Love is Doomed to Failure in Both Romeo and Juliet and Cal

Love is Doomed to Failure in Both Romeo and Juliet and Cal

Length: 883 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Love is Doomed to Failure in Both Romeo and Juliet and Cal

Romeo and Juliet is the most famous love story in the English literary
tradition. In Romeo and Juliet, love is a violent, ecstatic,
overpowering force that supersedes all other values, loyalties and
emotions. In the course of the play, the young lovers are driven to
defy their entire social world: families ('Deny thy father and refuse
thy name,' Juliet asks, 'Or if thou wilt not, be but sworn my love, /
And I'll no longer be a Capulet'); friends (Romeo abandons Mercutio
and Benvolio after the feast in order to go to Juliet's garden); and
ruler (Romeo returns to Verona for Juliet's sake after being exiled by
the Prince on pain of death). In comparison to Shakespeare's
Renaissance play, Cal was written at a very different time in a very
different style. Bernard McClaverty's novel, Cal, was published in
1983 based in a small Ulster town during "troubles" with the IRA.
Cal's unfulfilled love for Marcella is caused by social situations,
particularly religion and Cal's forced recruitment to the IRA.

Shakespeare's tragedy is a dramatic twist of desire, murder, exile and
suicide all provoked by a passionate love, which only lasts five days.
The development of love in Cal is set over six months, lacking the
dramatic excitement of a play, but enhanced by genuine realism. Romeo
and Juliet and Cal are linked; both portray a love across a divide. In
other words we see two lovers in both stories that cannot maintain a
loving relationship, because of their differences. Also, both stories
have an unhappy ending where we see the story end with a result of the
lovers dieing or being separated. Romeo and Juliet is based in the
beautiful Italian city of Verona. The characters have a high status;
both families are wealthy and important within the city. Shakespeare
concentrates on the doomed love between the young lovers. In contrast,
the main characters in Cal are working class, reliant upon social
conditions. For example, Cal is unemployed at the beginning and

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Love is Doomed to Failure in Both Romeo and Juliet and Cal." 27 Jan 2020

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

William Shakespeare 's Romeo And Juliet Essay

- William Shakespeare once wrote “love all, trust a few, do wrong to none.” Even dating all the way back to the 1500’s, love was something that could be understood and felt just as it is today, which is proven through the famous work of William Shakespeare, who is known as the most influential writer in all of English literature. The young love between Romeo (Montague) and Juliet (Capulet), two “star-crossed lovers” in Shakespeare’s famous tragedy of Romeo and Juliet, may have been destined to fail due to their fate and young age....   [tags: Romeo and Juliet, Characters in Romeo and Juliet]

Research Papers
1259 words (3.6 pages)

William Shakespeare 's Romeo And Juliet Essay

- Topic: ‘A pair of star-cross’d lovers take their life.’ Discuss the part fate plays in Romeo and Juliet. The classic idea of the fate that is embodied in the famous play “Romeo and Juliet” has an exceptionally crucial force, pulling the characters into an emotionally heightened state. The fate that is portrayed in the play becomes tremendously suspenseful which undoubtedly superintends the two young lovers to meet in the first place. The evident aspects of the play which unravel the role fate plays in the lives of Romeo and Juliet include the young lovers finding that they are from different families, the unfortunate death of Tybalt due to a misunderstanding and the unpredicted failure of F...   [tags: Romeo and Juliet, Characters in Romeo and Juliet]

Research Papers
1171 words (3.3 pages)

How Friar Lawrence and Fate Impacted the Demise of Romeo and Juliet Essay

- No plan is perfect – no matter how well one thinks it out, there is always margin for error. A successful, well thought out plan consists of a solid primary plan, alternate means of achieving the goal and leeway to allow for mistakes. In the play Romeo and Juliet, Friar Lawrence hastily thought up a plan to reunite Romeo and Juliet. It was poorly thought out and Lawrence neglected to think of the consequences that could take place if the plan should unfold as intended. Meanwhile, Fate seemed to have its way with the young couple, throwing numerous obstacles to get in the way of their love....   [tags: Romeo and Juliet]

Research Papers
633 words (1.8 pages)

Essay about William Shakespeare 's Romeo And Juliet

- 1.William Shakespeare’s “Romeo and Juliet” was first printed in 1597. 2.Which means that in 400 years there have been approximately 200,000,000,000 copies sold around the world.3. In every copy sold there has been an underlying question.4. Why did William Shakespeare write a tragic love story. 5. In the article “Love, Sex and Death in Romeo and Juliet” by Clayton G. MacKenzie she states “Sexuality and death have been linked in art and literature since ancient times” (29.) 6. It is a known fact that this is the world’s favorite play written by Shakespeare not only for the love and the passion, but the sacrifice of each other.7....   [tags: Romeo and Juliet, English-language films]

Research Papers
1742 words (5 pages)

Analysis Of Baz Luhrmann 's American Adaptation Of Shakespeare 's Romeo And Juliet

- Within Baz Luhrmann’s american adaptation of  Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet, he shows the impacts of how parents influence the actions of their children. One argue that Shakespeare demonstrates how Romeo and Juliet has matured over the course of the play, but Luhrmann suggests something on a societal issue that is present within teens in an American cultures, and should be addressed. Shakespeare matches these ‘star-crossed lovers’ Romeo and Juliet, who come from a very similar financial status in a society, but unfortunately their family are not very fond of each other....   [tags: Romeo and Juliet, Characters in Romeo and Juliet]

Research Papers
1219 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on Interpretation of Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet

- Interpretation of Romeo and Juliet What would cause young lovers to mysteriously commit suicide so they can be together. Is it their parents who forbid them to see one another, or is it themselves. William Shakespeare's play, Romeo and Juliet, tells about two young "star-crossed lovers" whose deaths were caused by fate, not their parents or themselves. First of all, Romeo and Juliet were from feuding families: Romeo a Montague, and Juliet a Capulet. Romeo was so depressed about his unrequited love for Rosaline when it just so happens, he goes to a masquerade party....   [tags: Shakespeare, Romeo and Juliet]

Free Essays
502 words (1.4 pages)

Essay on William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet

- In all of the best works of literature, each of a writer's characters has a purpose whether the role is small or big. Even if it goes unnoticed, the small characters usually play a key role to the story's plot development. These minor characters also add depth to the story's world and also help in the development of the major characters' personality. In William Shakespeare's play The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet, the minor characters of Friar Lawrence, the Nurse, and Tybalt are in many ways the most pivotal characters to the play's development. F...   [tags: Shakespeare Romeo Juliet]

Free Essays
1138 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on Friar Lawrence in Shakespeare's Romeo And Juliet

- The story of Romeo and Juliet was filled with a tragedy caused by two feuding families with an end of death. But could the fatal demise of these two been averted if one character had played a better part. This character is Friar Lawrence a man of the church renowned for his power of healing. When the lovers turned to him he married them, gave both advice in their ties of need and supplied a plan to bring them back together. But was the Friar responsible for such a crime and when they both lay dead was the blood on his hands....   [tags: Shakespeare Romeo Juliet]

Free Essays
901 words (2.6 pages)

Who is to Blame for Death in William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet Essay

- Who is to Blame for Death in William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet Beliefs are rested on the idea that fate killed Romeo and Juliet. People at this time also believed in arranged marriages. However many people and things can be considered to have increased the risk of their deaths therefore who or what is to blame for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. Friar John must take some of the blame for their deaths, as the failure of the letter reaching Romeo is his fault. I could not send it- here it is again- Nor get a messenger to bring it thee, (5.2.15)....   [tags: Romeo and Juliet Essays]

Research Papers
1728 words (4.9 pages)

Tybalt's Misinterpretation in William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet Essay

- Tybalt's Misinterpretation in Romeo and Juliet Romeo and Juliet is the story of two "star-crossed lovers who take their life" (prologue). Their families were ancient enemies based on an ancient grudge no longer known, but still strong. Romeo and Juliet fall passionately in love ignoring the fact they are, by household, enemies. Friar Lawrence joins them in marriage in hope "to turn their households' rancour to pure love"(p. 43). They married without their families' permission or knowledge and against their society's conventions....   [tags: Romeo and Juliet Essays]

Free Essays
856 words (2.4 pages)

Marcella works in a small library.

Romeo and Juliet and Cal differ in the protagonists' opinions of life
and Fate. In Romeo and Juliet we hear many times the mention of Fate.
At the beginning of the play Romeo and Juliet are addressed to the
audience by the Chorus as "star- crossed lovers". They seem constantly
aware of this, when Romeo believes that Juliet is dead, he cries out
"Then I defy you, stars," completing the idea that the love between
Romeo and Juliet is on opposition to destiny's plan. During the
Renaissance the idea of the Wheel of Fortune and Lady Fortune was
popular. They believed that lady fortune spins a wheel that has
everybody on it, one minute you could be at the top and have good
fortune or you could be at the bottom and have bad fortune. Romeo also
says after he kills Tybalt "O I am fortune's fool!" showing many
people believed that they could do nothing about their Fate at that

Cal is very different, the characters are a lot more modern and
familiar to our generation. For example, Cal gets caught up in the IRA
by Crilly and Skeffington and is unable to get out once he is part of
it. He doesn't blame the stars as Romeo does in Romeo and Juliet, he
accepts it as bad luck symptomatic of Ireland's social situation. In
Cal the mood is generally sombre, unlike scenes in Romeo and Juliet
like the Ball scene, which shows us the excitement of Italian
aristocratic life. The characters in Cal have a different lifestyle
and culture to Romeo and Juliet. For example, most of the characters
in Cal are badly off and struggle to earn a living, very different to
the characters of the families in Romeo and Juliet who are very
wealthy and high status.

The development of love in Cal and Romeo and Juliet is very different,
love develops very hastily in Romeo and Juliet with the two lovers
falling in love the night before they get married. Cal is based on
realism. Cal and Marcella's relationship is dragged on through a long
period of time, showing the characters to be less decisive towards
their emotions. Cal is in love with Marcella, but she only gradually
returns his affection and is much more hesitant about her feelings. In
contrast, the lovers fall in love at first sight in Romeo and Juliet.
Their decision to get married, despite the fact they are part of two
different rival families, shows their powerful love. They speak only
fourteen lines to each other before they first kiss. These lines
representing a sonnet, the idealised form of love.

However, Romeo and Juliet and Cal do share the similarity of the
relationship with the young and old generation. In both instances in
which "love is doomed to failure", the characters are unable to
consult their parents for advice. Juliet is forced into a marriage
against her wishes and Romeo turns to Friar Lawrence during his
troubles. Cal has a distant relationship with his father and lacks the
affection he received from his dead mother. The suggestion is that the
older generation are unable to provide solid emotional support. Juliet
is able to confide in her nurse, but she and Friar Lawrence even let
the two down at the play's conclusion, showing the older generation to
have a lack of understanding true love.

Shakespeare uses dramatic irony in Romeo and Juliet, the audience
knows a lot more than the characters do and this makes the play more
exciting. This is most clearly exemplified in the deaths of Romeo and
Juliet, which occur in a sequence of compounding action. Juliet drinks
a potion that makes her appear dead. Romeo then drinks a potion that
actually kills him. Juliet stabs herself through the heart with a
dagger. The audience is powerless to stop these tragic actions,
suggesting a love that is doomed to fail.

The amount of unhappiness and sadness in both Romeo and Juliet and Cal,
makes it debatable on whom to blame. In Romeo and Juliet we could
blame the parents of Romeo and Juliet, Friar Lawrence, Nurse, Prince
Escalus and Tybalt. The blame has to be split between these people but
I think most of the blame should go to the parents of both families
for their lack of understanding and carrying a ridiculous rivalry on
and not making any effort at all to make peace. The irony is that the
lovers suicide finally ends their families feud. Friar Lawrence's
words, "These violent delights have violent ends" are appropriate. In
Cal we can blame Crilly and Skeffington for forcing Cal into the IRA
and for not letting him quit so easily. The main similarity between
Romeo and Juliet and Cal is that they both display love across a
barrier, which finally ends in tragedy and doomed love.
Return to