Selling-Out the Asian-American Community in Amy Tan's The Joy Luck Club

Selling-Out the Asian-American Community in Amy Tan's The Joy Luck Club

Length: 673 words (1.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓

Selling-Out the Asian-American Community in The Joy Luck Club


i wish i could join in the universal praise for amy tan and her best-selling novel "the joy luck club." i wish i could find the latest chinese-american literary dish as appetizing as the rest of the american public does.  but i can't. before amy tan entered the scene, public images of asian america had not developed since the middle of the century. the asian american male did not exist except as a barbaric japanese or vietcong soldier. the asian american female remained the adolescent suzy wong pipe dream, toyed with for a while and then deserted.


amy tan, a gifted writer, had the chance to change those images, to dispel the public's misconceptions and to forge a new asian american identity. instead, she copped out on her obligations, meekly reinforcing every conceivable stereotype.


if you believe tan's first novel "the joy luck club," asian amerca is some mystical oddity, conforming to the mascot-culture view of the white thirtysomething women who predominated at tan's reading. san francisco chinatown is filled with hysterical chinese women playing secret mah jong games. china itself is a dreamlik landscape, filled with secrets and traditions, all exuding a delicate, storybook aura.

chinese mothers are all one-dimensional, superstitious and ignorant. their chinese phrases are delightful italics with quaint meanings. of course, what chinese comedy would be complete without a couple of garbled english words? when tan was late for her berkeley reading, her white husband directed the audience to mimic her mother's amusing syntax: "why so late?" rimshot.


amy tan's heroines are the white mother-in-law's dream come true. these china dolls talk and have strong feminine sympathies. as one of tan's heroines admits, "i used to push my eyes on the sides to make them rounder." futile self-denial, but, oh, isn't it cute?

tan's heroines gain identity by separating themselves from and looking down on their culture. when the heroine in "the kitchen god's wife" hears about her grand auntie's "spirit money," she sneers are her aunt's attempt to "bribe her way along to chinese-heaven" immediately suggests a negative contrast to the "truer" western heaven.


the same dichotomy is used with men as well. asian american men are inadequate -- they're either bothersome brothers or unsuccessful lovers who lead to "apathetic boredom."


love with a white male, however, is different.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Selling-Out the Asian-American Community in Amy Tan's The Joy Luck Club." 18 Nov 2018

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Joy Luck Club by Amy Tan Essay

- The Joy Luck Club One of the central themes in writing of the second generation Asian Americans is the search of identity and individual acceptance in American society. In the last few decades, many Asian Americans have entered a time of increased awareness of their racial and cultural identity built on their need to establish their unique American identity. In the book The Joy Luck Club, which revolves around four mother-daughter Asian American families whose mothers migrated from China to America and raised their daughters as Americans, we see the cultural struggle and differences by looking at their marriages, suffering and sacrifice, and their use of language in the novel....   [tags: asian americnas, identity]

Research Papers
603 words (1.7 pages)

Chinese Traditionalism in Amy Tan's The Joy Luck Club Essay

- A bleak, ominous cloud quite often hovers over the hopeful heads of immigrants, and waits surreptitiously to downpour at the most inopportune moments. Challenges can never be perfectly avoided for immigrants fervently seeking to find freedom, security, and acceptance in the lands and cultures of those who are vastly different from themselves. Barriers between diverse, contrasting cultures can never be completely obliterated, therefore immigrants must assimilate as successfully as they can into countries in which they have chosen to live and raise their children....   [tags: The Joy Luck Club 2014]

Research Papers
3500 words (10 pages)

Mother Daughter Relationships - Mothers and Daughters in Amy Tan's The Joy Luck Club

- Mothers and Daughters in The Joy Luck Club Although mothers and daughters are genetically related, sometimes they seem like complete strangers. When immigrants raise their children in America, there is a great concern for these parents that American culture will negatively affect their children. In the novel, The Joy Luck Club by Amy Tan, four mothers try to instill their Asian culture into their daughters' lifestyle; however, these daughters rebel against them, due to their desire to assimilate themselves into American culture....   [tags: Joy Luck Club Essays]

Free Essays
547 words (1.6 pages)

The Search for Identity in Amy Tan's The Joy Luck Club Essay

- The Search for Identity in The Joy Luck Club           When Chinese immigrants enter the United States of America, it is evident from the start that they are in a world far different than their homeland. Face to face with a dominant culture that often times acts and thinks in ways contrary to their previous lives, immigrants are on a difficult path of attempting to become an American. Chinese immigrants find themselves often caught between two worlds: the old world of structured, traditional and didactic China and the new world of mobile, young and prosperous America....   [tags: Joy Luck Club Essays]

Research Papers
3983 words (11.4 pages)

Biculturalism in Amy Tan's The Joy Luck Club Essay

- Biculturalism Exposed in Joy Luck Club          America does not have a culture. The established American society is made up of multicultural peoples that are forced into assimilation by social pressure. Webster's dictionary defines biculturalism as the existence of two distinct cultures in one nation. I am a prime example of biculturalism in America. My mother was born and raised in another country and her daughter was raised far away in the United States. The novel "Joy Luck Club" by Amy Tan illustrates biculturalism in America and the profound impact it had on the main character's life and is paralleled, in many ways by my own....   [tags: Joy Luck Club Essays]

Research Papers
2154 words (6.2 pages)

Mother and Daughter Relationships Exposed in Amy Tan's The Joy Luck Club

- Relationships Between Mothers and Daughters Exposed in The Joy Luck Club         Amy Tan's novel, The Joy Luck Club is one that is truly amazing and a joy to read. There are a number of issues at work in the novel, the most obvious one is the exploration of relationships between mothers and daughters. Unfortunately, for these four sets of mothers and daughters, there is not only a generational gap between them, but a cultural one as well. Tan reveals these rifts, and their love for one another, in much the same way William Faulkner or Toni Morrison let us glimpse their characters lives instead of telling us their stories....   [tags: Joy Luck Club Essays]

Research Papers
2377 words (6.8 pages)

Power of the Mother and Daughter Relationship Amy Tan’s Joy Luck Club Essay

- Power of the Mother and Daughter Relationship Amy Tan’s Joy Luck Club In the novel, The Joy Luck Club, the author, Amy Tan, intricately weaves together the roles and experiences of Chinese mothers with their American born daughters. During a time of war, the mothers flee from China to America, leaving behind a past filled with secrets that unravel as their daughters mature. While sharing their difficulties, these mothers must be able to teach Chinese beliefs and customs to their daughters in a way that relates to American society....   [tags: Joy Luck Club]

Research Papers
1496 words (4.3 pages)

Mother-daughter Relations and Clash of Cultures in Amy Tan's The Joy Luck Club

-         Amy Tan is an American Born Chinese, daughter of immigrants, and her family shares many features with the families depicted in her novels. Tan's novels offer some glimpses of life in China while developing the themes of mother-daughter relations, cultural adaptation and "women with a past".  Tan’s novels share many themes and elements, but this paper will focus mainly on two episodes of the novel The Joy Luck Club: "The Joy Luck Club" and "Waiting Between the Trees"; and will make references to The Kitchen's God Wife and The Hundred Secret Senses....   [tags: Joy Luck Club Essays]

Research Papers
2467 words (7 pages)

Mothers and the Chinese Spirit in Amy Tan’s The Joy Luck Club Essay

- Mothers and the Chinese Spirit in Amy Tan’s The Joy Luck Club    The Joy Luck Club is the telling of a tale of struggle by four mothers and their four daughters trying to understand the issue of gender identity, how they each discover or lose their sense of self and what they mean to one another. Throughout the book each of the mothers works hard at teaching their daughters the virtues of Chinese wisdom while allowing the opportunities of American life. They try passing on a piece of themselves despite the great barriers that are built between the women....   [tags: Joy Luck Club]

Research Papers
2111 words (6 pages)

The Joy Luck Club Essay

- It is true that all people are created different, and thus no two cultures will ever be the same. Throughout Asian American literature there seems to be a struggle between the Asian culture and American culture. More specifically, there is a struggle between Asian women and their Asian American daughters, and what it means to be feminine, and how a woman should act. The main struggle is between how the American woman should act and how the Asian woman should act. However, the behavior of the Asian woman seems to be dominant through out the story because although the daughters and the mothers may not get along all of the time, the mothers to receive a lot of respect from their daughters....   [tags: The Joy Luck Club Essays]

Free Essays
1715 words (4.9 pages)

Related Searches

another heroine explains, "we became inseparable, two halves creating the whole: yin and yang. i was victim to his hero, i was always in danger and he was always rescuing me. i would fall and he would lift me up."

i can understand why these images of helpless asian women would appeal to white america. surrounded by increasingly empowered minorities, an emasculated asian america with exotic females willing to please has certain romantic possibilities. a character in "the joy luck club" relates: "a lot of women in my aerobics class tell me i'm 'exotic' ... they're jealous that my breasts don't sag, now that small breasts are in." with such slavish self-effacement, asian american assimilation should be painless.


i couldn't go to the reading at black oak books. but several of asian american residents in ehrman hall told me tan defended her anti-asian bent by claiming that "fiction should not be a sociological treatise."


maybe in tan's dreamlike fictional world, this statement could be true. perhaps in the same world, t.s. eliot's anti-semitism and joseph conrad's anti-black sentiments could be shrugged off. but in a world where asian americans are struggling every day for dignity and identity, the damage that tan has caused is very real.


in "the joy luck club," one of tan's heroines can't understand why she should look after her brothers. she asks, "why? why did i have to care for them?"


it could very well be a question which tan should ask herself about the asian american community she so happily sold out.

the character's mother responds in chinese words which tan should have heeded: "yiding." you must.
Return to