Shylock Deserves Sympathy

Shylock Deserves Sympathy

Length: 603 words (1.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Shylock Deserves Sympathy

Shylock is indeed a complex character and has the dimension of pain-he
has suffered, still suffers and is one of a people who have suffered
over centuries. However, to what extent should Shylock suffer and does
he deserve our sympathy or hostility. Although anti-Semitism is
totally unacceptable today, it was quite normal in Shakespeare's time.
However, as he has done with other villains, Shakespeare actually
plays around with his audience's preconceptions and makes Shylock an
interesting, complex and sometimes likable character.

Being a Jew in Christian dominated Venice, Shylock is persecuted by
society. He is the victim of popular Christian prejudice, which scorns
his religion and restricts his means of employment. He is left with no
choice but to be a moneylender and earn his money from collecting
interest. To the Christians, collecting interest was against their
teaching. This is one of the reasons for the Christians hatred.

In Act III scene I Salanio and Salarino confront Shylock, mocking him
about his daughter's deception and insulting him. Shylock explains why
he will take Antonio's flesh, making his famous speech, 'I am a Jew.
Hath not a Jew eyes? Hath not a Jew hands, organs, dimensions, senses,
affections, passions?' This is where Shakespeare evokes our sympathy,
by making us realise how Shylock has suffered because of the
prejudices of the Christians around him. He explains his motives for
revenge in a rational way, showing how his actions are no different
from the Christians'. Look carefully at the language he uses, as well
as the insulting and mocking language used by the other two. At the
end of the scene, Shylock mourns the loss of his daughter, although
our feelings towards him are a bit mixed, for he seems to care more
about the money. He does give evidence, however, of his love for his
wife, which again, creates sympathy. Shylock is merely responding in
the same way that he has had people respond to him all his life.

However, it would be unjust to brand the Christians as spiteful

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Shylock Deserves Sympathy." 15 Dec 2018

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Shylock in William Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice Essay

- Shylock in William Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice Shylock is in many ways much more difficult for us to deal with today than for Shakespeare's audience. We have seen a hatred for the Jews since Shakespeare's time with Hitler's attempt to wipe out the Jewish race, but people in Shakespeare's day were unlikely to have met Jews who had not converted to Christianity as they had already been banned from England for three hundred years. So people in England would be opposing the character Shylock because they are ignorant of the Jews....   [tags: Merchant of Venice Essays]

Research Papers
1734 words (5 pages)

Essay about Shylock of William Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice

- Shylock of William Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice Shylock is one of the main characters in Shakespeare's play "The Merchant of Venice", he starts in the play as an outcast of society because he is Jewish. Shylock has been forced to become a banker in his life as an inhabitant of Venice, for the fact that his religion is seen as wrong. Although Shylock is forced to become a banker he plays a vital role in the city of Venice, without Shylock the city would struggle economically....   [tags: Merchant of Venice Essays]

Research Papers
795 words (2.3 pages)

The Character of Shylock in William Shakespeare's Play Essay

- The Character of Shylock in William Shakespeare's Play Shylock is a Jewish money lender living in Venice in the 1600s. He is a widower and has a daughter who he does not care about. In Venice Jews were discriminated against because of their religion, they were forced to live in separate places and were spat on. The definition of a victim is someone who is picked on. A villain is someone who discriminates about people. Venice was a trading city with ships coming in and out. My first point is about how Shylock is a victim....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
1103 words (3.2 pages)

Essay about Antigone Deserves More Sympathy than Creon

- Antigone Deserves More Sympathy than Creon      In the Antigone, unlike the Oedipus Tyrannus, paradoxically, the hero who is left in agony at the end of the play is not the title role. Instead King Creon, the newly appointed and tyrannical ruler, is left all alone in his empty palace with his wife's corpse in his hands, having just seen the suicide of his son. However, despite this pitiable fate for the character, his actions and behavior earlier in the play leave the final scene evoking more satisfaction than pity at his torment....   [tags: Antigone vs Creon]

Research Papers
2545 words (7.3 pages)

Shylock : Villain Or Victim Essay

- Shylock: Villain or Victim In the Shakespeare comedy The Merchant of Venice we find a Jewish moneylender, Shylock, a victim of anti-Semitism, cursed as he tries to make his way in a Christian society. It is not long before Shylock is presented with an opportunity to extract revenge on one of his oppressors a Christian merchant Antonio, who is in need of Shylock’s services. Antonio needs three-thousand ducats to send his good friend Bassanio on a romantic journey. In turn Shylock wants a “pound of flesh” to guarantee the bond....   [tags: The Merchant of Venice, Shylock, Portia, Usury]

Research Papers
1218 words (3.5 pages)

Sympathy for Shylock in William Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice Essay

- Sympathy for Shylock in William Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice Shylock shows an almost double sided character, he appears to be a villain some times and then a victim at others. Although with this in mind I have come to believe that he is really a true villain that has only a few good attributes compared to many more evil ones. Shylock in the majority of the play is trying to find a way in which he can seek his revenge on Christians in particular Antonio to whom some of his first words are directed; "If I can catch him once upon the hip, I will feed fat the ancient grudge I bear him," By this he means that if he just gets one opportunity then he will...   [tags: Free Merchant of Venice Essays]

Free Essays
868 words (2.5 pages)

Sympathy for Shylock in William Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice Essay

- Sympathy for Shylock in William Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice The Merchant of Venice is about a rich Christian merchant who borrows money from a Jewish moneylender to help his friend in marriage. Antonio borrows money from Shylock because Bassanio, one of Antonio's best friends, needed the money to impress Portia of Belmont. Although Antonio is rich, all his money is tied up in his business of shipping "Thou know'st that all my fortunes are at sea". Portia comes from a wealthy family, in her fathers will he says only the person who chooses the right casket can ask Portia's hand in marriage "the lottery that he hath devised in these three chests of gold, silve...   [tags: Free Merchant of Venice Essays]

Free Essays
1234 words (3.5 pages)

Macbeth Does Not Deserve Our Sympathy Essay

- Macbeth Does Not Deserve Our Sympathy   Our first impressions of Macbeth are that he is a hero, he is brave and fearless, and although we get this impression we also get the feeling that he is ruthless. We get this impression from the way he is referred to when his name is first mentioned. Macbeth has just been in battle against "The merciless Macdonwald" and a Captain is talking about how Macbeth and his fellow Captain, Banquo, performed in battle. While Macbeth is in battle the Thane of Cawdor is found to be a traitor and executed....   [tags: Macbeth essays]

Research Papers
1756 words (5 pages)

Sympathy, by Paul Laurence Dunbar: A Reflection of the African American's Struggle for Freedom

- Sympathy, by Paul Laurence Dunbar: A Reflection of the African American's Struggle for Freedom I know what the caged bird feels, alas. When the sun is bright on the upland slopes; When the wind stirs soft through the springing grass, And the river flows like a stream of glass; When the first bud sings and the first bud opes, And the faint perfume from its chalice steals-- I know what the caged bird feels. "Sympathy" was written by Paul Laurence Dunbar in 1899, right at the end of the Nineteenth Century....   [tags: Dunbar Sympathy Essays]

Research Papers
905 words (2.6 pages)

Shylock Essay

- Shylock Shylock is the topic of this piece of coursework. He was a character in the merchant of Venice which was written by Shakespeare. The play was first printed in 1600 and was first seen as a copy of the play “Jew of Malta”. One of the reasons Shakespeare chose Venice as the setting for his play was that Venice had many cultures and religions in it. Also Venice was very wealthy at the time. Shylock is in 5 scenes in the play. The part he plays is very important to the whole play....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
577 words (1.6 pages)

racists and describe Shylock as a helpless victim, deserving our full
sympathy. Shylock is also sinned against his own flesh and blood. Once
again, however, it would be a gross distortion to label Jessica as an
unfilial, daughter and regard Shylock as the innocent, injured party.
It was stated that Shylock was unfair to Jessica and did not treat her
very well. Later, after that incident, we see a more human side to
Shylock's character when he hears that Jessica has sold his ring given
to him by his wife.

However, Shylock loses our sympathy when we see his avaricious nature.
In addition, we cannot excuse Shylock's devious vengeful nature as
demonstrated in the way which he is cunningly entraps Antonio to 'feed
his revenge'. In the court scene, Portia, with whom the audience feels
great sympathy, is arguing against Shylock. His argument seems to have
less force here and we feel that he is being unfairly cruel and
stubborn, especially after Antonio has lost his fortune. His lack of
humanity is fully highlighted here, by not showing mercy to Antonio by
accepting the money. This can still be argued that Shylock
stubbornness was to show that he would hold firm to the law and he was
not a greedy man. However, some sympathy for Shylock may be created as
a result of Antonio's spiteful speech, 'I pray you, think you question
with the Jew: You may as well go stand upon the beach /And bid the
main flood bate his usual height;'

The fact that he does not win the case - and even loses a great deal
of money - may be just rewards, according to some people. Others feel
sorry for him, because it seems as if everyone, including the just
Portia, is against him. Moreover, the punishment meted out to him is
rather harsh on several counts.

Shylock leaves the play feeling ill and old, having lost everything
that makes his life worth living, including his self-esteem, a broken
man, we truly feel sorry for him, perhaps because the Christian relish
their triumph so much and because we feel in our heart of hearts that
Jessica's romance is built on ducats rather than devotion.

Ultimately, Shylock loses all our sympathy because his method of
revenge is that of cold and calculating murder. He is a villain, but
we do have sympathy in his sufferings for much of the play. Shylock is
difficult to judge because he is not merely a caricature, even though
Shakespeare perhaps meant him to be originally, he is a real person
and he is too complex to make facile judgments about.
Return to