Assessing New Right Criminology

Assessing New Right Criminology

Length: 443 words (1.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Assessing New Right Criminology

In the piece on 'How to sweep beggars from our streets' by David
Marsland, he likens them to menaces in society and an 'eye sore'
littering the streets of towns and major cities. His somewhat archaic
view in that a need to adopt a more Victorian approach to tackling the
problem of begging mirrors the right realist view on crime. John Major
in his 'law and order' debate talked about going 'back to basics' and
with a rise in crime their explanation was to blame a 'decline in
moral values' as the main factor. Marsland believed that beggars had
no moral fibre and that the problem did not stem from capitalism or
poverty but their mere existence was a 'blot on the complex but
orderly copy-book of a modern civilised society'

The right realist perspective was particularly connected to J Q Wilson
whom in the early 1970's in the US claimed that 'crime resulted from
selfish and wicked people who were undeterred by the criminal justice
system which had gone 'soft' on criminals' Wilson believed that in
order to combat crime there needed to be a remedy, he suggested that
through increased education, encouraged community organisation,
modernising poor housing and provision of counselling for young
trouble delinquents there lay the answer. Marsland takes a similar
view on combating begging. His remedy for the situation was the
toughening up of laws that were perhaps to lax and return to the
Victorian invention of work houses. Beggars needed to know the value
of hard work, self reliance and respectability. The causes of begging
in Marsland's opinion were 'The hand-out culture of the decaying welfare state' basically to
mean that the government were to quick to give out benefits and
therefore creating a society that relies on money handouts and causing
people not to want to work for a living. Secondly he states that
'turning a blind eye' and selfishness on the part of teachers and
political leaders is also a fact of why we have high rates of begging
in this country.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Assessing New Right Criminology." 19 Sep 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Theoretical Integration Within The Future Of Criminology Essay

- According to Lilly, Cullen and Ball (2011), the wisdom of theoretical integration lies in whether these efforts allow us to explain the causes of crime more adequately, although these criteria must be applied to whether integration achieves not only short-term gains in explanatory power but also long-term growth in theoretical knowledge. In review of theory integration, it is consider important for the future of criminology because it merges the insights from two or more theories into a single framework to introduction reasoning or cause for crimes that are being committed....   [tags: Criminology, Sociology, Behavior, Crime]

Research Papers
2559 words (7.3 pages)

The Context Of Criminology Left And Right Realism Essay

- In the context of criminology Left and Right Realism first came into prominence in accordance with the Reagan and Thatcher governments that emerged in America and Britain in the 1970s. Both administrations dominated politics for a considerable period and represented a significant break with much previous post-war politics and public policy, favouring free market economics and mounting a critique on social welfare programmes that had developed in previous decades (Newburn 2012). In this essay I will compare and contrast these two criminological perspectives, first by explaining Left and Right Realism, and subsequently developing an analysis to highlight any areas of contrast between the two p...   [tags: Criminology, Sociology, Crime, Political spectrum]

Research Papers
1427 words (4.1 pages)

Essay on The New Criminology : Marxist Perspectives And Jock Young

- The ‘New Criminology’, first published in 1973, was written to criticize all previous criminological theories, positivistic and classical however, were the main focus of critique and to eliminate crime and destroy inequality in a system which has the duality of freedom, and constraint simultaneously (Walklate, 2007). The three Neo-Marxists, Ian Taylor, with criminological theory, Paul Walton, with Marxist perspectives and Jock Young, and his strength in labelling theory approaches, incorporated all their strengths in order to create a fully reached criminological and sociological theory which would critique previous schools and expose their weaknesses(Walton, Taylor, Young, 1988)....   [tags: Sociology, Criminology, Marxism, Capitalism]

Research Papers
1384 words (4 pages)

Essay on Modern Criminology And Classical Criminology

- Classical Criminology is credited with initiating the shift away from rather barbaric forms of torture. In classical criminology, the naturalistic approach of social thinkers had challenged the way of the spiritualistic approach. During this time, the spiritualistic approach was the base for all policies in Europe. This means that every crime had as spiritual meaning for which it was committed. St. Thomas Aquinas, a contributor to the topic, argued that people had a natural tendency to be good rather than evil....   [tags: Criminology, Crime, Criminal justice, Punishment]

Research Papers
1973 words (5.6 pages)

The Role Of Enlightenment And Classical Criminology Essay

- Evaluate the role of Enlightenment thought in the development of Classical Criminology. In this essay I will be writing to ‘Evaluate the role of Enlightenment thought in the development of Classical Criminology’. I will do this by researching key theories and perspectives in the criminological field and seeing if there is a comprehensive relationship between criminological theory and political culture. I will be focusing on how the classical school grew out of the enlightenment. The European enlightenment was the progressive move towards moving out of the religious belief when it came to who ruled the society and law in that time....   [tags: Crime, Criminology, Criminal justice]

Research Papers
2016 words (5.8 pages)

Criminology : Understanding Criminology And Its Purpose Essay

- It is important to understand what it is as well as understanding crime when studying criminology. In the field of criminology, it is important to determine if criminal acts are rationally thought out before being committed, if society plays a role in crime, and what drives an individual to live a life of crime. Over the years many individuals have developed theories as to why crimes are committed. Before you can understand criminology and its purpose, you must have a clear understanding of crime....   [tags: Crime, Criminology, Criminal law]

Research Papers
1801 words (5.1 pages)

Feminist Criminology And Integrated Theory Essay

- Feminist Criminology and Integrated Theory Women have had a profound influence within our world since the beginning of time. From the time women entered the world, they have struggled vigorously to maintain and abide by a view in which society has set forth as one of a predominately male. Men as a whole hold a higher dominance over women in the work place and in many areas of society. This factor, while being biblically, does not hold a very high standing with women today. Women want to be just as equal as men and when women want something, they tend to get it....   [tags: Crime, Criminology, Criminal justice, Sociology]

Research Papers
1311 words (3.7 pages)

Criminology And Criminology Essay

- Although divergent in their analysis, approach and recommendations there is an overarching narrative that is shared by some criminological scholars. Put simply, the discipline of criminology broadly, and the work of criminologists, have been unsuccessful in enacting changes to criminal justice policy (Robinson, 2003, 234; Currie, 2007, 175; Mopas & Moore, 2012, 183). When considering the consensus that surrounds the pitfalls of criminology and criminologists, it seems natural to question the usefulness and the legitimacy of turning to this discipline and practice as a means of accomplishing change in criminal justice policy....   [tags: Crime, Police, Criminal justice, Criminology]

Research Papers
1074 words (3.1 pages)

Criminology Reflection Essay

- Over the years I have been a faithful fan of anything crime related; the anatomy of a crime, from the crime itself, to the investigation, and finally the court for trial and sentencing. I enjoyed the process. The internet became an interesting tool for me to learn all the different things I wanted to know about the subject of crime. I would see something in the media or on television but kept a neutral point of view about technology that was used on a program. Logically speaking, if a crime could be solved in 47 minutes and DNA results took weeks or months, not minutes to process than would it not make sense that real life crimes would be solved far quicker in the name of swift justice....   [tags: Criminology ]

Free Essays
970 words (2.8 pages)

Criminology Essay

- Criminology Assignment This essay will analyse a contemporary Policy document policing in the 21st century: Reconnecting police and the people. It is a document presented by the secretary of state for the Home Department by Command for Her Majesty in July 2010. It will look at how some philosophies of punishment and models of criminal justice are convincing in explaining the methods and tactics used to formulate criminal justice policies as evidence in Policing in the 21st Century: Reconnecting police and the people....   [tags: Legal Issues, Politics, Bureaucratic Models]

Research Papers
2530 words (7.2 pages)

Thirdly values adapted in the sixties, free love etc,
as had an impact on current thinking.

Q2. How does Field's view in Item B differ from the right realist

Field's view differs from that of Marsland, his belief being that
poverty and lack of prospects as well has poor housing the root cause
of begging. He doesn't paint the picture of the 'aggressive handling
of men, women and children' attitude that Marsland adopted but he
viewed them as clean, peaceful and almost faceless people in society.
He asked the question 'not way there are so many crimes committed in
inner-city areas; it is, rather, why aren't there more?' he is stating
that the fact that begging occurs is not a matter of deviancy and high
crime but a fact of life. With regards to right realism, Field's view
does not mirror it, rather it takes an opposite perspective
altogether. He does not believe that begging is the core reason behind
the dip in morals and there seems to be a misconception of the truth
and the reality being that these people in fact do not harass passers
by but beg in a peaceful manner. Field doesn't talk about the
underlying reasons behind begging or offers no explanation for why it
exists; he only paints a more flowery picture of

It instead.

Item B: Adapted from F. Field An Agenda for Britain, 1993, p72
Return to