A Materialist Rejection of the View that the Mind is Merely Reactive

A Materialist Rejection of the View that the Mind is Merely Reactive

Length: 455 words (1.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
A Materialist Rejection of the View that the Mind is Merely Reactive

What we believe today is that everything is physical, our minds are
chemicals and electrons whizzing round.

One of the implications of this materialist view of the mind is that
our minds only react to outside stimuli.

This is because of cause and effect. The two basics of cause and
effect are that every effect (or occurrence) has a cause. Nothing just
happens. The second is that cause and effect have a predictable
relationship. Given the same causes, the same effect will follow.
Basically because effect follows cause (like chicken and egg), we can
in theory keep following back and identify the big bang as the cause
of me writing this sentence. Dave discusses cause and effect in the
essay (Can we have free will? - Dave's theory of destiny / choice

However, the theory of destiny / choice duality is still a materialist
theory, and surely the tenant that we make no intentional thoughts,
but merely respond to experience stands?

Two points stand against this position. Firstly, we do not experience
the world directly. By the time the qualia caused by the outside world
reach our consciousness, they have been filtered through our minds,
and in a sense shaped by our experience, prejudices, culture and
language, etc.

This is to say that what we consciously experience is filtered and
altered by our unconscious minds. My identity is contained in my
conscious, higher mind, but information can only reach this part of
the brain from the unconscious, reactive animalistic (i.e. evolved
longer ago), lower parts of the brain. What I perceive is not what
reaches my brain.

As such what we experience is at least partly of our own creation, the
connections and thoughts that our sense impressions generate also form
part of our experience. At least part of the experience that reaches
the conscious mind is only indirectly caused by the external world.
Thus what we are responding to is in effect unknowable as a

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"A Materialist Rejection of the View that the Mind is Merely Reactive." 123HelpMe.com. 30 Mar 2020

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Relation Between Brain And Mind Essay

- The relation between brain and mind is disputed over a long time. The debate is whether mind and brain are separate entities or not and if the mind is a separate entity, then how are mental properties, functions and consciousness in relation with the brain, being things which are non-physical. Consciousness helps to understand the relation between the brain and mind, by contemplating the reason or the source of it, if it’s a manifestation of the mind or just a by-product of brain activity....   [tags: Mind, Philosophy of mind, Brain, Materialism]

Research Papers
1436 words (4.1 pages)

Plato 's View On The Mind Essay

- Plato felt we did not know we are ignorant which most of the world disagrees with. The world thinks what they see is what is real and feel they know what is best whereas Plato felt you are only seeing a one sided view which I agree with. We only see what is put before us so our knowledge is limited and we depend too much on our sense of sight to see what we conceive as real. Plato explained that though what we see is a portion of being real what is behind us may prove our sight to be wrong or distorted....   [tags: Mind, Ontology, Ripple effect, Thought]

Research Papers
720 words (2.1 pages)

Sigmund Freud 's View On Unconscious Mind Essay

- Sigmund Freud’s unconscious theory states how different mental states belong in different conscious minds. Freud explains the importance of the conscious, unconscious and preconscious mind. The conscious mind is in which individuals are aware of their thoughts and surroundings. As for the unconscious mind, it deals with ideas and thoughts that were once conscious but now are not, and lastly, the preconscious mind deals with the ideas that are not yet conscious. Sigmund Freud explains a well-developed theory about the conscious/unconscious mind as they both connect to each other when processing mental states....   [tags: Unconscious mind, Mind, Consciousness]

Research Papers
1290 words (3.7 pages)

The Theory Of Mind Body Dualism Essay examples

- RECALL: The writer makes several important points in “Body and Mind” from “Problems from Philosophy”. The writer discusses the idea of the body being a material entity and the mind as an immaterial entity. The mind and body problems arise due to the different types of facts and their relation with each other. The concept of mind body dualism is an attempt to solve this conflict between these two entities and the main points discussed in the chapter are: 1) According to the ‘Conceivability Argument for Dualism’, presented by Descartes, the mind and the body cannot exist without each other and if they were to do so, they would not be the same thing; 2) Physical facts are proven through observ...   [tags: Philosophy of mind, Mind, Materialism, Metaphysics]

Research Papers
943 words (2.7 pages)

Essay On Materialism And Materialism

- What is real. That is a question that is often debated in the metaphysical world of philosophy. The answer depends on the philosopher you ask. To a materialist, only physical objects exist. Materialists are like scientists because they only believe in what they can observe. On the other hand, a dualist would say that both material and immaterial objects exist, such as the body and soul/mind. Material objects are spatial, public, mechanical, and they take up space. Examples of material objects are chairs, a dog, and your body....   [tags: Mind, Metaphysics, Ontology, Platonism]

Research Papers
1308 words (3.7 pages)

Essay about External World Skepticism Is The View Of Our Mind

- External world skepticism is the view that we can’t know anything about the external world, only the thoughts inside our mind. It calls into question the validity of our senses in order to have knowledge. It doubts that we really know anything is real in the outside world since our sense could be wrong and each individual perceives things differently. It says that our sense and perceptions are uncertain because there is no evidence to support what we see outside of our mind. This differs from the common-sense account that “seeing is believing” and that if we see something it must be true, because we can rely on our senses to give us evidence of the external world....   [tags: Mind, Critical thinking, Perception, Reality]

Research Papers
1198 words (3.4 pages)

Kant 's View On The Mind Essay

- When two great professional like professor Bryan Magee and contemporary philosopher Geoffrey Warnock sit down to discuss and try to understand one those most complexes philosopher turn very hard for us understand the conception of the facts describe in that video. I was very interesting in Immanuel Kant life the way he was a brilliant orator, for more the 30 years university professor, and the first university philosopher. Kant had the capacity in write to in very single mind, even his friend considered him the most difficult writer....   [tags: Immanuel Kant, Philosophy, Morality, Ethics]

Research Papers
702 words (2 pages)

Essay Mind And Cosmos, By Thomas Nagel

- In Thomas Nagel’s book, Mind and Cosmos, Nagel argues that physical sciences cannot provide a full picture of life. A few of his arguments are that consciousness is naturally assigned to the brain, [Nagel 35] materialist arguments denying the mind means that the premise is false, [Nagel 15] and lastly, high cognitive functioning such as thinking can only be performed by beings that have a mind. [Nagel 73] When it comes to the consciousness being assigned to the brain, Nagel states “Subjective appearances, on the other hand- how this physical world appears to human perception- were assigned to the mind, and the secondary qualities like color, sound, and smell were to be analyzed relationall...   [tags: Mind, Perception, Philosophy of mind, Cognition]

Research Papers
1113 words (3.2 pages)

A View of the Woods Essay

- A View of the Woods Flannery O'Connor is a very complex writer in terms of her use of symbolism in addition to the elements of the grotesque and blackly humorous. O'Connor’s story, "A View of the Woods," is symbolically complicated. The story focuses on the relationship of Mary Fortune Pitts, a little girl, and her grandfather, Mr Fortune. The story is one of conflict that mounts to tragedy in the end. The conflict is basically between Mary Fortune and her grandfather over the sale of some ground that Mary Fortune finds important for her father's grazing of his cattle and for the view of the woods....   [tags: View of the Woods Essays]

Free Essays
879 words (2.5 pages)

The Mind-Brain Problem Concerning Dualism and Materialism Essay

- The Mind-Brain Problem Concerning Dualism and Materialism I am faced with the philosophical task of defending either dualism or materialism, depending on which one is most attractive to me. So either I support the theory of dualism, which is the belief that there is both a physical and a spiritual state, or I believe in materialism, which is the belief that everything that exists is material or physical. Although I believe materialism to be easier to prove, I find dualism more attractive to believe....   [tags: Dualism Essays]

Research Papers
833 words (2.4 pages)

significant proportion of it is generated from the mind itself which
no one else can have perfect access to.

Thus, it must logically follow that the mind cannot be said to be
reactive as the theory cannot be proved or disproved if the inputs to
the mind are unknowable.

Secondly, the output of the mind is not predictable based on knowledge
of the inputs (even assuming that knowing the inputs was possible).
The system is very complex and largely self-referential so that it is
not possible to replicate the same set of inputs to the mind, even
with identical external inputs or sense data.

If a system is unpredictable, how can it be said that it reacts to the
external world? It might be true to say that the external world
initiates the system to do something, but even the principle of cause
and effect breaks down in a system of this complexity, so the system
does not just merely react, but is self-organising. This leads to a
whole host of further implications, which may or may not be explained
by chaos theory, complexity theory, emergent systems and the potential
for quantum to have an control.

Using this argument it is possible to take a materialist stance whilst
rejecting the implication of materialist monism that our minds are
purely reactive. However please note that this is not an argument for
intentionality merely a rejection of the determinism implied by being
purely reactive.
Return to 123HelpMe.com