The Values on Sociological Research of Value Free Sociology, Value Laden and Committed Sociology

  • Length: 675 words (1.9 double-spaced pages)
  • Rating: Excellent
Open Document

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Text Preview

More ↓

Continue reading...

Open Document

The Values on Sociological Research of Value Free Sociology, Value Laden and Committed Sociology

Sociologists vary in their opinions on the effect of values on
research. Value free sociology is an opinion in sociology, started by
Emile Durkheim, that states that sociology should be seeking to use
methodology similar to that used in the physical sciences. One of the
key elements in their methodology to make it similar to the physical
sciences is objectivity. These positivists state that their values
have no effect on their research and that this should apply throughout
sociology. They argue that if a study is well planned it is possible
for the researchers personal beliefs to have no effect on the
findings. They argue that the nature of sociological research is no
different to that of any of the physical sciences, they are studying
and measuring a set of totally independent phenomena and constructing
and testing hypothesis as to the cause of this phenomenon. Positivists
also refer to social facts. These are the statistics obtained from
surveys and official publications. According to O’Connell Davidson and
Layder the personal views of the researcher are never relevant in
sociological research, and they point to the accuracy of opinion polls
on a range of subjects to display the accuracy of their surveys.

A second group of sociologists believe that weather objectivity is
desirable or not, it can never be achieved within sociology. They are
known as value laden sociologists. They also claim that sociologists
who argue that the subject is value free are doing it a dis-service.
They point to a number of issues to support their views. Gouldner has
pointed out that value free sociology points to Max Weber as a
sociologist who claimed that personal views never enter sociological
research. However Gouldner suggests that his words must be placed into
a historical context as he was living under an oppressive government
that frowned on intellectual freedom. They also point out that it is
impossible for sociology to be considered value free when we look at
the matter of funding.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"The Values on Sociological Research of Value Free Sociology, Value Laden and Committed Sociology." 25 Jun 2018
Title Length Color Rating  
Sociology and Lives of Illegal Immigrants Essay - Sociology is the systematic study of social behavior and human group (Scheuble, 2013). The book Just Like Us by Helen Thorpe studies the social behavior of illegal immigrants between their own group and those towards the out group. In the book the author observed that most illegal immigrants get fake Mexican identity card because their current circumstance would not meet the eligibility to get a real Mexican identity card. This is what happened to Yadira, she did not meet the requirements to get an ID card, so she had no other choice than to get a fake one (Thorpe,106)....   [tags: Just Like Us by Helen Thorpe]
:: 4 Works Cited
965 words
(2.8 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Essay on Sociology: The Power of a Label - In the film “The Outsiders” and the “The Saints and the Roughnecks” article there are two types of classes; a lower class viewed as deviant and a middle class viewed as perfect. These two classes are defined by different statuses, titles, and symbols. They are also labeled differently by government officials, police, and by their respective social classes. Putting a “deviant” label on a certain social class almost always causes the labeled class to complete their “fulfilled prophecy. The tension between classes further reinforces what happens when we apply labels to groups in society, labels that will cause pain, suffering, and unequal treatment of other classes....   [tags: socioeconomic classes and their vicissitudes]
:: 2 Works Cited
596 words
(1.7 pages)
Good Essays [preview]
Evaluation of Sociological Theories Essay - Evaluation of Sociological Theories Deviance can be described as: "Nonconformity with existing/traditional social norms. This nonconformity is often said to be pathological when it challenges power and privilege; yet it is said to be indicative of innovation or creativity when the gatekeepers of morality approve it. A loaded term, deviancy is a negative asset when the environment is stable but can be a positive asset to a society when the environment is irreversibly changing." Each perspective asks different questions and focuses on different issues regarding crime and deviance....   [tags: Papers Sociology Deviance Essays] 1862 words
(5.3 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
A Sociological View of Rastafarianism Essay - Organized religion is a duality between the religion and the church which represents it. Sometimes the representation of the religion is marred and flawed to those who view it because of the bureaucracy contained within. Unknown to those who gaze upon the dissolved morals and values of what is perceived to be the contradiction known as modern religion, it was never intended to be this way. Most religions started off as a sect, a minor detail on the fringes of the society it never wanted to represent....   [tags: Religion Sociology Rastafarianism essays] 3687 words
(10.5 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Essay about Understanding Social Issues - Sociology can be broken down into many different parts to help understand society. There are four main parts that define the structures of society, which are institutions, social groups, statuses, and roles. If one was to examine the institution of the structure he or she will discover it broken down into five conventional institutions known as family, religion, politics, economics, and education. Most of the worlds social problems stems from brokenness throughout the institutions. Knowing that the make of these institutions are occupied by humanity, and humans are a product of the family the author of this paper believes majority of the all failures within the institutions comes from the fa...   [tags: Sociology ]
:: 2 Works Cited
840 words
(2.4 pages)
Good Essays [preview]
How relevant are the early theories of Mass Society in today’s media environment? - The Media has been thought to have effects on people since its infancy. When the mass media first evolved many people became concerned about what influence it was having on society, and so various theories were used during this early period in attempt to explain just what these effects were. The reason for concern about the media was primarily based on the change in society, so there was the belief that the ‘powerful’ media could take advantage of this situation and manipulates the ‘masses’. This essay will discuss how relevant the early theories of mass society are in today’s media environment, as there have been vast changes in terms of society as well as the media....   [tags: Sociology]
:: 9 Works Cited
2113 words
(6 pages)
Term Papers [preview]
Sociology of Family Essay - "A family is a small social group of people related by ancestry or affection, who share common values and goals, who may live together in the same dwelling, and who may participate in the bearing and raising of children. They have a physical or emotional connection with each other that is ongoing" (Vissing, 2011) and is the foundation of all societies. They can be formed by a grouping of father-mother-children or even more complicated combination of relatives. In the primary stage of family life in the United States, everyone from every generation lived together in one house....   [tags: Sociology, Family Values ]
:: 5 Works Cited
1149 words
(3.3 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay on Sociologial Perspetctive: What´s Sociology? - What is sociology and what does the sociological perspective entail. C. Wright Mills (1959:1-7)): “ Neither the life of an individual nor the history of a society can be understood without understanding both.” He illustrated that you need to understand the history of a certain society to understand what people in that society really are. History forges people, affects their action and who they are going to be. A person can only be defined by analysing his background, social structure, and so call “milieux”....   [tags: culture, bevhavior, environment] 574 words
(1.6 pages)
Good Essays [preview]
Sociology Essay - Sociology is a field which developed over a millennia ago, but it was not until the nineteenth century that it came into the fore as a bona fide social science, in need of its own classification apart from other social sciences. Sociology, 'the study of the process of companionship';(pg.396, Ambercrombie,Hill,Turner), is a discipline, which is not exclusively independent in and of its self, yet borrows from many other disciplines such as: history, geography, and anthropology. 'American sociology is fundamentally analytical and empirical; it proposes to examine the way of life of individuals in the societies &#8230; prefers to explain institutions and structures in terms of the behavior...   [tags: Sociology Essays]
:: 8 Works Cited
1491 words
(4.3 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Sociology Essays - Sociology Miss Rowbotham Education Using material from Item A and elsewhere, assess the contribution of functionalist sociology to an understanding of the role of education in society A) Explain what is meant by ‘streaming’. (2 marks) Streaming is when you organise children into different classes in school depending on their ability. B) Give two examples of ways in which the school curriculum may be seen as ethnocentric. (4 marks) The school curriculum may be seen as ethnocentric as they only teach main culture/religion subjects and they do not give children a broad education....   [tags: Sociology Essays] 641 words
(1.8 pages)
Good Essays [preview]

Sociologists working for various government
departments will not find their work published if the findings do not
reflect well on the department they are working for. This means they
benefit from some outcomes of their research and loose out if it is a
different outcome, so they have a vested financial interest in the
outcome of their study. Philo and Miller have also argued that
scientists allow their work to be manipulated and misinterpreted by
public relations companies that are working on behalf of the funders.
Value laden sociologists argue that sociologists have person career
ambitions and goals and these will affect their work whether they
realise it or not. Postmodernist’s sociologists such as Lyotard argue
that the process of sociological and scientific thinking is based upon
a series of values about the nature of society. They disagree with the
idea that rational thinking based upon testable empirical evidence is
the best way to understand the world, they argue that there are many
approaches and that scientific thinking is just one.

There is a final approach to this argument, the one of the committed
sociologist, they argue that research should not be value free, but
should have specific value witch guide its approach to study. The two
main supporters of this approach are Marxists and feminist
sociologists. Two sociologists started a debate that is values were to
affect research whose side should they be on when conducting their
studies. Becker argued that sociology had traditionally been on the
side of the powerful, looking from the viewpoint of the professional,
the doctor or policeman. He argued that sociology should be on the
side of the underdog. Gouldner disagreed with Becker, and stated the
according to his argument sociology had already been studying those
with little power. After all what real powers do policeman have? He
claimed sociology should attempt to study the real powerful people,
those who create the rules of society. Marxists argue that the purpose
of sociology is to expose the ways in which to ruling class exploit
the working masses. They hope to breakdown the ways in which
capitalism operates only operates to benefit a few. Marxist
criminology writers Walton, Taylor and young argued that radical
criminological strategy is too expose the law as the biggest
instrument of the ruling class.

Feminist writers are also big supporters of the committed sociology
stance in this argument. Writers such as spender would agree with the
Marxists on the principal of exposing the workings of an oppressive
society, but they suggest they key is to explore how males dominate
and oppress in society. The aim is to expose the truth about men, thus
freeing women from the oppression of patriarchy. Feminist writers
obviously place enormous importance on values influencing work, as
their values mean they must fight against the oppression of patriarchy
and they try to expose its effect and encourage enlightenment through
their research.

Return to