War Poetry Analysis

War Poetry Analysis

Length: 1346 words (3.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
War Poetry Analysis

There are many different approaches to war in the poetry I have read.
Some are very jingoistic and strongly encourage conscription. They use
a wide range of colloquial language and often use puns to play on the
emotions of the reader and make their poems more interesting. A good
example of a poem of this type is, "Who's for the Game?" by Jessie
Pope. This kind of war poetry has often been criticised by other poets
with a more serious and realistic view to war. One of the most famous
war poets, Wilfred Owen has a completely different approach. Having
been a soldier in the war, his work was greatly influenced by all the
death and suffering he had experienced. This gives a less idealistic
view, based more on fact, not encouraging people to enlist. The third
poem I have chosen shows a more modern opinion particularly to nuclear
war. It is completely different to both of the other poems I have
chosen because it is about a slightly different issue. It is also very
anti- war but unlike Owen it does not dwell on death and fear but
tells us how quickly the world could end.

"Who's for the Game?" is completely different to "Dulce et Decorum
est" and "Icarus Allsorts" as it takes the totally opposite approach
to war by encouraging people to enlist and is very positive about the
whole idea of war by portraying it as, "The red crashing game of a
fight." Jessie Pope uses rhetorical questions to make the reader
examine their conscience and draw them into the poem by asking them,"
Who'll tackle the job unafraid?" and "Who wants a seat in the stand?"
This plays with the readers emotions and makes them feel guilty if
they do not want to go and fight for England as it "is looking and
calling for" recruits. The poet gives a very idealistic view on the
soldiers injuries by saying," Who would rather come back with a crutch
than lie low and be out of the fun?" when we all know that this would

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"War Poetry Analysis." 123HelpMe.com. 28 Feb 2020
    <https://www.123helpme.com/view.asp?id=119963>.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

War Poetry Analysis Essay

- War Poetry Analysis There are many different approaches to war in the poetry I have read. Some are very jingoistic and strongly encourage conscription. They use a wide range of colloquial language and often use puns to play on the emotions of the reader and make their poems more interesting. A good example of a poem of this type is, "Who's for the Game?" by Jessie Pope. This kind of war poetry has often been criticised by other poets with a more serious and realistic view to war....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
1346 words (3.8 pages)

Analysis Of Wilfred Owen 's War Poetry Essay

- Wilfred Owen’s war poetry examines the intense and extraordinary human experience of war. His body of work is clearly concerned with unveiling the real atrocities and devastation wreaked by war, as well as elucidating the falsity manifested by war propaganda. Owen’s poem illuminates the severe and debilitating effect war has upon the young, examining the painful way in which these young soldiers were left to die. ’Dulce Et Decorum Est’, subverts traditional perceptions of war as being honourable, by graphically portraying the debilitating and traumatic consequences of war on the young innocent soldiers....   [tags: Dulce et decorum est pro patria mori]

Research Papers
1472 words (4.2 pages)

Essay Analysis of Bruce Dawe's Anti-War Poem, Homecoming

- An anti-war poem inspired by the events of the Vietnam War, Homecoming inspires us to think about the victims of the war: not only the soldiers who suffered but also the mortuary workers tagging the bodies and the families of those who died in the fighting. The author, Australian poet Bruce Dawe, wrote the poem in response to a news article describing how, at Californian Oaklands Air /Base, at one end of the airport families were farewelling their sons as they left for Vietnam and at the other end the bodies of dead soldiers were being brought home....   [tags: Poem Analysis, Poetry, Vietnam War]

Research Papers
1412 words (4 pages)

The Reality of War and Death Depicted in Owen's Poem, Dulce Et Decorum Est

- If we look at the history of the world with a kaleidoscope, we can see the different aspects of war and what effect it had on the mind of different people and artists such as poets, painters and authors. Many poets romanticized war, luring it with their pen and giving it a beautiful look by glorifying death and obliging young blood to fight for their motherland. For example the poems “Peace” by Rupert Brooke and “Fall In” by Harold Begbie painted war with the highlights of glamorous and sensation....   [tags: Poem Analysis, War Poem, Poetry]

Research Papers
1091 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Owen’s Implied Meaning in Anthem for Doomed Youth

- The poem “Anthem for Doomed Youth” by Wilfred Owen is a very depressing and sad piece of literature. It is not focused on a single person or directed toward one person, but focuses first on the sounds that create a sad, lonely lament for dying soldiers and later turns toward those who are left behind by the soldiers. The meaning, philosophy, and emotion behind Wilfred Owen’s poem demonstrate his own life struggles. He was an enlisted soldier who fought in World War I and experienced the horrific images his poem impresses upon the reader....   [tags: Poetry Analysis, War]

Research Papers
1110 words (3.2 pages)

Owen's Dulce et decorum est Pro patria mori Essay

- Through the use of poetry, we are able to powerfully discuss an idea or opinion about certain topics that could not be so eloquently conveyed through other literary media. Wilfred Owen was both a Soldier Poet during WWI. He was a man firmly against the idea of sending young boys off to war with the promise of glory. His views of war and the gruesome reality that it is, is deeply rooted within this poem and emphasized though the use of vivid imagery, persuasive similes and carefully constructed figurative language....   [tags: Poetry Analysis War]

Research Papers
1357 words (3.9 pages)

Essay on Wilfred Owen's Attitude Towards World War 1 As Shown In His Poetry

- What is Wilfred Owen’s attitude towards Worlds War 1 and how is this shown through his poetry. You should comment upon and compare at least two of his poems and describe the tone he writes in the imagery he uses and the poetical techniques he includes to convey his opinions. Wilfred Owen was born in Shropshire on 18th March 1893. He was the son of a railway worker and was educated at schools in Shrewsbury and Liverpool. Wilfred was encouraged to write poetry from an early age by his devoted mother....   [tags: Poetry Analysis]

Research Papers
2295 words (6.6 pages)

Essay about Attitude of World War I Poets Towards War

- It is interesting when discussing WW1 poetry to examine how attitudes to war at the time may have influenced the poets. Before WW1 war was generally viewed as a positive thing. Many young men followed a career in the army and saw it as something of an adventure. The horrors of WW1 changed many people’s attitudes to war, the mechanisation of warfare led to millions of casualties and this resulted into a general realisation that war wasn’t a glorious adventure. Many soldiers wrote powerful poems about the reality of war as they wanted the truth to be known....   [tags: Poetry Analysis]

Research Papers
1643 words (4.7 pages)

War Photographer Essays

- ‘’War Photographer’’ is a thought-provoking and mind gripping poem by Carol Ann Duffy. The poem revolves around the life of the photographer as he juggles between his two personas as he try to develop his photos and reminisce about the war torn countries, all the innocent people and the horrific and gory things he has witnessed. As the poem progresses and the pictures begin to develop the memories of pain and suffering from his past starts to unravel and becomes clearer and clearer. The main message the writer is trying to convey is the fact that through modern times news about the war is being published by the media in a truthful way that people feel less sympathy towards the innocent live...   [tags: Poetry Analysis]

Research Papers
1581 words (4.5 pages)

A Poem Analysis Of Hearing That His Friend Was Coming Back From The War by Wang Chien

- In this poem, the poet describes a contemporary war which was more intense than those in the old days and the hopelessness for soldiers to come back from the war. When the speaker got the news that his friend, who saw service in that war, was coming back, he was then in an emotional conflict between the eagerness to see his friend returning from the war and the worry about if his friend was still alive or not because he understood the cruelty of the war. A possible theme of this poem is the senselessness of the war and the hopelessness for soldiers to escape from that intense war....   [tags: Poem Poetry Analysis]

Free Essays
1458 words (4.2 pages)

not be the case and that far more serious injuries would be obtained
during battle. I find this poem both naïve and above all, very ironic
as being a woman, Jessie Pope had no idea of what war was like as she
had never experienced it. All she knew was that Britain was
apparently, "up to her neck in a fight."

Jessie Popes' use of colloquial language is both persuasive and at the
same time quite amusing as she portrays war as a game, and this is
almost laughable in its own right as everyone knows that war is most
definitely not a game and I pity the people who enlisted after being
inspired by this poem as they were seriously mislead! The poem has
good rhythmic quality and is easy to read so it would appeal to any
person of any age or class. I think Jessie Pope aimed the poem at the
younger generation who could be easily influenced by war being
portrayed as a game. They would not know any better as they would most
probably never experienced war or know anyone who had so they were
relying on a naïve and ironically minded woman who had as much
knowledge on war, if not less than they already did! This a very
optimistic poem that could very easily have a great effect on a mans
ego by making them think about how they would feel if they had a seat
in the stand or didn't have the chance to come back from war as a
glorified hero and were made to feel like a coward by their families
and friends.

"Dulce et Decorum est" portrays a very pessimistic yet more realistic
view of war by describing how "Bent double, like old beggars under
sacks, knock- kneed, coughing like hags" they trudged through the
sludge. I feel that Wilfred Owens account of what war was like is a
far more reliable source than "Who's for the Game?" as Owen actually
fought in the war so he would have known what it was like more then
anyone. Wilfred Owen is famous for his disapproval of poets such as
Jessie Pope who glamorised war by making it seem trivial and making
people feel guilty and a disappointment to their country for not
wanting to fight.

Owen produced a more realistic portrayal of the injuries that could be
obtained during war. He informs his readers that death during war is
not glamorous or heroic. He talks of the man who "[drowned] under a
green sea" of gas. His death was by no means glamorous as it was slow,
painful and humiliating. He seems to be putting people off the idea of
fighting in a war by describing all of what seems to be the worst
parts instead of the best. He also mocks the idea that it is sweet and
wonderful to die for your country.

The poet describes war to be as "obscene as cancer." This is a far cry
from the fun game that war seemed to be insinuating by Jessie Pope.
Owen uses adjectives to express his views on war and seemed to be
greatly influenced by all the death he experienced during his time as
a soldier. This is the completely opposite approach tothe one taken by
Jessie Pope who seems to think that the worst injury to be sustained
during war would be to break a few bones and need a crutch. She seemed
to have no concept of the seriousness of war where as Owen did. I
think a lot of soldiers who have experienced the reality of war can
relate to "Dulce et Decorum est" as it is based on fact not fiction.

Wilfred Owens use of language had a great impact on me, the reader
when I read this poem as his use of vocabulary is shockingly bitter
and blunt. Even though I had no idea of what it would be like to
experience war, I already knew I did not want to when I read it. Owen
uses very negative words such as obscene, cancer, old beggars, hags
and many more to describe how he feels about war. The poem has less
rhythm than "Who's for the Game?" which immediately makes the poem
more serious and even though it does not rhyme, some of the lines are
very memorable for what they say, not how they are said.

Wilfred Owens use of emotive language is portrayed in a different
context to the emotive language used by Jessie Pope. I do not feel he
uses it to manipulate his readers the way Pope does; he is more of an
informative poet and does not manipulate his readers to make them
think the same as him.

"Icarus Allsorts" had a very modern approach to war favoured by
activists who demonstrated against nuclear war in the nineteen-
sixties. It has a strong rhythm and adopts the style of a nursery
rhyme which proves to be effective. The way in which the poet
expresses the true devastation and reality of nuclear war through a
nursery rhyme style had a great impact on me as a reader as it made me
realise that all our problems and woes seem so trivial compared to
nuclear war as it affects everyone on the planet no matter what
gender, nationality or religion. I like the way the poem describes how
"the king was in the counting house counting all his money, the queen
was in the parlour eating bread and honey" when the bomb hit and made
them all go "funny" and when it says," in the time it takes to draw a
breath." This proved to be most effective as again it shows how
quickly a bomb can hit letting no one escape. It also had a very
worthwhile and effective ending when it described how many people
would have been killed due to the bomb being set of at the touch of a
button!

This poem differentiates immensely from "Who's for the Game?" as it
has a totally different viewpoint on war. The fact that both poems
were written at different times and about different aspects of war
also made it difficult to trace any similarities between the two! One
similarity I did discover between the two was that both poems have
titles that lack seriousness and fail to have any link to war in the
slightest. Icarus Allsorts was a man who built a wax aeroplane that
melted when he flew too near the sun, and everyone knew that war was
most definitely not a game. "Who's for the Game?" expresses an
optimistic and more idealistic view to war than "Icarus Allsorts" but
the rhythmic language i similar between the two. Pope's poem
encouraged people to enlist where as "Icarus Allsorts" stressed how
the world could end in the event of a nuclear attack. They are
different in a sense that "Who's for the Game?" strongly favoured war
when "Icarus Allsorts" was strongly against it. Both poets used very
different styles of writing to portray their views to the readers;
Roger McGough used strong colloquial language and a "flowery" style to
express his anti nuclear war views, where as Jessie Pope used less
colloquial language and a more idealistic style to describe her
optimistically minded views on enlistment.

I find "Icarus Allsorts" extremely ironic due to the misinterpretation
of the bomb being set off when it was actually a meteorite. It is also
very superficial compared to "Dulce et Decorum est" as it lacked
seriousness and fulfilment when compared to a poem written by Wilfred
Owen. "Icarus Allsorts" and "Dulce et Decorum est" have slightly
different contexts as Owens' is written about first hand experience in
fighting in a war where as McGough's is about the effects of nuclear
war from an activists view point. Both poets use of language and
structure of their poems are very different. "Dulce et Decorum est"
has less rhythm than "Icarus Allsorts" and stronger, more hard-
hitting adjectives are used to portray the image where as McGough uses
rhymes to make his poem more memorable. Owens more realistic portrayal
of war is opposed by McGough's nursery- rhyme style as it seems a very
trivial and disrespectful way to describe a far more serious matter
such as nuclear war as at least with a war such as World War two. It
is awful that so many soldiers died but the war itself did not wipe
out every living thing on the planet!

Overall, I feel I have benefited from my experience in studying war
poetry as it has made me more aware of the different styles and ways
in which poetry can be written and how poets can get their views
across by using methods such as making it sound like a nursery rhyme
in the style of Roger McGough or disillusioning the reader by saying
that war is one thing when it is actually another in the style of
Jessie Pope. I have a deeper understanding of this style of poetry and
wish to extend this knowledge further in the future!
Return to 123HelpMe.com