The Thinking of the Scottish Enlightenment Thinkers

The Thinking of the Scottish Enlightenment Thinkers

Length: 533 words (1.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
The Thinking of the Scottish Enlightenment Thinkers
The theme of the "unintended and unanticipated consequences of social action" implies that social change occurs through social action without foreseeing the outcome. Scottish Enlightenment thinkers Adam Smith and Adam Ferguson, each provide their own theory of unanticipated effects of human action. Smith's theory is implicitly historicist; Ferguson's by contrast, is empirical and anti-historicist(Smith, 1998:30).
In Adam Smith's, "Wealth of Nations", private and egoistic interests are converted into collective social good by an 'invisible hand' which advances 'the interest of society' without intending or knowing it(Smith, 1998:30-31). Smith illustrates this through his discussion of the development of the commercial society. "Smith described initially the structural forces which led to the decline of the feudal society and property and the necessary evolution of trade and manufacture"(Smith, 1998:30). This social change, in Smith's view, was "unintended and unanticipated consequence of social action". The key to understanding this transition, Smith argued, was the actions of two contending social groups, the rich barons whose concern was with social status and ornament led to their gradual impoverishment and more secular, and efficient merchant class whose manufactured goods brought the ruin of the great landowners(Smith, 1998:30). Thus, the social action of the merchant class brought upon the social change that was unexpected in feudal society. Therefore, this social change that Smith explains, illustrates his perspective of how social change was brought upon unintentionally by individuals serving their self-interest.
Adam Ferguson viewed society functioning as a whole. Ferguson, in contrast to Adam Smith, developed no link between the social actions of individuals, as members of social groups, and the wider, collective historical process(Smith, 1998:30). "Man is a member of a community, 'part of a whole', his actions social because they are collective(Smith, 1998:30). Thus for Ferguson, social change through social action is not seen as the product of the actions of individuals alone. Instead, it is the efforts and social of the society as whole that is responsible for social change. There is nothing of Smith's individualism in Ferguson's concept of the unanticipated effects of social action, or the facile optimism that separated historical meaning from the human subjects which themselves constituted history(Smith, 1998:30-31).

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"The Thinking of the Scottish Enlightenment Thinkers." 24 Jan 2020

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay Overview of The Enlightenment

- The Enlightenment was a period of history throughout the mid-decades of the seventeenth century and during the course of the eighteenth century, in which intense revolutions in science, philosophy, society and politics occurred. This part of history was important because it was an enormous departure from the Middle Ages. Seldom before and after this time, did the Church have as much power as it did during the Enlightenment. There were three main eras of the Enlightenment: The Early Enlightenment, The High Enlightenment, and The Late Enlightenment and Beyond....   [tags: Science, Philosophy, Society, History]

Research Papers
965 words (2.8 pages)

Thinkers of the Enlightenment Essay

- Enlightenment The Enlightenment era was a new intellectual movement that stressed reason and thought and the power of individuals to solve problems. Even though different philosophers approached their goal differently, they achieved it none the less. They all approached their goal differently due to their different upbringings, their different backgrounds, and most importantly their different environments. A few among the many enlightened thinkers were Thomas Hobbes, John Locke, Baron Do Montesquieu, and Jean Jacques Rousseau....   [tags: Enlightenment Period]

Research Papers
499 words (1.4 pages)

An Investigation Into The Enlightenment And The Industrial Revolution Essay example

- Anyone studying or working in economics today owes a debt of gratitude to Adam Smith, who is considered by many to be the father of modern economics. Smith was a moral philosopher of Scottish ancestry who lived and wrote during the Scottish Enlightenment and the Industrial Revolution. Published in 1776, his work An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations decried government intervention in the economy and provided a blueprint for free markets and free trade. Thus began modern economics....   [tags: Adam Smith, Economics, Scottish Enlightenment]

Research Papers
1645 words (4.7 pages)

Essay on The Enlightenment and the Emergence of Free Thinkers

- The Enlightenment brought a wave of new thought and information into a society dominated by one controlling force: The Church. This final authority over the people in these dark times controlled them with religious dogma and powerful “suggestive” power over their state leaders. Being the largest and richest organization in the world for centuries gave The Church the ability to squash any free thinkers. Before the printing press, the majority of the educated and literate were the christian monks who controlled the information, mostly religious texts, and delivered this selected information to the ignorant masses....   [tags: Philosophy]

Research Papers
785 words (2.2 pages)

Education Is The Way Of Thinking Before The Enlightenment Essay

- The Enlightenment period was a time where change began in the education system. Prior to this time, religion was held in high regard and that is what was the driving force in education. One of the driving forces behind this push for change was because many started to see that the way people should be living life is by believing in reason and evidence, instead of what the beliefs are that have already been laid out for them to believe. Another aspect of the way of thinking before the Enlightenment was that life would be better after death instead of living a fulfilled life while they were living....   [tags: Education, School, Age of Enlightenment, Teacher]

Research Papers
1209 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on The Thinkers of the Enlightenment Tradition

- In this essay I will make a critical comparison between Locke and Hobbes, their idea of how Europe as a civil society has changed through time. Also, what was their vision of epistemology, sovereignty, peace, slavery, human nature, and future directions in international politics. In conclusion, I will give an overall opinion and view on how Locke, and Hobbes’s view have impacted the international political thoughts in conclusion I will identify one of the two of which I can compare my political views with theirs....   [tags: Philosophy ]

Research Papers
1249 words (3.6 pages)

Developing Strategic Thinkers : Strategic Thinking Essay

- Developing Strategic Thinkers Strategic thinking is regarded as an essential core competency for leadership positions. In fact, many organizations already use this competency, among others, to appraise and evaluate the performance of their executives and leaders. Thus, a competency gap in strategic thinking is considered serious, and organizations will attempt to eliminate this gap. This brief article explores the most effective means to develop strategic thinkers. Let us begin by listing some of the skills, knowledge, and attitudes that are attributed to this competency....   [tags: Management, Strategic management, Organization]

Research Papers
1238 words (3.5 pages)

The Enlightenment Set the Stage for New Imperialism Essay

- New imperialism was the mid nineteenth and twentieth centuries cultural equivalent to a modern day mafia, its roots entangled in the economic, cultural, and humanistic aspects of life. The sole objective of the nations entailed the exploitation of their controlled state. Gestating from the change in control of Asian and African nations to the Europeans by means of political deviance, malicious sieges, and strategic military attacks. The juxtaposition to the modern equivalent endures as the aforesaid is sheltered by the fairytale that these nations were in need of aid and by doing so the Europeans were the good guys....   [tags: The Enlightenment]

Research Papers
1371 words (3.9 pages)

Essay on Enlightenment Thinkers

- History Essay Do you agree with the Enlightenment thinkers such as Ben Franklin that humans are basically good. The Scientific Revolution had led people looking for laws governing human behavior. The ideas of the Scientific Revolution paved the way for a new period called the Enlightenment, also known as the Age of Reason. This period took place in the eighteenth- century. This was the philosophical movement that emphasized the pursuit of knowledge through reason and refused to accept ideas on the strength of religion or tradition alone....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
498 words (1.4 pages)

The Enlightenment Essay

- The Enlightenment Throughout Europe and the new American colonies in the 18th century there was a great movement in thought. This trend that preceded the French Revolution is known as the Enlightenment. Revolutionary writers and thinkers thought that the past held only darkness and ignorance, they began to question everything. Enlightened thought entered, or intruded, into all aspects of life in the 1700s. Governments were drastically reformed, art and literature changed in scope, religion was threatened, the study of science spread, nature was seen in a new light, and humanity evolved greatly....   [tags: History Historical French Essays]

Research Papers
1350 words (3.9 pages)

Ferguson thus argues, in contrast to what Smith advocates, that social change is brought upon society by the social actions of the community as a whole. Ferguson does not see the social actions of individuals as responsible for social change. In his perspective, society functions as a whole, not on an individual level. Therefore, social change should be seen as something created not by individual efforts, but the collective effort of the community as a whole.
The fall of communism in Eastern and Central Europe is an example of how social action led to social change. The people revolted against the corruption and economic despair, and thus led to the demise of communism. Through Smith's perspective, one can view this social change through the social action of individuals who were seeking to serve their self-interest which resulted in the good of society. From Ferguson's point of view, revolt of the masses against the state can be seen as the community or society functioning as whole to invoke social change through the social action of revoltion.
The thinking of Adam Smith and Adam Ferguson differs in that they view society differently. For Smith, he looks at the structures of society at the individual level. In contrast, Ferguson views society functioning as a whole collective unit. Smith argues that the efforts of individuals shape society in the form of social change, whereas, Ferguson, believes the individual is part of a community or society that effects social change through collective social action.
Return to