The Controversy Over the Brown Spruce Longhorn Beetle

The Controversy Over the Brown Spruce Longhorn Beetle

Length: 535 words (1.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
The Controversy Over the Brown Spruce Longhorn Beetle

A little bug is causing a big debate amongst government officials and citizens in the Halifax municipality. The little pest in particular is known as the brown spruce longhorn beetle, and this beetle, native to Europe and believed to have arrived on a container ship about a decade ago, is threatening to ruin Halifax's largest and busiest park, and could have the potential to ruin all of Nova Scotia's, and even Canada's, vast forest is action is not taken.
In order to hault the infestation, the Federal Court has given the Canadian Food Inspection Agency permission to cut down as many as 10 000 red spruce trees, many of which are not yet infested at all. Environmental activists such as the Coalition known as "Friends of Point Pleasant Park", greatly oppose this idea, and have raised the issue of scientific uncertainty.
The question of scientific uncertainty is a predominant issue in the fierce debate towards the cutting. In particular, even though the beetle may have arrived as much as a decade ago, it's harmful effects have only been recognized recently. There simply has not been enough research done to see if the beetle is a problem or if cutting down a whole park is the way to solve it. There is no guarantee that the beetle will cause that much harm or destruction. Sure, scientists would like to better understand the situation, which would require long term studies, but these studies are impractical and almost impossible to perform. We simply can not wait a year to see the effects (if any) the longhorn beetle has, because as with any infestations, humans find it difficult to sit on their hands and watch: especially when a major natural resource, such as trees, is involved.
Another scientific uncertainty is that nature is diverse, and understanding is always tentative. Since Point Pleasant Park is isolated in its location by being surrounded by water on three sides and the city on the fourth, it is unlike almost all other forests in the nearby area. Perhaps stronger trees in the wild are better able to cope with the beetle, and also the fact the forest contains more beetle predators, like woodpeckers and other birds, unlike the unique conditions that prevail in the park.
An additional scientific uncertainty lies in the fact that the scientists analyzing the park's situation all work for the government, meaning they are going to say what the government wants to do.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"The Controversy Over the Brown Spruce Longhorn Beetle." 09 Dec 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Effect Of Seed Biomass On Beetle Biomass Gain Essays

- In order to fully understanding of our data, the results are organized in three subsections: the beetle morphological traits results in which we assessed general data about species and sex abundance, morphological traits (i.e., tibia length, femur lengths and beetle biomass) and the sampling events and sites; the interplay between beetle’s morphological traits and host plant traits results in which we assessed the relationship among morphological traits and between resources traits; and finally the laboratory experiment where we investigated the effects of seed biomass on beetle biomass gain (for each sex), and its consequences on individual longevities....   [tags: Sex, Female, Male, Beetle]

Research Papers
1034 words (3 pages)

Essay on Guam and Rhino Beetle

- Nature is a balancing act. When a certain balance of a simple, natural ecosystem is disrupted, it becomes dangerously unstable. This is exactly what happened, and is currently happening, to the island of Guam. This two hundred and nine square mile island has a very simple ecosystem. The only native mammal here is the Mariana fruit bat (Miller). Consequently, when human development started on Guam its animal kingdom started to become quite unstable. For example, the brown tree snake has wiped out half of the bird population and is currently downsizing the population of rats....   [tags: nature, ecosystem, Palau, palm tree]

Research Papers
1405 words (4 pages)

Brown v. Board of Education Essay

- Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka, Kansas was a milestone in American history, as it began the long process of racial integration, starting with schools. Segregated schools were not equal in quality, so African-American families spearheaded the fight for equality. Brown v. Board stated that public schools must integrate. This court decision created enormous controversy throughout the United States. Without this case, the United States may still be segregated today. Although the Fourteenth Amendment, when adopted in 1868, gave certain rights to blacks, including citizenship, equal protection of law and other freedoms, African-Americans were considered inferior by whites in this country....   [tags: Brown v. Board of Education]

Research Papers
1158 words (3.3 pages)

The Da Vinci Code By Dan Brown Essay

- “The son of a mathematics teacher and a church organist, Dan Brown was raised on a prep school campus where he developed a fascination with the paradoxical interplay between science and religion. These themes eventually formed the backdrop for the Da Vinci Code.” (Greenburger, "Dan Brown") The story goes Leonardo da Vinci was a member of a secret society known as the Priory of Sion and hid secret symbols in his paintings that give away the secret of the holy grail. Religious symbology expert Dr....   [tags: The Da Vinci Code, Mary Magdalene, Dan Brown]

Research Papers
1222 words (3.5 pages)

Essay about The Vaccination Controversy

- ANA CEO and nurse Myrtle Aydelotte once said, “Nursing encompasses an art, a humanistic orientation, a feeling for the value of the individual, and an intuitive sense of ethics, and of the appropriateness of action taken”.1 In preparing to develop my own nursing practice, I find this statement to be invaluable. It is this philosophy which has guided my educational and experiential journey from scientific evidence and statistics alone, to include patient relationship and ethical understanding. My first exposure to the “Vaccine Controversy” occurred in my biology undergraduate....   [tags: nursing, vaccine controversy, informed consent]

Research Papers
2233 words (6.4 pages)

The Great Controversy according to Young Goodman Brown Essay

- In our own Christian struggles, people tend to believe that it is simple as good evil. People don't realize however that in this fight, the Devil can infiltrate a seemingly normal, Christian Human Being, but it's true. Better yet, in our own walk with God the Devil lurks near to test what might look like a strong relationship with Christ. As shown in Nathaniel Hawthorne's "Young Goodman Brown," even a grounded, sincere Christian can have his or her faith tested. Hawthorne's story refers to Brown's travel companion as 'the serpent,'; and though the story is allegory based the story itself raises an age old battle that is being fought to this day, the great controversy....   [tags: Free Essay Writer]

Free Essays
571 words (1.6 pages)

Essay on Psychological and Formal Analysis of Young Goodman Brown

- Psychological and Formal Analysis of Young Goodman Brown Young Goodman Brown by Nathaniel Hawthorne provides the reader with a unique insight into the lives of people in an early Puritan community. By the use of psychological and formal analysis, we capture a deeper sense of the story of a young man's struggle between his undeniable desires and his morality. Freud speculated that the repression of our sub consciousness and that, which we are unaware of, is manifested into the id, ego, and superego....   [tags: Young Goodman Brown YGB]

Research Papers
968 words (2.8 pages)

The Volkswagen Beetle Essay example

- The people's car &#8211; generically, Volkswagen in German &#8211; is almost as old as the automobile, and the type was familiar in Germany long before the advent of the Volkswagen. Usually these 'popular'; cars were minimal cars, though size and simplicity did not necessarily bring them within the reach of the ordinary man in the street. Henry Ford did build a successful universal car, to sell at a low price, but his Model T with its 2.9-litre engine was by no means a small car, nor was the Model A that followed it....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1162 words (3.3 pages)

Essay about Microsoft Window Longhorn

- In 2006, Microsoft is slated to release a new version of its Windows operating system. “Longhorn” is the code name for the next version of Windows. This generation of software will include new versions of Windows, Windows Server, .NET, MSN, Microsoft Office, and other products. Microsoft labels the key new technologies as "The Pillars of Longhorn," which are: • Fundamentals: new developments to the basic structure of the operating system including the .NET framework, further support for digital rights management (DRM), an application deployment engine ("ClickOnce"), improvements to the installation of applications (Windows Installer/MSI 4.0), and the Trustworthy Comp...   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
804 words (2.3 pages)

New beetle Essay

- Case9 : New Beetle EXTERNAL ANALYSIS 1. Market definition New beetle is competing in the small size car industry in the US market. 2. Market size In US market, the total of small car sales in 2,217,813 units, which is equivalent to 32 million dollar. Market size in dollar term = 2,217,813 * ($11,035 to $18,000) = $ 32 million In 1998, New beetle sales is 137,885 units, which is 6 percent of the market. Market share in 1998 = 137,885 = 6 percent. 2,217,813 3. Market growth The industry is considered to be in the position between the growth and maturity stage....   [tags: essays research papers]

Research Papers
2378 words (6.8 pages)

Many scientists outside the government claim that there is no proof the beetle is the serious threat to the park's red spruce that authorities claim, and that the prevention measures are futile.
Besides the high level of scientific uncertainty, other factors that are going to influence the outcome to this conflict can be found on economic, environmental, and political levels. Economically, the federal government would be wasting an incredible amount of money in cutting down 10 000 trees, an amount that many people argue could be better spent in other areas such as healthcare. Also, once the trees are cut down, who is going to finance the planting of new trees? This question has yet to be answered.
Environmentally, how will the loss of 10 000 red spruce trees affect other plants and animals in the park? The cutting has the potential to cause a chain-reaction effect, as animal's habitats would be altered immensely.
Politically, the impact of cutting will affect everybody who lives near the park or visits it. With cutting down 10 000 trees, there will be a lack of privacy for houses located on the fringes of the park, as before, they provided a year-round natural barrier from busy sections of the park. The park would loose much of it's beauty if the trees were cut, and this one-time "sanctuary" would be turned into an inhospitable grasslands.
Obviously, additional research will solve this problem of scientific uncertainty, yet, as some scientists have stated, this small bug has the potential to ruin one of Canada's largest natural resources, so it is unlikely that long-term research will be performed. The decision to cut may not be a popular choice by activists, yet this little bug could put the province's billion dollar forest industry, and possibly Canada's, in jeporady.
Return to