Evaluating the News Story About the Kilshaws Adopting Twin Babies
In the week of the 16th of January 2001, Judith and Alan Kilshaw from
Flintshire, North Wales decided to tell the tale of their
controversial adoption of the "Internet Twins", to the Sun. This
turned out to be a big mistake for them and their recently adopted
twins, Belinda and Kimberley. The stories that ensued described the
Internet baby industry "lurid" by some magazines, and follow-up
stories labelled the Kilshaws as a "dirty, eccentric couple who aren't
at all fit to be parents". Shortly after the story got out, social
workers in Flintshire took the twins into custody and a judge later
ruled that they should "remain in the care of the local authority"
while courts in both the USA and the UK decided the fate of the
"Internet Twins".
One question we could ask is where the "Internet Twins" really belong
but the first question we should ask is who is most to blame for the
fact that these two American born, eight month old "Internet twins"
are now in the care of British Social Services?
The first person we would think of would be the natural mother of the
twins, Tranda Wecker. She was the one who put her two youngest
children up for adoption in the first place. She was the woman who
sold her babies to one family (the Allens), via the Internet, for
$6,000 because she was going through a divorce and did not have the
money to bring them up, then deceived the Allens so that she could
take the babies and sell them again (for $12,500) to the Kilshaws. Now
she has decided that she wants her babies back again. The idea of
parents making money from putting their babies up for adoption is an
awful idea. You can't pay money for a person because people are not
things that can be bought and sold, each person has a life and you
can't buy and sell life. If you look at Tranda Wecker as that kind of
Patrick Lee and Robert P. George’s, “The Wrong of Abortion” is a contentious composition that argues the choice of abortion is objectively unethical. Throughout their composition, Lee and George use credibility and reason to appeal the immorality of abortions. The use of these two methods of persuasion are effective and compels the reader to consider the ethical significance. Lee and George construct their argument by disputing different theories that would justify abortions. They challenge the ontological and evaluation theories of the fetus, as well as the unintentional killing theory. This article was obtained through Google, in the form of a PDF file that is associated with Iowa State University.
Judith Jarvis Thomson, a 20th century philosopher, offers her argument defending abortion in her paper, “A Defense of Abortion”. She states initially that the fetus has a right to life, although contrary to her argument, she uses it as a premise to develop her thoughts. In short, Thomson says that the fetus’s right to life does not outweigh the woman’s right to control her body. She forces readers to participate in a thought experiment as she gives an odd example about a violinist suffering from kidney failure. The violist is facing death and in order to prevent it, he needs your help. Because you are the only one with his blood type, you are the only hope for him. You have been kidnapped by the Society of Music lovers and, without your consent, hooked up to him and you are filtering his blood and keeping him alive. In order to save his life, you must remain connected to him and support him for nine whole months. Thomson then asks if it is morally wrong to disagree to remain connected to the violinist. It is quite noble to agree to save the man’s life but should his right to life automatically force you to sacrifice nine months of yours?
government. It also marks the beginning of one of the biggest conspiracies still being investigated
Throughout the years, modern medical technology has resulted in the recent legalization of abortions throughout many countries in the world. However, the process of terminating a pregnancy has been around since the time women were able to have babies. Though the court has permitted selective abortion, many believe that it is murder and disagree with anyone with a “pro-choice” view. Sidney Callahan, the author of the article “Abortion and the Sexual Agenda” fights all points made by Harrison and Petchesky and believes pregnant women do not have the right to control another body. In a case study about a family who finds themselves unexpectedly pregnant with their third child, Callahan would support the pregnancy and agree with Bob Thompson in
Surrogate pregnancy was talked about and questioned in the early 1970’s but was not put into practice until 1976. The first case documented actually comes from the bible. It was the story of Abraham and Sarah. Sarah talks about her experience with infertility. She then turns to Hagar, her handmaiden, and asks her if she would carry their child for them since she was unable to. Hagar was their maid so in a way it was a command, not exactly a favor or question.
A responsibility is something for which one is held accountable. Often people say that one is responsible for one’s own words and actions; if something happens as a result of something one does one is responsible for it. But is it possible that something could be the result of various actions from different people who are therefore equally responsible, or is there always one person who is most responsible for the incident at hand? Such a situation where this question is relevant is present in the novel A Separate Peace by John Knowles. In the novel, the main character, Gene, ponders his responsibility for the death of his best friend, Phineas or Finny. After reading Gene’s account of the events that led to Finny’s death the reader may observe that there are three people who are all partially at fault for Finny’s death. Gene, a classmate named Brinker, and Phineas all had something to do with the incident, but who was most responsible for it?
actually pulled the trigger, but i think there are other people who actually caused the
In the article ”An Unlikely Second Mom” the author Orubba Almansouri describes a personal relationship between two woman from very different upbringings that can relate and vent in a healthy way. Almansouri talks about the times they shared from childhood into her becoming an adult.t The author met Layla when she was only the age of 5 and she moved from the middle east to America.Layla worked in almonsouris fathers store.Although orubba’s family felt she was becoming Americanized,Layla understood her and her foreign experiences, unlike her
The Federal government should not be held accountable for funneling so much support to a CA problem
Abortion is the ending of a pregnancy before the fetus has the ability to survive outside of the womb. There are two sides to abortion: Pro-life and Pro-choice. The poem “The Mother” by Gwendolyn Brooks is about a mother who has had more than one abortion and is thinking about the lives she took away from them.
question in many peoples mind through out the nation, “How big of a problem is
On March 11, 1997, US Senate and House Committees met jointly to hear testimony on "Partial-Birth Abortion: The Truth." The following testimony was presented by Helen Alvare, director of Planning and Information of the NCCB, specifying the lack of accuracy, if not purposeful lies, of the media regarding this abortion technique:
There were many wrongs committed in "MacBeth." But who should bear the major responsibility for these actions? The witches' prophesising? Lady MacBeth's scheming and persuasion? Or should MacBeth himself be held responsible? No doubt the witches and lady MacBeth influenced MacBeth in the course of action he took in his rise to power, but ultimately he must bear the major responsibility for his fate.
the radio. Should we, even take a stance on this issue when we have no idea
Before looking at the issue of if some people are more to blame than others we must first look the reasons in which people may commit crimes and the type of crimes. There are a variety of reasons for a person to commit a crime including greed, to be famous, need for money, pure hate, and insanity. The crimes in which they commit range from murder, robberies, or rape.