Teaching Language after the Critical Period Has Been Extinguished in A Silent Childhood

Teaching Language after the Critical Period Has Been Extinguished in A Silent Childhood

Length: 795 words (2.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Teaching Language after the Critical Period Has Been Extinguished in A Silent Childhood

Childhood is such a precious, yet trenchant part of life. We all have memories of our days as children along with stories of lessons learned. Childhood is reflected by most as being a time of bliss and enlightenment. As I recall my childhood an avalanche of mixed feelings suffocates me. Would I be able to interpret these feelings if I had not learned language? More importantly, is it possible to teach language after the "critical period" has been extinguished? This is the prominent question that arose in my mind as I read "A Silent Childhood". The researchers' goal was to establish if "Genie" was capable of language after eleven years of isolation. Also, how much of language, if any is innate, and how much is learned?
"Genie"? First of all, that name bothers me. Why in the world would someone name the child "Genie"? Granted, it was during the seventies when these events occurred, however, that is the best name they could conjure up? Webster's dictionary defines a genie as "a supernatural spirit that often takes human form". Were the researchers inferring that they did not view this poor child as human? Why not name her something ladylike and promising like "Hope" or "Heaven". With a child like "Genie" who was deprived of any sort of nurturing and positive reinforcement, I would think the name would be the first place to start in reconciling the child with a positive outlook upon herself and the world. A name like "Genie" gives me the impression that it is going to take magic to repair all the damage that has been done. The article later stated that "Genie" liked when she was described as pretty. Wouldn't it have been great if her name made her feel pretty? Since a name is something one hears hundreds time a day, the repetition of a beautiful name would redirect the negative thoughts that were pounded in her head for so many years.
Speaking of years, "Genie" was thirteen when her mother stumbled into the social welfare office. Scientists don't agree how language is acquired, but they do agree that the first years of life a critical for language. Some scientists even believe that language is almost impossible to learn after the age of seven, six years before "Genie" was brought in for help.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Teaching Language after the Critical Period Has Been Extinguished in A Silent Childhood." 123HelpMe.com. 04 Apr 2020

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay Analysis Of The Movie ' Silent Film '

- The Artist Analysis Introduction Silent film, a nearly extinct cinema genre, has been brought back to life to live out its final moments in the modern age. This art is the original form of cinema that first used the techniques of cinematography and acting to construct a base platform that made the film industry into the success it is today. The Artist is of the romance genre, as it tells the story of a silent film actor trying to survive the progressing technology with the film industry and the invention of the “Talkies” or films with dialog that can be heard and eventually finding his place in the end....   [tags: Film, Silent film, Sound film]

Research Papers
1256 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on Adolescence : A Critical Transitioning Period

- Adolescence marks a critical transitioning period in which individuals undergo through various types of changes such as physical, emotional, and cognitive maturation. Furthermore, many researchers have accounted for spirituality and religiosity as vital assets of development for youth as it provides morals, ideals, and a positive self-image. Spirituality is having an intimate experience of the sacred and divine, while religiosity correlates with organized religion. Religiosity embodies beliefs, practices, and rituals....   [tags: Gender role, Gender, Sociology, God]

Research Papers
1444 words (4.1 pages)

The Critical Period For Language Acquisition Essay

- Age is a significant reason why young individuals are better language learners than adults. Language acquisition affects an individual by their environment, education, and whether they are second language learners. For instance, a young English speaking American child taking Spanish classes at the YMCA will have a better understanding of the Spanish language in the future due to repetition, mixed culture, media, friends, and other influences. Because the child is growing in knowledge of their native language, they will also be able to grow in the concept of another language especially when dually exposed to both....   [tags: Second language, Linguistics]

Research Papers
1568 words (4.5 pages)

Essay The Silent Cinema

- As Richard Abel observes, “The materiality of silent cinema…has become so unfamiliar to us, so different from that of our own cinema in the late twentieth century” that it is difficult to view silent film as anything but anachronistic (4). However, with 2011’s The Artist—an homage to silent film—winning Best Picture at the Academy Awards, it may be worthwhile to examine the nature and appeal of silent film. In a way, silent film does something that the modern day special effects spectaculars do not do: it leaves more to the imagination and calls upon the viewer to use his or her own mind in correspondence with the moving pictures....   [tags: Movies, Entertainment, SIlent Movies, Analysis]

Research Papers
888 words (2.5 pages)

The 's Second Issue With The Critical Period Essay

- Tokudome’s second issue with the critical period stems from if there is a biological explanation to the theory, then it should hold under all but the most unusual of circumstances. In short, if the CP exists, then later learners should physically and neurologically be unable to reach native-like proficiency (Tokudome 23). This is expressed by CPH proponents such as Long who have stated that a native-like accent is impossible without first exposure occurring before age twelve or perhaps age six. They believe native-like pronunciation and native-like grammar are out of reach beyond the critical period (qtd....   [tags: Second language acquisition, Language acquisition]

Research Papers
1667 words (4.8 pages)

Critical Period of Language Acquisition for Children Essay

- The idea of a critical period for language acquisition, first introduced by linguist Eric Lenneberg in 1967, is a popular debate amongst many people. In his initial discovery of the “critical period hypothesis,” Lenneberg stated: “there are maturational constraints on the time a first language can be acquired. First language acquisition relies on neuroplasticity. If language acquisition does not occur by puberty, some aspects of language can be learnt but full mastery cannot be achieved.” Lenneberg also stressed that in the case of bilingual individuals, the critical period is broken into phases....   [tags: Behaviorism, Neuroplasticity]

Research Papers
2410 words (6.9 pages)

Essay on Critical Analysis On Critical Practice

- Define critical practice in academic essay writing It is considered that critics love to take sides. As compelling as it may be, being critical is not about trusting one’s instinct and taking a one-sided decision, but rather investigate, evaluate and consider different opinions and only thereafter cultivate one’s own perspective. In practice, critical thinking can be referred as an ‘active process’ that implies raising questions and finding information yourself, contrasting with the ‘passive process’ of receiving ideas and information from someone else.(Dewey, 1910) The ultimate question is why would a critical approach be better in an academic environment....   [tags: Critical thinking, Thought, Reasoning, Logic]

Research Papers
1314 words (3.8 pages)

Essay about Analysis of Silent Spring by Rachel Carson

- Analysis of Silent Spring by Rachel Carson Silent Spring is a novel written by a woman named Rachel Carson, which was published in 1962. With advance sales of 40 000 copies the book went on to be recognised in 1992 as the most influential book of the last 50 years, and was held in much the same respect and admiration as great works such as Karl Marx's 'Das Capital and Charles Darwin's 'The Origin of Species'. About the book ============== The book takes an in depth look at the hazardous and detrimental consequences of the use of chemical fertilisers and pesticides in not only agriculture, but in other activities particularly leisure....   [tags: Silent Spring Rachel Carson Agriculture Essays]

Research Papers
1277 words (3.6 pages)

Essay about Analysis of Silent Spring by Rachel Carson

- Analysis of Silent Spring by Rachel Carson Review: This book was focused on the concern of pesticides that industries, along with us as individuals, have been dumping (both knowingly and unknowingly) into water. Carson was concerned that the chemicals which the farmers spread on their fields, and even the chemicals we use in our homes (among others), in the end, might come back around and harm us. The beginning of the book tells a story of a place, that was once so beautiful, turned dead and ugly due to a “strange blight that crept over the area” and destroyed everything....   [tags: Silent Spring Rachel Carson Pollution Essays]

Research Papers
714 words (2 pages)

The Critical Period Hypothesis of Language Acquisition Essay

- The Critical Period Hypothesis of Language Acquisition "Ahhhhh!" I yell in frustration. "I've been studying Spanish for seven years, and I still can't speak it fluently." "Well, honey, it's not your fault. You didn't start young enough," my mom says, trying to comfort me. Although she doesn't know it, she is basing her statement on the Critical Period Hypothesis. The Critical Period Hypothesis proposes that the human brain is only malleable, in terms of language, for a limited time. This can be compared to the critical period referred to in to the imprinting seen in some species, such as geese....   [tags: Neurological Languages Learning Essays]

Research Papers
1107 words (3.2 pages)

Behaviorists like B.F. Skinner believed language is learned through imitation, association of sights and sounds of words, and reinforcement. "Genie" was not exposed to any of this. Linguist Noam Chomsky believes that when a child is given the adequate nurture, language just happens to the child. "Genie" was not given the adequate nurture either. Because of this and the terrible condition she was in, I would have taken care of her emotional and physical needs first. Putting her in the hospital was the right idea, but that particular hospital was not the best place. Even though the hospital was well known, it was perhaps too well known. There was a tremendous amount of commotion and this is exactly what "Genie" didn't need. I would have put her hospital that was smaller and less well known. The fact that "competition for access to "Genie" was fierce" by the researchers was something that should not have taken place. It appeared that many people were more concerned with their personal gains rather that the well being of the child.
Anyone concerned about "Genie's" well being would have tired to get her out the hospital as soon as possible into a stable family. Visits from her mother was a great idea, but Irene was incapable of taking care of a child with so many needs; even after Irene's therapy (which did not accomplish that much). I would have let "Genie stay in the hospital only long enough to find her a nurturing, stable home. She didn't need to get attached to a place where she would leave in a short while. She did get attached to the cooks and the handy man at the Rehabilitation Center. Being moved from Jean Butler's, back to the Rehabilitation center, to the Ringler's, to her mother's, and to foster homes was detrimental to any progress that was made. I would have let her stay with Jean Butler.
"Genie had gone from being 'the most promising case study of the twentieth century' to being, in Rigler's words, 'perhaps one of the most tested children in history.'" I realize that the studies were beneficial to both "Genie" and the human race, but I strongly believe the testing was excessive. Even though the tests were like a game and even though "Genie" preferred adults to children, she should have been able to have some sort of a normal childhood. I think too much studying was done and not enough caring was done. "Genie" needed more one-on-one time. She needed stability and the reassurances that she could act out and express herself. She only expressed herself to someone when she was used to him or her. She also stopped her "constipation" when she was used to staying somewhere. Because her environment was not threatening, she didn't have to feel like she needed to control something (her bowels and her expression).
I would have placed her with a family that agreed to adopt her for life (preferably Jean Butler). She would have had a home health aid to make sure she continued to be healthy and maybe do some physical therapy to ease her development. I would have let Susan Curtiss observe and visit maybe three to four hours a day and any other research would have to be limited to just two days a week for two to three hours. Visits from her mother are very important so she could visit her mother whenever time permitted. I think putting her in school was also a great idea. I would have placed her in school as soon as possible. It's hard to say if "Genie" would have been able to live independently, but that would have been my goal.
It is truly a shame that there was "competition" to study "Genie", but when she was living with her mother, and she needed help hardly anyone could be found. It is also unfair that out of all the money that went to study her, almost none of it went to the benefit her or her mother. Why is "Genie" now living in a home for adults who are retarded when she is not retarded? Did everyone just give up on her?

"I have neither given or received nor have I tolerated the use of unauthorized aid."
Return to 123HelpMe.com