Draconian Internet Laws in Australia

Draconian Internet Laws in Australia

Length: 1186 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓

   The Internet is a revolutionary new medium that has provided people the world round a new medium of communication.  In "cyberspace" as the Internet has been nicknamed, everyone can have a voice and it is relatively easy for one person to reach a very large audience.  In addition to revolutionizing the way messages are broadcasted, cyberspace has also revolutionized peer-to-peer communication.  E-mail and instant messaging have become a very convenient method of communication for many people, oftentimes replacing the use of telephones and conventional postal mail.  However, the new methods of communication emerging on the Internet have also created a new communication medium for criminals.  Many criminals have found e-mail to be a safer method of communication as opposed to the telephone as it is impervious to wiretaps.  Instances of criminal use of cyberspace include espionage and drug trafficking.  Cyberspace has also led to the rise of a new form of crime - cybercrime.  Such crimes include child pornography and online stalking. 

 

The Internet is an international medium, therefore, it cannot be regulated by any one government, however, as crimes committed using the Internet have serious ramifications within real world borders, it is necessary that governments of affected nations take safeguards to protect its citizens.  The way in which governments prevent crime on the Internet, however, has become a point of contention for many people.  For example, privacy advocates in the United States oppose the Federal Bureau of Investigation's implementation of "Carnivore" a program that reads all e-mail passing through mail servers on which it is installed.  They argue that while Carnivore's purpose is to intercept correspondence between criminals, it invades the privacy of all Internet users as it allows the FBI to monitor all e-mail that passes through a system1.  However, of all the nations implementing precautions to prevent cybercrime and crime committed with the aid of the Internet, Australia's are perhaps the most draconian. 

 

On November 25, 1999, the Australian Parliament passed laws permitting the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO) - the counterpart to the United States Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) - to gain access to private computer systems and alter data for surveillance purposes without the knowledge of the owner of the computer.  It is important to note also that the ASIO is not subject to the Privacy Act of 1988.  This makes many Australian citizens uneasy that the government may now not only to monitor their actions on the Internet but also to compromise their computer systems.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Draconian Internet Laws in Australia." 123HelpMe.com. 18 Nov 2018
    <https://www.123helpme.com/view.asp?id=13115>.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Australian Internet Service Providers Study

- (U) During February of 2014, Australia had 41 internet service providers (ISPs) delivering nationwide services such as ADSL, mobile, NBN, satellite, cable, and fiber. By 2012, 88.8 per cent of the population had connectivity to the internet.ii Statistically, Australia is twelfth in the world in terms of how deeply it has permeated the total population with connectivity. The percentage of people connected has steadily risen every two to three years by nine per cent since 2007.iii If this momentum continues, Australia will have 97 percent of its population connected by the year 2015.iv Australia has 22 peering/public exchange points in or near Perth, Adelaide, Melbourne, Sydney, and Brisbane....   [tags: isp, internet, australia, telecommunications]

Research Papers
1147 words (3.3 pages)

Australia 's Laws Against Terrorism Essay examples

- ... New South Wales Police increased the level of security at all the Anzac Day services after charging the teenager. He was arrested near his home in Auburn in Sydney’s west after an investigation was conducted. The matter was heard in the Children’s Court on Monday morning, and the teen didn’t apply for bail. Police charged him with one count of preparing for, or planning, an act of terrorism. Papers presented to the court showed the teenager was allegedly trying to obtain a gun to carry out an Anzac Day terror plot, which is an offence that carries a maximum penalty of life imprisonment....   [tags: Terrorism, Violence, Counter-terrorism, Australia]

Research Papers
1193 words (3.4 pages)

The Internet and Intellectual Property Laws Essay

- The Internet and Intellectual Property Laws With the emergence and growth of the internet, intellectual property laws are much harder to enforce and many people are saying that they are outdated and obsolete. Intellectual property allows you to own your ideas, thoughts, and creativity as you would own a piece of tangible property. The human mind is a creative tool that comes up with ideas, designs, schemes, and inspirations of all kinds. Intellectual property views these ideas as being property....   [tags: Internet Online Communication Essays]

Research Papers
1417 words (4 pages)

The Commonwealth Of Australia Essay

- The Commonwealth of Australia, created in 1901 when six British colonies chose to federate, is one of the oldest continuous democracies in the world and is made up of nine parliaments. There are six state parliaments, two territorial parliaments, and one Federal parliament. The country initially faced trouble with the electoral tradition that it carried over from its British roots, it later went on to create a system that would form the basis for the electoral procedures of many modern-day democracies....   [tags: Elections, Democracy, Election, Australia]

Research Papers
1003 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on CyberCrime in Australia

- Australia is dependent on technology, everything from state security, economics and information collaboration is more accessible resulting in an increased reliance on digital networks. The rapid increase in cyber activity has a symbiotic relationship with cyber crime. The evolving nature of cyber crimes are constantly leaving counter measures obsolete in the face of these new technologies. Australia takes insufficient action against cyber crime, inaction is based on Australia’s previous focus on counter-terrorism....   [tags: Internet Crime, Cyber Crime Essays]

Research Papers
972 words (2.8 pages)

Internet Censorship Two Case Studies: Australia and the United States Essay

- I. Introduction Internet censorship laws started appearing around the world in 1995. These laws covered content already illegal in existing laws for non-internet content, as well as for content that is not suitable for minors. Worldwide, four different approaches were taken with internet censorship. 1) The government encouraged user self-regulation, and voluntary use of content filters by their citizens. 2) Laws were implemented that penalized content providers who made censored material available online....   [tags: Internet Web Censorship Censoring Essays]

Research Papers
2715 words (7.8 pages)

Essay on Internet Laws

- Internet Laws There are a lot of debates dealing with laws concerning the Internet. Privacy and censorship are just two of the main points of argument. While searching through this information, I found it difficult to actually find new laws concerning the Internet. There are many ongoing debates that I am sure will reach legislation. I found the CNN website to be the most help. I used other search engines, such as Google and AllTheWeb, but I mostly got personal websites about their own opinions....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
413 words (1.2 pages)

Essay on Internet Laws

- Crime and the Criminal Internet Laws Cyber Space Law Right now there is a very interesting war being waged in the court rooms across America. It is a battle for the rights of citizens on the Internet. The Internet is a fairly new medium gaining wide popularity in 1994. Because of its incredible growth in popularity in a very short amount of time it has been hard to regulate. The first act to come out regarding the Internet and Freedom of Speech was PL 99-508 the Electronic Communications and Privacy Act of 1986 ....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1065 words (3 pages)

Australia Essay

- Australia Australia, the continent down under, filled with kangaroos, koala bears, and many more unique creatures. I always wanted to go to Australia, but never knew much about it, like the history behind it, and what there really is to do. So I decided to research it and talk to people that are familiar with it. I started my search off by looking in an encyclopedia called Encyclopedia International and looked up Australia. The encyclopedia was written back in 1970 but things have changed since that time....   [tags: Australia Research Papers]

Free Essays
2566 words (7.3 pages)

Internet2 Essay example

- Internet2 Internet2 was formed in 1006 with an original 34 institutions participating. With Internet2, the Clinton Administration was trying to advance technologies for many people. Their first step was to connect 100 institutions at 100 times the speed of the current internet. The applications generated by this research have already had a positive affect on fields such as health care, national security, distance learning, energy research, environmental monitoring, and manufacturing. Internet2 is an extremely interesting subject....   [tags: Internet Computers Technology Essays]

Research Papers
1512 words (4.3 pages)

Related Searches

  Deputy leader Senator Natasha Stott Despoja fears that the new laws could be abused to allow the ASIO to construe evidence.  "The government has found quite a convenient excuse for significant new excursions into personal surveillance," she said.  Chris Connolly, director of the Financial Services Consumer Policy Centre, claims that the new laws gives the ASIO "new powers to hack into computers ... access our tax records, and access our banking records."  (Parliament Passes ASIO Bill)

 

In addition to the new laws giving the ASIO more power, many southern Australians are upset by a recent push for net censorship.  In 2001, it is likely that the South Australian Government will pass the Classification Amendment Bill, which would give the police the power to prosecute citizens who distribute content that it deems unsuitable for minors.  (Parliament Passes ASIO Bill)

 

The reason for the Classification Amendment Bill is that the federal government requires that the Office of Film and Literature Classification rate all media content from the Internet.  The idea is to prohibit sites that distribute child pornography or provide instructions or encourage criminal activity.  (ASIO Report Under Fire)

 

While this would make the Internet safer for minors and would popularize the Internet among citizens who fear some of the information readily available on the Internet, many feel that the bill would prevent one from exercising the freedom of speech.  Opponents to Internet censorship claim that the legislation would suppress public discussion of many legitimate subjects.  Founder and former board member of the Electronic Frontiers Australia, Michael Baker, stated, "I think it's political censorship gone rampant."  Under the new legislation, South Australians would be prohibited not only from publishing filmed footage of discussions of adult themes on the Internet, but would also be prohibited from discussing such issues on Internet newsgroups or mailing lists of which archives are kept.  Mr. Baker comments, "These are things you can discuss in the pub, but you won't be allowed to discuss them on the internet."  Despite the rigidity of the proposed bill, it would have no impact on the availability of illegal content to minors, as there are many sources of such content on overseas servers.  (ASIO Report Under Fire)

 

As previously discussed, there are reasons why governments see the need to regulate cyberspace.  However, cyberspace, aptly yclept by William Gibson in his novel Neuromancer, is a space.  As such, it is also important that governments that choose to regulate its citizens' actions in cyberspace do so in accordance to the way they regulate real space.  The way in which Australia regulates its citizens' behavior in cyberspace is more resembling of the way space is regulated in the World State as depicted in Aldous Huxley's Brave New World.  This reveals a seemingly recurring theme involving the Australian government and technology:  they don't get it.  This is best illustrated by a proposal written in 1996 to "alter proprietary software so that it performs additional functions."  The intent was to facilitate law enforcement agencies' ability to compromise citizens' computer systems.  The morality of this aside, the idea is nearly impossible and doomed to be useless.  While in theory, it may look good to the bureaucrats who need only ask their underlings to implement their proposals, in reality, it would require nothing short of negotiating a contract with Microsoft and other operating system manufacturers to implement new undocumented features - as if Windows were lacking.  However, given Microsoft's disinclination to allow even trusted bundlers of their operating systems to modify the appearance of their desktop, such an implementation is highly unlikely.  As for such use to combat criminal activity, criminals will only resort to using open-sourced operating systems such as FreeBSD or Linux.

 

What the Australian government needs to realize is that cyberspace is an international medium that it cannot possibly control.  Instead of trying to control the small part of it that is within its legislation in order to prevent crime, the ASIO and other Australian law enforcement agencies should learn to use cyberspace to its advantage.  Cyberspace is a unique space that poses many weaknesses to criminals intending to use it.  The Australian government just needs to stop treating cyberspace as the enemy but instead as an ally.

 

 

Works Cited

Maher, William.  "ASIO Report Under Fire."  Australian Personal Computer:  Newswire.  14 May 1999:  n. pag.  Online.  Internet.  10 Jan. 2001.  Available http://newswire.com.au/apcweb/news.nsf/def5c94fb1fc5ea6ca25647b00461aa4/ace558bb8e62541e4a25677100258420!OpenDocument.

---.  "Parliament passes ASIO Bill."  Australian Personal Computer:  Newswire.  26 Nov. 1999:  n. pag.  Online.  Internet.  10 Jan. 2001.  Available http://newswire.com.au/apcweb/news.nsf/c1c1057939c26a87ca2564b90004cdec/7b86c55e8e8a81caca25683500228ebd!OpenDocument.

1 For more information regarding Carnivore and other methods of Internet surveillance in use or being proposed by other nations, see "Surveillance on the Internet" available online at http://www.geocities.com/l0s/srp.html.
Return to 123HelpMe.com