On the Border

On the Border

Length: 946 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Arturo Islas' "Migrant Souls" is a short story based on the life on a Mexican American Family living in Del Sapo, Texas. The children attend public schools and show signs of enculturation while the parents both encourage and resist the Americanization of their children. The family deals with the everyday pressures immigrants often face and maintain a sense of humor throughout every experience. In an effort to have a unique identity, the family struggles with the social, psychological, and cultural duality "living on the border" causes them to have.

The family in "Migrant Souls" is an example of the social effect racism has on a subculture. The first example of this is when Josie thinks about how her mother has sympathy for the families of "twenty-one Mexican males" who died in a boxcar on the way to a job. Josie believes her mother had compassion because "they were not from the poorest class." She knows her mother is making a reference that the men were not "wetbacks" and this elicits a response from Josie about the difference between her belief and her mother's belief regarding "who did and did not `deserve' to be in the United States." The difference between the mother and daughter is interesting. The mother, because of racism, obviously feels the need to separate herself from a lower class of immigrants. Josie, the daughter, feels a sense of connection within her ethnicity and doesn't believe socio-economic differences should decide if one is welcome in the US. Her conviction doesn't mean that she isn't confused by this difference. Josie wonders why her mother accepts the girls dressing up like Native Americans but yet looks down on a similar class within her own race. The little girl surmises that "Mexican Indians were too close to home and the truth" establishing the idea that Josie believes her mother must have something to be ashamed of. Within this passage shows the social affect of racism on a group. The mother is judgmental of other groups within her ethnicity, and the little girl does not understand why she would feel this way. Little textual support is given about what "home and the truth" means to Josie, but it could be her way of saying that there is not a difference between her family and the very people her mother looks down on.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"On the Border." 123HelpMe.com. 06 Dec 2019
    <https://www.123helpme.com/view.asp?id=110473>.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Conflict Of The Border Conflict Essay

- Problems raised surround the border, the border conflicts, bring out the need of a border thinking. Because border has already imbued with oppositions, the interaction happened in the border is also problematic. Conflicts happen not only identity conflict but also classed, racial, language etc. Mignolo and Tlostanova argue that this kind of “thinking or theorizing emerges from and as a response to the violence (frontiers), modernity, and globalization that continues to be implemented on the assumption of the inferiority or devilish intentions of the Other and, therefore continues to justify oppression and exploitation as well as eradication of the difference” (206)....   [tags: Consciousness, Mind, Identity, Border]

Research Papers
1091 words (3.1 pages)

A History Of The U.s. Border Patrol Essay

- Hernandez, Kelly Lytle. Migra. A History of the U.S. Border Patrol. (Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 2010). A leading American historian on race, policing, immigration, and incarceration in the United States, Kelly Lytle Hernandez’s Migra. A History of the U.S. Border Patrol tells the story of how Mexican immigrant workers emerged as the primary target of the United States Border Patrol and how, in the process, the United States Border Patrol shaped the history of race in the United States....   [tags: United States, Canada – United States border]

Research Papers
1268 words (3.6 pages)

Immigrant Fatalities on the Mexican-American Border Essay

- The deaths in the border between Mexico and the United states have been increasing rapidly in the past decade. The fatalities have doubled since 1998 due to the increase of borders patrol and border militarization. The result is the redistribution of the migratory flow to more dangerous and remote areas such as southern Arizona. Even though the number of immigrants who try to cross the border has decreased, the number of fatalities continues to increase. Immigrants will not stop coming unless the situation in their countries changes and with a more protected border, they will look for more remote areas to try to cross....   [tags: USA Mexico Border, Illegal Immigrants]

Research Papers
1802 words (5.1 pages)

Essay on Tighter Border Restrictions Will Reduce Illegal Immigration

- One of America’s many problems is the rise of illegal immigration. While steps have already been taken to reduce the number of immigrants coming through unlawfully, many are still entering. Such passage brings forth numerous problems that must be dealt with accordingly. Therefore, I propose tighter border restrictions as well as ways to offer more legal immigration to those who wish to enter the United States for residential purposes. By doing so, our country will become safer and more secure....   [tags: argumentative, border restrictions]

Research Papers
1670 words (4.8 pages)

Essay on New Years Celebration at Wagha Border

- Since my childhood, I have been celebrating New Year at my home sitting in front of TV watching the New year programs, or by wishing my friends New Year late night via sms. But, this time I celebrated my new year differently, in a very special way that I had never thought of and never planned for it. I would never forget the night of 31st December 2009 and the first day of New Year i.e.1st January 2010. Last year we had NOSPLAN (National Organization of Student of Planning) in the SPA, Delhi, in the month of Jan ’09....   [tags: New Year's Even, New Year, Wagha Border,]

Research Papers
858 words (2.5 pages)

Essay about Increasing Security at The Mexican American Border

- Nowhere else in the world does an invisible line draw such a disparity in wealth and lifestyle. Our border with Mexico divides one of the West's richest countries with a struggling third world economy. The nature of the border presents many unique issues; Mexican refuges looking for a better life here in America, Mexican drug lords exporting drugs to drug savvy America, American jobs going overseas for cheaper labor, as well as the integrating of our two cultures. Mexican immigration is a liability in our country, for reasons that I will state....   [tags: Politics Mexico America Border Security]

Research Papers
3623 words (10.4 pages)

On the Border Essay

- Arturo Islas' "Migrant Souls" is a short story based on the life on a Mexican American Family living in Del Sapo, Texas. The children attend public schools and show signs of enculturation while the parents both encourage and resist the Americanization of their children. The family deals with the everyday pressures immigrants often face and maintain a sense of humor throughout every experience. In an effort to have a unique identity, the family struggles with the social, psychological, and cultural duality "living on the border" causes them to have....   [tags: American Literature]

Free Essays
946 words (2.7 pages)

Border Patrol Essay

- The U.S. Border Patrol is the organization that polices the access of illegal immigrants into our country. The bureaucrat task of the United States Border patrol is to defend the boundaries of the United States by preventing illegal admission, and by detecting, interdicting, and detain illegal aliens, smugglers, and illegal imports. Today, the United States Border Patrol is accumulative of 21 sectors. A chief patrol agent controls each sector. There are 145 stations placed throughout the continental United States, and in Puerto Rico....   [tags: Mexico, Immigration, Police]

Research Papers
1607 words (4.6 pages)

Border Patrol Essay

- United States Border Patrol has been around since 1904 enforcing and regulating laws under the immigration and Nationality Act. U.S. border patrol is now under the Department of Homeland Security, which was created as a response to the attacks of September 11, 2001. Over the years, their jurisdiction and missions have changed to better protect the safety of nation. Although border patrol is a need for any nation, their extensive acceptations to constitutional laws can often be taken advantage of....   [tags: U.S. Government ]

Research Papers
1141 words (3.3 pages)

Border Patrol Essay

- Border Patrol You are driving along with a group of friends in your car. You and your friends are talking and laughing having a good time, suddenly as you look in your rear view mirror you see that a sport utility vehicle is following your car. As your imagination begins to grow you begin to try and lose this “stalker”, as you are making your break; you see the flashing lights and begin to hear sirens. No, you are not in a disco dance club; you have just become another victim of, Operation Rio Grande....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
873 words (2.5 pages)



Another example of the effect of racism on Josie is when she genuinely asks her father if they are "aliens." His response is passionate, denying that they are "aliens" while saying, "We are proud of both countries and have never and will never be that word you just said to me." Josie tells him that another girl at school said she was an "alien", probably to explain why she brought it up in the first place. His response initial scathing response is probably a gut reaction as a parent, wanting to protect his child from disparaging remarks. He goes on to explain to her the essence of racism, that words like "Aliens" allows people to objectify another group and allow for the other group to "deport of kill them." This shows the social pressures that the family faces. They are no longer simply Mexicans and they don't fit nicely into the stereotypical American term either, thereby living a life in-between.

Psychologically, the reader knows the family lives "on the border" because of the fear and tales about deportation this is part of their everyday existence. The first glimpse of this is shown when the little girls are playing in their Thanksgiving garb and the father, half joking, tells the girls not to wear the costume outside because they could be sent to a reservation. The little girls know too well what their father is referring to, sharing a knowing glimpse and think of the migra who "sneaked up on innocent dark-skinned people and deported them." This is the first of many references to deportation stories told to the girls to scare them into being cautious. The story about the "light-skinned" boy down the street who was taken by the migra shows that everyone is at risk of being taken at any moment for any slight misstep and also that the authorities don't necessarily care to find the correct identification for a person they decide to deport. The effect on of these myths/stories is that the girls are constantly afraid of being taken. Unfortunately for them, this probably perpetuates the insecurities about having the "right" to live in the country. When kids at school do call them Aliens, this fear of being taken out of the country would almost give the name calling more significance. Another important part within the psychological affect on the girls is shown when the family is smuggling the turkey across the border. Josie is gripped with fear as her mother jumps out of the car to distract the border patrol and we learn that Josie feels "too scared to laugh." Even though the father knows there is seriousness about the incident, it does not seem that he is gripped with the same type of terror as his daughter. The psychological affect on the girls is that much stronger because they are young and lack the control over their lives. Knowing that both the mother and the father fear deportation only furthers the girls' anxiety.

One positive area of the family living "on the border" both physically and psychologically is their ability to blend the two cultures that are a part of their life. The mother's effort to have an American style Thanksgiving pleases the girls a great deal. It is important to them because they are immersed in the fabled holiday at school and want to have a turkey because everyone else is doing it. The father, on the other hand, could care less about the tradition. Claiming that he could kill a pheasant that would be tastier than the turkey, he shows his indifference to the American custom of eating turkey. He tells his wife that eating turkey will "turn [his] girls into little gringos" insinuating that the enculturation of his daughters is a fairly negative occurrence in his opinion. Later the reader learns that he was probably just playing around, perhaps with a slight edge of truth, when the family goes "in search of the perfect turkey." Another point within the story that the reader is shown the cultural duality is when the father declares, "these Mexicans drive like your mother." Most drivers would not emphasize race if they were referring to a group they identified with, such as "these white people drive terribly." This suggests that he doesn't identify himself solely as Mexican, although he is not an American. This assertion shows that this family identifies themselves as Mexican-American, which is a unique and distinctive category on its own right.

Throughout their experiences, the family within Islas' "Migrant Souls" keeps an optimistic but cautious perspective about their role in the society in which they live. They try to protect their children from racial remarks and the threat of the migra. Unfortunately, the stories the parents tell have a negative affect on the children. This affect proposes the question of how much warning benefits a child. They effort they make to provide their children with both Mexican and American traditions is what makes this family the essence of an American family. The mixing of cultures, bringing the best of each country into traditions and rituals, is what makes this country unique. Perhaps the Coca-colas the family drank with the gorditas and menudo after their trip to smuggle the turkey shows best the natural integration of both worlds.
Return to 123HelpMe.com