September 11: An American Victory

September 11: An American Victory

Length: 1393 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
September 11: An American Victory

The terrorist attack on the World Trade Center and Washington DC has been described as an act of war and a tremendous defeat for the United States, a defeat that must not be allowed to be repeated and a loss that must be avenged.

Personally, I don't like the use of the phrase "Act of War". Wars are something that happen between states. Wars end when one side surrenders. If we treat this as a literal war, what will be the victory conditions? Who will surrender? How will we know that the war is over? Whose suit for peace will be listened to?

But, for the sake of discussion, let us ignore these concerns, let us concede for the nonce that the language of war is appropriate. Let us put aside the questions of who exactly the enemy is. We know, at least, who 19 of the other side's foot soldiers were. We know, more or less what happened.

I'm willing to set these questions aside because I have become angry, angry about how we ourselves are viewing the outcome of this attack, and how we are letting the world view it. I am angry about how we are viewing the acts of heroes, and how we are view ourselves as a nation.

Let me state this quite clearly...  The United States did not lose the Battle of September 11, 2001.

Claiming that we did diminishes the heroism that Americans showed. It underestimates American strength and it misses some very important points about the American character.

There were four phases of the battle, four attacks. The first two took us completely by surprise, and can easily be viewed as a two pronged attack. Two transcontinental planes flying from Boston were turned into bombs and used to destroy the twin towers of the World Trade Center. Because they had the element of surprise the enemy's first thrust was extremely effective. The battle started very badly for us.

The third phase occurred in Washington DC. The enemy hijacked a third commercial airliner. This time, however, US intelligence and technology began to come into play. At least one passenger was able to contact the Justice Department, inform them of what was happening and ask what instructions should be passed to the pilot. I'm speaking here, of course, of Barbara Olson's phone call to the Solicitor General, her husband Ted.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"September 11: An American Victory." 20 Feb 2020

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The September 11th Terroritst Attacks

- First shock, then terror, followed by sorrow and lastly rage were my emotions on September 11th, 2001 when a hijacked airliner crashed into the Twin Towers in New York City. Tunh. Tunh. Tunh. All circuits are busy; please try again at a later time. This message kept repeating as I tried to call my cousin in New York, who was working in the South Tower. At the time the American Airlines flight 11 just moments earlier crashed into the North Tower. I sat in my house in shock and terror. Then at 9:05 am, about twenty minutes after the first collision, United Airlines flight 175 crashed into the South Tower....   [tags: September 11 Terrorism Essays]

Free Essays
1078 words (3.1 pages)

Essay about September 11th: The Day Innocence Died

- September 11th, 8:45 a.m.: A large plane, possibly a hijacked airliner, crashes into one of the World Trade Center towers, tearing a gaping hole in the building and setting it afire. 9:03 a.m.: A second plane, apparently a passenger jet, crashes into the second World Trade Center tower and explodes. Both buildings are burning. 9:30 a.m.: Bush, speaking in Florida, says the country has suffered an "apparent terrorist attack." 9:43 a.m.: An aircraft crashes into the Pentagon, sending up a huge plume of smoke....   [tags: September 11 Terrorism Essays]

Free Essays
1564 words (4.5 pages)

Essay on The Nature of Victory in a War on Terrorism

-        While President Bush has proclaimed a "war on terrorism" and taken measured steps in a strategic battle against terrorist groups, most prominently al Qaida, American citizens have been living lives far removed from his proclamation.  The American people have responded to the September 11th "act of war" with an outpouring of democratic rhetoric and bizarre acts of patriotism1.  Sadly, our proud demonstrations have truly ignored the reality of ensuing war. Americans have donated blood and established funds for firefighters' families, while failing to look outside of our nation with any intention of understanding the grounds for popular terrorism in Arab and Muslim states.  The America...   [tags: September 11 Terrorism Essays]

Free Essays
3123 words (8.9 pages)

Essay about September 11 Was Mass Murder, Not an Act of War

- As we reflect upon the terrifying events of 11 September 2001, we are haunted by analogies from our past. But historical analogies require careful examination, for choosing among them influences the way we will think, speak, and act. Commentators have compared the attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon to Pearl Harbor, because both attacks came without warning. With Pearl Harbor as the primary analog, the attacks on New York and Washington were quickly termed "acts of war." That is understandable, but dangerously imprecise....   [tags: September 11 Terrorism Essays]

Free Essays
835 words (2.4 pages)

The American Civil War: Abraham Lincoln Essay

- ... He met Mary Todd and married her. Lincoln got elected to the house of representatives in 1846. He hadn’t been popular with voter in Illinois for his stance against the U.S. war with Mexico, but he began his term the following year. After his term was over, promising not to seek reelection, he moved back to Springfield in 1849. However, certain events pushed him back towards politics. Stephen Douglas, a democrat in congress, pushed the passage of the Kansas-Nebraska act, which declared that the voters of each territory had the right to chose whether the territory should have slaves or be free, instead of the federal government choosing that....   [tags: wartime leader, union victory]

Research Papers
739 words (2.1 pages)

The Contributions of the P-51 Mustang to the Victory of the Allies Essay

- The Contributions of the P-51 Mustang to the Victory of the Allies This paper deals with the contributions of the P-51 Mustang to the eventual victory of the Allies in Europe during World War II. It describes the war scene in Europe before the P-51 was introduced, traces the development of the fighter, its advantages, and the abilities it was able to contribute to the Allies' arsenal. It concludes with the effect that the P-51 had on German air superiority, and how it led the destruction of the Luftwaffe....   [tags: World War Two American History Essays]

Free Essays
4445 words (12.7 pages)

American Revolution : The American Revolutionary War Essay example

- Brandon Dille Hist. 1010 Final Project 11/30/2015 The American Revolution The American Revolution (1775-83) is also known as the American Revolutionary War and the U.S. War of Independence. The conflict arose from growing tensions between residents of Great Britain’s 13 North American colonies and the colonial government, which represented the British crown. The tension that arose because of this was due in simple fact thanks to the crown applying harsh rules and regulations involving taxes. Skirmishes between British troops and colonial militiamen commonly many times called the minutemen thanks to their ability to be into combat at any time in Lexington and Concord in April 1775 kicked off...   [tags: American Revolutionary War, American Revolution]

Research Papers
1748 words (5 pages)

Essay on The American Revolution

- The American Revolution was a very important part in American History, because it is when the colonies of America gained independence and became the United States of America. Enlightenment thoughts had been floating around, giving people many new ideas - one of them being independence of Britain. Colonists were ready for independence, they had a population consisting of 2.1 million people by 1770, and compared to Britain, there were many more opportunities for people to take advantage of in America because the English class system was absent....   [tags: American History, Britain, America, Colonies]

Research Papers
976 words (2.8 pages)

The American Revolution Essay

- The American Revolution also known as the United States War of Independence began in 1775. The war initially began due to ongoing conflict between the colonies and colonial government (British authorities). Colonists were furious after learning about the government’s attempt to raise revenue by taxing the colonies (known as the Stamp Act of 1765, the Townshend tariffs of 1767 and the Tea act of 1773). Colonists were also raged about their lack of representation in Parliament. Colonists were breaking the laws which caused massive chaos throughout the colonies....   [tags: American Revolutionary War, George Washington]

Research Papers
1099 words (3.1 pages)

Violence Will Never Bring Victory Over Terrorism Essay

- Violence Will Never Bring Victory Over Terrorism This has been a very angry year for many of us - the year since September 11, 2001. In a spirit of anger, hate spreads to become hostility. This hostility must be focused on something or someone. Howard Thurman in his book The Growing Edge, states, "If hostility cannot express itself toward anything else, then it is like a boomerang and turns upon its possessor." A key question that all Americans continue to face is how to respond to the death and destruction brought into our lives by the terrorist attacks....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics]

Free Essays
1177 words (3.4 pages)

Related Searches

Additionally, it appears that the intended target of this phase of the battle may have been the White House, and not the Pentagon. We'll probably never know for sure, but it seems that for some reason the enemy may have been forced to settle for an opportunistic attack on the Pentagon, passing up the primary target. And this happened after the people on board asked what they should do. Claiming that they took action that forced the change of targets is purely speculative, but one thing is sure: the attack on the Pentagon was much less effective, much less damaging than the attack on the WTC. Only a portion of the building was damaged. Many fewer people were killed, and the most important parts of the Pentagon were unaffected.

This brings us to the fourth phase of the attack: Flight 93. Like the third phase, this one appears to have been aimed at Washington, DC, probably on the Capital building. This time, several passengers contact the outside world. They definitely learned about the earlier phases of the battle and how badly they had gone. A handful of Americans -- ordinary citizens -- apparently took a vote to decide what to do, spoke to or left messages for their loved ones, and then with a battle cry of "Let's Roll", counterattacked.

And they were successful! They prevented the enemy from getting to the target. They stopped anyone on the ground from being killed.

This is important. A handful of ordinary Americans, with no training, no warning, and no weapons -- strangers, with nothing but their determination and courage, worked together to foil an attack that had been years in preparation. To underscore how American a reaction this was, it appears that these men had a vote to decide what to do. Many of my ancestors were Scots. The Scottish thing would have been to have a hero among the passengers who inspired the rest, lead them in a charge. Americans vote on what to do.

These heroes are the spiritual descendants of the militias that were the first to fight for the United States of America. In most countries, throughout most of history, armies have been something separate from the populace, even a force used against the populace. In America, our tradition is that the men on the street are our army. Our citizenry protects itself. Our people can and have from 1776 to 2001 risen to the defense of our country and our fellow Americans.

Once we knew what was happening, the course of the battle turned. The attackers stopped achieving their goals, and the on the ground casualties fell from thousands to hundreds to none.

It doesn't stop there. Next there are the heroes in the towers and on the ground, the two men who carried the woman in the wheel chair -- a total stranger -- down 68 flights of stairs to safety, the man who stayed with his paraplegic friend, all the fire fighters and doctors who saw the battle and rushed to the aid of their fellows. The enemy attacked two buildings where 50,000 people worked, totally destroyed them and there were only about 6,000 killed. Americans, hundreds or thousands of them, saved the rest.

And did you see the people, walking out of the city across the bridges? It looked nothing like the panic that would have been shown in a movie. Just thousands and thousands filing out in a basically orderly fashion. There was remarkable little looting or violence. Instead, grocers and pizzeria owners fed strangers and gave them water.

Or take the next couple of days. The WTC attack was an attack not only on our populace and our property, but upon our financial institutions. The enemy killed about 3/4 of the 1000 employees of Cantor Fitzgerald. You might think that that would cripple the company, but no, the survivors chose to put in an all night effort to see that the bond market could be reopened by the end of the week. They were bloodied, but not defeated. Succeeding in your mission after taking 75% casualties is a remarkable feet for soldiers in a state of war. Soldiers expect to die, to see death, lose comrades. These were financial analysts who died at work. The mission they succeeded at was trading bonds! That is not a small victory. That is an astounding victory.

And again, when the CEO of Cantor Fitzgerald was asked if his company could be ready to open the bond market, he didn't answer for the company. He went to his people and put it up to a vote. What did they want to do? Work all night and open the market the next day -- that was their decision. Again not only a victory, not merely heroic, but classically American.

I think it's time for us to realize that although the Battle of 9-11 started out badly for our side, by the time the day was over, the tide of battle had turned. It was turned by the spirit, pride and commitment that Americans have to our country and our fellow citizens. It's hard to think of an event where six thousand lives were lost as a victory, but in the end it was not a defeat. We Americans met the enemy and in the by the end we kept them from achieving their goals.

The attack was against our people, our institutions and our culture and we turned it back by means not of arms, but with our people, our culture and our institutions. Our people had courage, they decided issues with votes and volunteerism. They won by doing their jobs and by living by their values.

Our victories on the 11th of September and the days following were more important than mere military victories. They were a vindication of our spirit, national character and traditions. Please, let us remember this, and honor our heroes, all of them, and recognize the debt we owe them.
Return to