Cloned Instincts

Cloned Instincts

Length: 692 words (2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Matt Ridley argues in his essay, "Genome" written in 1999, that there exists a genetic basis for language acquisition. The essay, "A Clone Is Born," written by Gina Kolata, presents numerous view points on the issues of human cloning. Although both essays maintain significant and valid concerns about the use of genes, they conclude on two distinct concepts.

Kolata presents views of many experts without positioning herself in either side. She explains that the ability to clone living beings has staggering consequences. Cloning brings out questions about whether we are our genes or what makes us us. It also makes us question our ethics and beliefs. People fear the destruction of individuality and oppose the idea of playing God. Cloning is thought to be a violation of a human dignity. Through cloning, which poses danger of self-idolization and morality, the concept of self-surrender is lost. Although dignity does not have a clear definition in Kolata's essay, it still holds a foremost view on people.

A Lutheran theologian, Gilbert Meilaender, states that cloning would be "a new and decisive turn on this road." This idea explains that cloning results in the production, rather than the creation of a child. A child is known to be as a product of human will. Today, people have the freedom of using infertility and want children that can resemble to them. Yet, people are terrified of seeing their genetic replicas born again. Parents do want to create perfects kids but from this idea rises many questions such as how far will parents go? Kolata states in her essay that since people believe in individuality it would be unethical to create a clone without any uniqueness. Another factor of reproduction is the survival of the species. If cloning was to be introduced to society as an option, extinction of species would be solved.

Kolata represents in her essay the positive possibilities of cloning. She states that cloning can create animals whose organs are perfect genetic matches for humans. Creating animals with cells that are coated with human proteins could be used for transplantation. These organs with human protein can save millions of lives. Cloning can also be used to make animals that are living drug factories. Scientists could insert genes into cells that would force the cells to make valuable drugs, such as clotting. Zoologists can be able to clone animals that are on the verge of extinction.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Cloned Instincts." 10 Dec 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Mark Blumberg's Basic Instinct: The Genesis of Behavior

- Mark Blumberg, a neuroscientist wrote a book titled Basic Instinct: The Genesis of Behavior which revolves around the topic of animal and human behaviors. An instinct is an innate behavior as mentioned several times in the book which simply means that an animal or human is born with a certain behavior or it occurs naturally. An example of an instinct given in the very beginning of the book is “a panicked mother rushes into oncoming traffic to save her wandering child” (p. xi). Along with this example, there were other examples of instincts mentioned in the introduction....   [tags: instincts, innate or learned]

Research Papers
1201 words (3.4 pages)

The Reality of Maternal Instincts Essays

- Maternal instincts- are they just a myth or are they real. How can you tell when you are right or just want to be right. We claim that we know best for our children but do we really. There is no scientific test to prove maternal instincts exists, yet there are examples of it all around us. We can claim that maternal instincts are human nature, but not all women have maternal instincts. Mothers with maternal instincts know when their children are in danger. Are those mothers with this ability just more in touch with their emotions, or are there such things as maternal instincts....   [tags: charles darwin, human babies]

Research Papers
1282 words (3.7 pages)

The, Language, And Protective Instincts Essay

- Suzanne K. Langer, the author of “Language and Thought” states that “the birth of language is the dawn of humanity” (120). The “dawn of humanity” refers to the beginning of time, the beginning of life, the beginning of society, and we, as people need language to survive every day in civilization. Humans haven’t always had the glory of language. Millions of years ago, science has proven that we have evolved from chimpanzees because of our fairly similar DNA. We have similar facial structure, body language, and protective instincts; although language is what defines us as human and what allows us to become individuals....   [tags: Culture, Learning, Human, Linguistics]

Research Papers
1351 words (3.9 pages)

Science Celebrates with Dolly, the Cloned Sheep Essay

- ... The article in Time was written and put on the cover in 1997, but she was actually cloned in 1996. The authors reasoning of when Dolly was actually cloned/birthed is very confusing to the audience, which lessen the article’s standing. Another element used in this article was pathos in which they tried plucking at the hearts of the readers. With the development of cloning, the idea of cloning humans became an option and with that came “the possibility of bringing deceased relatives back to life.” At the end of reading this sentence, the authors want the readers to think of their family members who have already taken their last breath....   [tags: infertile, embryo, rhetorical]

Research Papers
1096 words (3.1 pages)

Essay about Human Instincts: Necessary for Humans to Survive

- Human instincts allow humans to survive in the wild. Without human instincts people would have to learn everything that they do. An instinct is a trait that is not learned, but passed down from generation to generation. It is a skill that is already known and perfected without training, or practicing that skill. Without human instincts humans would not be as superior today, and they would not have survived in the wild before civilization was created. Adrenaline is an instinct that comes from our ancestors....   [tags: anatomy, adrenaline]

Research Papers
900 words (2.6 pages)

Following Instincts in Lord of the Flies by Golding Essay

- ... “Perhaps he went back to the, the–”Beneath them, on the unfriendly side of the mountain, the drum-roll continued.” (Golding 58). This quote would portray the example of their instinct to play, which was when the lack of their attention to the fire resulted in a supposed death of a young boy when the forest got caught on fire. The conflict between being savage and being civil enlarges while the boys live more time on the island. It is clear that some boys want to be civil and other boys just want to be savage....   [tags: civil, savage, conflicts]

Research Papers
810 words (2.3 pages)

Cloned Zoos Essay

- Cloned Zoos Imagine an earth where every animal lives within an enclosed area where all humankind can see them. Yet, within these enclosures are the only places humans can see these animals alive. Why. It is because the animals' habitats have been damaged and completely destroyed for the needs and usage of human kind. These enclosed areas are called Cloned Zoos: The Final Stronghold of the World's Biodiversity. These cloned zoos are full of cloned animals that have been brought back from the dead or from the edge of extinction....   [tags: Research Paper Animals Cloning Papers]

Research Papers
4019 words (11.5 pages)

Cloned Meat: Its What's for Dinner Essay

- Cloned Meat: Its What's for Dinner "[Cloning] first involves destroying the nucleus of an egg cell from the species to be cloned. A nucleus is then removed from a cell of an animal of the same species and injected into the egg cell. The egg, with its new nucleus, develops into an animal with the same genetic makeup as the donor." (1) Sounds yummy, huh. You may soon be dining on Grade A, prime cut cloned beef. Or pork. Or chicken for that matter. Is the thought alone enough to make you want to become vegan....   [tags: Biology Essays Research Papers]

Research Papers
1089 words (3.1 pages)

First Cloned Baby - Newspaper Article

- First Cloned Baby - Newspaper Article The world's first cloned baby is due to be born early in January 2003, claimed controversial Italian fertility doctor Severino Antinori on Tuesday night. He said the pregnancy is "going well, there are no problems" at a press conference in Rome. Ultrasound scans reveal that the fetus weighs 2.5 to 2.7 kilogrammes and is "absolutely healthy", he added. Two other women carrying cloned fetuses are 27 and 28 weeks pregnant, Antinori said. But he refused to reveal the location of any of the women....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
763 words (2.2 pages)

Copola's Apocolypse Now and Human Instincts Essays

- The human race is believed to be at the pinacle of developement. We have reahed the top of the mountain of success and evolution; we have surely surpassed the wild animal. We have evolved past the primal use of insticts to the utilization of reason and intelect. There are times in the course of a human&#8217;s life however, in war for instance, where all reason and intelect is compromised and men revert back to instinct, back to animal. War presents a man with more hardship, physical and emotional stress, than any human being should ever have to endure....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1451 words (4.1 pages)

Many species can and will be saved. Scientists or doctors can use cloning to program genes to fix the defects and become healthy embryos. Scientists finally will be able to cure many diseases that have and could wipe out humans or other species.

In Kolata's essay, she quotes Fyodor Dostoyevsky's Crime and Punishment, "Man gets used to everything-the beast." This quote illustrates the understanding and misuse information of humans. Kolata presents this quote to prove that although humans can get used to anything and be comfortable, it will still be a matter of time before it is used against for the good. Kolata makes the write aware of the consequences and fears that can affect people's lives.

In the essay Genome, Ridley opposes the idea that human behavior is determined by environmental factors; with it, implying a connection between genetics and instincts. He states in his essay that "human beings do not have to rely on instincts; they learn instead;..." After Ridley presents this idea, he goes on to show the readers that human language owes to instincts. Noam Chomsky learned that part of the human brain comes equipped by its genes with a specialized ability to learn languages. He concluded that to learn a human language required a human language instinct.

More evidence is shown in Ridley's essay that children develop language in a predictable order or pattern, which suggests that there is an age limitation to when a child can fully learn the concept of a language. If this was the case, Kolata would argue how cloning can affect the clone's ability to learn languages.

Ridley presents that idea that genes control every part of the human body. He also believes that genes have a part in peoples' behavior and personality. He offers the idea that chromosome 7 lies a gene that plays an essential part in equipping human beings with an instinct. Kolata explained that cloning is an exact duplicate of a living animal. If chromosome 7 was to be cloned, that would be implying instinct could be copied through genes.

In both essays writes make valid points that there is a clear connection between genetics and instincts. Kolata presents her essay cooperating many experts and techniques that make her point valid. Since the writer does not stand on either side of the arguments she addresses her effort with strength. Although Kolata's essay takes another step on genetics to cloning, she may be trying to show the readers the positive and negative side of cloning instincts. Ridley presents his essay in his opinion by also cooperating many diverse experts and scientists. Ridley's essay could foreshadow the idea that language instinct may effect cloning different ways.

Gina Kolata presents the issues of human cloning in her essay "A Clone Is Born." Another essay that cooperates to the issues of instincts and language is written by Matt Ridley in "Genome." Both writes make clear points on the importance of how instinct has raised many questions. The writers use different concepts but similar conclusions about the use of genes.

Return to