Ramsay Macdonald's Betrayal of His Party in 1931

Ramsay Macdonald's Betrayal of His Party in 1931

Length: 562 words (1.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Ramsay Macdonald's Betrayal of His Party in 1931

In 1931, Ramsay Macdonald resigned from his position as leader of the
Labour Party and Prime Minster of Britain, to take up a position a few
days later as the leader of the new National Government set up to run
the country, and thus becoming the countries leader again. Many have
claimed that he betrayed the Labour Party by leaving them so he could
join another party in a better position; in other words he was
motivated by personal ambition. This theory can only be proven if it
was known whether or not Ramsay Macdonald knew if he was going to
remain Prime Minister at the time when he resigned Labour from power.

One view of Ramsay Macdonald's resignation is that he resigned from
the leadership to save the party. He realised that he could take the
party no further for the time being, and pre-empting future
embarrassments resigned the party from power to save face and keep
their reputation intact. It is obvious his main thinking behind this
was the rising unemployment in Britain, which was on the verge of
spiralling out of control at the time. Not forgetting that Ramsay
Macdonald was one of the founding members of the Labour Party and so
presumable would not want to see it fail, this argument seems
feasible. However, this view is not widely accepted by many modern
historians. Historian Norman Lowe accuses Macdonald of being:

'vain, ambitious and out of touch with the grass-roots of the party'

Ramsay Macdonald can only truly be judged as a traitor if he knew
before the National Government was formed that he would be heading it.
We can look at the facts to determine the truth. Macdonald would have
known his name would be mud, and in a job like an MP where reputation
is everything, crossing the floor so dramatically would surely have
been a last resort to gain power. But was it his only resort?
Historian David Marquand feels Macdonald didn't know he would remain
Prime Minister at the time he resigned Labour from power, but was:

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Ramsay Macdonald's Betrayal of His Party in 1931." 123HelpMe.com. 26 Jan 2020
    <https://www.123helpme.com/view.asp?id=114795>.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Betrayal of the Labour by Ramsay MacDonald in 1931 Essay

- Betrayal of the Labour by Ramsay MacDonald in 1931 There were many problems faced by Ramsay MacDonald which, forced him to resign however, in this essay I will be discussing whether he betrayed the labour government. This essay will be broken down in to five main bullet points which will all sum up to answer the question above. The main problems faced by Ramsay MacDonald was economic and also the minority position. Ramsay MacDonald’s government was opposed by the liberals and so as a result Ramsay MacDonald had to do something, a deal was struck with the Liberals that they would not stand against each other in by-elections leading up to 1914....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
967 words (2.8 pages)

George MacDonald's The Princess and the Goblin Essays

- George MacDonald's The Princess and the Goblin In his novel The Princess and the Goblin, George MacDonald has cleverly crafted an underground society populated by a distorted and "ludicrously grotesque" race. Within the body of his tale, he reveals that these people are descended from humans, and did in fact, once upon a time, live upon the surface themselves. Only eons of living separated from fresh air and sunlight have caused them to evolve into the misshapen creatures we meet in this story (MacDonald, 2-4)....   [tags: MacDonald Princess Goblin Essays]

Free Essays
1318 words (3.8 pages)

George MacDonald's The Princess and the Goblin Essays

- George MacDonald's The Princess and the Goblin All over the world people have believed in a race of creatures, superhuman and subhuman, that are not gods or ghosts, but differ from humans in their powers, properties, and attributes (Briggs, Vanishing 27). The concepts of these creatures/fairies have been passed down through generations in many cultures through forms such as songs, sayings, and stories. Stories such as folktales and myths have wide array of fairy types found in them from various cultures' folklores (Abrams 101)....   [tags: MacDonald Princess Goblin essays]

Free Essays
1667 words (4.8 pages)

George MacDonald's The Princess and the Goblin Essays

- George MacDonald's The Princess and the Goblin The moon has been worshipped as a female deity since the beginning of time. Not only is the moon a feminine principle, it is also a symbol of transformation due to its own monthly cycle of change. With this in mind, it is clear upon a close reading of The Princess and the Goblin by George MacDonald that the grandmother figure is a personification of the moon, and as such is a catalyzing agent for Irene's maturation and transformation through the course of the novel....   [tags: MacDonald Princess Goblin Essays]

Free Essays
1170 words (3.3 pages)

MacDonald's The Princess and the Goblin Essays

- MacDonald's The Princess and the Goblin The Princess and the Goblin is a story about self-realisation and the expansion of limits. The princess, Irene, is able to come to certain conclusions about herself with the help of her grandmother, who lives in the attic upstairs in the palace. The grandmother guides Irene through her rite of passage into adulthood, and helps to bring the princess and Curdie together in the end. However, the reader never really knows whether the grandmother even exists, and it is this uncertainty that causes the reader to question whether she is a personification of a force within Irene that is driving her to achieve all that she does....   [tags: MacDonald Princess Goblin Essays]

Research Papers
1231 words (3.5 pages)

Essay George MacDonald's The Princess and the Goblin

- George MacDonald's The Princess and the Goblin Like many other renowned novels aimed at children, George MacDonald's The Princess and the Goblin draws extensively from the folk tradition in his telling of the tale. Many of the figures presented, such as the nurse and Curdie, have precedent in the tradition, but the grandmother in particular stands out. Archetypally, she is a variant on the Old Man, though she bears the undeniable touch of the supernatural as seen in common folklore - at times she is otherworldly and some of her actions and abilities are of the sort frequently associated with witches....   [tags: MacDonald Princess Goblin Essays]

Research Papers
1238 words (3.5 pages)

Rhetoric and Betrayal in Julius Caeser Play Essay example

- William Shakespeare’s famous play Julius Caesar utilizes the literary element of rhetoric multiple times throughout to show the true power that words can hold. The rhetoric in Caesar accompanies the play’s themes of betrayal, deception, and exaggeration. Brutus uses rhetoric to persuade the crowd of plebeians that the murdering of Caesar was positive and beneficial to all of Rome, winning their support and causing them to join his cause. Soon after, Mark Antony gives a terrifically-persuasive speech that he claims to be a funeral oration for Caesar, but is truly a cleverly-shrouded undermining to Brutus’s speech....   [tags: julius caeser, shakespeare, betrayal]

Research Papers
1472 words (4.2 pages)

Essay The Germanic and Celtic Tradition by George MacDonald

- The Germanic and Celtic Tradition by George MacDonald One of the most interesting things about fairytales is how the author has borrowed ideas from ancient myths and legends and kept them alive in their writings. The Princess and the Goblin is one of these fairytales. In writing this novel, George MacDonald has incorporated much of the folk tradition in his characters and plot. Specifically, his concept of goblins seem to be drawn from the tradition of dwarfs, gnomes, and kobolds of Germanic myth and the fairies, or elves, of Celtic myth....   [tags: Germanic Celtin Macdonald Fairytales Essays]

Free Essays
954 words (2.7 pages)

Dr. Jeffrey MacDonald's Fight for Innocence Essay

- Dr. Jeffrey MacDonald's Fight for Innocence Debated as one of the most misrepresented cases in American legal history, Dr. Jeffrey MacDonald still fights for innocence. Contrary to infallible evidence, prosecution intentionally withheld crucial information aiding MacDonald’s alibi. Such ratification included proof of an outside attack that would have played a major role in Jeffrey’s case. Convicted for the murders of his wife and two kids, thirty-four years ago, Dr. MacDonald still endures the agony of being accused of killing his family....   [tags: Dr. Jeffrey MacDonald Crime Justice System Essays]

Research Papers
1458 words (4.2 pages)

MacDonald Essay

- Although they represented differed political parties, Sir John A. MacDonald and Sir Wilfred Laurier pursued the same goals while in office. MacDonald recognized Canada's need for protective tariffs on exported goods, the need of settlement in the west, and the need for a railway to unify the nation. MacDonald immediately implemented protectionism and the establishment of a railway. On the other hand, Laurier took these goals and expanded on them. John A. MacDonald outlined the goals of Canada in the National Policy and these goals were accomplished in the period of the Laurier Boom....   [tags: Business, Protective Tariffs Policy]

Research Papers
1180 words (3.4 pages)

'persuaded to stay on as Prime Minister of an all-party government as
the best way of avoiding an election and restoring confidence.'

The current period in office for Labour had been a struggle. The
previous two years had been marred by crisis after crisis, with Labour
inheriting many problems not dealt with by Baldwin's Tories. The most
pressing issue would be the alarming rise in unemployment that was
showing no signs of slowing down. To address this problem, Macdonald
turned to J. H. Thomas and a small committee including Oswald Mosley.
Macdonald promptly sacked an incapable Thomas. The Mosley Memorandum
put forward included reducing imports, subsiding agriculture,
introducing pensions at 60 and raising the school leaving age to 15.
This was dismissed for being 'too expensive'. Mosley was replaced by
Sir George May, whose May Report was forced through by Macdonald,
eventually winning 11/9.

Given these circumstances (his apart lack of support - only winning
11/9), it was quite likely that Macdonald would resign from power, yet
his final reason looks more like an excuse than a justification.
Macdonald took the 11/9 vote as a sign that he had hardly any support
and no majority, and resigned, yet more than 50% of the votes were in
his favour.

The fact that Macdonald formed the National Government, or was
persuaded to, shows that he still believed he was able to solve the
problems, especially unemployment. He felt he could relate to many
people's problems due to his middle class upbringing and socialist
background, and so leaving the Labour Party for personal reasons does
not seem such a strange idea.

The argument that Macdonald was motivated by personal ambition has
further weight added to it when it is claimed he resigned Labour to
save not only the parties' reputation, but his own. This is almost
certainly true, as he didn't want to suffer embarrassment on purpose,
yet it is probably not true that he wanted to save is reputation for
running the coalition.

We will never know the truth, as Ramsay Macdonald carried it to the
grave, yet we can surmise that his decision to resign Labour from
power was motivated by 75% wanting to do the best for Labour, and 25%
personal ambition.
Return to 123HelpMe.com