A Defense of Whitman

A Defense of Whitman

Length: 1213 words (3.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
A Defense of Whitman        


   Whether they have loved or loathed his poetry, each writer or critic who has encountered "Leaves of Grass" has had to come to some sort of reckoning with Walt Whitman. The Good Gray Poet, the grandfather of American poetry, has been deified by some and labeled a cultural and artistic barbarian by others. While Whitman freely admitted in his preface to the final publication of "Leaves of Grass" that the work was faulty and far from perfect, some critics see no redeeming qualities in Whitman's art. Henry James goes so far as to say, "Whitman's verse...is an offense to art." (James, p.16) James chastises Whitman for extolling and exploiting what James feels are truisms. To James, Whitman's poetry is completely self-aggrandizing; it lacks substance and coherence. Through an examination of a specific poem, "The Wound Dresser", the claims of James and other negative critics can be refuted.     

 

The broadest and most general critiques can be dismissed most readily. Henry James accuses Whitman of refusing to deal with challenging moral questions in his poetry. Whitman speaks of the evils of war, suffering, and senseless death in graphic detail in "The Wound Dresser", but to James these evils are obvious targets for lesser poets.

 

"A great deal of verse that is nothing but words has, during the war, been sympathetically sighed over and cut out of newspaper corners because it possessed a certain simple melody." (James, p.16)

 

 

James denies Whitman's poetry even a simple melody. Whitman is more an emotional opportunist than a poet. James even claims that Whitman's primary goal is the glorification of the Union army. The poem in question, however, hints at a different conclusion. "(was one side so brave? The other side was equally brave)" (Whitman, p.249). In dealing with supposed truisms Whitman's poem begins to ask the question: if the inherent evils of war, suffering, and senseless death are indeed so painfully obvious to you, Henry James, and your world, why are they supported with such fervor? Why in fact do they exist at all? Whitman happens to write from a sincere moral minority of which Henry James is a part. Thus to label Whitman altruistic is to label James as well.

 

John Jay Chapman levels the most absurd attack on Whitman:     

  

"The man [Whitman] knew the world merely as an outside observer, he was never a living part of it, and no mere observer can understand the life about him.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"A Defense of Whitman." 123HelpMe.com. 15 Dec 2019
    <https://www.123helpme.com/view.asp?id=11628>.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Abusing the Insanity Defense Essay

- ... Insanity how requires the defendant to prove he or she is mentally ill. When the defendants were stating their case they were a result of mentally ill. They were not accepting their crime of how wrong it was. This is to know the right from wrong. The case of Mr. Weinstein was that he strangled his wife and made it seem like it was suicide by throwing her out of a twelve floor apartment. The lawyer told judge that his brain was a spider web and this caused him to do violence he supposedly did not know....   [tags: drunk drivers don't know better]

Research Papers
870 words (2.5 pages)

Poetic Reflections of the National Spirit Essay

- Sir Philip Sidney wrote in the Defense of Poesy that “only the poet, disdaining to be tied to any such subjection, lifted up with the vigor of his own invention, doth grow in effect another nature, in making things either better than nature bringeth forth, or quite anew, forms such as never were in nature” (Sidney, bartleby.com). While history describes the actual and philosophy explores the abstract, only poetry is capable of weaving the two concepts together. Reading a nation’s history enlightens an individual to the significant events of a country’s past, but it cannot reveal the immaterial spirit of an era or people....   [tags: Literary Analysis, Whitman, Goethe, and Yeats]

Research Papers
2678 words (7.7 pages)

There's No Defense for Affluenza Essay

- "The Affluenza Defense: Judge Rules Rich Kid’s Rich Kid-ness Makes Him Not Liable for Deadly Drunk Driving Accident" -- Madison Gray, Time.com The relationship between motive and consequence is a complex one, and is made even more debatable when context becomes involved. Throughout our judicial history, the line between responsibility and exemption remains razor-thin in its subjectivity. If a woman murders her husband, but was abused by him for years, why is this considered different from a murder where the perpetrator wasn’t abused....   [tags: The Affluenza Defense]

Research Papers
1956 words (5.6 pages)

Comparing The Battle Whitman And Post War Whitman Essay

- Comparison of pre-war Whitman and post-war Whitman Walt Whitman is considered one of the famous American writers who lived in the 19th century. The author is primarily known for his poetry, and also best known for his masterpiece, Leaves of Grass, which was published in 1855 as a collection of 12 poems. Whitman’s poems were different from those written during the era, and this is because they had a unique style, as well as a concentration of commonplace subjects. The use of commonplace subjects led to many people calling the author the “poet of democracy.” This paper compares Pre-war Whitman and Post-war Whitman....   [tags: Walt Whitman, Leaves of Grass, Poetry]

Research Papers
1343 words (3.8 pages)

Leaves of Grass by Walt Whitman Essay

- Walt Whitman is possibly one of the best examples of an artist who drew no distinctions between art and culture. To Whitman art is culture, and culture is history. His role as an artist must then be intrinsically manifesting himself as a representative of the America masses, or express himself as America personified. He saw democracy as an inseparable attribute of Americaness. However, the America he lived in was desperately fractured amongst differing factions with different opinions on the definition of “democracy”....   [tags: Walt Whitman on Democracy ]

Research Papers
2891 words (8.3 pages)

Whitman's Out Of The Cradle Endlessly Rocking Essay

- Whitman's Poem "Out of the Cradle, Endlessly Rocking," is not, at first glance, an obvious love poem. Most readers would probably consider this a tragic poem about death and love lost. In spite of the fact that the poem is about intrinsically sorrowful events, or perhaps because of it, Whitman is able to capture a very unique and poignant portrayal of love. There are three major perspectives to examine how Whitman develops the theme of love in Out of the Cradle, and by examining each reoccurring theme in the poem separately, we can come to a more complete understanding of how they work together to communicate Whitman's message about love....   [tags: Walt Whitman]

Research Papers
1488 words (4.3 pages)

Whitman's Music as a Means of Expression Essay

- Whitman's Music as a Means of Expression In his verses, Walt Whitman eradicates divisions of individual entities while simultaneously celebrating their unique characteristics. All components of the universe are united in a metaphysical intercourse, and yet, are assigned very distinct qualities so as to keep their identities intact. Often times, Whitman demonstrates these conceptions through elements of song. “Walt Whitman caroled throughout his verse. For the Bard of Democracy, as America came to call our great poet, music was a central metaphor in his life and work, both as a mindset and as a practical reality.” (Hampson) His musical poetry lyrically encompasses themes of social equality...   [tags: Whitman Music Musical Essays]

Research Papers
2421 words (6.9 pages)

Walt Whitman as a Voice for the People Essay examples

- Walt Whitman as a Voice for the People "The proof of a poet is that his country absorbs him as much as he absorbs his country." This brilliant quote from Walt Whitman thus ends his preface to Leaves of Grass, and thereafter begins the poem "Song of Myself." To many, upon their first reading, this was a crude, shocking and distasteful piece of work. but to me...this was a celebration of life. And not just a celebration of his own life, but of every life, of the American life. Walt Whitman is the "voice of the people" and this I believe because, while he did write of things that were not seen as aesthetically beautiful by many...including homosexuality, loneliness, and death....   [tags: Walt Whitman Essays]

Research Papers
1192 words (3.4 pages)

Essay about The Defense Mechanism

- Defense mechanism, in psychoanalysis, any of a variety of unconscious personality reactions which the ego uses to protect the conscious mind from threatening feelings and perceptions. Sigmund Freud first used defense as a psychoanalytic term (1894), but he did not break the notion into categories, viewing it as a singular phenomenon of repression. His daughter, Anna Freud, expanded on his theories in the 1930s, distinguishing some of the major defense mechanisms recognized today. Primary defense mechanisms include repression and denial, which serve to prevent unacceptable ideas or impulses from entering the conscience....   [tags: Defense Mechanisms]

Research Papers
3474 words (9.9 pages)

Essay on Whitman's Interpretation of Emerson

- Whitman's Interpretation of Emerson Walt Whitman was able to take the spark of an idea from Ralph Waldo Emerson and tend, nurture, and support it until the spark grew into a huge flame of something surprising and original - new American poetry. Whitman did not only learn from Emerson, but he also took Emerson's ideas and expanded them into something much more encompassing. Whitman was able to use Emerson's principles that are outlined in "The Poet" to springboard into something more expansive than Emerson was able to describe or create....   [tags: Whitman Emerson Poet Poem Essays]

Research Papers
913 words (2.6 pages)

Related Searches

"(p.105) 

 

 

"The Wound Dresser" is a personal account and reminiscence of Whitman's days

 as a medic during the Civil War.

 

"The crush'd head I dress, (poor crazed hand tear not the bandage away,)

...Hard breathing rattles, quite glazed already the eye, yet life struggles hard." (Whitman, p.250)

 

 

These are hardly the words of a passive spectator. Whitman was an active participant in life; life intoxicated him. His poetry reflects his immediate intense sensitivity to the world around him.

 

This sensitivity is the basis for Whitman's attempt to create a higher level of coherence and meaning in each poem. This Cosmic Sense, as Richard Maurice Bucke terms it, provides a grand unifying theory which pervades and binds all his poetry (Bucke, p.112). Whitman uses an almost structural method building with paradox and antithesis. The dialectics in "The Wound Dresser", youth and age, innocence and wisdom, noise and silence, image and truth, begin to hint at a universal sense gained by the old man in the poem. The poem is a series of gory and painful memories, yet the old man concludes by saying,

 

"I recall the experience both sweet and sad, (Many a soldier's arms about this neck have cross'd and rested, Many a soldier's kiss dwell on these bearded lips.)" (Whitman, p.251).

 

 

It is precisely this sort of statement, however, that leads Henry James and John Jay Chapman to attack Whitman for lacking any sort of unity or coherence. "We look in vain, however, through your book for a single idea." (James, p.17) Whitman's use of paradox and antithesis does differ from structuralism because these elements do not build upward and point to a single idea. These elements extend horizontally in all directions implying both infinity and universality. This is the source of James' frustration.

 

"No arrangement of Whitman's thoughts can resolve the paradoxes or discover them in a fully coherent pattern. He was incapable of sustained logic, but that should not blind the reader into impatient rejection of the ebb and flow of hisantithesis." (Matthiessen, p.31)

 

 

James and Chapman complain of Whitman's lack of coherence when in reality they themselves are standing against the tide of a universal unity.

 

James couples his logical attack with one more specific and fundamental. "Art requires, above all things, a supression of one's self, a subordination of one's self to an idea." (James, p.17) Whitman's poetry will never be art because he places his own consciousness above ideas or concepts. His poetry is the supreme statement of one's self; it is the essence of Whitman's ego.

 

To Whitman, however, ideas are in no way subservient. The ideas and images of any poem affect and shape the consciousness of the poet. Therefore, in order for Whitman to attain his ideal of Cosmic Consciousness, the ideas that propel him into such a state must be at the very least equal if not superior to the ego of any one poet. In "The Wound Dresser" a simple but very potent idea is the driving force behind the poem: the sanctity of life and the struggle to preserve it. This idea causes the old man to choose his occupation as a medic and even to enjoy it in some form. Without this idea to motivate and mould Whitman's conscience, he would never have written,

 

"I never knew you.

Yet I think I could not refuse this moment to die for you, if that would save you" (Whitman, p.250).

 

 

As the poem so aptly states, Whitman's poetry exists "in dreams' projections", the very realm of ideas and abstractions. Thus concepts and consciousness become equitable partners in the creation of something larger than the sum of both parts: art. Whitman's art is an amalgamation of coarse reality, paradox, and free floating ideas. Faulty as it is, Henry James is sadly mistaken when he claims that Walt Whitman's poetry is an insult to the very concept of art. At its finest, his poetry is a splendid assimilation of humanity through the eyes of a tender and wise man.      

 

Selected Bibliography    

 

Bucke, Richard Maurice. Cosmic Consciousness. E.P. Dutton Inc., New York: 1923, p.225-37.  Rpt. in  A Century of Whitman Criticism. ed. Edwin Haviland Miller. Indiana University Press, Bloomington: 1969, p.112.  

 

Chapman, John Jay. "Walt Whitman (1898)", The Selected Writings of John Chapman, ed. Jacques Barzun. New York: 1957, p.145-49.  Rpt. in A Century of Whitman Criticism. ed. Edwin Haviland Miller. Indiana University Press Bloomington: 1969, p.105.                  

 

James, Henry. "Mr. Walt Whitman (1865)", Views and Reviews. New York: 1908, p.10110.  Rpt. in A Century of Whitman Criticism. ed. Edwin Haviland Miller. Indiana University Press, Bloomington: 1969, p.16, 17.    

 

Matthiessen, F.O.  American Renaissance. Oxford University Press, New York: 1941, p.51732.  Rpt. in A Century of Whitman Criticism. ed. Edwin Haviland Miller. Indiana University Press, Bloomington: 1969, p.180.

 

Whitman, Walt. Leaves of Grass. Bantam Books, New York: 1983, p.248, 251.

 
Return to 123HelpMe.com