Evaluating the Success of the League of Nations

Evaluating the Success of the League of Nations

Length: 921 words (2.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Evaluating the Success of the League of Nations

The League of Nations was formed in 1919 to encourage the member
countries to co-operate in trade, improve social conditions, complete
disarmament and to protect any member country that was being
threatened with war. The League of Nations was the initial idea of
Woodrow Wilson, the president of the USA, and was formed to make sure
such world atrocities like the First World War never happened again.
However, we know that a Second World War with even greater loss of
life took place, and therefore most people conclude that the League of
Nations failed. But why did the League fail?
The League of Nations had many 'design' weaknesses; with probably the
most important and noticeable weakness was the absence of the USA. It
was a great shock and disappointment for the rest of the world when
the American people voted for a 'policy of isolation', and despite the
campaigning of Woodrow Wilson, decided not to join the League of
Nations. This can be considered a great weakness because the USA was
becoming the most powerful and influential country in the world, and
therefore the League would probably be unwilling to make a decision
which would go against the USA, and it would also mean that a country
inside the League, who had trade sanctions placed upon them would
still be free to trade with the USA.
The League of Nations also seemed to have a weakness in not accepting
Germany in the League when it was first formed. This gave the
impression that the League was for the 'winners' of WWI, with Britain
and France part of the inner council, and kept the German people
bitter and still wanting revenge.
Another weakness of the League was that it did not have an army of its
own, and that if it wanted an army to stand up to a troublesome
country, it must raise an army from member countries. This became
ineffective, as many member countries were very unwilling to raise an
army and physically challenge a country, as they were afraid that it

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Evaluating the Success of the League of Nations." 123HelpMe.com. 05 Dec 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Evaluating the Success of the League of Nations Essay

- Evaluating the Success of the League of Nations The twentieth century continued the traditional cycle that had emerged after the Treaty of Westphalia in 1648. Periods of warfare were followed by periods of idealism and of nations striving for world unity with the goal of never allowing another war to happen. The century had barely begun when war broke out in Europe. A series of alliances and political assurances quickly thrust all the major nations in Europe together in what became known as the Great War....   [tags: Papers]

Research Papers
1529 words (4.4 pages)

Essay The Failure Of The League Of Nations

- This essay is interested in addressing the argument made by ‘liberal idealists’ in the inter-war period of the prospects for designing international institutions to reduce or eliminate the probability of war. The essay will discuss the failure of the League of Nations in maintaining international peace and security; and how this lead the allied powers of World War 2 to work toward the creation of an international institution that would be more efficient and powerful in the establishment of international peace and security....   [tags: United Nations, World War II, League of Nations]

Research Papers
1442 words (4.1 pages)

The League Of Nations : A Flawed International Organization Essay

- The League of Nations has been seen as a seriously flawed international organisation and its failure to prevent World War Two has been well documented. Provide something of an alternative perspective by identifying and highlighting important policy-areas in which the League made valuable progress. The League of Nations was an Intergovernmental Organisation which persisted from 1919 up until 1946 where it was formally replaced with the United Nations towards the end of the Second World War. Many consider the League as one of the International Systems greatest failures due to it being widely regarded as an ‘ineffective instrument to tackle aggressors’ (Catterall, 1999, p....   [tags: League of Nations, World War II, Woodrow Wilson]

Research Papers
1453 words (4.2 pages)

The League Of Nations By President Woodrow Wilson Essay

- The League of Nations sounds like a superhero team and in a sense, the goal that The League was trying to achieve could have been something straight out of a comic book. Originally proposed by President Woodrow Wilson during World War I, The League was born after some alterations. The League of Nations’ main intention was to bring an end to the war and prevent another one of the same atrocious proportions from happening in the future. Forty zealous countries joined this fight, but the most powerful country of all was not among them: The United States of America....   [tags: World War II, United States, League of Nations]

Research Papers
750 words (2.1 pages)

The Treaty Of Versailles Should Be Drafted And The League Of Nations Essay

- Each of the major Allied leaders had extremely contrasting outlooks on how the Treaty of Versailles should be drafted and the League of Nations should carry out its duties. While all of the Allied nations shared the belief that Germany should be punished for its involvement in the provocation of war, each belief was to varying degrees. These outlooks were generated by the nations’ experience of the War, where the severity of the outlook corresponded to the severity of the devastation they were subjected to....   [tags: League of Nations, World War II]

Research Papers
1587 words (4.5 pages)

The United Nations And The League Of Nations Essay

- The United Nations and its predecessor, The League of Nations, are both Intergovernmental Organisations that have had a large impact in the realm of international politics, and the course it has followed during the twentieth and twenty first century. Both were formed out of the aftermath of devastating World Wars, which have helped define the goals, powers and functions that both the League and United Nations held. This has impacted the way these organisations have run, and how successful they have been in achieving what they have set out to do....   [tags: World War II, United Nations, World War I]

Research Papers
1976 words (5.6 pages)

United States Effect on the League of Nations Essay

- ... The assembly of nations did a fantastic job at the outset. The United Nations first step into a major conflict was in 1950 when the Communist regime of North Korea invaded South Korea. On June 25th 1950 at four in the morning the military forces of North Korea crossed over the border into South Korea. The main force of North Korea’s attack focused their attack on the capital of South Korea, Seoul. While two smaller forces of Northerners attacked the eastern cities of Yoju and Wonju. An emergency session of the U.N....   [tags: protect, nations, peacekeeper, war]

Research Papers
2250 words (6.4 pages)

Assessment of the Success of the League of Nations Essays

- Assessment of the Success of the League of Nations In 1914 war broke out in Europe. The war ended in 1918 and Germany solely blamed. The end of the war was signed with the treaty of Versailles. From the war was born the League of Nations; who helped nations resolve disputes peacefully without going to war. When the League was formed, the defeated nations were not invited to join. The League originally had forty-two members. All forty-two members made up the assembly, who met once a year....   [tags: Papers]

Research Papers
764 words (2.2 pages)

America's Failure to Join the League of Nations Essay

- America entered World War One in 1917. America and the President, Woodrow Wilson, were horrified by the destruction that had taken place in such a humane part of the world. The only way to avoid a repeat of such a disaster was to create an international committee whose purpose was to prevent wars by maintaining world peace. This would be the task of the League of Nations. Woodrow Wilson was the creator of the League of Nations in his Fourteen Points Speech. This was ironic because the United States failed to join the League of Nations....   [tags: History US Wilson League Nations]

Research Papers
1043 words (3 pages)

League of Nations Essays

- League of Nations I have a few topics that I feel that I should bring to the attention of the people of the United States. There are a few matters that feel that the people of America should be able to speak their minds about. In particular to us I have recently come up with fourteen points. Only a few of the fourteen points were included in the treaty, the only important one being the League of Nations. All of the points that I have presented were good, but not being able to include any of these points did not catch me by surprise....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
667 words (1.9 pages)

would affect their own self-interests, as we'll see later in the
Manchurian and the Abyssinian crisis.
Despite all these weaknesses, the League did have some success in the
1920's. The League had successfully sorted out a disagreement between
Finland and Sweden over the Aaland Islands; between Germany and Poland
over Upper Silesia, and between Greece and Bulgaria. Apart from
international disputes, some of the League's greatest successes came
in its work in the 'International Labour Organization', in which they
got member countries to agree to things such as the '8 hour maximum
working day' and that there should be 'No-one to be in full time
employment under 15 years of age'. However, the League did have
failures in the 1920's, such as Vilna and Corfu, and failed in its aim
to achieve disarmament.
The small holes in the League became gaping ones after its downright
failure to do anything significant in the two main 'crisis'' of the
early 1930's: The invasion of Manchuria by Japan in '31 and the
invasion of Abyssinia by the Italians in '35.
In 1929 the world experienced the 'Wall Street collapse', a mass
economic depression that affected many of the countries of the world
hard, especially Japan. Therefore, Japan was in desperate need of raw
materials such as coal and Iron Ore, which an area of China, named
Manchuria, was rich in. Japan already had influence in Manchuria, and
so decided to take it over. China appealed to the League, which
decided to set up a Commission of Inquiry under Lord Lytton, who was
sent to the area to make a report. During the year it took to make the
report, Japan tightened its grip on the area. When the League finally
'morally condemned' Japan with the report, Japan simply ignored the
report and left the League. Japan continued to make successful trade
with the USA, its biggest trading partner, and then announced the
intention to invade China itself. This incident showed that if an
aggressive dictator wanted to invade neighboring countries, he could.
This point was underlined 4 years later, when Abyssinia appealed for
help to the League about the Italian Invasion. The League took eight
months to discuss the matter, and then concluded that Italy could have
some of Abyssinia (as Italy had roots in Abyssinia), but Mussolini
rejected this offer. The League delayed its decision to apply trade
sanctions, meaning that Italy could stockpile enough resources. Also,
in self-interest, France and Britain refused to stop trading in oil
with Italy as it could harm their own economies, and refused to shut
the Suez Canal, the route Italy used to get things from Italy to
Abyssinia, because they were afraid of war with Italy, and they also
did not want to upset Mussolini, as they hoped he would be their ally
with in increasing threat of Hitler. So, this meant that the League
did not manage to stop Italy, and showed that the League was actually
weak and quite powerless. Hitler saw this, and was able to exploit the
League's weakness to rearm and march into the Rhineland.
So, in conclusion, and to directly answer the question "Was the League
bound to fail?" I would say that yes, the League was bound to fail
eventually, as I personally feel that the League's Physical weakness
was too great in a world that was still very self-interested. For
example, Britain and France were happy for Italy to invade the
virtually defenseless country Abyssinia, as long as it meant that they
would stay on good terms with Mussolini. To put it simply, the
League's main aim above all others was to end world conflict, and it
failed to do this, meaning that the League must have been a failure.
However on the other hand can it truly be argued that the League of
Nations was a failure when so many of its principles and structures
were echoed less than half a century later? It seems clear that the
failures of the League were not that of the League itself but of the "realist
attitudes of the nations involved". Unwilling to surrender their ideas
of sovereignty to another organisation. The fact that the United
Nations is still functioning suggests that ideas of sovereignty are
less important or that "Realism has been understood with the
intentional trigging of the veto power to the permanent members". The
United Nations is almost the League in another form but it is deemed
to be successful so far, however the U.N has its own problems for it
has picked up some of the League Of Nation problems in a dictating
country to big to be repremanded but instead being allowed to dominate
and do what ever they please The United States Of America. So was The
League, therefore, successful in that it created a legacy for the
future! But will this legacy of The future altogether be a success or
just another wonderful idea thurst into the sands of time? As You
there are far too many pieces of information to take into account so I
will take the neutral side and say the league was both a failure and a
Return to 123HelpMe.com