Why Euthanasia? Why Doctor-Assisted Suicide? Why Now?

  • :: 2 Works Cited
  • Length: 1174 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)
  • Rating: Excellent
Open Document

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Text Preview

More ↓

Continue reading...

Open Document

Why Euthanasia? Why Now?

   Americans wonder why the big push for legalizing euthanasia and assisted suicide. After thousands of years of considering such practices sinful and illegal, why the vocal effort at changing policy? This paper will look closely at how and why the new pro-euthanasia/assisted suicide attitude is sweeping around the world.


The 89 year old woman died of dehydration starvation after six days without food and fluids, despite evidence that she had repeatedly asked for water. A scene from a drought-stricken Third World country or Nazi Germany? No. Ella Bathurst died October 28, 1984 at a prestigious Midwestem hospital in the USA. Mrs. Bathurst had been living alone until she fell and fractured her hip. She was treated at the hospital and then she was transferred to a nursing home. When she developed problems in swallowing, she was transferred back to the hospital for rehydration therapy. After three days, at the insistence of Mrs. Bathurst's daughter, the IV was discontinued and food and fluids were withheld. According to hospital records, Mrs. Bathurst was "alert and responsive" most of the time, yet she was not consulted regarding the withdrawal of food and water. (Gula)


Similar cases are occurring more frequently as a traditional medical standard - the presumption to treat -- is being eroded. Under common law, competent patients are able to refuse treatment, provided the decision is reasonable and based on sufficient information for informed consent. In the case of an incompetent or comatose patient, the usual method of determining treatment was for the physicians involved in the case to discuss treatment options with the family of the patient. It was presumed that the patient would want beneficial treatment and would not want to die of dehydration and starvation. Likewise, it was presumed that the family would want the best care for the patient. Physicians themselves swore to the Hippocratic Oath: "First, do no harm."


Unfortunately, this presumption in favor of treatment is being eroded in our society. Generally, through five means: the medical profession, pro-euthanasia organizations, state legislation, court opinions, and the media:

1. As an indication of where segments of the medical profession are heading, in March 1986 the judicial council of the American Medical Association (AMA) ruled that it is ethical for physicians to withhold "all means of life-prolonging treatment" from people in "irreversible" comas even if death is not imminent.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Why Euthanasia? Why Doctor-Assisted Suicide? Why Now?." 123HelpMe.com. 25 Jun 2018
Title Length Color Rating  
Essay on Euthanasia and Doctor-Assisted Suicide - The Will to Live - Euthanasia and the Will to Live   The denial of food and fluids to Terri Schindler-Schiavo, the 36 year old Florida woman in a vegetative state since a heart attack, has caused Americans to ponder the fact that any one of them could be in this woman's place for a variety of reasons, like an auto accident, fall, mishap, etc. And most Americans don't want to be treated by their family as Terri is being treated by her husband - being denied food and fluids in order to hasten death.   It is appropriate to be appalled, but no one should be shocked....   [tags: Euthanasia Physician Assisted Suicide] 596 words
(1.7 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Free Euthanasia and Doctor-Assisted Suicide Essay - Assisted Suicide - Euthanasia The purpose of this essay is to inform readers clearly and coherently enoughof the terms and issues in the euthanasia debate that they can make sense of the euthanasia question. Descriptions are in relatively simple, non-technical language to facilitate learning. The definition of euthanasia is simple: "Easy, painless death." But the concept of euthanasia proposed by adherents of the euthanasia movement is complex and has profound consequences for all. Because the subject involves the discipline of medicine (diagnosis, treatment, prognosis, medical ethics and so on) as well as the discipline of law, the general public will have difficulty understanding it without some kno...   [tags: Euthanasia Physician Assisted Suicide] 994 words
(2.8 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Euthanasia Essay - The Controversial Issue of Doctor-Assisted Suicide - The Controversial Issue of Doctor-Assisted Suicide      Imagine youu have just found out you are going to die within three months. Recently the questions have been changed form, "What am I going to do with the rest of my life?" to "When should I kill myself"?  With painful and crippling diseases such as AIDS and cancer, and Alzheimers along with doctors such as Dr. Kavorkian, some people are choosing death over life.  Doctor assisted suicide has been a very controversial subject in the past few years.  Some states such as Oregon have passed laws which allow doctors to prescribe lethal drugs to patients who have less then six months to live.(Henin 1)  Other state have tak...   [tags: Euthanasia Physician Assisted Suicide]
:: 3 Works Cited
804 words
(2.3 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Euthanasia Essay - Lutheranism and Doctor-Assisted Suicide - Evangelical Lutheranism and Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide    As a member of the Evangelical Lutheran Church of America, I feel it important to express in this essay the stand of the church on the question of euthanasia and assisted suicide. Our church has strong biblical and traditional reasons for adamantly opposing these new end-of-life approaches.   Increasingly, people know from their own experience some painful dilemmas involving elderly or handicapped individuals who are in pain. While the achievements of modern medicine have been used to prolong and enhance life for many, they have also helped create an often dreaded context for dying....   [tags: Euthanasia Physician Assisted Suicide]
:: 3 Works Cited
1504 words
(4.3 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Why Euthanasia? Why Doctor-Assisted Suicide? Why Now? Essay - Why Euthanasia. Why Now.      Americans wonder why the big push for legalizing euthanasia and assisted suicide. After thousands of years of considering such practices sinful and illegal, why the vocal effort at changing policy. This paper will look closely at how and why the new pro-euthanasia/assisted suicide attitude is sweeping around the world.   The 89 year old woman died of dehydration starvation after six days without food and fluids, despite evidence that she had repeatedly asked for water....   [tags: Euthanasia Physician Assisted Suicide]
:: 2 Works Cited
1174 words
(3.4 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay on Doctor-Assisted Suicide is Rare - A new survey published in the April 23 New England Journal of Medicine finds that few doctors have ever assisted a patient's suicide -- but that over a third would do so if the practice were legalized. "This is really not happening very often," says survey co-author Dr. Diane Meier of New York's Mount Sinai School of Medicine. "That's the most important finding. It's a rare event" [Associated Press, 4/23/98]. The survey was based on a questionnaire sent in 1996 to 3,102 physicians under the age of 65; 1,902 doctors responded anonymously....   [tags: Euthanasia, Physician Assisted Suicide] 625 words
(1.8 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay on The Vegetative State and Doctor-Assisted Suicide - The Vegetative State and Euthanasia         Much media attention has been directed at the very practical use of euthanasia or assisted suicide on patients who are in a vegetative state or irreversible coma. The truth is that a significant number of such cases actually recover. This essay is devoted to those types, some very young, who would have been killed if euthanasia/assisted suicide had been legalized.   Let's begin our consideration with a nine-year-old named Ryan Atencio. He was taken off life-support systems, except for a feeding tube, after being in a vegetative state following a massive head injury in a December 10, 1988 car accident....   [tags: Euthanasia Physician Assisted Suicide]
:: 7 Works Cited
2499 words
(7.1 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Doctor-Assisted Suicide Should be Legalized Essay examples - “Dogs do not have many advantages over people, but one of them is extremely important: euthanasia is not forbidden by law in their case; animals have the right to a merciful death.” ― Milan Kundera, The Unbearable Lightness of Being One of the most controversial topics that is being debated today, both morally and legally, is assisted suicide, sometimes known as active euthanasia. Assisted suicide is the act of directly intervening in order to end the life of a terminally ill patient (i.e. administering a large amount of sleeping pills)....   [tags: Euthanasia Physician Assisted Suicide]
:: 8 Works Cited
3190 words
(9.1 pages)
Research Papers [preview]
Essay on Doctor-Assisted Suicide and the Hospitals' Bottom Line - Euthanasia and the Hospitals' Bottom Line      An important factor in debates over health care and treatment strategies is the issue of cost. It is tremendously expensive to provide the state-of-the-art care that the modern hospital offers. Concerns about where the money will come from to care for elderly citizens appear to be making the case for "mercy killing" even more compelling. Under financial pressure, hospitals are exercising their right to deny such expensive healthcare to the aged or seriously ill....   [tags: Euthanasia Physician Assisted Suicide]
:: 1 Works Cited
1217 words
(3.5 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay about Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide are Murder - Euthanasia is Murder Euthanasia - is it killing or letting die. In the last thirty years, this has been a highly controversial topic, the worldly morals versus the Christian. Although there are certain instances where it is justifiably considered to be letting die, it is essentially murder. Euthanasia comes from a Greek word, meaning "easy death," and is now often associated with the infamous Dr. Kevorkian. There are three types of euthanasia - what doctors consider to be "letting the patient die," for instance taking both conscious and unconscious patients off of life support, not reviving the patient in case of a heart failure, et cetera....   [tags: Euthanasia Physician Assisted Suicide] 1077 words
(3.1 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]

Related Searches

The AMA included food and water as "medical treatment," thereby supporting physicians who would starve comatose people to death. Another frightening problem with this ruling is that no one can predict with absolute certainty the outcome of a particular medical condition. Numerous patients, such as Sgt. David Mack of Minneapolis, have awakened from what physicians diagnosed as "irreversible" comas. (Sgt.)

2. Pro-euthanasia organizations like Concern for Dying and the Society for the Right to Die (formerly the Euthanasia Society of America) are increasing support for the pro-death mentality. In addition to other educational efforts, Concern for Dying holds seminars for medical, theological, and law students to expose them to the goals of the euthanasia movement. The Society for the Right to Die focuses on influencing politicians to vote for pro-euthanasia legislation. It also files briefs in court cases dealing with the issue. A more radical pro-euthanasia group is the Hemlock Society, whose co-founder, Derek Humphrey, assisted his cancer-stricken wife to commit suicide. The Hemlock Society distributes a "how-to" suicide manual and has proposed legislation in California, Arizona, Florida, and Washington that would allow physicians to kill terminally-ill patients by lethal injection.

3. State legislators and judges have focused on three legal mechanisms which further erode the presumption to treat:

a. Living will legislation has already been passed in a large majority of states and the District of Columbia. Although the laws vary, basically a living will is a directive in which a person authorizes a physician to withhold or withdraw medical treatment or care should he or she become incompetent. Like the AMA ruling, many of these laws define even food and water as "medical treatment." Because living will legislation is vague and the directive is often signed in advance of the diagnosis of a particular disease or medical condition, the door is left open for serious abuse.

b. Durable power of attorney statutes have passed in some states. These laws allow a person to appoint someone else to make medical decisions should he or she become comatose or incompetent. Since the only limitation on the appointee's power to refuse treatment is that it be done in the patient's "best interest," durable power of attorney statutes can be very dangerous. 'This is especially so in view of the belief of many that the seriously ill and the elderly are "better off dead."

c. Some courts have invoked the so-called "doctrine" of "substituted judgment" in order to withdraw beneficial medical treatment from incompetent patients in states where there are no durable power of attorney statutes. In these cases, someone authorized by the court determines what the patient would request if he or she were to become competent for a moment. Again, the appointee has nearly unlimited power to remove all care - including food and water - from the patient. The Minnesota Supreme Court in 1984 used this mechanism to grant a court-appointed conservator the authority to remove a respirator from Rudolfo Torres, who suffered brain damage as the result of an accident at Hennepin County Medical Center in Minneapolis.

4. The media - newspapers, television, radio, and movies - have added to the confusion surrounding the euthanasia issue by neglecting to carefully examine legitimate objections to the death-related legislation and court decisions just described. In addition, by focusing on the sensational "hard cases" and by disseminating inaccurate and biased information, the media contribute to public support of the pro-euthanasia philosophy.


It appears that the presumption-to-treat standard will have to be specifically spelled out in the law in order to ensure that the rights of the elderly, the ill, and the incompetent be protected. With the law presuming that patients want beneficial medical treatment and food and water, once again a physician who withholds such care would be liable for damages under malpractice laws and could even face the loss of his or her medical license.


Medical decisions should always be based on medical, not social, reasons. The "quality" of a person's life, financial concerns, and the effect of treatment on a patient's caregivers and family are social reasons and should not be used by a physician to justify the withholding of beneficial medical treatment.


There is a point in everyone's life when death cannot be held off, no matter what means are used. Therefore, it is not morally nor medically required that every possible treatment be given a patient nor that life be preserved at all costs. However, when the benefits of a treatment outweigh the burdens, it should be administered; and food and water, as basic human needs, should not be withdrawn or withheld.


Sgt. David Mack http://www.feministsforlife.org/FFL_topics/euthanasia/euthabor.htm

Gula, Richard M. Euthanasia: Moral and Pastoral Perspectives. New York: Paulist Press, 1999.

Return to 123HelpMe.com