Criticism of Joyce's Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man

Criticism of Joyce's Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man

Length: 484 words (1.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
James Augustine Aloysius Joyce, the author of A Portrait of an Artist as a Young Man, was once described by a friend, Constantine Curran, as "a man of unparalleled vituperative power, a virtuoso in speech with unique control of the vernacular." While Constantine viewed Joyce's quality of verbal abuse "powerful," and praised his "control" of the language, many viewed this expressive and unrestrained style of writing as inappropriate and offensive. A dramatic new step for modernism, Joyce used language, style, and descriptions of previously unwritten thoughts and situations which stirred the cultural norm, thus sparking controversy over what was necessary and acceptable in literature.

While the reactions to A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man were not as severe as were those of Ulysses, it was still considered shocking, and was judged by critics including "The Times," "The Manchester Guardian," and even Edward Garnett, who had encouraged D. H. Lawrence. Criticisms and complaints about the book's "occasional improprieties" (The Times), and "astounding bad manners" (Manchester guardian) were common, and it is easy to see why taking into account the reserved culture in 1916. This aspect of supporting whether or not I agree with the accusations of the books morality and appropriateness is difficult because one cannot base the subject matter and use of language on today's culture and acceptance. Surely the material written by Joyce does not provoke the same feelings today as it did when it was first published, but, putting the time period in respect, I would agree that it was inappropriate material to have presented. Considering that even the bed-wetting event which takes place on the first page of the book was considered unsuitable, I feel that while it may have been practiced, such matters of prostitution and sexual promiscuity were certainly unnecessary.

In addition to the controversial content of the book was the matter of Joyce's style. Not denying Joyce's ability, Garnett wrote it was "ably written," except he felt that it was too "discursive, formless, unrestrained, and ugly things, ugly words, are too prominent." Also, Garnett criticized that it was too "unconventional," and "unless the author will use restraint and proportion he will not gain readers." Having read the book, I too agree with Garnett that the style in which the book was written does not encourage the reader to advance through the story.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Criticism of Joyce's Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man." 20 Oct 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay Religion and Stephen in Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man

- Religion and Its Effect on Stephen in A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man Religion is an important and recurring theme in James Joyce's A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man.  Through his experiences with religion, Stephen Dedalus both matures and progressively becomes more individualistic as he grows. Though reared in a Catholic school, several key events lead Stephen to throw off the yoke of conformity and choose his own life, the life of an artist.             Religion is central to the life of Stephen Dedalus the child....   [tags: Portrait Artist Young Man]

Free Essays
1194 words (3.4 pages)

Rejection and Isolation in A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man Essay

- As James Joyce's A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man unfolds, the central theme of isolation and rejection becomes evident. From birth to adolescence, the protagonist of the story, Stephen Dedalus, responds to his experiences throughout life with actions of rejection and isolation. He rebels against his environment and isolates himself in schoolwork, family, religion and his art, successively. James Joyce uses Stephen Dedalus' responses of isolation and rejection to illustrate the journey that the artist must take to achieve adulthood....   [tags: A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man]

Research Papers
1072 words (3.1 pages)

James Joyce's Alter Ego in A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man Essays

- James Joyce's Alter Ego in A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man Works Cited Missing In James Joyce's A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, Stephen Dedalus, a young man growing up, has many of the same traits of the young James Joyce. For example, "On 1 September 1888, at the age of 'half-past-six', Joyce was taken by his parents to be enrolled in the finest Catholic preparatory school in Ireland, Clongowes Wood College, situated about twenty miles west of Dublin in the countryside near Clane"(Anderson, James Joyce 15)....   [tags: Papers]

Research Papers
925 words (2.6 pages)

The Negro Artist And Racial Mountain Essay examples

- A Year in the Rearview Mirror We are born in world where people are classified, a world where each one of us has a role to fill. Most times, it is hard to wake up and escape from this world and its system, so we can make a change. Sometimes some people do realize that something is wrong with our society, however when it comes to get others to see what you see and make them stand up with you, that is when it gets serious and dangerous. We can see how this is true through Malala’s life....   [tags: African American, Black people, The Invisible Man]

Research Papers
1020 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on The Unworthy Artist: Cy Twombly

- Three blank white canvases are put on display as a triptych in a prestigious French art gallery. Paintings that look more like hastily scribbled pencil marks, or seem to resemble a child’s graffiti on a blackboard, are sold for over four million dollars. Some viewers and critics would venture to ask, “What’s the big deal?” or comment, “My six year-old could do that.” Although normally I enjoy abstract, experimental art – being such a painter myself – I do not believe Cy Twombly to be a “worthy” artist....   [tags: art, art criticism, painting]

Research Papers
877 words (2.5 pages)

Comparing the Women in Dubliners, A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, and Ulysses

- Characterization of Women in Dubliners, A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, and Ulysses   Joyce's depiction of women is characterized by a high degree of literary self-consciousness, perhaps even more so than in the rest of his work. The self-consciousness emerges as an awareness of both genre and linguistic expectations. contrasting highly self-conscious, isolated literary men (or men with literary aspirations) with women who follow more romantic models, even stereotypes. In Dubliners, Joyce utilizes a clichéd story of doomed love ending in death-physical or spiritual-in "A Painful Case" and "The Dead." The former holds far more to these conventions and can be read as a pre...   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Research Papers
3158 words (9 pages)

The Style in Hawthorne's Young Goodman Brown Essay

- The Style in “Young Goodman Brown”                Nathaniel Hawthorne’s short story or tale, “Young Goodman Brown,” is an interesting example of the multi-faceted style of the author, which will be discussed in this essay.   Edgar Allan Poe in “Twice-Told Tales - A Review,” which appeared in Graham's Magazine in May, 1842, comments on Hawthorne’s “originality,” and “tranquil and subdued manner” which characterize his style:   The Essays of Hawthorne have much of the character of Irving, with more of originality, and less of finish; while, compared with the Spectator, they have a vast superiority at all points....   [tags: Young Goodman Brown YGB]

Free Essays
4245 words (12.1 pages)

Essay on The Style of Hawthorne's Young Goodman Brown

- “Young Goodman Brown” – the Style                Sculley Bradley, Richmond Croom Beatty and E. Hudson Long in “The Social Criticism of a Public Man” state: “Beyond his remarkable sense of the past, which gives a genuine ring to the historical reconstructions, beyond his precise and simple style, which is in the great tradition of familiar narrative, the principal appeal of his work is in the quality of its allegory” (49). The style found in Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “Young Goodman Brown” contains the features quoted in the above passage, as well as many others – which will be discussed in this essay....   [tags: Young Goodman Brown YGB]

Free Essays
3380 words (9.7 pages)

Posthumous Rating of Hawthorne and “Young Goodman Brown” Essay

- Posthumous Rating of Hawthorne and “Young Goodman Brown”       This essay intends to trace the main literary criticism of the author, Nathaniel Hawthorne, and “Young Goodman Brown”since the author’s death in 1864.   Nathaniel Hawthorne’s acclamation as a great writer by both critics and the general public was not an overnight occurrence. The Norton Anthology: American Literature states that “he was agonizingly slow in winning acclaim” (547).   Initially, of course, Nathaniel Hawthorne’s literary works went unranked among those of other American and British writers....   [tags: Young Goodman Brown YGB]

Free Essays
1422 words (4.1 pages)

Conflict, Climax, Resolution of Hawthorne's Young Goodman Brown Essay

- Conflict, Climax, Resolution of “Young Goodman Brown”              Hugo McPherson in “Hawthorne’s Use of Mythology” makes a statement regarding the nature of the conflict in the works of Hawthorne:   Everything he has to say is related, finally, to ‘that inward sphere.’ For the heart is the meeting-place of all the forces – spiritual and physical, light and dark, that compete for dominance in man’s nature. …Those who read him as a Christian moralist recognize instantly an opposition between Head and Heart, reason and passion which is related not only to Puritan theology but to the Neo-Classical view of man….(68-69)   Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “Young Goodman Brown” is, in the estimati...   [tags: Young Goodman Brown YGB]

Research Papers
2196 words (6.3 pages)

As Professor Brandon Kershner of the University of Florida at Gainsville notes, "Portrait is among the most frequently taught novels in modern university curricula." At this age and educational level, it is discouraging to continuously flip back and forth between the footnotes so that the story can be fully understood. The language he uses is informal and culturally specific to such a degree that it seems to separate the reader instead of connect, as a result, also gaining the criticism of the Irish community, who were more offended than even the British, because of the way they are stereotyped, for example, to hate the English.

However, while it's cultural criticism and controversial language were what sparked censure from critics, reviewers and society, it nonetheless has become "Joyce's most widely-read work," suggests Professor Kershner, who feels that Joyce is one of the most influential modern writers. The inappropriate material, the sexual implications, the "filth" that so greatly disturbed the literary world when it debuted in 1916, has become the reasons for its popularity and success. While the material today is by no means offensive to the previous extent, it is now something that the undergraduate students, those that Kershner has identified as the greatest majority of its readers, can relate to; frustration under the authority of church, state, and parents.

Return to