Comparison of the Book and Movie Version of A Clockwork Orange

Comparison of the Book and Movie Version of A Clockwork Orange

Length: 1236 words (3.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
A Comparison of the Book and Firm Version of A Clockwork Orange

 
In the story of his teenage years, starting at fifteen.  He begins his tale as the
leader of a small gang that spends its evenings pillaging and wreaking havoc on the town until the gang mutinies and "Your Humble Narrator," as Alex refers to himself, is caught by the police.  From there, Alex travels to State Jail 84F to serve 14 years, but receives an offer from "the Government" which entails undergoing experimental treatment in return for early release.  He seizes what seems to him an opportunity, but is horrified by the "cure" he endures.  The new "good" Alex that is released unto the world is depressed, frustrated, and lonely, although no longer violent.  A radical political group then exploits him as an example of the cruelty of "the Government."  This faction tries to force Alex to suicide in order to gain a martyr, but Alex's attempt fails and he is nursed back to health and his natural mental state by the Government, who in the end comes out on top.

      Alex, whose last name is not mentioned in the book, is a violent, aggressive teenager of fifteen, who is the leader of a four-person gang.  He truly enjoys violence, reveling in the sight of blood or weapons.  Alex's love of hate is not simply a rebellious emotion, but as he explains, it is his very nature, and he could not change it if he wanted to.  Despite his passion for what most see as ugly and disgusting, Alex does have a great appreciation for classical music, especially Beethoven.

      Alex's main conflicts are both external and internal.  His external conflicts are between him and the members of his gang.  Dim and Georgie, two of the members of Alex's gang, are unwilling to accept Alex's leadership.  They challenge his authority, and Alex reacts rashly by trying to re- establish his dominance through defeating both of his aggressors in fighting.  This confrontation only raises tensions within the gang, and leads to a betrayal which results in Alex's capture on the charge of murder.  Alex's main internal conflict is a physiological one.  The Government's experimental treatment which Alex undergoes involves conditioning to produce a feeling of nausea and

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Comparison of the Book and Movie Version of A Clockwork Orange." 123HelpMe.com. 19 Sep 2019
    <https://www.123helpme.com/view.asp?id=12958>.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

A Clockwork Orange Essay: A Movie Analysis

- A Clockwork Orange A Movie Analysis      In 1962, Anthony Burgess' novel A Clockwork Orange was published for the first time. This novel was an anti-utopian fable about the near future, where teenage gangs habitually terrorize the inhabitants of a shabby metropolis. The novel deals with the main focus that man is a sinner but not sufficiently a sinner to deserve the calamities that are heaped upon him. It is a comic novel about a man's tragic lot. (Bergonzi 152).      In 1971, Stanley Kubrick turned Burgess' novel into a 136 minute, color motion picture produced by Warner Brothers....   [tags: Movie Film comparison compare contrast]

Research Papers
1699 words (4.9 pages)

Comparison of Linguistic Differences in the Film and Novel of A Clockwork Orange

- Anthony Burgess’ A Clockwork Orange - Linguistic Differences in the Film and Novel A Clockwork Orange, written by Anthony Burgess, is experienced differently as a novel than it is as the movie directed by Stanley Kubrick. The heart of the difference between the two forms is expressed by Bakhtin: "The potential for [‘double-voiced discourse’ between the author and narrator] is one of the most fundamental privileges of novelistic prose, a privilege available neither to dramatic nor to purely poetic genres" (Bakhtin, 320).1 An entire dimension of the novel’s story is lost in the movie when Alex’s role is reduced from narrator to commentator....   [tags: Comparison Compare Contrast Essays]

Research Papers
2227 words (6.4 pages)

One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest- Book And Movie Comparison Essay

- "The Power of Words" In recent years, it has become popular for many of America's great literary masterpieces to be adapted into film versions. As easy a task as it may sound, there are many problems that can arise from trying to adapt a book into a movie, being that the written word is what makes the novel a literary work of art. Many times, it is hard to express the written word on camera because the words that express so much action and feeling can not always be expressed the same way through pictures and acting....   [tags: Comparative Essays]

Free Essays
1887 words (5.4 pages)

Confucianism, Taoism, and Buddhism in the Film Kung Fu Panda Essay

- The Bridge between Actual and Fictional “Life is a series of natural and spontaneous changes. Don't resist them - that only creates sorrow. Let reality be reality. Let things flow naturally forward in whatever way they like” (Lau Tzu). Born into a life of noodles and relaxation Po, a chubby panda, always wanted to be a Kung Fu master. Out of nowhere an opportunity arises to have his dream become reality. Po, like any normal panda snatches up this once in a lifetime opportunity and runs with it....   [tags: Movie, China]

Research Papers
523 words (1.5 pages)

Analysis Of The Book ' Clockwork Orange ' Essay

- 1. As I was reading the book Clockwork Orange, I felt like it deserved a 8 out of 10. I enjoyed the book because while I was reading it, I did not have such a clear image of all the rape, sex, and violence. Talking from personal experiences, I did not want to picture those images in my head. Finding out there was a movie of Clockwork Orange kind of scared me but also gave me excitement because I wanted to see how different the the book was from the movie. After viewing Clockwork Orange, I would rate it a 7 out of 10....   [tags: A Clockwork Orange, Stanley Kubrick]

Research Papers
1002 words (2.9 pages)

A Comparison of the Opening Sequence in Two Film Versions of the Novel Great Expectations

- A Comparison of the Opening Sequence in Two Film Versions of the Novel Great Expectations I am going to compare the first 20 minutes of two film versions of the novel, Great Expectations. One version is by David Lean 1946. The other version is by Alfonzo Cuaron 1999. In Lean's version and Cuaron's there is one big difference and that is that Lean's version is in black and white, while Cuaron's is in full colour. The colour projects a better effect because it is clearer and more understandable whereas the black and white version is less effective in my opinion....   [tags: Great Expectations Essays]

Free Essays
1031 words (2.9 pages)

Comparing Marlow of Heart of Darkness and Willard of Apocalypse Now Essay

- Comparing Marlow of Heart of Darkness and Willard of Apocalypse Now    Whenever books are adapted for film, changes inevitably have to be made. The medium of film offers several advantages and disadvantages over the book: it is not as adept at exploring the inner workings of people - it cannot explore their minds so easily; however, the added visual and audio capabilities of film open whole new areas of the imagination which, in the hands of a competent writer-director, can more than compensate....   [tags: Movie Film comparison compare contrast]

Research Papers
1513 words (4.3 pages)

A Comparison of Othello and the Movie O Essay

- A Comparison of Othello and the Movie O When Shakespeare composed the tragedy Othello televisions were not. Along with no televisions, life in the late 1500s had many different qualities than it does today. This time period had no war on drugs and no high school shootings. Peer pressure was not an issue. The audiences of Othello in the 1500s did not face the circumstances that we, American high school students, face today. With these significant differences in daily life, come the attempts of movie creators to help prevent our modern day tragedies....   [tags: Movie Film comparison compare contrast]

Research Papers
1551 words (4.4 pages)

Essay on Being There: Comparison of Book and Movie

- Being There: Comparison of Book and Movie The book, "Being There," is about a man named Chance, who is forced to move out of the house he lived in his whole life and his experience in the outside world. Based on the success of the book, the movie, "Being There," was made. The author of the book, Jerzy Kosinski, also wrote the screenplay for the movie. I think the major difference between the book and the movie is that in the book, we get to read what Chance is feeling and thinking, but in the movie, we only get to see his actions....   [tags: Being There Literature Movies Essays]

Research Papers
1118 words (3.2 pages)

A Clockwork Orange Essay

- A Clockwork Orange We are first introduced to Alex (Malcolm McDowell) in the company of his posse, strangely sipping drugged milk in a freakish bar with anatomically indiscrete manikins serving as tittie-taps and tables. The ensuing scenes flash from Alex and his three droogs brutally beating an old man to a violent rape scene to a semi-chaotic gang-brawl. The story is of Alex and his love of the old ultra-violence, his act of murder, his betrayal and imprisonment, and his cure (twice). Adapted from Anthony Burgess’ 1962 novel, A Clockwork Orange is in part a response to psychological behaviorism and the age of classical conditioning....   [tags: A Clockwork Orange Essays]

Research Papers
565 words (1.6 pages)

Related Searches

overbearing fear when violent tendencies are encountered.  Since Alex's nature is to respond to situations violently, he is ruined by the conflict between his physical and emotional feelings.

      The climax of the book occurs at the end of Alex's conditioning, when he is made to feel sick by his own true emotions, and he realizes fully that he must change his entire way of life.

      The major difference between the film and the book versions of A Clockwork Orange was the lack of theme or meaning in the film.  The film easily conveyed all aspects of the story's plot and dialogue, but was quite lacking in the conveyance of the thoughts within Alex.  It seemed that without this key part of the book, the film was completely devoid of any merit whatsoever.

      Between the film and book versions of A Clockwork Orange, I prefer the book infinitesimally.  The whole reason Anthony Burgess wrote the book in the first place was to convey a question of morality:  is it justifiable to corrupt the pure nature of a person for the benefit of the greater society?  His epochal query was clearly communicated within the book, but Stanley Kubrick did not even begin to deal with this moral issue in his movie which I perceive as a shallow and strange film which I could not enjoy, knowing that the message behind Burgess' story was not the advocation of blatant violence, as portrayed in the film.

      The climactic scene in the book occurs when Alex has finished his conditioning, and he is displayed as an example of the new technique in criminal reform.  Alex is put on stage in front of government dignitaries, where he proves that he is incapable of committing an act of violence.
 
      In the book, Alex is thrust on stage, where he tries to defend himself against an attacker, but is choked back by the acute nausea he experiences with violence.  With Alex narrating, the reader experiences the main character's thoughts and feelings as his physical body strangles his true emotions and prevents him from acting on them.

      The movie shows the same scene, but without examining any of the psychological aspects of it.  All the viewer sees is Alex being bullied by another man, and unable to fight back, crippled by some unknown internal monster.

      I did not like the film's version of this scene because it did not clearly show what was transpiring within the characters.

      The theme of the book deals with a person's most basic right to be himself.  Burgess questions whether it is right to destroy an individual's self in the interest of society.  He also questions the morality of the government judging what is right or wrong for everyone.

      While these themes were evident throughout the book, they were only once mentioned in the film, by a minor character who appears only once.  I think the film does not deal with theme because it is difficult to impart the thoughts of the main character without changing the plot of the film, which would lead it astray from that of the book.

      The most obvious and powerful symbol in the book was the slang language used by the teens, called "nadsat."  Nadsat has chiefly Russian origins.  Many of the words were chosen because of their forceful sound, as a symbol of the attitude of the nadsats, or teens.  For example, "grahzny bratchny" sounds much more harsh than "dirty bastard," although one is a literal translation of the other.  This is similar to Gene Roddenberry's creation of the Klingon language, which sounds very much like Russian, in his series "Star Trek," although this may have been due to a cold war stereotype.

      This symbol, although it was attempted in the film, did not work well. It seemed that dropping words like "droog, tolchock," and "zooby" in the middle of a sentence of otherwise perfect English only confused the viewer, especially without any reference to the nadsat language.

      A Clockwork Orange, by Anthony Burgess, presents an issue that should be discussed in schools, although the book may be too potent for some.  The film, however, is definitely too focused on plot and the portrayal of destruction and violence, without enough of a focus on theme.  I would recommend reading the book; its social commentary is much more relevant now than when it was written in the sixties.
 

Works Cited and Consulted

Aggeler, Geoffrey.  Anthony Burgess:  The Artist as Novelist.  University:  University of  Alabama, 1979.

Burgess, Anthony. A Clockwork Orange. New York, NY: W W Norton & Company. 1986.

De Vitis, A. A.  Anthony Burgess.  New York:  Twayne Publishers, 1972.


Internet Sources

Beck, Michael and Thomas Waites. Cineman Syndicate. 1979. Received from America Online on April 18, 2003.

Cohen, Alexander J., Clockwork Orange and the Aestheticization of Violence. Accessed April 28, 2003 from the A Clockwork Orange homepage.

Kane, Robert. Selections from The Significance of Free Will. http://www.iusb.edu/~lzynda/scifi/kane.html.

Keckler, Jesse.  "Biography."  A Critical Look at A Clockwork Orange.  27 Nov. 1999. <http://www.geocites.com/Athens/4572>

Skinner, B.F. "Freedom and the Control of Man." http://www.iusb.edu/~lzynda/scifi/skinner.html.

Utting, Bryce. A Clockwork Orange discussion notes. Accessed April 25, 1997 from A Clockwork Orange home page.
Return to 123HelpMe.com