Representation of Women in Men Should Weep by Ena Lamont Stewart and Perfect Days by Liz Lochead

Representation of Women in Men Should Weep by Ena Lamont Stewart and Perfect Days by Liz Lochead

Length: 994 words (2.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Representation of Women in "Men Should Weep" by Ena Lamont Stewart and "Perfect Days" by Liz Lochead


Both plays portray women as very independent people. In “Men Should
Weep”, Maggie is the main female character. She is a housewife living
in a male dominated society. The main theme of the play is her journey
form oppressed housewife to self-empowered women.

Whereas in “Perfect Days” Barbs the main female character is an
extremely independent woman from the start and has worked hard to earn
herself her own hairdressers.

Maggie’s husband John is a very self-centred character; he doesn’t
have a job or any notion to ever help around the house. Yet he thinks
that is perfectly acceptable. Due to the way society was in that day
and age then it said that once a woman wedded they automatically
became their husband’s property. This meant that they had no choice
but to obey their husbands every demand. What they said went.

“I’d an idea a wis heid o this hoose”

This demonstrates that even though John doesn’t contribute to the
family he still feels he is superior to them all. Maggie takes this
though she doesn’t argue with him as she believes that he is head of
the household and she constantly stands up for him.

Lily, Maggie’s independent single sister is very much against men she
thinks ‘there aw dirty beasts’. As she argues with Maggie about John
but Maggie straight away stands up for her husband.

“You leave John alane! He does his best for us”

Even though Maggie knows John doesn’t do anything for her and her
children she still stands strongly by her husband as that was the
right thing to do.

Not only does Maggie have her husband to run around after her and look
after her, but she also has five children.

“If you’ve got wee ans, you’ve got tae put up wi the fella that gie’d
ya them”

The women in the play are constantly making excuses for the men and
their behaviour. Maggie is particularly bad at doing this. This is a
prime example of this behaviour as Mrs Bone her neighbour gets
domestically abused and this is Maggie’s attempt to offer her support.

As the play progresses Maggie gradually starts to see sense and comes
to realise how weak men really are.

“They canna staun up tae things like a wummen”

This shows female strength and is the start of a major turning point
for Maggie as she becomes more and more disenchanted with her life.

Jenny, Maggie’s eldest daughter runs of at the beginning of the play
but returns at the end with money and the opportunity for Maggie and

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Representation of Women in Men Should Weep by Ena Lamont Stewart and Perfect Days by Liz Lochead." 123HelpMe.com. 25 Sep 2018
    <https://www.123helpme.com/view.asp?id=102653>.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Masculinity in Men Should Weep by Ena Lamont Stewart and Perfect Days by Liz Lochead

- Masculinity in "Men Should Weep" by Ena Lamont Stewart and "Perfect Days" by Liz Lochead Both plays portray men under a negative light. In ‘Men Should Weep’ men are the dominant sex and are seen socially of far greater importance. Whereas in ‘Perfect days’ men are easily manipulated and tend to be controlled by the contents of their trousers. ‘Men Should Weep’ is a play which examines how the family unit crumbles under the pressure of poverty. ‘John’ the father of the family is the main male figure throughout the play....   [tags: Weep Stewart Perfect Days Lochead Essays]

Research Papers
1184 words (3.4 pages)

Of Nightingales That Weep by Katherine Paterson Essay

- Of Nightingales That Weep Chapter 1 This chapter is about Takiko and her first family home. It tells a lot about her family. They talk about the war In this chapter also. Takiko’s mother decides that she will remarry after her father dies. Takiko’s finds out that her father is died. Chapter 2 This chapter the book tells about Goro who is Takiko’s stepfather. Takiko finds out that Goro is a injured man. She thinks it will be very hard to live with Goro because of his problem. Chapter 3 This chapter tells about Takiko living with Goro for a few months now....   [tags: Of Nightingales That Weep Katherine Paterson]

Research Papers
699 words (2 pages)

Gender Representation in Advertisements Essay

- I have to admit I am an avid reader of magazines. I read everything from the the stupid celebrity gossip magazines to Time magazine and National Geographic. Since our brief overview of magazine advertisements in class, I decided to look into how magazines make us think and more specifically I wanted to see how the magazine advertisements portray women, since that has been a hot topic for a while now. I like analyzing advertisements and looking at how viewers react to specific advertisements that may or may not be targeted toward them....   [tags: Intrinsic Beauty, Lesbian Representation]

Research Papers
2595 words (7.4 pages)

Representations of Nature in King Lear Essay

- We are lucky, today, that the majority of the world’s nations are democracies. This has only been the case in very recent times. For the greater part of human history, society has subscribed to the belief that birth is the most important determinant of one’s future. In Elizabethan England, this was especially true. Those born into the nobility enjoyed a lifetime of privilege, while those born outside of their ranks mainly existed to serve them. A century later, the British encountered an even stricter form of this belief when they conquered India....   [tags: Representations of Nature in King Lear]

Research Papers
856 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on J.D. Salinger's A Perfect Day for Ortgies

- J.D. Salinger's A Perfect Day for Bananafish At first glance, J.D. Salinger's short story 'A Perfect Day for Bananafish' is the story of a psychically-torn war veteran whose post-traumatic stress moves him to take his own life while on a second honeymoon with his wife. Indeed, that is the story, but that first glance does not reveal the inner motives and symbolic pathways Seymour Glass takes to reach the final decision to end his life. The carefully placed details and minute innuendoes are deliberate on Salinger's part, and they represent pieces of the puzzle to find out what is really happening in the protagonist's head....   [tags: Salinger Perfect Day Bananafish Papers]

Research Papers
1870 words (5.3 pages)

An Overview of the Movie Pitch Perfect Essay

- Directed by Jason Moore and screenplay written by Kay Cannon, Pitch Perfect is one of the funniest films to watch and the nations’ number one cappella comedy. There was a special screening of the film, which aired on September 25, 2012, at LSU Student Union Theater, which turned out to be a great success. Approximately, half of the students that stood in line got in to see the movie as it sold out. Since there were more students waiting to see the movie, a second show aired right after the first show ended....   [tags: jason moore, cappella movie, pitch perfect]

Research Papers
1138 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on Analysis of A Perfect Ganesh

- A Perfect Ganesh Analysis of the play elements. The author: Terrence Mcnally’s career began in the New York off-off-Broadway boom of the late 1960s. Most of his 60’s plays are not really relevant although some are funny. However, during the 70’s his plays began to get recognition. Nowadays, his plays are performed in off-Broadway theaters and he is known as the author of tragicomic plays, filled with breadth and depth. He still lives in New York and is one of the America best playwrights. He is the author of numerous plays, including Master Class and Love....   [tags: Perfect Ganesh Essays]

Free Essays
2310 words (6.6 pages)

A Perfect Day for Bananafish Essay

- A Perfect Day for Bananafish Picture walking into a hotel room and finding a man dead on a bed. Upon closer inspection it becomes obvious that he has supposedly taken his own life with the gun that lay beside him. In talking to his wife who was asleep on the bed next to him when this incident occurred, it is learned that he just walked in the door and shot himself late the previous night. Out of the many questions that could be asked from this story, I believe that it is probably extremely important to consider why the main character, Seymour Glass, decided to commit suicide....   [tags: Perfect Day Bananafish]

Free Essays
718 words (2.1 pages)

Essay about A Comparison of The Perfect Storm Movie and Novel

- A Comparison of The Perfect Storm Movie and Novel                                The Perfect Storm is a novel written by Sebastian Junger, that retells the horrific story of fishermen and sailors who were caught in the eye of the worst storm in history. The book mainly focuses on the Andrea Gail, a swordfishing boat, with a crew of 6 men, who disappeared without a trace deep into the northern atlantic sea. In the year 2000, almost 10 years after the tragic event took place, a motion picture, perfectly titled, The Perfect Storm which was based on the novel was released....   [tags: Perfect Storm Compare Contrast Essays]

Research Papers
863 words (2.5 pages)

Blatchford vs. Lamont Essay

- Blatchford vs. Lamont Corliss Lamont, who is in opposition to Robert Blatchford, presents to us the issue of “freedom of choice and human responsibility.” Lamont attempts to prove that there is existence of free will, and that freedom is a necessary condition of moral responsibility. On the other hand, Blatchford develops a view of determinism against the theories of freedom and free choice. He suggests that the past, along with the laws of nature, determine our future. Every event that occurs, including human actions and choices, are predestined given the laws of nature and the events that preceded it....   [tags: Free Essays]

Free Essays
418 words (1.2 pages)

her family to escape poverty. Maggie grabs the opportunity despite
John’s requests. For Maggie this is a moment of self-discovery she can
have the control of her own life now.

“I can manage him ….. I can aye manage him”

This is a very revealing line as it reveals that there is hope for
things to change and get better. She is an independent woman.

Whereas Barbs the main female character in “Perfect Days” is a very
independent woman from the beginning of the play. She is financially
independent due to her success in hairdressing. Spending her time
between TV appearances and doing celebrities hair. A well grounded,
hard working, strong woman. But don’t be fooled she may seem to have
everything but she doesn’t. She wants a baby.

Barbs has three male figures in her life Brendan her gay best friend,
Davie her unreliable ex-husband and Grant her ‘toyboy’ 14 years her
junior. Although Barbs doesn’t rely on any of them she still needs
them to be there. Essentially the only reason she needs a man in her
life is to reproduce.

“I tell him no need for precautions I’ve got a coil which is a lie but
he doesn’t need to know”

This portrays the men as naïve, thoughtless easy to manipulate
characters. As Barbs sees them only in a chemical light due to their
only use to her being to reproduce. Due to Barbs unsuccessful attempts
to have a baby she ends up turning to Brendan who offers to donate his
sperm in a bid to artificially conceive a baby.

Whilst Brendan and Barbs are trying to conceive a baby, Barbs is
secretly having a fling with grant. Who very much believes he loves
Barbs. But Grant and Brendan don’t know about each others affairs with
Barbs. And when it the truth is revealed it ends in Grant asking
Barbs.

“Why are you so ashamed of me”

Barbs is an independent woman, who doesn’t want a man in her life she
just wants some fun but Grant mistakes this for something more and
falls in love with her.

As the play comes to an end Barbs, Mum Sadie passes away but at the
same time there’s some good news.

“I’m Pregnant . . . . . I want my mother”

Finally Barbs has the baby she wanted but at the same time she lost
someone she loved dearly.

In conclusion the representation of the women in the two Scottish
plays I have studied show that women don’t need men to survive, that
sometimes you’re just better off without them.

I feel that the representation of women in both plays reflect real
women and the issues that are dealt with are ones that still reoccur
every day.

“Ena Lamont Stewart” the writer of “Men should Weep” really made her
play highlight poverty and how bad it was, also the way that women
were treated. Sadly this is something that a lot of women can still
relate to. I feel that she was successful in doing this and showing
what effects a male dominated society can have.

“Liz Lochead” the writer of “Perfect Days” really expressed that women
can be independent. That woman can make their own way in life and be
just as successful as men if not even more.
Return to 123HelpMe.com