Investigating What happened in the Red Square

Investigating What happened in the Red Square

Length: 2214 words (6.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Investigating What happened in the Red Square

The building, which is outlined in the Red Square, is our site called
"The Glasshouse pit", Scotch horn, Nailsea.

I am investigating what happened at this site and what certain
features were used for at the site, by using various sources provided.

I had to split up the following statement and answer it in separate
bits.

"There are no problems explaining the Glasshouse pit. It was a 19th
century Coal mine with a steam driven pumping house, a horse gin for
winding and 2 shafts, all in use at the same time".



[IMAGE]



· Part 1, "19th century coal mine"?

Our site located at Scotch Horn was a 19th century coal mine because,
source 1 states that there was coal, with sandstone under Nailsea.
This source is accurate and reliable because it is an official
geography map presented by trained geologists. Geologists are taught
in top universities an would of carried out several tests beforehand
to prove that the Nailsea area had coal present.

Again source 27 has a detailed map of the Nailsea area, showing where
the major coal mines were based in Nailsea. Source 27 is reliable
because a local historian called Mark Hornby has produced this map of
Nailsea, showing where all the major coalmines in the 19th century
Nailsea coalfield were based. So this means that since there were so
many coalmines in Nailsea, this suggests that coal was definitely
mined in the 19th century.

Source 11 "The 40 Fathoms" again suggests that coal was mined in
nailsea because in great detail, it explains about an old coal pit on
back land, now called "Whites field Road". It goes on to say that the
coal mine was ceased by about 1830, which is in the 19th century.
Source 11 is a reliable source because it is an extract of a history
book, which was written by a local historian.



Source 10 explains about the depth of the mineshafts and it was a
report by H.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Investigating What happened in the Red Square." 123HelpMe.com. 05 Dec 2019
    <https://www.123helpme.com/view.asp?id=113254>.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Analysis Of The Movie ' Red Square '

- As if watching the sun rise from dusk. The mood of each dance performances started off, dark with splices of light, increasing through the performance. Numerous elements from each dance piece, combined to create the mood. Performed by the University of Houston dancers, Chapman-Dance, and Teresa Chapman, they each evoked different compelling perspectives of modern dance. Dusky and Vibrant theme was evident in each performances through such elements as costumes, movements, and concepts. I. Body A....   [tags: Dance, Performance, Choreography, Isadora Duncan]

Research Papers
1187 words (3.4 pages)

The Air Defense And Military Force During The Middle Of Red Square Essay

- In 1987, a nineteen year old West German landed his Cessna light aircraft in the middle of Red Square simultaneously shocking western defense and diplomatic officials while embarrassing the Soviet military and political elites. A single, cheap civilian airplane, in the face of seemingly insurmountable USSR air defense, had achieved a significant strategic effect. Such an action ran counter to traditional western military philosophy. Not discounting other forms of national power, nations have normally turned to military force to achieve desired strategic effects....   [tags: World War II, Cold War, Soviet Union, Red Army]

Research Papers
700 words (2 pages)

Investigating The Permeability Of The Membrane Using Red Blood Cells Essay

- An investigation of the permeability of erythrocyte membranes. A membrane is a barrier between the cell contents and the cells surroundings. The structure of a membrane contains a lipid bilayer that forms a membrane by the arrangement of molecules. (Wright, 2015) The functions of the membrane are to protect the cell, detecting molecules and cells within the external environment and control the cells contents. (Nature Edition, 2012) Chemicals can get through a cell membrane by the nuclear pore complex, which controls what enters and exits the nucleus....   [tags: Cell membrane, Red blood cell, Cell nucleus, Blood]

Research Papers
939 words (2.7 pages)

Analysis Of Chi / Square Test For Independence And Chi Square Essay example

- 12 – Chi (Ki) Square Slide 1: Welcome back. During the past several power points, we have discussed various statistical techniques using a dependent variable at the interval or ratio level. Slide 2: This power point presentation presents the statistical technique, Chi-Square, which is designed to test the significant relationship between the attributes or categories of a nominal independent variables and a nominal dependent variable. There are two types of Chi-Square Tests - Chi-Square Test for Independence and Chi-Square for Goodness of Fit....   [tags: Pearson's chi-square test, Chi-square test]

Research Papers
1546 words (4.4 pages)

Essay about The Immortal Villain of Washington Square

- The Immortal Villain of Washington Square       In Washington Square, Henry James confronts us with an exceptionally hopeless kind of tragedy. The oppressive circumstances of protagonists usually arise from failures of individual or social enlightenment. Such stories are optimistic to the extent that they suggest that progress might eventually lift mankind beyond the scope of the type of situations depicted. In Washington Square, however, truth itself is the oppressor -- a universal truth of human nature which, a century after publication, we are still loath to recognize....   [tags: Washington Square Essays]

Research Papers
2184 words (6.2 pages)

Convention and Realism in Henry James’ Washington Square Essay

- Convention and Realism in Henry James’ Washington Square Realism, as described by William Dean Howells in the late nineteenth century, replaces the high art and style of the literature of the preceding decades by permitting such characters as Howells' Silas Lapham to have a distinct place in the pantheon of American literary characters. Fervently, Howells invoked the "truth" of the realist genre, writing, "ŒLet it portray men and women as they are, actuated by the motives and the passions in the measure we all know...let it speak the dialect, the language, that most Americans know - the language of unaffected people everywhere'" (Fictions of the Real, 188)....   [tags: Washington Square]

Research Papers
2404 words (6.9 pages)

Essay about Malevicth red square

- Malevicth red square The painting Red Square by Russian painter Kasimir Malevich is a particularly interesting piece. It is simple red square on a white background representing a peasant woman. It is an example of the Malevich's unique style of suprematism, which focuses on motion and feeling. The painting was done near the beginning of the twentieth century when science was developing at a rapid rate. Einstein's Theory of Relativity was gaining ground at the time. Malevich's painting seemed to borrow from this theory that attempted to explain relative motion....   [tags: Essays Papers]

Free Essays
572 words (1.6 pages)

Essay on Henry James' ‘Washington Square

- Henry James' ‘Washington Square In ‘Washington Square', Henry James used a refined technique of narration, language, symbolism and irony as he explored the psychological dimensions of his characters' actions, motivations and interpersonal relationships. He did so as he confronted the tragedy of the immorality of human beings, personified in the characters of Dr. Sloper and Morris Townsend, in dominating the spirit of Sloper's daughter, Catherine, for their own ends. In other works of fiction where the oppressive circumstances of protagonists usually arise from failures of society and within the specific individual there is often an optimism to the extent that it is suggested that progress m...   [tags: Henry James Washington Square Analysis]

Free Essays
1413 words (4 pages)

Tian An Men Square Killings Diary Essay

- Tian An Men Square Killings Diary Foreword: During my nightmarish time in China I met many people whom I would call heroes. Nothing in this recital is exaggerated. It reads the way it happened. April 3rd As we arrived in Beijing, we were by met Lao Xu our guide and personal VIP pass to all of China's interesting and exiting places. He approached us and introduced himself and gave us a warm, but slightly hesitant welcome. Lao Xu found it difficult to say my name, so he decided he would give me a Chinese name, Shan Da, which means "tall mountain"....   [tags: China Tian An Men Square History]

Free Essays
1769 words (5.1 pages)

Henry James' Washington Square Essay

- Henry James'Washington Square Henry James' Washington Square is more than a simple novel with simple characters connected by a simple plot. There are more complex issues brought forth within the text besides a daughter heartbroken over her father's control and the departure of her money grubbing suitor. Yet only the simplistic issues and characterizations are brought forth in the critical article written by Elizabeth Hardwick. Within the pages of "On Washington Square," published in English 3230, Hardwick offers her readers the entire plot, including the ending of James' novel, without shedding new light on the text....   [tags: Henry James'Washington Square]

Free Essays
409 words (1.2 pages)

Law in 1854, so again it states that coal was mined in
the 19th century.
===================================================================



Source 9a says and shows by an illustration that Nailsea was a part of
a large mining industry, "The Bristol coal field". Nailsea contributed
to the over all total of 13,00 to 14,000 tones of coal per week.
Source 9a is reilable because it is a first hand account, meaning that
someone wrote out what they saw at that time.
======================================================================



Source 6 is also a reliable source because it says that no new
colleries were needed because the old ones still existed are were
fully functional. This source is useful because some one in the coal
business has carried out a survey of coal measurements.
====================================================================

19th century conclusion

The evidence suggests that our site was in use in the 19th century
around the years when the Bristol coal field was around, which was in
the early 19th century. The Nailsea coal field was part of an
expansion of the Bristol coal field in the 19th century.

· Part 2, "What was the circular structure at out site, and what was
it used for"?

I think the circular wall like structure at our site was a Horse Gin.
I think it is a Horse Gin because Source 36 shows in a reconstruction
diagram that a horse Gin is a circular stone structure, with a
mineshaft in the middle, which relates to our site. Source 36 is
reliable because a specialist in geology has drawn the diagram.
However this source is a reconstruction and therefore may not be
reliable.

Picture of horse gin "source 36".




The picture of the Horse gin on source 36

Is a Horseshoe shaped wall with a shaft,

to One corner. It also has to ramp shaped

pieces Of wooden ramps either side of a

tiled box object., which could have been

steps. This picture suggests that it was

used for some sort of winding instrument.

Picture of horse gin "our site".

The circular stone structure at our site does

Relate to source 36. This is because it has

a hole in one corner of the ground

which most probably was a mineshaft.

The stone structure also has step like stones

to one side of it, which is similar

to source 36.

The evidence from source 36 suggests

that our Site was a horse gin, but we are

still not sure what it was used for.

Souce 13 says that the Horse Gin as used for pumping water from
underneath the ground (from the shaft) in north Wales in 1698. Source
13 is not very reliable because its in the wrong time frame meaning
that its to early, and is completely irrelevant to us. Secondly it is
not very reliable because North Wales is a completely different area
to the Bristol district and could use different equipment for
different purposes.

Source 11 is completely different to the previous source because it
states that Horse Gins were used for winding coal, instead of pumping.

Source 14 is also a useful source because it goes on to tell you that
a horse gin acts as a winding engine and it uses horse power for the
pumping and pulling up coal. This source is a reliable one because it
is a source from the "British Social and Economic History" by P F
speed.

Horse Gin Conclusion

The evidence suggests that Horse Gins were either used for pumping
water from underground or for winding in coal from the mineshaft.
Horse Gins used horsepower and pulled in coal and even miners from the
mineshaft.

HORSE GIN

Pumps water Winding engine for coal and

perhaps people

Horse power

· Part 3, "2 Mineshafts"?

After looking at the evidence, I don't agree that there were 2
Mineshafts at our site at Scotch Horn, but only 1 shaft instead.

I believe this because I only saw one shaft at our site, which was
located in the corner of the horse gin. Also source 11 "the 40
fathoms" says that many of the mines in Nailsea had only one shaft, so
it's likely that the one at scotch horn also had one shaft. Source 11
is reliable because it goes in to a lot of detail what the mines were
like in Nailsea, but I doesn't say when it was written or who wrote
it, so it may also be unreliable. The reconstruction on source 36 has
a diagram of the horse gin and it shows only one mineshaft in it.

Picture of a mineshaft, source 36




The mineshaft is based in between 2

large wooden beams and was used

for the miners to access the coal from

beneath the ground.

The depth of mine shafts varied, some

were50-90 ft deep where as some

were 240ft deep such as the

"40 fathoms" (1 fathom =6ft).

2 mineshafts conclusion

Even though there is little evidence about mineshafts, there is no
evidence that agrees with any mines having 2 mine shafts, but only
evidence that points to it having one shaft.

· Part 4, "what was the tower at are site used for"?


The tower at our site, at scotch horn may have been a pumping house.
This is because on source 36 it shows a picture of a pumping house at
elm colliery and did look similar to the tower at our site. The tower
looked similar because it is a tall narrow building, with an archway,
which looked like windows. These windows look familiar to the ones in
source 36, source 36 shows that beams came out of the windows of the
pumping house and were led down to the horse gin. The ruined building
at scotch horn also has several holes in the wall, which also,
according to source 36, had large beams coming from them. As said
previously, source 36 is a Reconstruction by David Lambert and may be
unreliable.
---------------------------------------------------------------------


There is also another source (source 24) which suggests that it is a
pumping house because it explains about pumping arrangements at the
elm colliery. It has a listed diagram of different equipment including
pumping equipment, and where they were positioned. This source may be
reliable because it backs up source 36, which again talks about elms
colliery. This source may not be reliable because it is also a
reconstruction and it has no key or author written on it.
----------------------------------------------------------------------


Source 36- picture of pumping house
-----------------------------------




The building is a tall arched building
--------------------------------------

Similar to our site. The picture

Shows a large boiler to one side, Of

the tower which Has no resemblance

to our site. The windows are very

similar to our site because the patter

is the same.

Overall this building has the correct

Shape and structure to the ruin at our

Site. Lack of evidence.

Alternatively our site could have instead been a winding house.

The site could have been used as a winding house because source 36 has
a picture of a winding house, which has some familiar features on it,
such as it has a wheel in the wall. This wheel went through the wall
and at our site there is a large groove shaped indentation, which may
have well been where the wheel was. Secondly this picture on source 36
has a chimney to one corner of it, our site looked as if it also had a
chimney due to the ruined shape spout to one corner. Otherwise this
picture has nothing else similar to the building at our site because
the shape is completely different to the picture in source 36, the
building is tall and not a small rectangle shape like the picture of
the winding house, source 36.

As said previously source 36 may not be reliable because it is a
reconstruction and therefore may be completely different.

Source 11. The 40 fathoms says that "the tower behind the ivy was a
winding house for the mine, similar to the one at scotch horn playing
fields". This source may not be reliable because it had no dates or
authors on it at all, but the source does sound interesting and has a
lot of detail. I think this source is crucial because it says directly
what the tower at scotch horn was used for, but it still may not be
very reliable. Source 5 is also a useful source because it is a plan
of the Nailsea glassworks produced in 1870. This building at scotch
horn is labelled a "coal winding house". This source may be reliable
because it is an official plan of the Nailsea glassworks and it is
labelled with a key. This source may not be reliable because in my
view it is poorly annotated and it has no author.

Source 25 is also interesting because it is the winding arrangements
of at elms colliery and it shows the equipment used in the winding
house. This source is reliable because it is an official plan of the
winding arrangements at elms colliery. However this source may not be
reliable because it has no dates, no authors, and it is very brief
like the plan of the Nailsea glassworks.

Conclusion for what the tower was used for.

The evidence suggests that there is more suitable (stronger) evidence
that points towards the tower being a winding house. I think the tower
was most probably used as a winding house but it could have been used
for both? Judging on the size of the tower, I doubt it would be able
to fit all of the pumping and winding equipment in.

· Part 5,"All in use at the same time"?.

The Horse gin and the engine house were not in used at the same time;
I think this because on source 2 there is a map of Nailsea glassworks,
late 1830's. This source shows that there is a circular structure
where our site is, this was most probably the horse gin, but there was
no sign of the tower in this source. This source is reliable because
it is an official plan of the Nailsea glassworks belonging to Messrs
Lucan Cothupe & Coin the late 1830's. However this source is poorly
annotated and has no detail, it is just very brief and has a vague
date, it doesn't have any labels or keys on it.

Source 4 is very similar to the previous source and it proves that the
Horse gin and the engine house were not in use at the same time
because the map seems to have half a tower and no horse gin on it.
This may suggest that the tower was in development and was being built
or rebuilt, we wont no though because of no date on this source. This
source is not very reliable because it has no date, no author or no
title and it is poorly annotated. Source 5 also says that the tower
was in 1870 but the horse was not.

Conclusion, " In use at the same time"?

The evidence suggests that the Horse gin and the engine house were not
used at the same time. The sources say that the horse gin or the tower
could have been built at different periods and eventually used at the
same time.

· Part 6, "there are no problems explaining the glass house pit".

There are many problems explaining our site for example may pieces of
evidence were not reliable either because they were wither poorly
annotated, given a vague date or had no author. The evidence is mainly
contradictory and could be fake or incorrect. Plans such as the
Glasswork plans are poor because they don't have very good keys, if
any. Reconstruction's such as source 36 can seem interesting and
helpful but it could also be a poor reconstruction, and is in my view.
Evidence was in small quantities for several questions such as, " It
was a pumping house", and I couldn't find much information about it at
all, apart from source 36 which is a reconstruction.

The evidence its self may not be to blame for problems. This is
because the site is not in great condition and various clues could
have been taken away when Tesco was built, leaving us with various
answers that cannot be explained.

There is also a lot of puzzling features at our site for example the
large groove in the wall, which was most probably where the wheel went
for the winding, but we can not be sure of that still. There were a
few holes in the wall about 3-4 inches deep. These could have been
used for large wooden beams, which led down to the horse gin, but we
won't know because of a lack of evidence in this field. There were
step like stones on the side of the horse gin, which I have no idea
what they were used for and there is no evidence suggesting anything
to do with steps. I think they may have been used for a helpful access
to the mineshaft, which is in the horse gin.

The chimney was tiered and had an archway on it, I don't know why the
chimney would need to be tiered or have an archway on it and there is
no evidence saying why.

Conclusion.

I agree with the lack of helpful evidence because there is a lot of
evidence but most of it is irrelevant and does not help at all. If
there were more useful evidence then maybe we would be able to answer
the puzzling features. I also agree with our site being in bad
condition. I believe this because the tower is only in a basic form at
the moment, it only has the foundation left and there is nothing left
inside, it isn't protected and is vulnerable to vandalism. Someone
could mistake it for some sort of medieval jail. I also blame Tesco in
a way because they should not of taken valuable pieces of history away
from the site.

I don't agree with that fact that some of the evidence is fake, this
is because at the time someone would realise it was fake and it
wouldn't of been published if it was fake.

· Question 2, "Why were the interpretations different"?

There are various reasons why interpretations were different such as
many different pieces of evidence were looked at. For examplethe
interpretations about mine shafts in Nailsea are different because we
looked at several different sources that has completely different
views to each other, such as source 24. Source 24 is about the pumping
arrangements at elms colliery, this source suggests that pumping took
place, not winding. Where as source 11 " 40 fathoms" suggests that the
site was used for winding not pumping. Source 36, the reconstruction,
suggests that is may have been used for a winding and pumping station.

The time frame of different sources could make a huge difference
because after researching the site now we have more evidence, where as
in the 1960's there was less evidence. The author of a source may have
different opinions to someone else's view about a particular fact thus
making 2 opposite sources. Guessing could have happened, such as
reconstruction's could not be as accurate as they could be and the
author could of added something that may not of existed.

The Tourist board most probably made the facts basic and simple so
that tourist's could understand or the tourist board may of wrote a
statement on coal mines in general or ones that are within this
district (Bristol), but the scotch horn coal mine could be different
to those elsewhere.
Return to 123HelpMe.com