How U.S. Schools Are Stifling Male Students

How U.S. Schools Are Stifling Male Students

Length: 961 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Mary Pipher's "Saplings in the Storm" and William S. Pollack's "How U.S. Schools Are Stifling Male Students"

Mary Pipher's "Saplings in the Storm" and William S. Pollack's "How U.S. Schools Are Stifling Male Students" are two writers that are very different but at the same time striving to get to the same goal which is to improve the lives of young children. They go about getting the same results two very different ways. Pipher is a female psychologist who concentrates on the adolescent development of females in today's society. Pollack is a male psychiatrist who writes about boys and the developmental stunting by schools in the United States. Their audience seems to be the same group of people, that off parents, but different kinds of people, parents with girls vs. parents with boys. This would point out that both writers seem to be trying to reach a friendly audience, but this is not apparent in the approaches they take.

Pipher's tone in her piece seems to be more of a concern about the fate of young girls in today's society as she would say it. She takes this tone to try to be more emotionally attached with her audience. For example in one instance she's talking about Polly and how she felt when she started her period, "This left Polly confused and shaky."(Pipher p.240) Including Polly's personal emotions on the situation allows you as the reader to understand emotionally what she is going through. Also to try to get her audience more in touch with her the author she adds direct anecdotes about herself, "Recently I sat sunning on a bench outside my favorite ice-cream store."(Pipher p.241) This adds to the intimate tone she try's to keep throughout the whole piece. She's not just a database of information, but more of a intelligent concerned individual. She wants it be different, she wants a change and she wants this change to come quickly before they loose all their individualism and when she talks about these things her tone slightly changes almost allowing the reader to hear the importance of the situation in her writing, such as "Something dramatic happens to girls in early adolescence. Just as planes and ships disappear mysteriously into the Bermuda Triangle, so do the selves of girls in droves."(Pipher p.241) You can hear the sincerity, the importance of this situation to her in her writing. At the same time she doesn't give any examples of what can be done to remedy this problem.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"How U.S. Schools Are Stifling Male Students." 10 Dec 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Male and Female High School Students Should be Educated in Separate Schools

- A debate has centered recently on the argument of whether strategy for students at high school should be applied to obtain a successful education system, with a voice calling for providing the appropriate environment of education for both gender-students that assists them to concentrate better on their studies and eliminate all aspects of disruptions. Fulfilling such strategies would improve the quality of education at high schools and raise the range of obtaining high marks. However, should boys and girls be educated separately at high school in order to have higher marks....   [tags: education, argumentative, persuasive]

Research Papers
1355 words (3.9 pages)

Essay on Students in Urban Schools

- An urban student faces many disadvantages when attending school regardless of whether they attend a public or private school. Before we can consider how to take an urban student seriously we must examine where they are from. Urban students are those living in higher density communities within the inner-cities; areas of diversity, poverty, crime and low-income. Today we can best assign the term “urban school” to public schools that are in these metropolitan areas. Many of these schools exist within educational systems that lack sufficient resources and quality educators to ensure their educational needs are met....   [tags: Urban Education, Urban Students]

Research Papers
2102 words (6 pages)

How Male And Female Students Use Language Differently By Deborah Tannen Essay

- From a young age, we have heard the phrase “men are from Mars, and women are from Venus,” but exactly how much truth does this adage hold. Deborah Tannen, a linguistics professor at Georgetown University, sought to solve this question in her book You Just Don’t Understand: Women and Men in Conversation, from which the excerpt “How Male and Female Students Use Language Differently” is taken. In this, Tannen analyzes how men and women behave in the classroom, and classifies the distinct behaviors that she noted into male and female conversational styles....   [tags: Male, Sex, Question, Female]

Research Papers
1124 words (3.2 pages)

Bilingual Education in Schools Essay

- Aiming to succeed in the rapidly developing world, possession of knowledge of several languages is no longer useful supplementary, but an indispensable quality of citizens of the globalized world. First theorists were convinced that there was no possibility to possess the knowledge of several languages at the same level. There was a belief that native language is overwhelmed by foreign, thus decreasing the level of its knowledge. However, modern research have eventually proved that there is a prospect to achieve the balance between the languages (Mocinic 2011)....   [tags: students, schools, education, spanish]

Research Papers
931 words (2.7 pages)

Public Schools Should Implement a Strict Dress Code, Ban Cell Phones, and Separate Students by Gender

- Over the years safety has gone down and violence has gone up in the public school system. The public school system should lower the violence in their schools by implementing a strict dress code, banning students from having a cell phones on campus , separate students by sex, as well as looking more into the background of teachers that they employ. In today society it is all over the news how students and teachers are constantly wreaking havoc because of facebook, fighting because of what someone said in their status, or messaged them on facebook This is due to the generation of students that has emerged, they are more concerned with who is dating who, who is wearing what, and what such and s...   [tags: public schools]

Research Papers
1869 words (5.3 pages)

Truancy Laws: Policies to Prevent Absenteeism in Schools Essay

- Ralph Waldo Emerson once said “the purpose of life is not to be happy. It is to be useful, to be honorable, to be compassionate, to have it make some difference that you have lived and lived well”. Throughout Erie there are numerous organizations that live by this quote, they strive to help others. The Booker T. Washington Center is one of them. Located on 1720 Holland street. The BTWC works to improve the Erie community and improve conditions for work, play, and health of the Erie community. Their after school program run by Chris Pullium operates Monday through Thursday from 2:30 to 5:30 pm....   [tags: schools, homework, students]

Research Papers
1334 words (3.8 pages)

Full Inclusion versus Self-Contained or Special Schools Essay

- Full Inclusion Versus Self-Contained or Special Schools The treatment of individuals with disabilities has changed dramatically since the 1800’s. Reynolds 1988, describes, Progressive inclusion, the evolution of services provided to those with various disabilities. In the early 1800’s residential institutions, or asylums were seem as common place accommodations for individuals with hearing, visual, mental or emotional impairments. Institutions remained the primary educational support until a century later in the early 1900’s....   [tags: students with disabilities in public schools]

Research Papers
1144 words (3.3 pages)

Are Students Getting Smarter? Essay

- Students just about everywhere are becoming less intelligent. However, this reality is fairly counter-intuitive to many. It is a fairly common belief that the next generations are getting smarter, technology is becoming more complex, we’re discovering more every day so how could our students possibly be becoming less intelligent. We are sending them to schools to increase their intelligence, making sure that the students are doing their homework, all sorts of different techniques to help make our kids smarter....   [tags: Students, Schools, Education, Intelligence]

Research Papers
1665 words (4.8 pages)

Charter Schools Essay

- In the 1980s there was much debate on school reform in the United States. The charter school model was an idea for educational reconstruction. These charter schools insured the continuing improvement of schooling (Budde, 1989). In 1991, Minnesota was the first state to pass legislation to create a charter school. In 1992, Minnesota opened the doors of the first charter school in the United States (“Resources,” 2012). Since then, Charter schools have gained wide spread acceptance across the United States....   [tags: education, public schools, student]

Research Papers
983 words (2.8 pages)

Switching Schools Essay

- Making new friends, walking through the halls of a new school, and trying to become popular are a few concerns students stress over, prior to their first day of classes. I, Eitan Boutehsaz fell under this category as I made my switch from a private school, Yeshiva Ohr Chaim, to a public school, Great Neck North Middle School. It was the day after Labor Day, September 5, 2005, and I finally arrived at the institution where I would spend the next year attending. I was anxious, nervous, and in doubt of what this new chapter of my life at Great Neck North would have in store for me....   [tags: schools, ]

Research Papers
1983 words (5.7 pages)

She just recognizes that it is there and brings it to our attention in a story like setting; Pollacks tone seems to be more hostile and angry, "Boys are failing in school, our schools are failing our boys."(Pollack p. 262) This being the first sentence a reader sees, he starts the piece off directly and rigid. He recognizes that people notice this decline in performance by boys but he does not understand why it has not stopped. You can hear the indignation and frustration in his writing. He is upset about what is happening to male students in this country and he doesn't understand why it's happening hence the frustration. Each writer takes on these unique tones to elicit a response from the audience. The response they want is that of action, they do not want people to read, recognize, and sit. They want people to read, recognize, and act. With any topic dealing with children there will be an attempt at an emotional appeal to the audience, and I believe this to be true in both pipher's writing and Pollack's writing.

Their style of writing also are different. Pollack uses fact after fact and percentages to back up his argument. "Indeed, 8th grader boys are 50% more likely to be held back than girls."(Pollack p.263) And that being just one of the many he uses to prove his point. He also adds false analogies to try to make his argument that much more effective, for example "Such lowered self-view does more than lead to school failure. It creates a pathway to drugs, violence, depression and suicide." (Pollack p.263) He gives nothing to support this claim, and by itself it's unreasonable. These analogies he uses looses credibility with him to certain audiences, such as younger adults. He compares incomparable events and because he used the facts he uses some might take these analogies as facts, this is done intentionally to make his argument stronger. Pipher's piece was more of a personal narrative. She uses little to no actual facts or numbers like Pollack did, but her piece still gets her point across just the same. "As we talk, the years fall away. We are back in junior high with the cliques, the shame, the embarrassment about bodies, the desire to be accepted and the doubts about ability."(Pipher p.246) This is a perfect example of her getting a valid point across without using any numerical data. Her anecdote seems to be more of a story than an explanation of why things are so, which made it easier for me to swallow but harder for me to except as reality. Pollack's was harder to accept because of the false analogies but easier to see as real because of the raw facts he uses. One who might find this hard to accept is that who he is talking about, a young man but a young woman reading Pipher's would understand what she is talking about and may even relate.

As far as the writers expertise go, Pipher directly makes references to her wisdom on the topic stating "Before I studied psychology, I studied cultural anthropology."(Pipher p. 247) On the other hand Pollack does not do that, instead he shows his skill by research, facts, and data so he does not feel the need to list off his accomplishments in his field of study.
Return to