Essay PreviewMore ↓
Is it ethical for doctors to bend the truth in order to get an insurance company to pay for medical treatment? According to this article, most doctors do. A survey has shown that 58% of doctors say that they would be willing to give an insurance company "deliberately deceptive documentation" to influence the company's decision to approve surgery or other treatment for a life-threatening illness.
These doctors believe that if they did not lie, their patients would receive sub-standard health care. Insurance companies are continually looking for ways to reduce their costs, and the most common way is to second-guess the doctors' opinions or to approve the minimum treatments necessary. This has created a crisis in American medicine in which doctors feel they must be dishonest with the insurance companies in order to be the "good guy" to their patients.
Does the end justify the mean? After all, these doctors seem to have a good reason for lying. They are trying to help someone, right? But it does not make it morally and ethically right. Lying is wrong, no matter what the reason is. Even though saving someone's life seems to be a valid reason for bending the truth, it does not solve the problem. It is unethical for a doctor to lie, even to an insurance company. Although
HMO's and insurance companies need to be dealt with, lying is not the way to defeat them. You should not lie to "beat the system." It solves nothing. Lying is a quick fix. It may work on a case-to-case basis, but health care reform is the only permanent solution.
While we can condemn doctors for being untruthful, we also have to look at the flip side -- HMO's and other insurance companies who are trying to cut back costs, approving the least expensive treatments and sometimes denying those claims that have real merit. These companies do breed an environment where it is difficult for doctors to be completely honest. Doctors are supposed to be looking after the interests of their patients, and they sometimes see lying as the only way to skirt the policies of some HMO's.
The author takes the position that it is morally and ethically wrong for doctors to lie to insurance companies. However, in the current health system, dishonest pays.
How to Cite this Page
"Deceptive Health Insurance Practices." 123HelpMe.com. 28 Feb 2020
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- The Standards for Privacy of Individually Identifiable Health Information, better known as the Privacy Rule, that took effect in April 2003 for large entities and a year later for small ones, was established as the first set of national standards for the protection of health information. This rule was issued by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services to meet the requirement of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA). The Privacy Rule was born out of a need for health information to be appropriately protected yet still allowing the health information to be shared to ensure quality health care and to protect the public’s health and well being.... [tags: Healthcare, Privacy Rule, HIPAA]
1793 words (5.1 pages)
- Nothing is free. You pay either price or tax for the air you breathe, no way can you get health care free of cost. Health insurance is a way to pay the cost for health care. Most people cannot afford to pay the high cost of health care on their own and that’s where the insurance comes in. It simply a protection from paying the full cost of medical services when you’re not well. The payment is in the form of monthly premium. People have freedom to select the plan from different insurer in the health insurance market and pay decided fix amount as a premium.... [tags: Health insurance, Health care, Insurance]
1644 words (4.7 pages)
- Health insurance is very important in our lives and we will never know until we are left to battle with many medical bills. With health insurance you are able to pick if you want a PPO or HMO plan, this determines the providers you may see. Having health insurance allows you to be able to see a provider with little to no out-of-pocket expenses. If you pay for health insurance benefits, it limits the amount of debt that you may have for medical expenses. There are many different types of health insurance plans that may help pay for medical expenses.... [tags: Health care, Health insurance]
1496 words (4.3 pages)
- In the United States, health care finance is a vital aspect for health delivery systems to function. The distribution of national health spending has several financing sources, including a major component known as health insurance. The distribution of citizens with health insurance coverage has continually increased throughout the years, however millions still remain uninsured. The establishment of The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act has expanded health care coverage to millions of Americans, making it more accessible and affordable while decreasing the number of uninsured.... [tags: Health economics, Health care, Health insurance]
1504 words (4.3 pages)
- Health Insurance Everyone though out the United States are being to have some sort of health insurance since legislations passed the patient protection affordable care act that began in the beginning of 2014. The reform act basically states all people have to have some type of health insurance and if they fall to have the minimal required insurance then will face a tax penalty. However, with the written laws the information is difficult to understand and even more difficult to interpret what the impact will be if people fail to comply and get insurance (Suelzer).... [tags: Health insurance, Health care, Insurance]
1259 words (3.6 pages)
- Many individuals would concede that a lack of health care insurance is incredibly difficult during these times. It can be daunting to select an excellent health care plan which is still affordable. If you are choosing which medical insurance plan you need, think of your health plus your family 's health. This might lead you to purchase insurance that has a cheaper premium if you do not possess any anticipated health problems. While that may be cheaper upfront, it may prove risky if there are actually problems later on.... [tags: Health insurance, Health care, Insurance]
883 words (2.5 pages)
- Health Insurance Everyone though out the United States is required to have some sort of health insurance since the enactment of the patient protection affordable care act that began in the beginning of 2014. The reform act basically states all individuals have to have some type of health insurance and if they fall to have the minimum required insurance then will face a tax penalty. However, with the way the law is written the information can be difficult to understand and even more difficult to determine what the impact will be if individuals fail to comply and obtain insurance (Suelzer).... [tags: Health insurance, Health care, Insurance]
1293 words (3.7 pages)
- SECONDARY RESEACH HEALTH INSURANCE NAME OF STUDENT:…………………. UNIVERSITY OF THE PEOPLE 11/24/2015 This paper entails information gotten from secondary research such as encyclopedia, websites and articles. The table below describes the comparison of the result I found under the topic health insurance, the definition of terms, the URLs, complete bibliographical information, names of the authors and their backgrounds, quantity of relevant information, depth of analysis, objectivity, and how current it is (recency).... [tags: Health insurance, Health care, Insurance]
705 words (2 pages)
- Health Care in the USA is expensive and only the richest of us can afford to pay the full cost. Having health insurance affords you to the opportunity to get care at any hospital or clinics in the USA for a fraction of the full cost. Health Insurance is designed to help you and your family pay for medical care which includes doctor visits and sometimes your prescriptions. It’s similar to car insurance, where you are responsible for paying a monthly premium weather you use the services provided or not.... [tags: Health insurance, Preferred provider organization]
1280 words (3.7 pages)
- Medical Health insurance is a formal agreement to provide and/or pay for medical care. The health insurance policy describes what medical services are "covered" by the insurance company. There are medical services that are not "covered" and will not be paid by your insurance company. There are a variety of private and public health insurance programs. Most women obtain health insurance through their employer or like a "dependent" in a family plan. There are also public health insurance plans funded by the federal and state governments.... [tags: Health insurance, Health care, Health, Insurance]
777 words (2.2 pages)
Perhaps someday we can agree upon a reasonable system where the needs of the patient come before the wallet of the insurance company. Only then will doctors feel that they are not obligated to lie and integrity will be restored to the American health system.
Doctoring the Truth. The New Republic. Nov 15, 1999. P 13.