Israel's Refusal to Sign the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty

Israel's Refusal to Sign the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty

Length: 446 words (1.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓

Israel has recently come under fire from the United Nations for their failure to sign the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty. If Israel doesn't want to abide by the UN's ruling, then why did they give up part of their own sovereignty to be part of the United Nations? John Locke explains this in his essay The Treatises of Government. His thesis basically is that states are "willing to joyn in Society with other who are already united, or have a mind to united for the mutual Preservation of their Lives, Liberties, and Estates." Israel like other members of the UN, joined for security reasons. But in order for the UN to be successful in its effort to avoid conflicts and promote peace, it must first establish law, second be an indifferent judge of the law disregarding passion and revenge, and third it must be able to enforce the law and support the sentence when right.
The United Nations established the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty to protect the world from possible nuclear war. It requires nuclear powers to work toward disarmament while forbidding non-nuclear countries from obtaining nuclear weapons. Israel remains the only country in the Middle East that has not signed onto the treaty, which in turn has caused Egypt to lead the effort to encourage Israel to allow the International Atomic Energy Agency to inspect their nuclear facilities. Although the law of nature is clear in this case, according to Locke, Israel won't "apt to allow of it as Law binding to them in the application of it to their particular case."
Secondly, the United Nations must be an indifferent and unbiased judge, "with authority to determine all indifference according to the established law." I find the UN falls short on this issue in this area. Unfortunately for the UN, the United States is a biased "indifferent judge" when it comes to the power of the United Nations. Because the US holds so much clout, we have managed to lead off direct criticism of Israel at the last treaty review conference in 1995. But according to Locke, the UN must "determine all differences according to the established law." According to the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty, Israel is in direct conflict with the established law.
Thirdly, the UN must have the power to enforce the law. I believe this is the most important of the 3 for without the power to enforce, the other 2 are meaningless.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Israel's Refusal to Sign the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty." 10 Dec 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on To Sign, or Not to Sign

- In “The Day Language Came into My Life”, Helen Keller recalled the time she learned how to use sign language. As an infant, Helen had the ability to both see and hear, but at eighteen months old, she suffered from a severe illness that caused her to lose her seeing and hearing abilities, thus making her both blind and deaf. Three months before she turned seven, Helen’s parents hired Ms. Anne Sullivan to teach her sign language, and show Helen the world around her. Frustration ensued between Helen trying to learn sign language, and Ms....   [tags: Hellen Keller, sign language, communication]

Research Papers
711 words (2 pages)

Israel P.L.O. Peace Treaty Essay

- Israel P.L.O. Peace Treaty The Middle East has always been known as the Holy Land, the land of the Bible. For centuries, prophets have walked there, nations have collided and conquerors have come and gone. While Jews claim a three thousand-year-old attachment to this ancient land, Arabs also stake their devotion. In 1993, these two peoples, involved in a tragic conflict that has lasted more than half a century, saw the possibility of a new beginning. It was called the Oslo Accord, and it transformed the political realities of the Middle East (Peres, p.2) However, there have been many turbulent events that have followed the signing of the Accord, events that have undermined the agreement an...   [tags: Middle East Politics Political Essays]

Research Papers
3259 words (9.3 pages)

Essay on Effects Of The Treaty Of Versailles

- To what extent did the Treaty of Versailles contribute to the rise of Fascism in Germany. The Treaty of Versailles officially ended the war between Germany and the Allies (England, France and the US) on 28th June 1919. While the delegates of the victorious countries should have been concerned with the prospects of future peace in Europe, they instead focused solely on making Germany as weak as possible. Graebner and Bennett (2011) argue that “the democratic powers at Versailles had the opportunity in 1919 to set an aggrieved Germany, one that scarcely resembled Hitler’s, on a different course.” They of course failed....   [tags: World War I, Treaty of Versailles, Adolf Hitler]

Research Papers
1656 words (4.7 pages)

The Treaty Of Versailles Treaty Essay

- “Given these results, the Versailles treaty must be judged one of history’s greatest catastrophes”. The treaty of Versailles was one of the worst treaties or even agreement that the United States and their allies ever agreed to. The treaty of Versailles was the end result of WW1 between the Allies (England, France, Russia, United States) and the Central Powers (Germany, Austria-Hungary, Ottoman Empire). WW1 was the first time in history that multiple nations all over the world fought against each other through alliances and because that caused major blood shed on a scale that was never seen before and is therefore called “The War to End All Wars”....   [tags: World War I, World War II, Treaty of Versailles]

Research Papers
1279 words (3.7 pages)

Essay on Ethiopia Immigration and Coexistence in Israel

- Coexistence in Israel can be perceived as an empty notion considering Israel’s segregation policy, such as their mixed cities phenomenon. Israel’s concealed segregation policy creates a microcosm of marginalizing and excluding a minority group from the benefits of the state (Humphries, Isabelle). These policies have been preserved and enforced regardless of Israel’s democratic image it portrays to the international community (Humphries, Isabelle). Given the fact, Israel is a recent and socially developing country that has been compelled to accommodate massive waves of immigration in a relatively short period....   [tags: Racism In Israel]

Research Papers
3023 words (8.6 pages)

Egyptian President Anwar El Sadat Flew On Israel Essays

- Through additional research on these agreements, 1978 turned out to be a monumental year in the Middle East. Egyptian president Anwar El-Sadat flew to Israel, and delivered a speech to the Knesset. El-Sadat became the very first Arab leader to recognize Israel, which was a playing factor within the Arab-Israeli conflict. El-Sadat joined the Israeli prime minister at Camp David, Maryland, along with President Carter to create a peace agreement as mentioned above. This is when the Camp David Peace Accords were signed....   [tags: Israel, Jordan, Egypt, Arab League]

Research Papers
1331 words (3.8 pages)

Conflict In Israel Essay

- Since the inception of an Israeli nation-state in 1948, violence and conflict has played a major role in Israel’s brief history. In the Sixty-One year’s Israel has been a recognized nation-state, they have fought in 6 interstate wars, 2 civil wars, and over 144 dyadic militarized interstate disputes (MIDs) with some display of military force against other states (Maoz 5). Israel has been involved in constant conflict throughout the past half century. Israel’s tension against other states within the Middle East has spurred vast economic, social, and political unity that has fostered a sense of nationalism and unity in Israel not seen in most other states....   [tags: Israel]

Research Papers
1986 words (5.7 pages)

Israel and Iran's Incompatibility Essay

- The incompatibility for the game between Israel and Iran is because Iran would not play by the same set of rules that were set between the United States and Russia during the Cold War. This assumption is based on Iran’s own unique scenario in a regional game in the Middle East, as well as Iran’s history to avoid inside the box thinking when it comes to strategic warfare. Tira concludes that the unreliability accompanying the area’s instability and Iran’s known use of creating black swans to continuously push and wear down an opponent, shows that if a nuclear Iran were to develop it would be a major threat not to be taken lightly....   [tags: Bushehr, Iran, Israel]

Research Papers
1866 words (5.3 pages)

Global Warming and the Kyoto Treaty Essay

- According to David Easterling, principal scientist at the National Climatic Data Center in Asheville, N.C. in twenty years the United States has had thirty seven weather related catastrophes each with damages exceeding one billion dollars (Levin 1). A country as wealthy as the United States can afford to pay thirty seven billion dollars in twenty years, assuming of course that the weather related disasters only cost one billion dollars each. Unfortunately, the weather does not work that way. Hurricane Katrina alone may have cost one hundred billion dollars (Tucker 13)....   [tags: Climate Change and the Kyoto Treaty]

Research Papers
2788 words (8 pages)

Palestine and Israel Essay

- Palestine and Israel On the day of January 18th, 2004 Israeli forces rushed through the Gaza strip and attempted a dangerous raid. The effects of the raid left eight Palestinians civilians dead in cold blood. Within twenty-four hours a young Palestinian police officer by the name of Ali Jaara climbed onto a Jerusalem bus and detonated a bomb, killing him and ten Israeli passengers. This is a very sad but common example of the never ending war that takes place not only on the battlefield but now on the streets and in homes of innocents....   [tags: Middle East War Palestin Israel Essays]

Research Papers
1452 words (4.1 pages)

I feel too, that the UN can fall short in this category. In this case, all the UN can really do is support a special representative to urge Israel to gain the treaty and to report on progress before 2005. According to Locke, Israel would be likely "make good their injustice," with proper Execution from the United Nations. The only question which remains is, does this special representative hold enough power on behalf of the UN to enforce its established law. The answer remains to be found.
John Locke holds outstanding insight into the nature of states actions in dealing with security issues. In fact, it is so outstanding that he has essentially predicted the exact course of action taken by the United Nations to force Israel's signing of the treaty. As long as the UN continues to follow Locke's ideas of "man in the state of nature," then it will be a successful deterrent of war, as well as a promoter of peace. Unfortunately, my main objection (and I think Locke would agree) with the UN, is that it is rarely indifferent due to the United State's overwhelming power and influence in its decision making.
Return to