hangs in the balance.  While Sam's life doesn't hang in the balance due to his love, his life is slightly diminished after Cora's death and being under his children's constant watchful eyes. Sam and Satine are similar in the fact that they are both offered the ultimate love. Although different, their loves are similar and both have the potential of being life lasting.    

 The difference is that Sam Peek embraces his love and Satine puts seemingly more important matters before her love.   

 

Works Cited

Kay, Terry.  To Dance With The White Dog.  New York:  Pocket Books, 1990.

Moulin Rouge. Baz Luhrmann. Perf. Nicole Kidman and Ewan McGregor. Twentieth Century Fox, 2001.

 
Return to 123HelpMe.com